The New Jersey and Steven Vitale Collection Auction Sales - An Introduction

 

Lot Viewing March 16-18, 2023 Whitman Baltimore Show - GFRC Booth #818

Welcome to the second GFRC Online Auctions sales event of 2023 featuring a Liberty Seated coinage extravaganza. The Steven Vitale Collection is a complete set of circulated Liberty Seated dimes with the majority of the pieces being offered in the March auction sale. The New Jersey Collection features an important offering of Liberty Seated halves that are further complimented by lots from the Newtown, Oregon Beaver, and Emerald Collections.

The Steven Vitale Liberty Seated Dime Collection sale is noteworthy as a complete Business Strike date and mintmark set along with including Major Varieties as listed in the PCGS Set Registry. This is a well assembled set in circulated grades that spans nearly ten years of effort. But there is more! Steven took die variety collecting into the Top 100 Varieties realm with a broad range of die preparation anomalies. Most significant and impressive are the four key Carson City dates that were hand selected in uniform VF25-VF30 gradings. The 1871-CC and 1874-CC dimes are strictly original with a GFRC-Choice quality rating. I remember being hired by Steven to assess and bless his purchase of the 1874-CC dime at a Whitman Baltimore show as his set was then complete. The die variety portion is equally impressive for its comprehensiveness and only lacking the key show-stoppers like the 1839 Pie Shattered Obverse and the 1874 Polished Arrows. About 80% of the collection is being offered in this auction sale with the balance being low priced dates that will be kitted and sold as lots.

The New Jersey Collection is none other than Carl Feldman and yet another installment of his life long collection that GFRC has been bringing to market. This Liberty Seated half dollar installment features two early San Francisco dates that are most special for their grade rarity. By 1855, the Western Frontier economy was rapidly expanding with an acute need for smaller denominated silver coinage. Seated half dollar production was initiated in 1855 with the entire mintage entering commerce save a few rare hold outs that were carefully preserved by happenstance. The New Jersey 1855-S is graded NGC AU58 with CAC approval and is among the finest known. As impressive as the 1855-S is, the 1857-S half is my overall favorite for its gem toning and amazing preservation. Also graded NGC AU58 with CAC approval, the 1857-S sports a CAC population at a mere 22 pieces in all grades, with only a single coin higher, at MS66. The CDN CAC Guide pricing spread between AU58 and MS66 is massive. How this piece will fair at the March 25 auction close will be the focus of the Liberty Seated half dollar collecting community.

Please be aware that the GFRC office will be transitioning back to Maine as this auction comes to its usual crescendo on Saturday evening, March 25th. I will not be in email contact during that weekend. Therefore, please ask those final bidding questions come the 18th and subsequent bidding period.

Finally, GFRC will continue to offer three payment lay-a-ways for auction winnings over $5000. To take advantage of this payment option, bidders must registered with me and confirm the lay-a-way requirement. Those that don't confirm prior to the auction will not be afforded that privilege.

The GFRC Online Auctions application was designed with simplicity for bidders given the No Buyer's Fee policy. Bidders do not need to contemplate the Buyer's Fee percentage when placing bids. Every bidder is free to bid what they wish to pay for a lot. This fact become measurably important during the final hour of bidding whereby bidders can stay focused on determining that final last minute bid towards winning a prized lot.

The GFRC Online Auctions platform has become yet another divestment option for collectors along with the regular price list consignments. I've seen the GFRC community become incrementally comfortable with taking holdings onto an auction platform for bidding potential and increased prices realized upside. Again, with a simplistic No Buyer's Fee structure, collectors can easily calculate their proceeds using the final bid and GFRC regular commission rates. All lots that do not meet reserves are posted on the regular GFRC price list along with the Collectors Corner numismatic marketplace. Our goal is to promptly sell you coins across multiple marketing channels.

Good luck with bidding. As I tell everyone who asks questions concerning lots, please bid strong and often!

Thank-you, Gerry

 

New Jersey Collection Half Dollar PDF Sale Catalog Has Arrived!

 

Bidding Instructions

Existing GFRC clients and those who have registered can submit bids by selecting the bidding icon. Those who have yet to registry can participate in this eagerly awaited GFRC Online Auctions offering by contacting Gerry Fortin at gerry@seateddimevarieties.com.

 

Sale Terms and Conditions

 

Photo Type Date
Grade		 TPG Variety
GFRC Rating		 Description Reserve/High Bid Bid
Capped Bust 50C 1835 Capped Bust 50C 1835

AU58 		NGC
3433789011 		O-108

Gem 		Gem Original, New Jersey Collection. Lustrous steely centers lead toward colorful rims, and the eye appeal of this late-date Bust half is stunning. Intense blue patina fills the stars and reverse legend, while an interior band of maroon toning surrounds Liberty and the eagle. The luster is exceptional for the grade level and penetrates even the thick skin at the edges. The images do not completely convey the in-hand aesthetic appeal of this GFRC-rated Gem piece, and we expect competitive bidding. O-108, with star 11 recut at three points. Housed in a newer NGC holder with edge view insert and the O-108 attribution on the label. Current Bid: $1755
# of Bids: 3
Unique Bid Number: 89977 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Capped Bust 50C 1836 Capped Bust 50C 1836

AU58 		NGC
3433789015 		O-110

Choice 		Near-Gem Original, New Jersey Collection. Steely luster highlights this rim-toned example, which features pleasing patina among the stars and legend. Deep aqua color fills the stars, with shades of maroon and gold also present. O-110, with a spike at the outer point of star 7. Production of Bust half dollars was substantial, and these coins circulated widely. Today they are highly collectible, although exceptionally attractive examples, such as this piece, are challenging to locate. Housed in a newer NGC holder with edge view insert and the O-110 attribution on the label. Current Bid: $1100
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 23154 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Capped Bust 50C 1839O Capped Bust 50C 1839-O
Reeded Edge
EF45 		NGC Fatty
180913008 		GR-1

Choice 		Choice Original, New Jersey Collection. Lightly mirrored fields exhibit sharp, reflective luster, and bright light examination reveals less intense color than suggested by the images. Deep chestnut and aqua patina liberally covers both sides, while original mint frost peaks out from the figure of Liberty. GR-1, the only variety using this obverse, with die cracks in the digits. The Reeded Edge half dollars varieties are described in Dick Graham's 2012 work A Registry of Die Varieties of Reeded Edge Half Dollars. Housed in a NGC Gen 5 (1992-1995) fatty holder with pristine reverse hologram. Current Bid: $2450
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 53367 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1839 Seated 50C 1839
With Drapery
MS64
 PCGS Rattler
5083102 		WB-5

Gem 		With Drapery, Gem Original, Newtown Collection. Light russet toning at the rims highlights the swirling, frosted luster of this GFRC-rated Gem example. Occasional shades of olive and blue-green are additionally evident at the dentils, and the vibrant eye appeal is undeniable. Strike is typical, with some softness in the left leg. WB-5, with repunching in the 8. The CAC population is 58 pieces in all grades, with eight coins at MS64 and five examples higher, all at MS65. This piece won't sell cheaply, but coins of this quality are rarely acquired at bargain prices. Housed in a PCGS Gen 1.2 (1986-1989) rattler holder with CAC approval. Reserve: $9500 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1839 Seated 50C 1839
With Drapery
MS64 		PCGS
3423500 		WB-5

Choice 		With Drapery, Choice Original, Newtown Collection. Thick, old-time toning covers both sides of this With Drapery example. The rims reveal deep olive and slate patina, while the centers exhibit light rose and grey color. Cartwheels are active on both sides and original Mint frost is readily apparent. WB-7, with arcing lines through the skirt. This is a remnant of the lathe lines imparted during the creation of die, which normally were smoothed out by hand. In this case, the engraver was a bit hasty. The left leg is softly impressed, which is common among earlier-date Seated halves. PCGS has certified 20 examples in MS64 with only five finer, all at MS65. Housed in a PCGS Gen 4.0 (1998-2002) holder. Reserve: $5000 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1839 Seated 50C 1839
No Drapery
AU58
 NGC
1731147005 		WB-4

Choice 		No Drapery, Choice Original, New Jersey Collection. The Philadelphia Mint struck both No Drapery and With Drapery types in this year, with the No Drapery pieces being decidedly scarcer. The steely luster of this example reveals sharp cartwheels, and the in-hand flash is considerable. Toning is mixed silver and gray, with occasional bits of gold patina evident on the reverse. A few stars to the left are soft, while the reverse strike is exceptional, much better than usually seen, with near-complete feathers and claws. CAC notes 60 pieces in all grades, with eight pieces at the Mint State level. The CAC price guide value is $10,200. Housed in a NGC Gen 14 (2003-2004) holder with CAC approval. Reserve: $13500 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1839 Seated 50C 1839
With Drapery
AU58
 PCGS
35813738 		WB-7

Gem 		With Drapery, Gem Original, New Jersey Collection. Steely, frosted luster highlights the pleasing toning of this GFRC-rated Gem example. Light russet color inhabits the fields and becomes more intense at the rims, and only light rub at the high points separates this coin from a much higher grade. Sharply struck, with defined star centers and virtually complete feather detail. The CAC census notes 58 pieces in all grades combined, with 15 at the Mint State levels. WB-7, with arcing lathe lines evident in the lower obverse. The CAC price guide is $2,060, and we expect that bidding will exceed that level. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval. Current Bid: $2751
# of Bids: 2
Unique Bid Number: 26516 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1841O Seated 50C 1841-O

AU50
 PCGS
16026339 		WB-11

Choice 		Near-Gem Original, New Jersey Collection. Thick skin is the hallmark of this New Orleans piece, with gray and olive patina underlaid by occasional bits of gold, russet, and blue-green color. Overall detail is sharp, with defined star points and delineated claw knuckles. WB-11, with a die crack between stars 3 and 4. Some chatter in the right obverse field is noted. As is typical, CAC is more concerned with originality than marks. The CAC population is 54 pieces in all grades with 13 coins at the MS level. The CAC guide value is $998. Housed in a PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval. Reserve: $1150 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1844 Seated 50C 1844

MS62 		NGC
1969805002 		WB-2

Choice 		Choice Original, Emerald Collection. Partially reflective luster highlights thick blue-green skin, surrounded by russet shades at the rim. The reverse reveals additional gold color throughout. Star center points are defined, while the eagle's left claw is softly impressed. A few lines are evident in the right obverse field. WB-2, with the top of an 8 evident in the dentils. The NGC price guide value in MS62 is $1,200. Housed in a NGC Gen 17 (2004-2008) holder. Reserve: $1100 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1846 Seated 50C 1846
Tall Date
MS63
 PCGS
90031970 		WB-14

Choice 		Tall Date, Near-Gem Original, Newtown Collection. Lightly mirrored surfaces reveal deep purple-rose color under a light, and the eye appeal is exceptional. Faint surface chatter, consistent with the technical grade, is evident upon close inspection. The 1846 Tall Date is a Guide Book-listed variety and easily attributable, with the date filling most of the vertical space between the rock and rim. This example is sharply hammered with pinpoint detail throughout. WB-14, without die crumbling, indicating a late die state per the Bugert reference. The CAC population is 54 pieces across all grades, with nine examples finer. The CAC price guide is $3,000 in MS63 and jumps to $6,750 in MS64. Housed in a PCGS Gen 4.1 (2002-2004) holder. Reserve: $2650 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1846 Seated 50C 1846
Medium Date
AU58
 NGC
632483004 		WB-8

Gem 		Medium Date, Die Cud, Gem Original, New Jersey Collection. Gem surfaces with only high point rub make for a perfect AU58 example, and this coin might be more appropriately graded AU61 or AU62. Obverse luster is steely, while the reverse leans toward frosty. Scattered charcoal streaks crisscross both sides, laid atop a silver and gray background. Nicely struck, with star points sharp and near-complete feather detail. WB-8, with a rim cud at K-7. The CAC population is 43 pieces, with 15 of these at the Mint State level. The CAC price guide is $936, which seems somewhat low for this GFRC-rated Gem example. Housed in a NGC Gen 7 (1997-2000) holder with CAC approval. Current Bid: $1900
# of Bids: 2
Unique Bid Number: 30964 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1849 Seated 50C 1849

AU58
 PCGS
3478418 		WB-12

Gem 		Medium Date, Gem Original, New Jersey Collection. Generous frost covers Liberty and the eagle, creating a cameo look atop the glassy fields. The rims reveal deep russet patina, increasing the contrast with the untoned central figures, and the overall eye appeal is exceptional. The strike is strongly impressed, with design elements nicely rising above the plane of the fields. WB-12, with diagonal lines in the upper left portion of the reverse shield. The CAC population is 50 pieces in all grades, with 19 at Mint State levels. The CAC price guide is $1,080 in AU58; this piece should be worth all that and then some. Housed in a PCGS Gen 4.0 (1998-2002) holder with CAC approval. Current Bid: $1500
# of Bids: 3
Unique Bid Number: 72966 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1851 Seated 50C 1851

AU55 		PCGS
83528389 		WB-8

Original 		Rare Die Variety, Misplaced Date Digits, Near-Choice Original, Emerald Collection. Partially mirrored surfaces create strong reflectance, highlighting silver and gray surfaces. A couple star centers are soft, while the feathers and claws are nicely defined. Half dollars from the early 1850s are challenging, as production fell in response to the increasing value of silver. WB-8, with a misplaced digit in the dentils. Bugert rates this variety as an R-6, with a population between 13 and 30 pieces. The PCGS guide value is $3,500. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. The label captures the attribution as MPD WB-104. Reserve: $3350 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1855S Seated 50C 1855-S

AU58
 NGC
1710014003 		WB-3

Choice 		Choice Original, New Jersey Collection. This is the owner's favorite coin in the current consignment, and it is not difficult to understand why. Disregarding the rarity for a minute, this is a stone original example, with antique patina that reveals even silver and gray surfaces. Original Mint frost is easily evident in the protected areas, and the coin reveals vibrant cartwheels when tilted under a light. The strike is excellent, with only a touch of softness in the feathers of the left leg. Even if this were a common date coin, it would easily stand above most other examples. The rarity of the 1855-S half dollar is well known, and, next to the 1878-S, this coin attracts the most interest among the San Francisco pieces. Production was low to begin with, 129,950 coins, and high grade survivors are few and far between, as eastern collectors of the time cared little about mintmarks. All that adds up to only a handful of known Mint state examples. CAC has approved only 17 pieces in all grades, with three pieces at AU58 and a lone example finer, at MS61. NGC notes four pieces at AU58, with three coins finer, while PCGS reports four examples at AU58 and two pieces higher. Between crossovers and crackouts, it is clear that this piece among the finest known. Combined with its aesthetic appeal, this coin delivers the whole package. The CAC price guide is $18,700. Housed in an NGC Gen 7 (1997-2000) holder with CAC approval. Current Bid: $29500
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 82989 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1856O Seated 50C 1856-O

AU50 		PCGS
25799718 		WB-14

Choice 		Repunched 56, Choice Original, New Jersey Collection. This piece offers exceptional luster for the grade, with active cartwheels easily evident as the coin is tilted. Silver and gray shades cover both sides, a bit more heavily on the reverse. Strike is typical, with a couple soft stars and the left claw joints blending together. WB-14, with a repunched date and clash in the reverse shield. The PCGS price guide is $350, and this flashy example represents "a lot of coin for the money." Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $450 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1857S Seated 50C 1857-S

AU58
 NGC Fatty
247377014 		WB-4

Choice 		Choice Original, New Jersey Collection. Steely luster covers both sides of this semi-key San Francisco piece, produced to the extent of only 158,000 coins. Sea-green and silver surfaces underlay ample charcoal patina in the fields, while the strike is typical, with characteristic weakness at the eagle's left leg. WB-4, with a high date sloping downward and a mintmark tilted to the right. The CAC population is a mere 22 pieces in all grades, with only a single coin higher, at MS66. PCGS notes six pieces in all MS grades, while NGC reports five coins. Our consignor acquired many coins in the pre-CAC era, and clearly his eye was trained long ago, as this example demonstrates. The CAC price guide is $3,450 in AU58. For those collecting CAC-approved half dollars, the present coin represents an important opportunity. Housed in an NGC Gen 5 (1992-1995) fatty holder with pristine reverse hologram. Current Bid: $13500
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 29553 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1859 Seated 50C 1859

AU53
 PCGS
6330417

Choice 		Near-Gem Original, New Jersey Collection. Lightly mirrored fields host medium shades of mauve and lilac patina, with generous Mint frost remaining in the protected areas. Obverse stars are sharp, while a few of the claw joints blend together. Although the Guide Book values this coin as a common date, the CAC population reveals a more challenging situation. The CAC census notes a low 45 pieces in all grades, and the rarity of Liberty Seated coinage, when considering originality, is not yet completely recognized by the market. The CAC price guide is $398. Housed in a PCGS Gen 3.0 (1990-1993) old green holder with CAC approval. Current Bid: $495
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 41851 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1860O Seated 50C 1860-O

AU58 		ANACS
2870476 		WB-7

Original 		Eagle Laying Egg, Near-Choice Original, Emerald Collection. Our consignor had an eye for varieties, and this 1860-O "eagle laying egg" WB-7 is distinct, with the highly placed mintmark almost appearing to be part of the eagle itself. This is reminiscent of the Charlotte quarter eagles, where the lack of available space sometimes causes the eagle and the mintmark to significantly overlap. This example reveals brilliant, frosted luster with swirling cartwheels. Russet and autumn patina covers the obverse, while the reverse is more uniformly toned. Nicely struck, with sharp claws and just a couple soft stars. A few reverse lines to the left hold back the GFRC choice rating. Housed in an ANACS blue label holder. Current Bid: $600
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 43898 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1860S Seated 50C 1860-S

AU58 		PCGS OGH
4450611 		WB-1

Choice 		Choice Original, New Jersey Collection. Brilliant, frosted luster reveals silver surfaces with patches of smoky gray and charcoal patina on both sides. This is a lower mintage issue, at 472,000 pieces, at a time when the Philadelphia Mint was regularly striking half dollar into the millions. Still, the pricing profile of this piece is similar to a Philadelphia coin, until one gets into the higher grades. As a general rule, the branch Mint pieces in the Liberty Seated series were not systematically collected at the time of issue, and high-grade survivors are typically more challenging than their Philadelphia counterparts. WB-1, with a high mintmark. A few lines in the right obverse field are noted. PCGS reports 17 pieces in AU58, and 31 in all Mint state grades. The PCGS price guide is $1,250. Housed in a PCGS Gen 3.1 (1993-1998) old green holder. Reserve: $1450 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1861O Seated 50C 1861-O
Louisiana Administration
MS62 		PCGS
21713671 		W-8

Choice 		Choice Original, Emerald Collection. The 1861-O half dollar is without doubt the most pursued issue in the entire Liberty Seated series, the result of a combination of legitimate history and well-managed promotions. This example represents the WB-8 variety, attributed to the Louisiana administration, which held control over the Mint following the secession of the southern states. The date slopes up steeply, while the mintmark is high and centered. This is a GFRC-rated choice example, with granular, frosted luster than imparts dancing cartwheels. Light rub is evident, precluding CAC approval, which might well be forthcoming if this piece was slabbed at the AU58 level. An excellent start to a 15-piece die marriage set of 1861-O half dollars. The PCGS price guide is $2,750. Housed in a PCGS Gen 4.1 (2002-2004) holder. Reserve: $2500 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1862 Seated 50C 1862

AU55
 PCGS OGH
4359688

Choice 		Near-Gem Original, New Jersey Collection. Frosty luster radiates from the surfaces of this near-Gem example, with only minor chatter in the right obverse field holding the coin back. Nicely struck, with sharp stars and most of the claw joints delineated. The CAC census reports 35 pieces in all grades, with survivors bunched in the AU/MS bands, an indication that these pieces did not circulate heavily. Hard money was hoarded in the Civil War period, with the result that higher grade pieces are more accessible today. The CAC value is AU55 is $1,110. Housed in a PCGS Gen 3.1 (1993-1998) old green holder with CAC approval. Current Bid: $1250
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 90978 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1862 Seated 50C 1862

EF45 		PCGS
25799719

Choice 		Choice Original, New Jersey Collection. This is a better-date Civil War issue, with 253,000 half dollars produced at the Philadelphia Mint in this year. Steely fields host a band of deep purple shading across the obverse, while similar color is evident at the reverse rim. Strike is typical, with star centers present if faint. High point wear is consistent with the grade, and the GFRC Choice rating attests to the above-average eye appeal. The PCGS guide value is $600. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Current Bid: $600
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 32563 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1862S Seated 50C 1862-S

AU58 		PCGS OGH
4255510 		WB-5

Choice 		Choice Original, New Jersey Collection. Creamy, satiny luster hosts light tan patina on both sides. The bright color suggests an old dipping, but the surfaces are pleasing and the usual hairlines that one might expect are not evident. We rate the coin as Choice overall. WB-5, with the date sloping upward and a mintmark tilted to the left. Well struck, with only a couple soft stars and most of the claw joints cleanly separated. The PCGS price guide is $1,400 in AU58. Housed in a PCGS Gen 3.1 (1993-1998) old green holder. Current Bid: $1925
# of Bids: 4
Unique Bid Number: 87100 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1864 Seated 50C 1864

AU53 		PCGS OGH
4676373

Choice 		Choice Original, New Jersey Collection. Brilliant, frosted luster imparts active cartwheels, and the flash is readily evident as the coin is tilted. Light surface chatter is noted on both sides, as is a reverse rim mark at K2, consistent with the technical grade. The strike is sharp, with distinct star centers and near-complete feather detail. Half dollar production was lower in this Civil War year, with 379,100 pieces produced in Philadelphia. The PCGS guide value is $1,000. Housed in a PCGS Gen 3.1 (1993-1998) old green holder. Current Bid: $1000
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 14943 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1864S Seated 50C 1864-S

AU55 		PCGS
13037231 		WB-1

Choice 		Choice Original, New Jersey Collection. Granular, frosted luster hosts scattered bits of charcoal color at the rims, while smoky gray patina fills the fields. The strike is deeply impressed, with the usual problem area of the eagle's left leg sharply detailed. GFRC does not micro-split our ratings, but this piece might be better evaluated as "Choice Plus." WB-1, with the date punched to the right and the mintmark tilted to the left. The PCGS price guide is $1,750. Housed in a PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder. Current Bid: $1850
# of Bids: 2
Unique Bid Number: 44330 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1866 Seated 50C 1866
With Motto
AU53 		NGC
3671523013

Choice 		Choice Original, Emerald Collection. Steely, frosted luster highlights the exceptionally choice surfaces. Deep maroon patina marks the fields and rims, with less color evident in the central figures. The technical wear is more consistent with an AU50 grade, and this piece might well achieve CAC certification at that level. WB-1, with a misplaced digit in the dentils below the right 6. Strike is typical, with some of the feathers and claws blending together. The NGC price guide is $425, and this piece is a good value at that level. Housed in a newer NGC holder with edge view insert. The label captures the FS-302 MPD die variety. Current Bid: $600
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 58761 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1868S Seated 50C 1868-S

AU58
 PCGS
19556322 		WB-5

Gem 		Gem Original, New Jersey Collection. Brilliant, frosted luster creates vibrant cartwheels atop the surfaces of this San Francisco piece, and the GFRC Gem designation is fully warranted. Scattered crust on both sides accompanies smoky tan patina. The hairline-free fields are free of distracting marks, and the originality is easily apparent. CAC has approved 25 pieces in all grades, with just six examples at the Mint state level. WB-5, with a small, slightly tilted mintmark. The CAC price guide is $858, which seems rather low for a piece ranking this high in the census. Housed in a PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval. Current Bid: $2000
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 23121 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1868S Seated 50C 1868-S

EF40 		PCGS
42415937 		WB-4

Choice 		Choice Original, Oregon Beaver Collection. Natural coin gray color contrasts with the original crust that clings to the protected areas. Fields are evenly toned with occasional charcoal flecks and the overall eye appeal is wholesome. WB-4, with misplaced digits in the dentils, below 68 in the date. The PCGS guide value is $375, and this example represents a near-perfect collector grade selection at that level. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2022) holder. Reserve: $300 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1869S Seated 50C 1869-S

AU58 		PCGS
20272190 		WB-3

Choice 		Choice Original, New Jersey Collection. Scattered emerald patina covers both sides of this San Francisco issue, more heavily on the reverse. Steely, original fields reveal soft reflectance, and the in-hand appeal is strong. High-point rub is more consistent with an AU55 grade l, and this example would be a strong candidate for CAC consideration at that level. WB-3, with a date sloping noticeably downward. Stars 1-2 are soft, but the feathers and claws exhibit clean separation. The PCGS price guide is $1,500. Housed in a PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder. Reserve: $1250 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1869S Seated 50C 1869-S

AU55
 PCGS
83095919 		WB-1

Choice 		Choice Original, Oregon Beaver Collection. Soft, satiny luster reveals pristine, hairline-free fields, and the CAC approval is no surprise. Light russet color is scattered at the rims and throughout the central figures, while a few crusty bits mark the reverse. WB-1, with die lines at stars 11-12. Strike is typical, with softness in the eagle's left leg. The CAC population is a mere 23 pieces, with only four examples finer. The CAC value is $858, which seems an attractive value for an issue that is rarely found choice. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval. Current Bid: $1251
# of Bids: 2
Unique Bid Number: 24797 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1870CC Seated 50C 1870-CC

VF25 		PCGS
34132536 		WB-1

Original 		Original, Oregon Beaver Collection. Liberty Seated enthusiasts tend to be Carson City fans by definition, as the rarity of "CC" coinage is well-known by anyone building a denomination set. Among the half dollars, the keys are the 1870-CC< 1874-CC, and 1878-CC issues, with the 1870-CC being the scarcest of the three. This example exhibits rich ebony toning with hints of maroon and plum color underneath the thick skin. High points are lighter, as expected from a well-circulated coin that has been subject to extensive handling. Moderately reflective surfaces suggest retoning over an old dipping, but still within the PCGS standard of acceptability. Regardless, any 1870-CC half dollar is a desirable coin, and this mid-grade collector example is no exception. WB-1, with the CCs slanting down. The PCGS price guide is $6,500. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $5500 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1871S Seated 50C 1871-S

MS62 		PCGS
25294328 		WB-2

Choice 		Choice Original, Oregon Beaver Collection. Brilliant, frosted luster booms from the untoned centers of this San Francisco piece, surrounded by sprays of russet and tan color at the rims. The strike is hammered, with sharply delineated claws and feathers. A few marks between the foot and star 13 hold this piece back from a GFRC Gem rating, but the in-hand flash is undeniable. WB-2, with the top of the mintmark thin. The PCGS price guide value is $1,750. Housed in a PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) Dupont hologram holder. Current Bid: $1500
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 66421 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1872 Seated 50C 1872

MS62
 NGC
956720002

Gem 		Gem Original, New Jersey Collection. Generous frosty luster imparts dancing cartwheels, and the "pop" is immediately apparent as the coin is tilted in hand. Original silver skin covers the smooth surfaces and admits a few hints of golden patina at the rims. The strike is sharp, with virtually complete feather detail, and the GFRC Gem rating is completely warranted. CAC notes 28 pieces in all grades with six coins finer. The CAC guide value is $1,350, an attractive price point for a coin that is remarkably advanced in the condition census. Housed in a NGC Gen 7 (1997-2000) holder with CAC approval. Current Bid: $1972
# of Bids: 2
Unique Bid Number: 76530 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1872S Seated 50C 1872-S

EF45 		PCGS OGH
4689537 		WB-2

Choice 		Choice Original, New Jersey Collection. An 1872-S half isn't quite as good as two 1872-S quarters, but this remains a better date in the half dollar series, with just over a half million pieces struck. This example exhibits steely, frosted luster, and the technical detail is just a touch removed from the AU level. Original Mint bloom is evident around the stars and protected areas, and the eye appeal is wholesome. WB-2, with the date to the left and a squat mintmark. The PCGS price guide value is $500. Housed in a PCGS Gen 3.1 (1993-1998) old green holder. Reserve: $625 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1875S Seated 50C 1875-S

AU53 		PCGS OGH
9781122 		WB-1

Choice 		Medium-Small S, Choice Original, New Jersey Collection. Silver and gray patina blankets both sides of this collectible San Francisco piece, with tan shades additionally present on the reverse. Scattered field marks are evident here and there, consistent with the technical grade. Strike is typical, with claw joints melding as one. WB-1, with a die crack at the base of the date and a low, tilted mintmark. This issue is rich in varieties, and the present piece is worthy of in-hand study, in consultation with the Bugert reference. The PCGS guide value is $375. Housed in a PCGS Gen 3.1 (1993-1998) old green holder. Current Bid: $475
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 14953 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1876S Seated 50C 1876-S

MS62
 PCGS
30631148 		WB-17

Choice 		Choice Original, Newtown Collection. Exceptional luster radiates from the brilliant centers and leads toward scattered russet and maroon patina at the rims. Fields are marky, more than conveyed by the images, but CAC weighs originality heavily and the green bean is clearly merited in this case. The booming flash immediately grabs the eye, and the first impression is controlling. The CAC population is 43 pieces in all grades, with 20 examples finer. The CAC price guide is $936. Housed in a PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) Dupont hologram holder with CAC approval. Current Bid: $1285
# of Bids: 2
Unique Bid Number: 30105 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1876S Seated 50C 1876-S

AU58
 NGC
178648007 		WB-32

Choice 		Choice Original, New Jersey Collection. Eye-catching rings of color surround the brilliant centers of this San Francisco piece, with russet, aqua, and golden patina evident. The luster is steely and the overall presentation is appealing. Liberty's head is a touch soft, while the claws exhibit clean separation. WB-32, with die lumps in the obverse shield and a centered, small mintmark. A few lines in the obverse right field are noted. CAC notes 43 pieces in all grades, yet another low figure in the Liberty Seated series, where CAC populations less than a hundred examples are typical. The CAC price guide is $546. Housed in a NGC Gen 5 (1992-1995) fatty holder with pristine reverse hologram. Current Bid: $927
# of Bids: 5
Unique Bid Number: 75393 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1877 Seated 50C 1877

MS65+
 PCGS
25559686

Gem 		Gem Original, Newtown Collection. Dancing cartwheels boom from the surfaces of this colorful half, which exhibits a wash of russet and tan color highlighted by electric blue patina at the rims. Ample, frosty luster easily penetrates the medium skin, and the images do not completely convey the compelling in-hand eye appeal. Obverse star centers are sharp, while some feathers on the eagle's left leg blend together. CAC notes 71 pieces in all grades, with 17 coins finer. The CAC price guide is $3,250 in MS65 and $7,500 in MS66. Housed in a PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder. Reserve: $4000 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1878 Seated 50C 1878

MS65 		PCGS
38372610

Gem 		Gem Original, Oregon Beaver Collection Electric blue, russet, and sea-green patina fill the obverse of this late-date Philadelphia piece, while the reverse center is brilliant and leads toward deep rim toning. Colors are transparent under a glass, and the skin is less thick than conveyed by the images. Frosted, granular luster imparts swirling cartwheels, and the GFRC Gem rating is consistent with the flash and overall eye appeal. Star centers are fully defined, while a few of the claw joints blend together. The PCGS price guide value is $5,000 in MS65, $12,500 in MS66. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $4300 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1878CC Seated 50C 1878-CC

AU53 		PCGS
30368981 		WB-1

Choice 		Choice Original, Newtown Collection. Pristine, smooth fields are the hallmark of this richly toned, challenging CC piece. Tan and ebony patina predominates, with hints of sea-green and olive color evident underneath the thick skin. The Carson City Mint produced few half dollars in this year, 62,000 pieces total, as production capacity was diverted to coining massive quantities of Morgan dollars. WB-1, the only die marriage for this issue. The PCGS price guide value is $8,000. The Carson City pieces are always the first examined when viewing Liberty Seated sets, and this high-grade survivor will best most other examples. Housed in a PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) Dupont hologram holder. Reserve: $7000 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1878CC Seated 50C 1878-CC

VF30
 PCGS
16076158 		WB-1

Choice 		Choice Original, Newtown Collection. Coin grey surfaces host scattered dirt, with additional goldish-olive patina evident on both sides. This piece exhibits what some call the "CAC look," meaning a piece with moderate crust than has somehow escaped the "curators" for a long period of time. Close inspection of the hairline-free fields of this example is recommended, and frequent auction lot viewing of CAC-approved pieces will further train the eye. WB-1, the only variety for this issue. CAC notes 32 pieces in all grades. Remarkably, only 11 of these are finer than the present example. The 1878-CC issue is a key in the Seated half series, and CAC-approved examples are few and far between. The CAC guide value is $4,200. Housed in a PCGS Gen 4.3 (2004) holder with CAC approval. Current Bid: $4350
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 18906 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1879 Seated 50C 1879

MS65
 PCGS
29975015

Gem 		Gem Original, Newtown Collection. The low-mintage, 1879-1890 runs are well known to Liberty Seated half and quarter dollar enthusiasts, and this 12-coin group might easily stand on its own as a "set within a set." The present example, from the inaugural year of this run, presents a thick skin of smoky grey patina with sea-green highlights in the protected areas. Steely, frosted luster creates swirling cartwheels, and the eye appeal is compelling. Stars are sharply impressed, while a few of the feathers on the eagle's left leg are soft. The CAC census notes 79 examples in all grades, with 30 coins finer. The CAC price guide is $4,120. Housed in PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) Dupont hologram holder with CAC approval. Reserve: $3950 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1879 Seated 50C 1879

AU53 		NGC
3309450004

Original 		Near-Choice Original, New Jersey Collection. A semi-prooflike obverse features a brilliant center surrounded by deep aqua shades at the rim, while the reverse exhibits a uniformly thick skin of intense blue patina. Bright-light inspection reveals the considerable depth of the toning, with various shades evident as the coin is tilted. Prooflike pieces in the 1879-1890 are typical, as production was low and dies were less susceptible to wear. WB-102, the business strike dies, with a die line through LIB. The PCGS guide value is $1,150. Housed in a newer NGC holder with edge view insert. Reserve: $1150 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1881 Seated 50C 1881

AU55
 PCGS
18570088

Choice 		Choice Original, New Jersey Collection. Pristine coin-gray surfaces host hints of rose patina, leading toward sprays of ebony color at the rims. Smooth fields are partially mirrored and the overall eye appeal is strong; indeed, this is a near-perfect collector-grade example. Strike is typical, with feathers and claws blending together. CAC notes 34 pieces in all grades. The CAC guide value is $1,280. Housed in a PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval. Current Bid: $1650
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 93567 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1885 Seated 50C 1885

MS65
 PCGS
41344564

Gem 		Gem Original, Newtown Collection. This is a piece that has to be seen in-hand to fully appreciate the deeply original surfaces and swirling cartwheels. Medium to thick rose skin covers both sides and leads toward blue crescents at the rims. The frosty luster is fully Gem and further highlights the old-time color of this low-mintage example. Star centers are completely delineated, while a few of the claw joints meld as one. CAC has approved 28 pieces in all grades, with three coins finer. The CAC guide price is $6,000, a reasonable level for a near-finest known example. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2022) holder with CAC approval. Reserve: $5750 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1885 Seated 50C 1885

AU58 		NGC
3122754004

Choice 		Near-Gem Original, New Jersey Collection. Sharp luster and pleasing color radiates from the surfaces of this late-date, low-mintage Philadelphia example. Lilac, rose, and blue patina mix on both sides, and the in-hand appeal is strong. Partially-mirrored luster is exceptional for the grade and imparts dancing cartwheels. Star centers are cleanly defined, while the reverse exhibits typical softness in the left leg feathers. The NGC price guide value is $1,300. Housed in a NGC Gen 17 (2004-2008) holder. Current Bid: $1600
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 62510 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1887 Seated 50C 1887

AU58 		NGC
1938110010

Original 		Near-Choice Original, New Jersey Collection. Both sides of this Philadelphia piece exhibit brilliant, untoned surfaces. The strike is deeply impressed, with stars rising well above the plane, while most of the claws are separated if faintly so. Fields are mirrored and sharply reflective, and the absence of color suggests an old dipping. Production of Liberty Seated halves was minimal from 1879-1890 as Mint capacity was diverted toward striking Morgan dollars. Today, business strikes are more challenging than proof examples, which were widely collected at the time of issue. The NGC guide value is $1,100. Housed in a NGC Gen 17 (2004-2008) holder. Reserve: $1250 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1888 Seated 50C 1888

AU55
 PCGS OGH
6322374

Gem 		Gem Original, New Jersey Collection. Collectors with even the most endowed of checkbooks will pause to consider the present example, a russet headlight that generates substantial contrast with the frosty, silver background. The reverse additionally exhibits bits of aqua patina at the rim, and the eye appeal is off the charts. Swirling cartwheels are especially active for the grade, and the GFRC Gem rating is no surprise. The CAC population is 51 pieces, and the CAC price guide value is $1,280. This piece will sell for more - the only question is how much more! Housed in a PCGS Gen 3.0 (1990-1993) old green holder with CAC approval. Current Bid: $1900
# of Bids: 2
Unique Bid Number: 63681 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1889 Seated 50C 1889

AU58 		NGC
1774743013

Choice 		Choice Original, New Jersey Collection. Lustrous, untoned surfaces host faint hints of color at the rims, while white, frosted luster radiates from the protected areas. This piece was likely dipped in the past, with a few hairlines evident. Nicely struck, with significant detail in the claw joints. Production was low in this year, 12,000 pieces, as the Philadelphia Mint churned out millions of Morgan dollars. Business strikes are today scarcer than proofs, with NGC reporting 129 circulation strike coins, as compared to 204 proof examples. The NGC price guide is $1,100. Housed in an NGC Gen 14 (2003-2004) holder. Reserve: $1600 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 50C 1891 Seated 50C 1891

AU58 		PCGS
21640369

Original 		Near-Choice Original, New Jersey Collection. After a decade of low mintages, the need for circulating small change caused the Mint to greatly increase the production of quarters and half dollars in this year. Brilliant, frosted luster covers the surfaces of this largely untoned example, while the strike is typical, with a couple flat stars and the left claw joints blended as one. Some obverse field chatter is noted. The PCGS price guide is $850, a reasonable level for a near-MS example of a 19th century half dollar. Housed in a PCGS Gen 4.1 (2002-2004) holder. Reserve: $1000 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1837 Seated 10C 1837
No Stars, Large Date
AU55 		PCGS
2717121 		F-101b

Original 		Large Date, Near-Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. We open the Steven Vitale Liberty Seated Dime Collection offerings with this 1837 F-101b lot. This large date specimen was struck with later die state dies given the pie shaped die cracks on the lower obverse. A light silver-gray patina covers both sides while the underlying luster is steely. The presentation is struck original and exactly as expected for the date. Some faint lines in the lower right obverse field preclude a full Choice quality rating. Overall eye appeal is pleasing at the certified grade. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.0 (1998-2002) holder Reserve: $950 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1837 Seated 10C 1837
No Stars, Small Date
EF45
 PCGS
81228932 		F-102

Choice 		Small Date, Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. The 1837 Small Date strikes were executed from only two obverse dies. The first, as employed for this F-102 example, has the 7 digit pointing at a denticle and a shallow date punch. The reverse exhibits a die crack through the tops of (UNI)TED though faint. The reverse die alignment is normal coin turn with a 6 degree counterclockwise rotation. CAC approval was a foregone conclusion as the presentation is exceptional at the certified grade. Bright light inspection accentuates obverse peripheral blues and center rose while the reverse features center blues surrounded by rose-gold. Fields are unabraded other than a single tick in the obverse field that is inconsequential. Worthy of a strong bid as ideal for type. CAC guide is $655. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval. Current Bid: $800
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 83954 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1838 Seated 10C 1838
No Drapery, Large Stars
AU53 		PCGS OGH
5356170 		F-106

Choice 		Cracked Obverse #1, Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. The 1838 F-106 die variety is well known for its significant die crack starting at the rim between stars 6 and 7, then proceeding downward through Liberty's left side and exiting through the shield point into a space between the 1 and 8 digits. Surprisingly, the Cracked Obverse #1 still comes well struck even with the die crack severity. Moderately brilliant frosted luster is present on both sides along with faint gold highlights. Surfaces are well preserved with some cartwheel under angled lighting. Strictly original and worthy of its GFRC-Choice quality rating. Listed in the Top 100 Varieties set. Housed in PCGS Gen 3.1 (1998-2002) old green holder. Current Bid: $350
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 18363 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1838 Seated 10C 1838
No Drapery, Small Stars
AU53 		PCGS
13606683 		F-101a

Choice 		Small Stars, Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. A classic example of the later Small Stars die state with a bold die crack through the left stars and reaching down into the date. Dies are worn with light "orange peel" surfaces leading to a satiny frosted appearance. Luster is more than adequate at the certified grade while surfaces are unabraded. Please note that the rim mark on the upper reverse is a strike through error and not post mint damage. Fully choice and strictly original. Please consider a strong bid for this lovely F-101a. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder. Reserve: $500 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1838 Seated 10C 1838
No Drapery, Large Stars
AU50 		PCGS
18742045 		F-102

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. Peripheral copper-gold shades nicely decorate this lightly worn 1838 F-102 dime. The Small Stars reverse, with die doubling, is pair with a single Large Stars obverse to produce this die variety. Frosted luster and vibrant cartwheels are easily activated with angled lighting. Fully choice and certain to please the winning bidder. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder. The label captures variety attribution as DDR FS-802. Current Bid: $325
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 96973 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1838 Seated 10C 1838
Partial Drapery
AU50 		PCGS
83434234 		F-108a

Choice 		Partial Drapery, Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. One of the great ironies of the Liberty Seated dime series, the 1838 Partial Drapery does not originate from a separate hub die but rather is a function of bold die clashing. I consider the F-108a die state as the true "partial drapery" since having corresponding reverse die clashing. The later F-109 obverse die pairing just does not do it for me. This Steven Vitale F-018a example is completely struck and essentially unabraded. Golden gray surfaces validate the originality. Images accurately capture the presentation and should stimulate bidding. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $400 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1838 Seated 10C 1838
No Drapery, Small Stars
EF45 		PCGS
81723382 		F-101

Choice 		Small Stars, Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. A single 1838 obverse die was punched with stars intended for half dimes. This die struck a fair quantity with progressive die states. This early die state F-101 lacks obverse die cracks while the reverse die doubling on (D)IME and the left wreath is bold. Bright light review reveals peripheral sky blue and light center rose toning along with steely fields that are mildly reflective. Strike is complete while the grading is accurate and fair. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $400 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1838O Seated 10C 1838-O
No Stars
VF30 		PCGS
81637660 		F-101

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. Nearly a twin to the 1837 F-102 offered in this sale, this attractively toned 1838-O F-101 lot was part of the first dimes to be struck in New Orleans. The F-101 reverse is easily attributed by a boldly repunched mintmark. Toning is predominately aquamarine-blue with obverse rose-gray with an old album origin most likely. Devices are well defined with limited wear at the certified grade. Worthy of a GFRC-Choice quality rating and certain to attract competitive bidding. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Current Bid: $550
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 83908 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1839 Seated 10C 1839
No Drapery
AU50 		PCGS
81220673 		F-103

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. This is a lovely 1839 F-103 example with satiny luster resulting from late die state surfaces. Cartwheels are vibrant during inspection. The F-103 obverse has been polished resulting in the elimination of repunching at Star 11. The Denticle Ruler measurement has shifted from -2C to -2R due to the reduction in size of the 1 digit. The reverse exhibits a severe die crack from the rim, down through ST(AT)ES and into the wreath with an exit point at UNI(T)ED back to the rim. The reverse is rotated clockwise 18 degrees. A quality example that requires background knowledge to appreciate the die state, surface conditions, and overall presentation. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Current Bid: $285
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 90239 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1839O Seated 10C 1839-O
No Drapery
AU53 		PCGS
28687059 		F-105

Original 		Near-Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. Brilliant frosted luster is readily evident on this 1839-O F-105 lot. One of the more available die pairing for New Orleans strikes of that year, the dies will show progressive wear and terminal die start obverse cracks. This Steven Vitale piece was struck by interim die state dies. Strike is complete given the sharp star center points and wreath leaves. Wear is visible on the higher points along with faint hair lines in the obverse fields. Well preserved though luster dominates the certified grade. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.6 (2013-2014) holder. Reserve: $600 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1839O Seated 10C 1839-O
No Drapery
EF40 		PCGS
28178880 		F-104

Choice 		Repunched Mintmark, Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. Repunching is clearly evident to the south east of the mintmark on the 1839 F-104 die pairing. This example is in an early die state as the reverse shows no traces of the typical horizontal die crack through UN(I)TED and into (DIME). Surfaces are toned a natural coin gray with peripheral copper-gold highlights. Pleasing surfaces are essentially unabraded. This is a noteworthy example of a challenging R4 variety easily cherrypicked reverse repunching. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.6 (2013-2014) holder. The lable captures RPM FS-501 die variety attribution. Reserve: $400 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1840 Seated 10C 1840
With Drapery
EF45 		PCGS
81228933 		F-101

Original 		With Drapery, Original, Steven Vitale Collection. 1840 brought the transition from the No Drapery to With Drapery master hub. While 1840 No Drapery coinage is moderately available, With Drapery coinage is quite scarce and always in demand by date and mintmark collectors. This new design hub date can be located in Good through Very Fine grades but becomes very difficult in EF or better and very rare in Mint State. This example is worthy of attention as the eye appeal is quite pleasing. Light gray centers are framed by peripheral copper gold. Surfaces are lightly abraded resulting in the GFRC-Original quality rating. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $1000 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1840 Seated 10C 1840
No Drapery
VF35 		PCGS
34908060 		F-102

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. No Drapery Seated dimes are always popular as a type coin with 1840 Philadelphia strikes not often seen as the early 1838 strikes. This 100% original F-102 exhibits crusty surfaces with lighter shades at the wear points. Surfaces are pristine regardless of considerable time in circulation. A CAC candidate if the economics were higher. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $150 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1841O Seated 10C 1841-O

AU50
 PCGS
09943396 		F-115

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. A fully choice and desirable 1841-O F-115 lot that should garner attention and bidding. The F-115 die variety captures the die pairing of Obverse 10 with an early die state Reverse F. The reverse is found in an early state with a die crack from wreath through AMER(I)CA to rim. This CAC approved example exhibits soft frosted luster from essentially unabraded surfaces. Light gold is dominant on the obverse while peripheral blues decorate the reverse. A premium exhibit that warrants strong bidding. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder. Current Bid: $375
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 89012 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1841O Seated 10C 1841-O

VF20
 PCGS
29739515 		F-101

Choice 		Large O, Transitional Reverse, Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. Please don't under estimate the importance of this lot as locating a choice 1841-O Closed Bud dime at or above the VF grade level will take years of patient searching. This strictly original and choice example is one of the Steven Vitale Collection highlights. Obverse and reverse devices are well struck considering the reverse die is well worn, cracked and left over from 1840. Die cracks from UNITED to rim are overtly defined. The 1841 Transitional dimes were struck at the New Orleans mint during January 1841 with left over 1840 reverse dies since no new 1841 reverses were available. The PCGS label reads, "Trans Rev, Large O, Sm Lett, FS-902 (FS-003.3). This label allows the new owner to immediately add into PCGS Set Registry's Top 100 Seated Dime Varieties set. The reserve is certainly fair for the overall quality and grade rarity. Previously sold by GFRC during November 2018 into the Vitale Collection. Housed in PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) Dupont hologram holder with CAC approval. Current Bid: $2000
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 91827 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1841O Seated 10C 1841-O

G06 		PCGS
28092786 		F-102

Choice 		Small O, Transitional Reverse, Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. Greer 101, Fortin 102. Discovered after Ahwash published his Encyclopedia. Transitional Small O Closed Bud Reverse. Struck in early 1841 at the New Orleans mint with a left over Closed Bud reverse die from 1840 due to lack of die shipment of the new Open Bud reverse design. Greer indicates that "transitional Large and Small O dimes were struck from leftover 1840-O reverse dies most likely before the arrival of the first reverse dies of 1841 Open Bud which were delivered on Apri 7, 1841. Mint records for 1841 show 160,000 dimes were delivered from New Orleans prior to April of that year. I believe that these were deliveries included the Closed Bud 1841-O dimes, as well as many dated 1840-O. The extreme rarity of both closed bud varieties indicates a very small mintage." This offered example is conservatively graded and choice at the assigned Good 6 grade level. Both sides are covered with original gray patina. The obverse rim is bold and elevated above the fields. Four to five letters of LIBERTY remain on the scroll. The reverse is struck from a well worn die that is also bulging in the center resulting in uneven device details. Once again, the rims are fully intact suggesting that a minimum VG grade would be appropriate. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.6 (2013-2014) holder. The label documents the die variety attribution as Trans Rev, Sm O, Sm Lett FS-901. Current Bid: $1150
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 64833 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1842 Seated 10C 1842

EF40 		PCGS
81220679 		F-106

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. Distinguishing 1842 die varieties can be challenging as there is little horizontal movement of the date punch. The F-106 pairing is easier than most due to a set of horizontal die lines behind or through Liberty's right elbow. This Vitale Collection example is fully choice with natural coin gray patina and well struck motifs. GFRC images accurately capture the desirable presentation. Certain to please the winning bidder. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $100 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1842O Seated 10C 1842-O

EF40
 PCGS
27870850 		F-101

Choice 		Shattered Reverse #3, Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. 1842 New Orleans Seated dime strikes feature some of the poorest quality output from that mint. Lapped dies, weak strikes, and shattered reverse dies are common place. The F-107 variety captures the previously listed Shattered Reverse #3 as defined by Greer. During this pairing, the obverse has been lapped reducing date size and eliminating die details in Liberty's upper body area. Date position shifts from Denticle Ruler 0R to 0B1. The dot defect at Liberty's nose is still visible after die maintenance. The reverse is shattered with a bold die crack at STAT(ES). This example is toned an even coin gray with pristine surfaces. Worthy of a GFRC-Choice quality rating and then some. Listed in the Top 100 Varieties set. Housed in a PCGS Gen 4.6 (2013-2014) holder with CAC approval. Reverse E is again paired with Obverse 4 and degrades further. The die crack at STAT(ES) is the primary diagnostic for the variety while cracking at A(MERICA) becomes very evident and is a good secondary diagnostic point. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.6 (2013-2014) holder with CAC approval. Current Bid: $625
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 72907 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1843 Seated 10C 1843
Repunched Date
EF45 		PCGS
13616323 		F-102

Choice 		Repunched Date, Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. All four date digits are strongly repunched above the final date punch on the 1843 F-102 die pairing. This repunched date variety is well known in the Liberty Seated dime series and has been occasionally listed separately on price guides. It was included in the Top 100 Varieties set due to popularity with collectors. This Vitale example is fully choice and struck with early die state dies as the doubled date is boldly visible. Steely fields retain their natural luster regardless of time in circulation. A crusty gray patina is consistent on both sides. Worthy of an advanced die variety collection and strong bidding. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.5 (2012-2013) holder. The label captures the die variety as RPD FS-301. Current Bid: $185
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 22187 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1843 Seated 10C 1843

EF40 		PCGS
81220681 		F-101

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. A thick crusty patina uniformly covers both sides of this perfectly original 1843 F-101 dime. A candidate for CAC approval if the economics were more favorable as this piece has the right "look" and accurate grading. Let's see who gets to take this one home with a strong bid. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $130 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1843O Seated 10C 1843-O

EF40 		PCGS
12267213 		F-101

Original 		Original, Steven Vitale Collection. One of the most challenging early New Orleans dates and very scarce in VF or better. Locating a well struck and problem free 1843-O example in EF or better will prove to be most difficult. The 1843-O is a key date in AU or better and is extremely rare in Mint State grade. This example is one of 150,000 struck and manage to survive circulation in the deep South. Steely fields are toned an antique gray with embedded blues appears during bright light viewing. Strike consistent is above average with strongly impressed stars and wreath leaves. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder. Reserve: $2800 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1844 Seated 10C 1844

VF30
 PCGS
30434820 		F-102

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. A lovely example of the 1844 Little Orphan Annie dime that is housed in PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) Dupont hologram holder with CAC approval. That approval is unquestionably warranted due to the choice surfaces and attractive old album toning. Both sides are layered with golden blues shades along with embedded aquamarine. Strike is well executed while the overall surfaces are well preserved with no blemishes. This date is easily available at the Good through Fine grades but becomes increasingly difficult in VF and very scarce in EF. Choice AU examples are rare. This Vitale Collection specimen is an important opportunity for collector constructing a CAC centric set of Liberty Seated dimes. Reserve: $850 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1845 Seated 10C 1845

AU53 		PCGS
16772218 		F-104

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. A lovely 1845 Philadelphia strike with steely frosty luster along with soft golden patina and deep peripheral shades. Strike is deeply impressed with full head and hair curls, elevated stars, and bold reverse wreath leaves. There are no blemishes to mention for this F-104 die pairing strike. Accurately graded and offering first rate eye appeal. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval. Previously sold by GFRC during September 2017. Current Bid: $250
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 71873 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1845O Seated 10C 1845-O

VF35 		PCGS
32754653 		F-101

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. !845 New Orleans strikes are typically available in grades Good through Very Fine, becomes difficult in EF, and rare in AU or better. 1845-O dimes are extremely rare in Mint State, the Eliasberg 1845-O dime being the finest known. This Steven Vitale example is toned a light gray with peripheral gold accents. An early strike with the die rust remaining visible in the drapery folds regardless of the wear. Strike is evenly executed and close to complete. A sole contact mark in the right field requires mention but is not distraction. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $1000 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1846 Seated 10C 1846

VF25 		PCGS
81637662 		F-101

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. The With Stars series key date with only 31,300 struck. A scarce date that is always in demand. This GFRC-Choice rated example exhibits light gray patina over pristine surfaces which should be evident from the images. Strike is deeply impressed including a host of "die chips" surrounding the left obverse stars. Wear is consistent and uniform. A premium lot that should garner serious bidding. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. The label captures the Dr. James G. K. McClure pedigree. Reserve: $1650 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1847 Seated 10C 1847

EF40 		PCGS
33108184 		F-102

Gem 		Gem Original, Steven Vitale Collection. I've always been a huge fan of the 1847 date and still believe this date remainis underrated in all grades, but especially Mint State. This lightly worn F-102 example is about as good as it gets for the certified grade and has earned a GFRC-Gem rating. Brownish-gray crusty patina covers both sides with embedded gold within the reverse. Bright light review exposes steely fields. Strike is complete with the digits touch the base even though the base over all digits has been trimmed to accommodate the placement of the large date punch. Worthy of a strong bid. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. The label document the F-102 die variety attribution. Reserve: $300 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1848 Seated 10C 1848

EF45
 PCGS
81798205 		F-101a

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. A better date Liberty Seated dime lot with considerable eye appeal, this 1848 F-101a lot offers choice surfaces and a thin gray patina that remains transparent to the underlying luster. The residual luster is quite evident under bright light, especially throughout the reverse. Angled light view indicates obverse rose-gray with some blue at the rims. Center rose and peripheral light blue is most attractive on the reverse. The F-101a die state captures a bold die crack through the lower left wreath and ribbon end. A premium Liberty Seated dime lot that deserves close inspection and spirited bidding. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval. The label documents the F-101a die variety attribution. Current Bid: $285
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 36563 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1849 Seated 10C 1849

EF40 		PCGS
80804061 		F-101a

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. A wholesome 1849 dime, at the certified grade, that deserved inclusion in the Steven Vitale Collection auction. Light gray surfaces are enhanced with peripheral grayish-gold. Strike is complete and above average for the date. Fields are unabraded with some "dirt" validating the originality. The F-101 obverse is easily recognized by a thin date with the 1 and 8 digits being especially weak. All digits are shallow in relief and are separated as compared to the remainder of 1849 obverse dies. For F-101a designation, the reverse must exhibit a long die crack starting from rim, through UNITE(D) and into the wreath. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $125 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1849O Seated 10C 1849-O
Large O
AU50 		PCGS
82690112 		F-101

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. As a rule, 1849 New Orleans dimes are often seen with problematic surfaces and weak strikes. The F-101 large O die pairing, in particular, is notorious for partial heads. What a pleasant surprise when first laying eyes on the Vitale lot! This is a unquestionably premium example with lightly crusted golden silver-gray patina and a bold strike. All but the top of Liberty's head is completely impressed with full wreath leaf views. It does not get better than this for a F-101. Reddish-gold "dirt" is evident in the protected areas as a testament to the strict originality. Worthy of a strong bid as the winner will be pleased. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $875 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1850 Seated 10C 1850

AU58 		PCGS
84782975 		F-104

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. The 1850 F-104 obverse has a lightly punched date with an open 5 digit. A reverse die crack from the lower left wreath through left stem end to rim matches the same die crack position found on 1849 Reverse B. This example is at the upper end of the Vitale grade range at AU58 with steely frosted luster and aquamarine, blue and gold light toning. Luster is brilliant and pleasing. Strike is hammered with spider web like die crack through the stars. Might I suggest careful scrutiny of the images and an aggressive bid to take this choice example home? Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Current Bid: $428
# of Bids: 3
Unique Bid Number: 29753 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1850O Seated 10C 1850-O

VF30 		PCGS
80804064 		F-103

Original 		Near-Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. 1850 New Orleans struck dimes will be found with three different mintmark sizes. The Large O is the most frequently encountered followed by a debate on whether the Medium O or the Small O are more difficult since each from a single die pair. My web-book rarity rating is R5 for the Small O in grades of VF or better. Now that the die variety rarity has been exposes for this Vitale Collection example, bidders should take note and bid accordingly. Surfaces are a natural gray with the often seen weak obverse strike. Please note the images and bid accordingly. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $325 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1851O Seated 10C 1851-O

VF35 		PCGS
80804066 		F-101

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. The 1851 New Orleans dime issue totaled 400,000 and suggested for years that more than one die pair should have been utilized. However, decades of research have only identified one a single die pair with the obverse receiving careful maintenance. The maintenance resulted in progressively weaker motifs and many seen with steely to partially mirrored fields. This Vitale Collection lot was struck early on during the production year as the drapery is well defined as bold along with all motifs and elevated rims. Fields are essentially unabraded. Worthy of a strong bid as the reserve is quite fair for the quality. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $400 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1852O Seated 10C 1852-O

VF30 		PCGS
80804068 		F-101

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. Pretty orange-brown and peripheral teal blue toning brought the inclusion of this 1852-O dime into the Vitale auction. A popular New Orleans date that is always in demand due to a limited mintage of only 430,000. The F-101 die variety is easily attributed by a thin mintmark. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $325 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1853 Seated 10C 1853
With Arrows
AU55
 PCGS
34664191 		F-107

Gem 		Repunched Date, Gem Original, Steven Vitale Collection. This Vitale Collection offering is quite noteworthy and should garner substantial interest. The 1853 With Arrows mintage is massive for that era with over 12 million pieces struck. A portion of the obverse dies were sunk with separate date and arrows punches, certainly a tedious task for the Chief Engraver or assistant. Only one die has been discovered with bold repunching which is a testament to the workmanship of that period. Early die state F-107 examples will show bold repunching on the 1853 digits in the date and a perfect reverse die. As the dies age, the date repunching is diminished and reverse die cracks appearing at top of letters STA(TES) and A(MERICA). John McCloskey first published the 1853 With Arrows repunched date variety in the March 1980 issue of the Gobrecht Journal. This gem example was struck by early die state dies as the surfaces are partially mirrored with steely reflectance. Copper-gold shades are predominant with a thin aquamarine ring at the periphery. Listed in the Top 100 Varieties set and highly desirable. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval. The label captures the die variety as RPD FS-301, F-107 Current Bid: $400
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 67176 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1853 Seated 10C 1853
No Arrows
VF25 		PCGS
81228934 		F-102

Choice 		No Arrows, Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. The 1853 No Arrows dime remains elusive in all grades other than Mint State. 1853 was a substantial transitional year for American coinage. Early in 1853, the Philadelphia Mint produced 95,000 dimes under the old weight standard of 2.67 grams. Subsequently in 1853, the planchet weight was reduced to 2.49 grams. To signify the change, engravers initially hand punched arrows on either side of the date, and proceeded to strike over 12 million pieces. As the No Arrows was issued at the Philadelphia mint, there were enough local collectors to save some Mint State example with the balance reaching circulation. Circulated survivors are infrequently offered in today's market. This Vitale lot is superbly preserved with natural gray patina is that is strictly original and uniform. The old time eye appeal is readily evident. As a VF20, this piece would easily secure CAC approval, therefore bid accordingly. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $550 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1854O Seated 10C 1854-O
With Arrows
EF40 		PCGS
80804072 		F-106

Original 		Original, Steven Vitale Collection. The Vitale Collection 1854-O dime certainly illustrates the F-106 polished reverse die variety well!. Note how the legend and mintmark are partially effaced. Surfaces are toned a medium gray while the reflectance holds this one back from a choice rating. The reserve has been set accordingly. A cool example for the die variety specialist. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $200 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1855 Seated 10C 1855
With Arrows
AU58
 PCGS
82690113 		F-109

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. 1855 Philadelphia strikes are a much better With Arrows date as mintage decreased to slightly over 2 millions as compared to the 12+ million struck during 1853. While the 1853 strikes were saved in quantities in high grade, final year With Arrows strikes entered circulation with a minimum number of choice Mint State survivors. This Vitale Collection lot is perfect for the certified grade given its nearly pristine surfaces along with a complete strike. Natural golden brown decorates both sides while bright light review exposes steely luster. A well hidden line above O(N)E is noted for completeness. Serious fans of the Seated dime series should be ready to place a strong bid given the CAC approval. CAC has approved only 30 in all grades with 11 finer. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval. Current Bid: $475
# of Bids: 2
Unique Bid Number: 69869 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1856 Seated 10C 1856
Small Date
AU50 		PCGS
16455387 		F-108
Choice 		Double Die Obverse, Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. 1856 Philadelphia strikes are known for multiple doubled obverse dies. The F-108 obverse exhibits dramatic horizontal die doubling and has been included in the Top 100 Varieties set. The entire shield and gown lines above the pendant are doubled east. Doubling is also visible on Liberty's pole. The 185 digits are repunched. Repunching can be seen above the flag of the 1 digit, on the upper loop of the 8 digit and above the flag of the 5 digit. This Vitale example exhibits crusty golden-gray patina while strike is complete. Partial wire rims are also evident. A premium F-108 offering that warrants scrutiny and a strong bid. The Top 100 Varieties pricing guide can be found at https://www.seateddimevarieties.com/major_100_pricing.htm. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.5 (2012-2013) holder. The label documents the die variety as Small Date DDO FS-1101. Current Bid: $275
# of Bids: 2
Unique Bid Number: 36693 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1856O Seated 10C 1856-O

VF30
 PCGS
27363980 		F-108

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. The 1856-O F-108 die variety is typically located in an early die state with a medium upward sloping date. The denticles below the date are poorly struck. The Medium O mintmark is positioned left and low. Die clashing is visible between DI(ME) and above the lower leaf to the right of the mintmark. This VF30 certified example is strictly original with uniform coin gray patina in the fields that provide circulated cameo contrast to the lighter motifs. A picture perfect lot that deserves spirited bidding. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.6 (2013-2014) holder with CAC approval. Reserve: $200 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1856O Seated 10C 1856-O

VF30 		PCGS
13709655 		F-105

Original 		Near-Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. The 1856-O Repunched Date Down has been a favorite Top 100 Varieties set listing given the bold initial 56 digits that are easily recognized behind the final date. This die was poorly maintained with considerable die rust that leads to weak motifs. Rose-gray patina is consistent on both sides of this example with the die being in an earlier die state. Rim abrasions at K-10 preclude a GFRC-Choice quality rating. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.6 (2013-2014) holder. The label documents the die variety attribution as RPD FS-2301. Reserve: $200 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1856S Seated 10C 1856-S

EF45 		PCGS
81798221 		F-101

Original 		Near-Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. 1856 brought the first year of Liberty Seated dime production at the San Francisco mint. Only 70,000 pieces were struck with essentially all entering western frontier circulation. This date is very rate in Mint State with EF and AU survivors rated as R5+ by Greer and Fortin. This Vitale Collection example exhibits a complete strike with minimally worn device high points. While the reverse is toned a natural copper-gold and has original steely fields, the obverse is more reflective with several lines in the right field. Regardless, this is a desirable example to fill in that difficult "hole" in a date and mintmark set. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $1850 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 18571878 Seated 10C 1857-1878

VF-EF 		PCGS


Choice 		1857 Through 1878, An 8 Piece Lot, Choice at Grades, Steven Vitale Collection. An eight piece lot offering of lower priced date and grades from the Steven Vitale Collection. Dates and PCGS grades are as follows; 1857 VF35 light gray, 1858 EF45 gray with peripheral copper-gold, 1861 Type 2 obverse, light gray, 1868 EF40 medium gray, 1871 EF45 even gray, golden peripheral highlights, 1873 VF30 No Arrows Open 3 ebony-gray, 1875-CC Below Wreath, white frosted luster, 1878 MS62 with olive-gray surfaces. All are newly graded and housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 and 6.1 holders. Please click on icon image for a high resolution download. One bid can win this entire lot! Reserve: $975 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1857O Seated 10C 1857-O

EF40 		PCGS
33809766 		F-105

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. How I wish that all circulated Liberty Seated coinage could be so strictly original as this Vitale 1857 F-105 dime. Both sides are layered with thick crusty gray patina that is quite attractive. Surfaces are well preserved with a coating of "dirt" on the left wreath and into the denomination. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $125 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1858O Seated 10C 1858-O

EF45
 PCGS
28653337 		F-101

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. 1858 New Orleans dime coinage was accomplished with from a single die pair. As the dies produced a substantial 290,000 strikes, soft strikes become the norm with weak head, gown line and reverse wreath leaves. This Vitale Collection example is a real sweetheart in terms of originality and a better than average strike. Steely reflective fields are consistent for the date while the bright light reflectance and eye appeal is well above the cataloger's expectations. While a single mark by the 1 digit precludes a higher GFRC quality rating, the overall appearance is certain to please fans of the series. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.6 (2013-2014) holder. Current Bid: $490
# of Bids: 3
Unique Bid Number: 92369 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1858S Seated 10C 1858-S

AU50 		PCGS
32657490 		F-103

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. The superb 1858-S example should garner substantial attention and bidding. One of the three low mintage 1850s dates, choice survivors are terribly difficult to locate. This Vitale Collection lot is well beyond my expectations for the F-103 die pairing, usually seen with a weak obverse strike. Unabraded surfaces have been meticulously preserved while the toning is a natural rose-gray with peripheral gold highlights. Unquestionably original and deserving of aggressive bidding. Don't let this GFRC-Choice rating example get away! Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $2500 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1859 Seated 10C 1859

AU55
 PCGS
14698347 		F-107

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. Exposing this 1859 dime to a bright light unleashes brilliant steely luster and a color cavalcade. Intermixed rose, gold, and aquamarine provide a pleasing viewing experience along with more defined ring toning on the reverse. A complete strike further enhances the eye appeal. CAC population totals 54 in all grades. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval. Current Bid: $513
# of Bids: 3
Unique Bid Number: 86494 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1859O Seated 10C 1859-O

AU53
 PCGS
11782742 		F-103

Choice 		Near-Gem Original, Steven Vitale Collection. 1859 New Orleans strikes will be seen with two mintmark sizes; Large O and Medium O. This F-103 Medium O is absolutely delightful given its brilliant frosted luster and aquamarine-gold patina. The dark obverse coloration slightly mutes the luster while the reverse is fully transparent. Mint frost is present on both sides and nicely decorates a complete strike. This lovely example is worthy of a GFRC-Gem quality rating and is guaranteed to delight the winning bidder. Please don't hold back on this Vitale Collection lot. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval. Current Bid: $428
# of Bids: 2
Unique Bid Number: 90236 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1859S Seated 10C 1859-S

VF35 		PCGS
28687065 		F-101

Original 		Near-Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. 1859 San Francisco strikes amounted to only 60,000 pieces with only three examples securing a PCGS Mint State certification. Acquiring specimens even at the VF and EF grades will prove to be quite challenging as few reach the market in a year's time. This date is well known for its low survival rate when choice as nearly all examples entered circulation during the busy California gold rush era. This Vitale Collection example is toned a moderate coin gray with steely fields and residual reflectance. Though the strike is not complete, a constant issue for the date, this lot features complete stars and well defined leaves in the upper wreath. Surfaces have been lightly wiped in the past but well within the PCGS requirements for certification. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.6 (2013-2014) holder. Reserve: $1800 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1860 Seated 10C 1860

AU50 		PCGS
81637663 		F-110

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. 1860 brought the introduction of the initial With Legend obverse design hub per Longacre-Paquet. The motifs have delicate device details which are subject to rapid wear. The F-110 die pairing exhibits a weak date punch as the bases of the 1 digit are thin and the 6 digit is open with the upper ball of the 6 digit is well away from the lower loop. This Vitale Collection example retains its steely-frosted luster which leads to a pleasurable bright light viewing experience. Copper gold shades decorate the obverse while the reverse is toned a uniform gray. Strike is typical for the variety. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $100 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1860O Seated 10C 1860-O

VF35 		PCGS
29459342 		F-101

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. The final year of New Orleans pre-Civil War dime production amounted to only pieces. All went into circulation with many survivors being battlefield metal detector finds. This date is brutally difficult to locate choice as CAC has approved only 26 in all grades with the majority being in VF or lower. This Vitale Collection specimen has secured a GFRC-Choice quality rating and a CAC attempt that was unsuccessful. Surfaces are deemed original with typical light silver gray coloration. This date often comes poorly struck as is the case here. This is an above average example that would well represent the date in most any Seated dime date and mintmark set. Housed in PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) Dupont hologram holder. Reserve: $3500 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1860S Seated 10C 1860-S

VF35
 PCGS
24065592 		F-102

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. 1860 San Francisco strikes where accomplished with the With Stars design hubs while the Philadelphia and New Orleans mint made the transition to the new With Legend design. This example is a choice original survivor with moderate wear and residual steely luster. Surfaces are toned a light gray with golden highlights. The green bean sticker is warranted. CAC population totals 34 in all grades. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.5 (2012-2013) holder with CAC approval. Reserve: $700 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1861S Seated 10C 1861-S

VF35 		PCGS
81228935 		F-101

Original 		Original, Steven Vitale Collection. 1861 San Francisco struck dimes are the most challenging of the Civil War era. Mintage was limited to 172,400 piece struck with the Type 1 obverse hub that was prone to rapid wear of the delicate devices. This Vitale Collection example is typical of present day survivors as the surfaces are light gray with some reflectance from a long ago wipe but sufficiently attractive for PCGS certification. Choice examples are rare as CAC has approved only 21 in all grades. Most collectors will be pleased to own a certified example as is the case here. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $750 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1862 Seated 10C 1862

AU53 		PCGS
81637664 		F-101a

Original 		Original, Steven Vitale Collection. A pleasing circulation strike example of the F-101 die pair that was also employed for earlier proof strikes. Fields retain their lightly mirrored reflectance when placed under a bright light. Toning is a rose-gold. Elevated wire rims are noted on both sides and consistent with the die variety. Field chatter precludes a higher quality rating. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $100 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1862S Seated 10C 1862-S

VF30 		PCGS
32962292 		F-102

Original 		Original, Steven Vitale Collection. Crusty mottled gray surfaces are promptly noted for this 1862 San Francisco strike. Grading is conservative as the left breast has limited wear along with complete gown lines and raised edges on the shield's banner. There are multiple obverse surface abrasions that could have resulted in a net grade opinion. Overall strike is bold with nicely defined motifs. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $650 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1863 Seated 10C 1863

VF35
 PCGS
16126769 		F-101a

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. Civil War era Philadelphia business strikes have been collecting challenge for decades. Many collectors have resorted to placing proof strikes into those difficult to fill "hole". I applaud the Vitale consignor for locating this GFRC-Choice example with natural coin gray patina and steely fields. Circulated examples are consider to be an R5+ rarity by Greer and Fortin while CAC has approved only 10 examples in all circulated grades. Spirited bidding is expected and deservedly so. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval. Reserve: $2700 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1863 Seated 10C 1863

VF25 		PCGS
15860230 		F-101a

Original 		Original, Steven Vitale Collection. The Vitale Seated Dime Collection contains a duplicate 1863 dime which has been added to the auction event. Another Civil War era offering with only five certified by PCGS at the VF25 grade. This moderately worn example exhibits frosted light gray surfaces along with copper-gold at the rims. Most collectors lack these difficult low mintage Philadelphia dates with this example being yet another opportunity for acquisition. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder. Reserve: $1650 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1863S Seated 10C 1863-S

EF40 		PCGS
20955688 		F-101

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. 1863 San Francisco dimes are notorious for exhibiting weakly struck obverses, especially at STATES OF within the legend. Locating fully struck examples will take considerable effort. I'm quite impressed with this Vitale Collection example given the medium gray patina along with embedded rose and blue shades that appear under angled lighting. Steely surfaces are well preserved while the strike is above average. This lot warrants close inspection and consideration. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder. Reserve: $875 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1864S Seated 10C 1864-S

VF35 		PCGS
80804076 		F-101

Original 		Original, Steven Vitale Collection. 1864 San Francisco strikes totaled 230,000 pieces with strike weakness at Liberty's head and the bow knot being common. This Vitale Collection example presents residual steely reflective luster during bright light assessment. Surfaces are toned a light gray with hints of rose and blues. Strike is typical while the grading is accurate. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $500 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1865 Seated 10C 1865

VF30
 PCGS
82455070 		F-101b

Choice 		Near-Gem Original, Steven Vitale Collection. A premium 1865 business strike lot that was previously source from GFRC with the coverted JUST BUY IT NOW recommendation. This PCGS VF30 CAC approved example continues to hold it Pop 1 status. Mintage was limited to only 10,500 resulting in a R5 rarity rating at all grade levels. Quality Civil War Philadelphia mint strikes have all but disappeared from the market given the popularity of the United States Civil War era. This 1865 example offers choice original surfaces and a bold strike. Rims are quite sharp for the certified grade while only one obverse line holding this piece from a GFRC-Gem quality rating. There is considerable eye appeal as light to medium gray toning allows all the device details to be easily enjoyed with naked eye. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval. Current Bid: $2650
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 55939 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1865S Seated 10C 1865-S

VF30 		PCGS
29550947 		F-102

Original 		Original, Steven Vitale Collection. 1865-S dimes are well known for partial head strikes and this F-102 die pairing struck example is typical. A new die marriage sees the F-101 obverse paired with an old reverse die that was previously used during 1861 and 1862. For unknown reasons, the die was not discarded and appears again during 1865 for a limited number of strikes. This Vitale Collection lot has original gray surfaces with steely fields during bright light assessment. The darker spots are field ticks that have accumulated dirt. Housed in PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) Dupont hologram holder. Reserve: $650 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1866 Seated 10C 1866

EF45 		PCGS
81751162 		F-102a

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. Steely reflective fields are promptly noted when inspecting this GFRC-Choice rated 1866 business strike under bright light. Strikes were limited to only 8,000 pieces with circulated examples assigned an R5+ rarity rating by Greer and Fortin. The GFRC images are limited in their ability to portray the eye catching coloration that is activated by angled lighting. The reverse, in particular, shifts from even gray to center rose and peripheral blues. This Vitale lot is well preserved with essentially unabraded fields that are clashed consistent with F-102b diagnostics. Collectors should be aware of 1866-S dimes with a weak or missing mintmark being offered as a Philadelphia 1866 dime. Always check for an upward sloping date as validation of a Philadelphia strike. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $1750 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1866S Seated 10C 1866-S

EF40 		PCGS
32892431 		F-101

Original 		Original, Steven Vitale Collection. Rose-gray toning is consistent on both sides of this 1866-S F-101 dime. Bright light inspection exposes steely fields and the predominance of rose coloration, especially on the reverse. Like many F-101 examples, the mintmark is lightly impressed, which has been known to cause confusion with separating this variety from regular Philadelphia strike. Accurately grades with the usual reverse wreath weakness. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $600 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1867 Seated 10C 1867

MS63 		PCGS
80594025 		F-102

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. The key Philadelphia date within the Liberty Seated dime series as only 6,000 1867 dated dimes were struck from a single die pair dedicated to circulation strikes. All 1867 business strikes will be found with an obverse die that is heavily clashed, however the reverse die shows no signs of being clashed. Both Ahwash and Greer indicated that no proofs have been seen from this die pair. This Vitale Collection example features heavily striated fields that might be seen as hairlines by the inexperienced numismatist. Fields are mirrored with sharp reflectance. Wire rims are well defined on both sides. Peripheral copper-gold nicely frames untoned centers. Accurately graded and housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $3850 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1867 Seated 10C 1867

F12 		PCGS
80641342 		F-102

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. Circulated 1867 dimes are actually rarer than their Mint State counterparts with Greer and Fortin assigning R6 rarities to those in circulated grades versus R5 to those in Mint State. PCGS certified population at offer grade is only 5 pieces. This well preserved and naturally toned example is evenly worn and covered with medium gray patina. All letters in LIBERTY are clearly defined along with crisp banner edges. Surfaces are unquestionably choice with abrasions limited to a single ancient line from Liberty's midsection into the shield. An opportunity to acquire the Philadelphina key date with perfectly original surfaces. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $1800 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1867S Seated 10C 1867-S

VF35 		PCGS
19448691 		F-102

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. By 1867, the Civil War had concluded with the United States moving into the Reconstruction era. Across the continent, the San Francisco mint continue to strike subsidiary silver coinage including 140,000 dimes from two die pairs. Both die varieties share the same obverse. This F-102 lot is toned an even coin gray with hints of peripheral copper-gold under angled lighting. A few circulation micro-ticks do not impact the overall eye appeal. The F-102 variety will be rarely seen with a partial date due to a grease filled die. Fairly graded and housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $550 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1868S Seated 10C 1868-S

EF45 		PCGS
29427480 		F-101

Original 		Near-Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. The entire 1868-S mintage of 260,000 was accomplished with a single pair. Those dies suffered significant erosion during later die states. Heavy metal flow lines will predominantly be seen on the reverse along with weakly defined wreath devices as is the case for this Vitale Collection specimen. Though the devices are weak, mint bloom has been imparted to both sides with glowing satiny luster during bright light assessment. This piece has been conservatively grade from a wear perspective with AU device details. Housed in PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) Dupont hologram holder. Reserve: $500 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1869 Seated 10C 1869

VF25 		PCGS
33809774 		F-105a

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. 1869 dimes will be found with two different date punch styles. They are known as the Short and Large Flag 1 punches. The Long Flag 1 dies were initially employed for proof strikes and later, business strikes with the (a) suffix on the variety number. This F-105a example is evenly worn with rich aquamarine and peripheral gold patina. The underlying fields retain their steely reflectance during bright light assessment. An unquestionably choice example that warrants a strong bid. PCGS has only certified 4 at grade and an additional 9 at VF30 as this is a challenging date. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $165 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1869S Seated 10C 1869-S

VF35 		PCGS
80804078 		F-101a

Original 		Original, Steven Vitale Collection. 460,000 dimes dated 1869 were struck at the San Francisco mint that year with two different mintmark styles. The F-101 pairing, the offered example, has a small thin S mintmark while the second reverse is easily attributed by a small weak S. The F-101 die pair will become clashed before major die degradation takes place. In this late F-101a die state, the obverse exhibits considerable die wear and heavy metal flow lines between the rim and all the letters in UNITED STATES. This Vitale example is well preserved with consistent gray patina. Several surface anomalies limit the GFRC quality rating. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $275 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1870 Seated 10C 1870

AU55 		PCGS
82696062 		F-104

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. Interestingly, 1870 F-104 repunched date survivors will be seen with a similar die finish that results in rich steely frosted luster. This Vitale Collection is consistent in appearance and especially appealing under a bright light. The bold date repunching won this variety a spot in the Top 100 Varieties set. Surfaces are well preserved with a GFRC-Choice quality rating being a conservative assessment. Nicely raised rims are noted on both sides. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Current Bid: $250
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 30307 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1870S Seated 10C 1870-S

AU58 		PCGS
36484122 		F-101

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. 1870-S dated dimes have a reported mintage of only 50,000 from a single die pair. This date is one of the great challenges facing a new Seated dime set collector as few choice examples are known. CAC population is a tiny 12 examples with 8 being in MS64/MS65. A hoard of six Mint State pieces was reported by noted Seated dealer, Jim O'Donnell, when I was collecting in the 1990s. Locating a choice AU58 example in the Vitale Collection was a pleasant surprise. Steely frosted luster is quite brilliant along with active cartwheels. The reverse eye appeal is particularly compelling. Strike is typical for the issue with a partial head and wreath devices. Please consider this lot carefully as it could be years before another AU58 reaching the marketplace. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Current Bid: $3000
# of Bids: 2
Unique Bid Number: 67865 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1871CC Seated 10C 1871-CC

VF25 		PCGS
82465901 		F-101

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. I must applaud Steven Vitale for his attention to the four key date Carson City issues. All are found at the VF grades with the 1871-CC and 1874-CC examples being fully choice and without a trace of porosity or being "enhanced". Locating strictly original 1871-CC dimes is a substantial challenge but now bidders can make their play. This example is toned a light gray with moderated circulated cameo eye appeal. Surfaces are unabraded regardless of considerable time in circulation. Reverse "dirt" is seen surrounding the left wreath devices. This piece will garner much attention and is worthy of a strong bid as few come this nice and problem free. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Current Bid: $17850
# of Bids: 3
Unique Bid Number: 61845 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1871S Seated 10C 1871-S

VF35 		PCGS
80804079 		F-101

Original 		Near-Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. Three different die pair were employed to strike all of the 320,000 1871-S dimes producted. All three varieties have a small, weak mintmark with one reverse being left over from 1869 and 1870 usage. The F-101 die pairing can be attributed by repunching above the 18 digits though the repunching will be difficult to see during later die states. Dusty coin gray patina cover both sides of this Vitale lot. Birght light inspection reveals steely-frosted fields with residual luster. Surfaces are lightly abraded but consistent with the cerified grade. A decent example that is worthy of careful inspection. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Current Bid: $350
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 11933 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1872 Seated 10C 1872

MS61 		PCGS Rattler
7238603 		F-101

Choice 		Near-Gem Original, Steven Vitale Collection. This is a superb 1872 F-101 example with partially mirrored fields that radiate gobs of reflective luster with angled lighting. A few obverse field hairlines preclude a higher GFRC quality rating but the eye appeal is that of a gem. Rims are elevated and attest to the Mint State certification. Though a "common" date, this piece deserved careful scrutiny and aggressive bidding. Housed in PCGS Gen 1.2 (1986-1987) rattler holder. Current Bid: $250
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 57602 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1872 Seated 10C 1872

AU53 		PCGS
28724950 		F-102

Original 		Triple Punched 2, Near-Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. The 1872 F-102 variety is well known for exhibiting a 2 digit that has been triple punched. The most obvious repunching is seen within the upper loop of the digit. Additional repunching is seen along the top of the base of the 2. This Vitale Collection example offers brilliant steely frosted luster when viewed with angled lighting. Strike is bold, and consistent with the Philadelphia mint workmanship of that year. Two lines at Liberty's foot preclude a higher quality rating though the eye appeal is that of a choice specimen. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.6 (2013-2014) holder. Current Bid: $145
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 30469 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1872 Seated 10C 1872

EF40 		PCGS
18724749 		F-105

Original 		Doubled Die Reverse, Original, Steven Vitale Collection. A spectacular doubled die error on the reverse of an 1872 dime was discovered by Dave Thomas during April 1999 and published in the Gobrecht Journal by Tom DeLorey in July 2003. The reverse die was hubbed twice with the second hubbing being rotated approximately 175 degrees from the initial hubbing. Both the obverse and reverse dies are heavily clashed resulting in a treasure trove of attribution diagnostics. This Vitale Collection example is toned a light silver-gray with peripheral gold. Surfaces are minimally abraded and pleasing. Nearly all F-105 examples will be found with a partial head as is the case with this lot. Listed in the Top 100 Varieties set and worthy of an aggressive bid. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder. The label documents the die variety as DDR FS-801. Reserve: $750 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1872 Seated 10C 1872

EF40 		PCGS
33474145 		F-109a

Choice 		Misplaced Date, Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. Thick crusty patina and steely reflective fields are the highlights of this wonderful F-109a misplaced date lot. The misplaced right base of a 2 digit is easily seen below the pendant. This obverse die was first employed for a tiny number of proof strikes before being reused for business strikes. This fact becoming readily evident with bright light inspection due to the steely fields. A cool die variety that is listed in the Top 100 Varieties set. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. The label documents the die variety as MPD FS-302, F-109a. Current Bid: $125
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 37911 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1872CC Seated 10C 1872-CC

VF30 		PCGS
81637027 		F-101

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. Of the "big four" key date Carson City dimes, the 1872-CC is probably the easiest to locate given a mintage of 35,480. The Vitale Colletion specimen is a lovely VF30 certified example that warrants close scrutiny as assigned a GFRC-Choice quality rating. Angled ligthing exposes steely reflective fields that I believe are 100% original. Toning is a light silver gray. with slightly darker shading in the right obverse field. Some mint frost is still evident in the protected areas. This is a compelling offering that deserves aggressive bidding. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $6000 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1872S Seated 10C 1872-S

EF40 		PCGS
16772239 		F-101

Original 		Original, Steven Vitale Collection. A single die pair was employed to strike 190,000 1872 dated dimes at the San Francisco mint that year. This has resulted in the date being quite challenging to locate in EF or better. The Vitale Collection contains a steely-frosted example with obverse rose toning coupled with bluish shades in the center reverse. Strike is close to complete with the hair curls lacking full definition. Field chatter is seen on the obverse and precludes a higher GFRC quality rating. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder. Reserve: $400 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1873 Seated 10C 1873
No Arrows, Closed 3
AU55 		PCGS
82197164 		F-103a

Choice 		Repunched Date, Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. This is a wholesome 1873 F-103a lot with easily observed reverse die cracks. The digits in the date exhibit obvious repunching. Repunching is seen at the bottom left of each digit. There is a diagonal die line in the lower right gown. Examples of the F-103 die paring are typically seen with strong strikes, including full heads, regardless of die state. This Vitale Collection example offers frosted luster that is somewhat muted by a moderate crust of silver-gray patina. Surfaces are nearly unabraded and pleasing. A solid example that will please the winning bidder. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $225 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1873 Seated 10C 1873
With Arrows
AU55 		PCGS
29754711 		F-121

Choice 		With Arrows, Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection The reappearance of arrows at the date in 1873 coincides with the omnibus Mint Act of February 12, 1873. This act attempted to introduce the metric system for United States coinage weights. Much has been written about the lack of merit of this act given that the new metric weight of 38.58 +/- 1.5 grains (2.5 +/- 0.097 grams) for dimes completely overlapped the prior weight requirement of 38.4 +/- 0.5 grains. The re-introduction of arrows for coinage of 1873 and 1874 has created a desirable two year type coin. This F-121 example presents steely-frosted luster during angled lighting assessment. Strike is close to complete with only the upper left wheat grains lacking full definition. Light gold toning is more evident at the peripheries. A nicely presented example for the later date With Arrows type. Housed in PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) Dupont hologram holder. Reserve: $325 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1873 Seated 10C 1873
No Arrows, Closed 3
AU50 		PCGS
18742044 		F-103

Original 		No Arrows, Closed 3, Near-Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. A later die state example of the 1873 No Arrows F-103 die variety with all four date digits repunched. The repunched remains visible through the strength of the earlier digits is weakened. Surfaces are nicely frosted with luster that is consistent or better than the certified grade. Faint chatter is seen in the fields with a 10x. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder. The label documents the die variety as Closed 3 RPD FS-301. Current Bid: $150
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 65722 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1873 Seated 10C 1873
Doubled Die Obverse
VF35 		PCGS
16664662 		F-103

Choice 		Doubled Die Obverse, Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. This 1873 Double Die Obverse example offers incredible insights into the extensive doubling in the shield as the strike is hammered in the obverse center. The 1873 F-103 doubled obverse die variety was discovered by Kam Ahwash, but not published in his 1981 encyclopedia. This variety is considered as having an R-6 rarity and is infrequently encountered, bringing a significant premium when located. The Vitale example is strictly original with choice surfaces that are toned rose-gray with embedded gold that appears under angled lighting. Though not CAC approved, this lot is significant and should garner aggressive bidding. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder. The label documents the die variety as Doubled Die Obverse. Reserve: $2950 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1873CC Seated 10C 1873-CC
With Arrows
VF25 		PCGS
13656734 		F-101

Original 		Original, Steven Vitale Collection. By 1873, the Carson City mint was entering its fourth year of production. 1873 With Arrows strikes amounted to 18,791 pieces with the usual low survival rates for present collectors. This Vitale Collection example has been commercially graded as a 10x reveals surfaces that have been conserved. Bright light reflectance is considerable for a circulated example at the VF25 grade, but then again marketable survivors are few and far between. Obverse toning is gray with embedded rose while the reverse is more obviously toned. An important offering that has a fair reserve price. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder. Current Bid: $9500
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 50846 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1873S Seated 10C 1873-S
With Arrows
AU50 		PCGS
81637665 		F-101

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. Crusty antique gray patina is prevalent on this GFRC-Choice rated 1873-S F-101 dime. The toning is partially transparent to the underlying steely luster, more so on the lightly toned reverse. Residual mint frost is evident in the protected device areas. This is an unquestionably original example with repunching above the feet of the 1 digit. Deserving consideration and a strong bid. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $450 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1874 Seated 10C 1874
With Arrows
EF45 		PCGS
31515010 		F-109

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. Blue, rose, and gold intermixed colors are thoroughly pleasing on this 1874 F-109 dime. The underlying frosted luster is activated during bright light inspection. Surfaces are choice and fundamentally unabraded. A pretty piece for type or whatever your collecting goals might be. Housed in PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) Dupont hologram holder. Reserve: $225 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1874CC Seated 10C 1874-CC
With Arrows
VF25 		PCGS
84763771 		F-101

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. Finally, we arrive to the main act of the Steven Vitale Liberty Seated Dime collection. This 1874-CC dime is the key date for the entire series and will notably garner much attention. Most important is that the surfaces are choice and entirely free of porosity. Natural coin gray coloration is consistent on both sides. There are a few light scattered abrasions on the obverse while the reverse is pristine. I remember acting as a consulting for Steven when he remotely purchased this dime after I review the piece at a Whitman Baltimore show on his behalf. This piece has not been sent to CAC since being purchased through the selling dealer was probably sophisticated enough to make an attempt. All eyes will be watching the bidding on this key date piece and deservedly so! Housed in PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) Dupont hologram holder. Current Bid: $21500
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 29611 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1874S Seated 10C 1874-S
With Arrows
EF45 		PCGS
32948931 		F-102

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. This is a truly choice 1874-S F-102 dime with natural coin gray toning. The F-102 die pairing is easily attributed by a small thin S mintmark is that weakly punched into the reverse die. The reverse was poorly hubbed from the get go and is well known for its lack of wreath details. Bright light inspection is pleasing with hints of steely reflectance remaining. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $450 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1875 Seated 10C 1875

AU55 		PCGS
81637666 		F-118

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. A colorfully toned 1875 dime that secured a spot in the Vitale Collection auction sale though being a lower priced offering. Fully choice with steely fields under the thick patina. Perfect as a With Legend type piece or other collecting reason that could garner a bid. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $150 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 18751882 Seated 10C 1875-1882

VF-AU 		PCGS


Choice 		1875 Through 1882, An 8 Piece Lot, Choice at Grades, Steven Vitale Collection. An eight piece lot offering of lower priced date and grades from the Steven Vitale Collection. Dates and PCGS grades are as follows; 1875-S Below Wreath AU55 frosted luster, 1875-S In Wreath VF30 crusty light tannish gray, 1876 EF45 light gray, 1876-CC AU53 F-134 Doubled Die Reverse, 1876-CC VF35 peripheral copper-gold, 1877-CC EF45 steely gray with eye appeal, 1878 AU55 old album ring toning, and finally a delicious 1882 AU58 with golden gray patina. All are newly graded and housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 and 6.1 holders. Please click on icon image for a high resolution download. One bid can win this entire lot! Reserve: $1050 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1875CC Seated 10C 1875-CC
In Wreath
AU50 		PCGS
33780134 		F-107b

Original 		Near-Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. 1875-CC dimes have been one of my favorite dates since the early days of constructing The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Variety Collectors which was released during 2004. This In Wreath F-107b specimen was a pleasant surprise as few have been seen in several decades. The F-107b designation documents a greased fill die event where Liberty's head and shoulder are effaced to different degrees as the grease was worked out of the coin press. The Vitale specimen has a partial head with divot at the neck plus a partial shoulder. The reverse die crack in the left wreath is bold and consistent with the variety. Surface emit a silky frost with ample brilliance at the certified grade. Light gold patina is also present. A wonderful example of a rare die state that is worth aggressive pursuit. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $385 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1876CC Seated 10C 1876-CC
Type 1 Reverse
AU50 		PCGS
18742043 		F-111

Original 		Misplaced Date, Near-Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. The 1876-CC F-111 die variety is a spectacular occurrence of a two digit blundered date. The extra bases of the 76 digits are centered on either side of the right scroll end. The two misplaced bases of the 6 digit are easily seen to the right of the scroll end. The bases of the 7 digit can be found in the lower fold of the scroll, directly below LIBERT(Y). This Vitale Collection example is fully struck with bold motifs that accurately illustrate the misplaced digits. Under bright light, the fields present steely luster along with moderate rose-gold patina. A 10x review notes light hairlines in the obverse field that precludes a full GFRC-Choice quality rating. Listed in the Top 100 Varieties as entry #74. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder. The label documents the die variety as MPD FS-301. Current Bid: $350
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 11868 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1876CC Seated 10C 1876-CC
Type 2 Reverse
EF45 		PCGS
83650078 		F-101

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. Any appearance of an 1876-CC Type 2 reverse example is a big deal along with this Vitale Collection piece so crusty original. Though there are marks in the upper right wreath, I'm maintaining a GFRC-Choice quality rating given the marvelous preservation and rarity. A single Type 2 reverse die was employed for an unknown mintage. Die variety specialists should be all over this lot! Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. The label documents the die variety as Type 2 Rev FS-901, F-101. Reserve: $500 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1876CC Seated 10C 1876-CC
Doubled Die Obverse
EF40 		PCGS
36484929 		F-107

Original 		Right C High, Near-Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. The last of the three reverse die pairing with the 1876-CC double die obverse features a mintmark with the right C high. This pairing is the most available along with being the most poorly struck as the obverse die is heavily worn. Reverse marks preclude a higher quality rating though the surfaces are 100% original and covered with cursty brownish-gray patina. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. The label documents the die variety as DDO FS-102 Right C High. Current Bid: $425
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 91844 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1876CC Seated 10C 1876-CC
Doubled Die Obverse
VF35 		PCGS
33767631 		F-105

Choice 		Right C Low, Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. This is a strictly choice example of the first double die obverse die pairing that comes with pronounced doubling in the right legend. Greer states that "This is the scarcest of the three doubled die obverse die pairings overall, however this die pair is more often available than the Level CC mintmark reverse in grades of XF to Mint State. Rare in any grade." Orange shades become readily apparent when viewed with angled lighting. Worthy of a GFRC-Choice quality rating and strong bidding. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. The label documents the die variety as DDO FS-103 Right C Low. Current Bid: $200
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 63409 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1876CC Seated 10C 1876-CC
Doubled Die Obverse
VF25 		PCGS
37375819 		F-106

Original 		Level CC, Near-Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. 1876 Carson City dime production brought a host of die varieties including a boldly doubled obverse die that was paired with three different reverse dies. Greer conducted extensive rarity research for these die pairings. The doubled die obverse is in an interim die state when paired with a second reverse die that is easily recognized by a level CC mintmark with the denomination being doubled. The right side of the wreath including open corn ear is weak near the rim. Greer indicates that "This die combination is not as scarce as Right C Low reverse pairing, but in grades of XF or better it appears to be the rarest of the three. Extremely scarce above VF." This example is nicely original but some reverse marks preclude a higher quality rating. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. The label documents the die variety as DDO FS-101 Level CC, F-106 Current Bid: $250
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 62415 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1876S Seated 10C 1876-S
Type 1 Reverse
AU55 		PCGS
20349612 		F-123
Original 		Near-Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. One of the later 1876 San Francisco die pairings that was added to the Liberty Seated dime web-book with Type 1 Reverse F-123 designation. Note the Small Filled S and the partially hubbed M in DIME as the diagnostics. This near-choice Vitale Collection specimen offers an above average strike for the 1876-S date with crisply defined devices throughout obverse and reverse. A faint gold patina covers the surfaces that offer considerable luster. Frankly, this piece is conservatively graded and a great value at the reserve price.Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder. Current Bid: $150
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 82227 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1877 Seated 10C 1877
Type 2 Reverse
AU55
 PCGS
32258313 		F-115
Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. A splendidly preserved 1877 Type 2 reverse dime that should secure spirited bidding. Steely frosted fields are boldly reflective under angled lighting. Strike is hammered with sharp wire rims. Don't let this one get away as mightily fine! Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval. Current Bid: $150
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 59886 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1877CC Seated 10C 1877-CC
Type 2 Reverse
MS61 		PCGS
36129781 		F-108
Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. One of the most intriguing With Legend die varieties is the 1877-CC Type 2 F-108 as a case study example of multiple die preparation anomalies with the first identified overdate, date digit repunching including triple punching, and large obverse die scratch. This Vitale Collection specimen is well suited for the die variety specialist to enjoy viewing all anomalies including the 1877/6 overdate. Frosted surfaces are moderately brilliant with angled lighting. Chatter in the right obverse field is likely responsible for the certified grade. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. The label documents the die variety as F-108, Type 2 Rev, 1877/6 Reserve: $425 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1877S Seated 10C 1877-S

AU50 		PCGS
33809779 		F-101

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. A nicely original example of the 1877-S F-101 die pairing. The F-101 repunching is visible above the left and right feet of 1 digit and within the lower loop of the 8 digit on earlier date state examples. This Vitale Collection lot does not exhibit the repunching under 10x so bid accordingly. Surfaces are tone an even antique gray with soft frosted luster. Choice surfaces are pleasing. Note the dark area surrounding the reverse denomination is surface "dirt". Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $135 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1878 Seated 10C 1878
Type 2 Reverse
MS64 		PCGS
45544851 		Unlisted

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. Sharp wire rims and a bold strike were promptly noted when cataloging this near-gem 1878 dime. The die variety is unlisted as I'm unable to match this piece with any of those previously defined in the web-book. Brilliant frosted luster is partially muted by the thick multi-color patina. Rose and aquamarine shades are predominate on the obverse while the reverse exhibits center aquamarine surrounded by overlapping copper and yellow gold. Accurately graded as there are a few well hidden micro lines of little consequence during normal viewing. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2022) holder. Current Bid: $525
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 52404 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1878CC Seated 10C 1878-CC
Type 2 Reverse
AU53 		PCGS
06640153 		F-103

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. This is an exceptional example of the 1878-CC F-103 die variety with a lapped reverse die resulting in weakly defined left wreath devices. For 1878 Carson City strikes, three left over 1877 Type 2 reverse dies were lapped to accomplish the balance of the year's coinage demand. Those reverse dies are consistent weak with at least a full grade difference between obverse and reverse when located in circulated grades. The F-103 is the rarest of the 1878-CC Type 2 reverse die pairings with few extant in Mint State. Steely fields are covered with a base layer of gunmetal blue-gray patina along with overlaid gold on the obverse legend and reverse wreath. Surfaces are basically unabraded except for an ancient contact mark on Liberty's head. Other than the big four Carson City dates and the 1846, I believe this 1878-CC lot is one of the most important offering of the Steven Vitale Collection. Please bid accordingly. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.5 (2012-2013) holder. Reserve: $1400 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1879 Seated 10C 1879

AU58 		PCGS
30670346 		F-102a

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. 1879 brought three years of low mintage Seated dime coinage at the Philadelphia mint along with none struck at the branch mints. Regardless of only 14,000 pieces struck, the date was saved by collectors leading to present day availability. This F-102a business strike was struck from proof dies leading to partially mirrored fields and reflective luster when viewed under a bright light. Coloration is attractive with light rose-gold centers framed by peripheral aquamarine and gold. Fully choice with unabraded surfaces. Housed in PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) Dupont hologram holder. Current Bid: $800
# of Bids: 2
Unique Bid Number: 85664 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1880 Seated 10C 1880

MS63 		PCGS
81637667 		F-102a

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. 1880 Seated dime mintage increased to 36,000 pieces though still very low as compared to the high volume 1870s. This Mint State example presents steely frosted luster along with vibrant cartwheels. Darker peripheral copper-gold shades are readily evident in the images. Surfaces are essentially unabraded. The F-102 die pair is easily attributed by broken 8 and O date digits. The F-102a designation is for business strike from dies previously employed for proof coinage. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $675 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1880 Seated 10C 1880

EF45 		PCGS
16570396 		F-101

Original 		Proof Dies, Near-Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. The Vitale Collection 1880 dime is worthy of further study. The Fortin Seated Dime web-book list the F-101 die pairing as a proof only issue. However, this lot appears to be a business strike with matching F-101 diagnostics. The shallow head along with weakness in the left wreath elements is more consistent with a circulation strike. Natural rose-gray patina is consistent on both sides. Steely fields exhibit some reflectance with angled lighting. Circulation marks are noted on the lower gown folds and shield. The broken 8 digit and the lump on DI(M)E are easily seen with a 10x. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder. Reserve: $485 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1881 Seated 10C 1881

MS62 		PCGS
32972939 		F-102a

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. This is a thoroughly pleasing 1881 dime struck with dies original employed for proof strikes. Much of the 1879 through 1881 Seated dime coinage was accomplished with dual use dies. Fields are partially mirrored through bright light inspection exposes a light frost associated with business strikes. Wire rims are noted. Coloration is mostly teal with rose, gold, and aquamarine hues evident depending on the viewing angle. A few scattered micro-ticks are seen with 10x. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $800 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1881 Seated 10C 1881

EF40 		PCGS
43366673 		F-101a

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. The Vitale Collection contained two 1881 dimes with this being the second offered. Struck from the F-101 die pairing which was also employed for both proof and circulation strikes. Unabraded surfaces are layered with a thick coin gray patina. The grading appears to be a bit stringent but then again, I am more lenient with Legend design grading due to the shallow relief and propensity for weak strikes. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Current Bid: $475
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 79933 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 18831888 Seated 10C 1883-1888

EF-AU 		PCGS


Choice 		1883 Through 1888, An 8 Piece Lot, Choice at Grades, Steven Vitale Collection. An eight piece lot offering of lower priced date and grades from the Steven Vitale Collection. Dates and PCGS grades are as follows; 1883 EF40 crusty gray, 1884 EF45 light gray, 1885 old album aquamarine and copper-gold, 1886 AU53 classic gray AU with frosted luster, 1887 EF40 light gray, 1887-S EF40 frosted gray, nice surfaces, 1888 MS61 pretty frosted light gray with F-107 misplaced bottom 8 in shield, and finally 1888 AU58 brilliant frosted luster with F-105 repunched date. All are newly graded and housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 and 6.1 holders. Please click on icon image for a high resolution download. One bid can win this entire lot! Reserve: $750 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1884S Seated 10C 1884-S

VF35 		PCGS
33878889 		F-105

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. 1884 San Francisco dime production returned that year with a bit over a half millions struck with three obverse dies and four reverse dies. The F-105 pairing is a remarriage of both dies with their strikes being challenging to locate. This Vitale Collection example is evenly worn while covered with crusty gray patina. Surfaces are well preserved given the amount of time in circulation. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Current Bid: $150
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 15162 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1885S Seated 10C 1885-S

VF25 		PCGS
33587556 		F-101

Original 		Original, Steven Vitale Collection. Like the 1870-S date, 1885 San Francisco strikes are beyond challenging to locate choice. Nearly all survivors seen, from a mintage of 43,690, will have issues. It appears that the mintage went directly into west coast circulation and remains there for years. This Vitale Collection lot is typical of those seen. This piece has been wiped or dipped followed by retoning to its current brownish-gold coloration. Surfaces are reflective under angled lighting. Still a reasonable example of a very scarce date that could be the best located for several years. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $1750 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1886S Seated 10C 1886-S

AU53 		PCGS
30626161 		F-101

Original 		Near-Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. Brilliant frosted luster and light copper-gold toning are noted on this original 1886-S dime. Struck from the F-101 die pairing, which accounts for nearly all of the issue. Mint frost is evident in the protect areas. Several obverse hairlines preclude a higher GFRC quality rating. Housed in PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) Dupont hologram holder. Reserve: $450 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1887S Seated 10C 1887-S

MS66 		PCGS
37466747 		F-110

Gem 		Gem Original, Steven Vitale Collection. A single MS66 certified dime graces the Vitale Collection with fresh grading and unfortunately, an incorrect PCGS attribution. This gem 1887-S dime was struck from the F-110 die pairing and exhibits brilliant frosted luster and swirling cartwheels consistent with a superb gem certification. Intermixed rose, gold, and greens are semi-transparent to the underlying luster. Pristine surfaces are consistent with the assigned grade. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. The label documents the die variety as RPM FS-501, F-117 which is incorrect. This is not a repunched mintmark die variety. Reserve: $1200 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 18881891 Seated 10C 1888-1891

EF-AU 		PCGS


Choice 		1888-S Through 1891-S, An 8 Piece Lot, Choice at Grades, Steven Vitale Collection. An eight piece lot offering of lower priced date and grades from the Steven Vitale Collection. Dates and PCGS grades are as follows; 1888-S EF40 light gray with luster, 1889 EF45 gray with peripheral gold, 1890 EF45 crusty golden-gray, 1890-S AU55 F-116 partially mirrored with reflective luster, 1891 AU55 steely-frosted luster, 1891 EF40 even gray, F-107 misplaced date, 1891-O AU55 frosted white luster, 1891-S AU50 Small S steely gray with copper-gold rims. All are newly graded and housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 and 6.1 holders. Please click on icon image for a high resolution download. One bid can win this entire lot! Reserve: $700 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1889 Seated 10C 1889

AU58 		PCGS
04430546 		F-105

Choice 		Doubled Die Reverse #2, Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. Doubled Die Reverse #2 is one of five 1889 Liberty Seated dime reverse dies with obvious die doubling. The doubling on #2 is located on the outer left edge of (O)NE along with doubling on the outer edges of the maple leaves. This example is perfectly original and choice at the assigned grade level. Both sides offer uninterrupted frosty cartwheel luster. The obverse is toned in golden brown shades while the reverse is essentially untoned. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder. The PCGS label reads, "DDR FS-801 (FS-005.3)". This Vitale Collection lot is also the F-105 "web-book" plate coin at The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors. Ex. Gerry Fortin reference collection. Reserve: $235 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1889S Seated 10C 1889-S

AU55 		PCGS
81637668 		F-104

Original 		Near-Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. Brilliant frosted luster and vibrant cartwheels are the highlight of this 1889-S F-103 Small S mint marked dime. Cartwheels are vibrant and pleasing. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Reserve: $225 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1890 Seated 10C 1890

AU55 		PCGS
27642539 		F-105

Choice 		Misplaced Date, Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. The top loop of an extra 8 or 9 digit is seen immediately to the right of the scroll end on the 1890 F-105 die variety. The variety is listed as part of the Top 100 Varieties set. This Vitale lot is visually appealing due to brilliant frosted luster and light gold toning. The cartwheel action is vibrant and eye catching. Some field chatter on the upper left obverse precludes a higher GFRC quality rating. This is a great example of the variety at a fair reserve. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.6 (2013-2014) holder. The label documents the die variety as MPD FS-301. Current Bid: $135
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 33109 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1890 Seated 10C 1890

AU50 		PCGS
13935293 		F-106

Original 		Misplaced Date, Original, Steven Vitale Collection. This lot is the rare Four Misplaced Digits In Lower Gown die variety. The top loops of four digits are visible in the lower gown. The left and right outer digits appear to be the top loops of an 8 and 0 digits and are positioned directly above the final date punch. The two inner misplaced digits appear to be the top loops of a 9 and 0 punch. Chris Pilliod first published this spectacular misplaced date in the Gobrecht Journal. I consider the 1890 F-106 MPD to be one of the key varieties within the Seated Dime misplaced date series and also within the Top 100 Varieties set. The Vitale example is noted to have partially mirrored fields. Their reflectance is limited by scattered field abrasions thus the GFRC-Original quality rating. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.6 (2013-2014) holder. The label documents the die variety as MPD FS-302. Reserve: $300 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1890S Seated 10C 1890-S

AU53 		PCGS
13709617 		F-111

Choice 		Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. The 1890-S F-111 die variety is a bit of a controversy. The Medium S mintmark exhibits a strong right tilt. There is a punch artifact in the upper loop of the mintmark. This artifact has been designated as the remnants of a Small S mintmark in the Cherrypicker's Guide by Bill Fivaz and J.T. Stanton. After close examination of the this mintmark on several F-111 examples, I am not convinced that this variety is a Medium S over Small S mintmark. However, the offered Vitale specimen is quite choice with its brilliant frosted luster and light rose toning. Cartwheels are vibrant and pleasing. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.5 (2012-2013) holder. The label documents the die variety as RPM FS-501. Current Bid: $400
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 95924 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1890S Seated 10C 1890-S

AU53 		PCGS
32280554 		F-108

Original 		Near-Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. Only two of the fourteen documented 1890-S reverse dies were punched with a Small S mintmark. The F-108 variety has the Small S to the far left while the other is nicely centered. I've seen this second mintmark size occasionally listed in price guides as a special variety. Clearly much rarer than the Medium S with Greer and Fortin assigning an R5+ rarity rating for the Small S in EF/AU. Steely frosted luster is able to radiate through the light golden gray toning with angled lighting on this example. The reverse is fully struck with boldly defined motifs and pristine fields. The obverse has a weaker strike with a few contact marks. Housed in PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) Dupont hologram holder. The label documents the die variety as F-108, Small S. Reserve: $275 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1890S/S Seated 10C 1890S/S

AU58 		PCGS
28178889 		F-107

Choice 		Repunched Mintmark, Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. An important offering of the very scarce 1890-S/S F-107 die variety featuring offset repunched mintmark. The Medium S mintmark is repunched left. The right outline of the earlier Medium S is very visible to the right of the final S. The upper loop of the first S mintmark is also clearly visible within the upper loop of the final S. This offering has a similar appearance with the "web-book" plate coin though more uniform white. Brilliant reflective luster is eye catching as are the semi proof like fields. Strike is hammered with deeply impressed devices. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.6 (2012-2014) holder. Label contains die variety attribution as, "RPM FS-502. Current Bid: $500
# of Bids: 1
Unique Bid Number: 26113 		Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 10C 1891O/O Seated 10C 1891O/O
O/Horizontal O
VF30
 PCGS
38750635 		F-109

Gem 		O/Horizontal O, Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection. The Greer macro image plate coin (Greer-101) within the Complete Guide to Liberty Seated Dimes. Fully attributed and housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval. The PCGS label reads, "O/Horiz O FS-501, F-109 (FS-005.6). This lot was purchased by Fortin from Brian Greer during November 1992 after the release of his DLRC Press guide book. Sold into the Steven Vitale Collection early 2020 and now part of his auction divestment event. A thoroughly special example and probably the finest at the VF-EF grade level. Reserve: $500 Auction ends
9:00pm Saturday March 25th
Seated 5C 1840O Seated 5C 1840-O
With Drapery
EF45
 PCGS
15626249 		V-5

Gem 		Gem Original, New Orleans Collection Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval. Reserve: $1500 Auction Opens
9:00pm Saturday April 29th
Seated 5C 1852O Seated 5C 1852-O

AU58
 PCGS
12489276 		V-1

Choice 		Near-Gem Original, New Orleans Collection Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval. Reserve: $1450 Auction Opens
9:00pm Saturday April 29th
Seated 5C 1859O Seated 5C 1859-O

MS65
 PCGS
06864209 		V-1

Gem 		Gem Original, New Orleans Collection Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval. Reserve: $1850 Auction Opens
9:00pm Saturday April 29th
Buffalo 5C 1937D Buffalo 5C 1937-D
3 Legs
AU58
 NGC
6472608010

Choice 		Popular 3 Legs Variety, Choice Original, Osprey Collection. Housed in new large font NGC holder with CAC approval. Reserve: $2500 Auction Opens
9:00pm Saturday April 29th
Seated 50C 1841O Seated 50C 1841-O

EF40
 PCGS
13015736 		WB-9

Choice 		Choice Original, New Orleans Collection Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval. Reserve: $550 Auction Opens
9:00pm Saturday April 29th
Seated 50C 1878 Seated 50C 1878

MS63
 PCGS OGH
4545774

Choice 		Brilliant Frosted Luster, Choice Original, Saw Mill Run Collection Housed in PCGS Gen 3.1 (1993-1998) old green holder with CAC approval. Reserve: $1500 Auction Opens
9:00pm Saturday April 29th
Barber 50C 1895O Barber 50C 1895-O

MS64
 PCGS
25050300

Choice 		Near-Gem Original, New Orleans Collection Housed in PCGS Gen 4.5 (2012-2013) holder with CAC approval. Reserve: $3500 Auction Opens
9:00pm Saturday April 29th
Barber 50C 1895O Barber 50C 1895-O

VF35
 PCGS
18617814

Choice 		Choice Original, New Orleans Collection Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval. Reserve: $325 Auction Opens
9:00pm Saturday April 29th
Seated 25C 1840O Seated 25C 1840-O
No Drapery
VF35
 PCGS
14714450 		Briggs 1-A

Choice 		Near-Gem Original, New Orleans Collection Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval. Reserve: $500 Auction Opens
9:00pm Saturday April 29th
Seated 25C 1854O Seated 25C 1854-O
Huge O
VF35
 PCGS
12742941 		Briggs 1-A

Gem 		Huge O, Gem Original, New Orleans Collection Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval. Reserve: $3500 Auction Opens
9:00pm Saturday April 29th
Seated 25C 1856O Seated 25C 1856-O

EF45
 PCGS
13606660 		Briggs 7-F

Choice 		Choice Original, New Orleans Collection Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval. Reserve: $450 Auction Opens
9:00pm Saturday April 29th
Seated 25C 1890 Seated 25C 1890

AU50
 PCGS
84309063

Choice 		Wonderful Steely Luster, Light Gray-Gold Patina, Choice Original, Saw Mill Run Collection The second to last year of Liberty Seated quarter production at the san Francisco Mint brought only 80,000 strikes. The 1890 date is constantly in demand and never lasts long on the GFRC price list. This wonderfully choice example, from the Woodbridge Collection, also sold prior to reaching the price list. Surfaces are toned an even gray-gold and do not impede the underlying steely luster. Bright light viewing exposes lovely rose shades. Fairly graded and housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 holder with CAC approval. Reserve: $600 Auction Opens
9:00pm Saturday April 29th
Capped Bust 10C 1827 Capped Bust 10C 1827

AU50
 PCGS
21256681 		JR-11

Choice 		Choice Original, Osprey Collection. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.0 (1998-2002) holder with CAC approval. Reserve: $900 Auction Opens
9:00pm Saturday April 29th
Seated 10C 1859 Seated 10C 1859

MS62+
 PCGS
18438723 		F-103

Choice 		Extra 9 In Gown, Choice Original Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval. Reserve: $850 Auction Opens
9:00pm Saturday April 29th
Seated 10C 1875CC Seated 10C 1875-CC
Below Wreath
AU58
 PCGS
21620018 		F-104

Gem 		Gem Original, Ex. Lemus Collection, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection Housed in PCGS Gen 4.1 (2003-2004) holder with CAC approval. Purchased raw during October 2005 at the Stacks Lemus Collection Sale in New York City. Graded "choice BU" at the sale and subsequently holdered with fresh CAC approval. The F-104 plate coin within The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors. Reserve: $575 Auction Opens
9:00pm Saturday April 29th
Seated 10C 1875CC Seated 10C 1875-CC
Below Wreath
AU55
 PCGS
2781619 		F-111

Gem 		Gem Original, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection Housed in PCGS Gen 4.1 (2003-2004) holder with CAC approval. Purchased raw April 2002 and subsequently holdered with fresh Gold CAC approved. Reserve: $650 Auction Opens
9:00pm Saturday April 29th
Seated 10C 1876CC Seated 10C 1876-CC
Type 1 Reverse
MS64
 PCGS
60126715 		F-119

Choice 		Near-Gem Original, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection Housed in PCGS Gen 4.1 (2003-2004) holder with CAC approval. Purchased April 2006 from Dick Osburn in current holder with fresh CAC approval. The F-119 plate coin within The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors. Reserve: $1350 Auction Opens
9:00pm Saturday April 29th
Seated 10C 1889 Seated 10C 1889
Doubled Die Reverse
MS63
 PCGS
21300803 		F-122

Choice 		Double Die Reverse #3, Choice Original, Top 100 Varieties Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval. Reserve: $700 Auction Opens
9:00pm Saturday April 29th
Seated 10C 1890 Seated 10C 1890

MS64
 PCGS
31661958 		F-106

Choice 		Misplaced 9 In Gown, Near-Gem Original, Top 100 Varieties. Housed in PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) holder with CAC approval. Reserve: $750 Auction Opens
9:00pm Saturday April 29th
Gold G$2.5 1910 Gold G$2.5 1910
Liberty
MS61
 NGC Fatty
152837004

Gem 		Gem Original Housed in pristine NGC Gen 4 no line brown label Fatty holder with CAC approval. Reserve: $850 Auction Opens
9:00pm Saturday April 29th
Gold G$2.5 1926 Gold G$2.5 1926
Liberty
MS61
 NGC Fatty
152837003

Gem 		Gem Original Housed in pristine NGC Gen 4 no line brown label Fatty holder with CAC approval. Reserve: $850 Auction Opens
9:00pm Saturday April 29th
Gold G$2.5 1929 Gold G$2.5 1929
Liberty
MS62
 NGC Fatty
152837007

Gem 		Gem Original Housed in pristine NGC Gen 4 no line brown label Fatty holder with CAC approval. Reserve: $850 Auction Opens
9:00pm Saturday April 29th
Gold G$5 1905 Gold G$5 1905
Liberty
MS60
 PCGS
18277988

Gem 		Gem Original Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval. Reserve: $950 Auction Opens
9:00pm Saturday April 29th