CAC Certified Coins

To Order: Contact Gerry by Phone (207-329-9957) or Email using the shopping cart ()

About CAC Coins: John Albanese efforts to identify above average coins in Third Party Grading service holders is having a significant impact within the numismatic marketplace. Coins designated with the Green Bean easily bring full trend guide pricing along with premiums. Astute collectors are demanding only CAC validated coins for long term collecting objectives and sound financial holdings.

This price list features only Gerry Fortin Rare Coins inventory that has CAC approval. Look for the icon by individual listings.

 

There are 207 Coins for Sale. New coin(s) added on April 27, 2025

Photo Type Date Grade TPG Variety GFRC Rating Price Description Buy
Half & 1 Cent
Early Copper 1C 1822 Early Copper 1822
AU55
PCGS
84213480

Gem $1100 New March 5! Ideal Coronet Design Type, First Rate Eye Appeal, Coppery-Gray, Pristine Surfaces. GFRC does not have a vast early copper price list as I'm quite selective when purchasing this metal. The colors must be deeper chocolate and chocolate-gray for circulated example with a pristine planchet. What a surprise when Dr. Tim Cook include this 1822 Coronet example in his recent Liberty Seated dime consignment. Tim did very well with this purchase as the coloration is rich copper-gray with bold devices. The surfaces are entirely unabraded with light rub on the high points. If you like the images, then the coin in had will be that much better. Let's go with a JUST BUY IT NOW to make the point. Price consistent with the CAC price guide with 55 approved in all grades. There are 7 at the offered grade, a small number. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder.
Indian 1C 1872 Indian 1872
MS62BN
NGC
4712009002

Choice $1150 Semi-Key Date, Low Mintage, Unquestionably Choice. A choice 1872 Indian BN cent that is a semi-key date in the series. Though the mintage amounted to a tad over four million, the date circulated widely less than 75 certified by PCGS in the individual BN Mint State grades. CAC populations are much lower with 53 pieces approved in all graded when considering the BN designation. This offered example contains a substantial amount of red coloration when subjected to a bright light. Frosted luster and moderate cartwheels are also eivdent. A choice example for an Indian cent date set without breaking the budget. Housed in new large font NGC holder with CAC approval.
5 Cents
Capped Bust 5C 1831 Capped Bust 1831
MS62
NGC
4239596005
LM-6
Choice $950 Steely-Frosted Luster, Rose-Blue Centers, Strictly Original Presentation, CAC Approved. Yet another 2024 Whitman Baltimore new purchase that immediately spoke to me during its initial inspection. Steely-frosted luster has some sparkling traits under a bright light, and most important, is perfectly consistent on both sides. Blended rose-blue patina is predominate on the obverse center with the rose hues being a bit more pervasive on the reverse. The strike is complete with unabraded surfaces noted under a 10x. Overall, this is a charming piece that is a pleasure to view with angled lighting. Housed in new large font NGC holder with CAC approval.
Seated 5C 1838 Seated 1838
No Drapery, Large Stars
MS64
NGC
2685622002

Choice $1400 Creamy Frosted Luster, Complete Strike, Near-Gem, CAC Approved. Consignor Price Reduction - A boldly repunched star 8 is readily evident on this superbly preserved 1838 Seated half dime. Radiant mint bloom radiates creamy frosted luster when placed under angled lighting. Strike is fully executed with a reverse die crack through O(F) into the wreath. One reverse field mark holds this piece back from potential higher grade. The eye appeal is certainly there. Newly consigned and a premium example. Housed in new large font NGC holder with CAC approval.
Seated 5C 1858O Seated 1858-O
MS64
PCGS
21891928
V-1
Choice $825 Better Date, Brilliant Frosted Luster, Choice Original, CAC Approved, New Orleans Collection.. The New Orleans Collection continues to release duplicates including this pleasing 1858-O half dime candidate for a Mint State type set or a more comprehensive date and mintmark project. This near gem exhibits thick frosted luster on both sides without interruption under a bright light. Surfaces are unabraded and visually pleasing. Strike is nearly complete with only the right obverse stars showing mild weakness. Golden hues are a bit richer at the borders. A premium example that is certain to satisfy. the CAC price guide is currently $775 as reference. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.3 (2004) holder with CAC approval.
Seated 5C 1872 Seated 1872
PF64
CACG
706625039

Gem $950 Watery Mirrored, Colorful Presentation, Pristine Surfaces, Fresh CACG Grading. 1872 Liberty Seated half dimes proof strikes totaled 950 pieces. This survivor has been meticulous preserved leading to a host of positive attributes. First are the watery mirrors noted under a bright light along with colorful toning that consists of blues, aquamarine, and gold on the obverse while the reverse presents a rose center surrounded by green-gold overlaying the wreath. Second are the pristine surfaces without any traces of a single hairline. Finally, the strike is fully executed along with partial wire rims. The watery mirrors will be thoroughly enjoyed under a bright light. The lovely little half dime has been conservatively graded and is housed in new CAC Grading holder and graded consistent with CAC approval standards.
Seated 5C 1872S Seated 1872-S
In Wreath
MS65
NGC
3041167003

Gem $775 New March 9! In Wreath, Brilliant Frosted Luster, Swirling Cartwheels, Gem Original, Sheffield Collection. This 1872-S In Wreath half dime will provide Seated collectors with years of viewing pleasure. An irrefutable gem with brilliant frosted luster and swirling cartwheels under a bright light. Both sides are heavily clashed with a rotated reverse. The strike is 100% complete with fully defined devices. A die crack from Liberty's head into the upper right denticles is noted. Whether assembling a date and mintmark set or just shopping for type, this Sheffield Collection release is guaranteed to please. Housed in NGC Gen 17 (2004-2008) holder with CAC approval.
Liberty V 5C 1904 Liberty V 1904
PR64
CACG
55716718

Choice $485 Brilliant Mirrors, Near-Gem, Port Matilda Collection. The 1904 Liberty nickel proof mintage is 1,817 which renders this date common and with a high survival rate. The date is ideal for type collectors who wish for a proof specimen without paying a strong premium. Cameo example are rare or may not exist due to the way 20th century proofs were struck. This just released Port Matilda example features brilliantly reflective mirrors under a bright light. The surfaces are essentially unabraded and pleasing during 10x inspection. Housed in new CAC Grading holder and graded consistent with CAC approval standards.
Liberty V 5C 1905 Liberty V 1905
MS65
PCGS
45449795

Gem $550 Ideal Liberty 5c Type, Dazzling Frosted Luster, Swirling Cartwheels, Fully Struck. If attempting an early type set and searching for the right Liberty nickel, this 1905 gem example might fit the bill! A superb survivor with dazzling frosted luster and swirling cartwheels. This piece certainly rocks under a bright light and is an exciting viewing experience. Faint gold toning is more prevalent on the obverse. Strike is fully executed. This offering has eye appeal of a higher grade but a small mark on the reverse explains the certified grade per technical standards. I'm so impressed with this piece that a JUST BUY IT NOW call is necessary. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2022) holder with CAC approval.
10 Cents
Capped Bust 10C 1814 Capped Bust 1814
STATESOFAMERICA
VF25
CACG
145136361
JR-5
Choice $1700 Popular STATESOFAMERICA Variety, Circulated Cameo Eye Appeal, Beautifully Preserved. The 1814 Capped Bust dime date features three major varieties including the Large Date, Small Date, and STATESOFAMERICA as one word. CAC has only stickered 22 in all grades with this new offering as the lone piece housed in new CAC Grading holder and graded consistent with CAC approval standards. GFRC images accurately illustrate the darker olive-gray fields that nicely contrast with the much lighter devices. A careful 10x review revealed no abrasions or marks as the surfaces are surprisingly pristine given the time in circulation. Under a bright light, the fields present a steely appearance. This Summer Baltimore new purchase looks much better in-hand than on the images.
Capped Bust 10C 1820 Capped Bust 1820
Large 0
VF35
PCGS
15015334
JR-6
Choice $535 Better Die Pairing, Large 0, Notched Stars, CAC Approval. So what are "notched stars" for the 1820 Capped Bust dime date? Notched stars have a die punch defect on the outer star point facing the denticles. This JR-6 example also brings an R3 rarity rating and thick gray encrusted surfaces. A fully choice piece at the assigned grade that will please fans of strict originality. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval. A fresh GFRC buyback.
Capped Bust 10C 1821 Capped Bust 1821
Large Date
F15
PCGS
30709261
JR-5
Choice $315 Large Date, Near-Gem at Grade. This 1821 JR-5 dime does not warrant a long description as the images provide everything one needs to know about this offering. Surfaces are evenly worn and nicely preserved with a natural coin gray patina. Surfaces are well preserved considering the amount of time in circulation. The circulated eye appeal is certainly satisfying. CAC green bean approval provides further validation of the premier quality. Housed in PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) holder with CAC approval.
Capped Bust 10C 1834 Capped Bust 1834
Large 4
AU55
CACG
87189624
JR-4
Choice $825 Large 4, Noteworthy Eye Appeal, Steely Luster, Previously NGC CAC Approved, Emerald Isle Collection. How I wish more early type coins could be so well preserved as this pleasing 1834 JR-4 Large 4 dime. Steely surfaces are toned with rose, gray, and peripheral aquamarine shades. Obverse toning is lighter and facilitates rose colored reflective luster while the reverse has a thicker rose-gray "skin". Strike is fully executed other than the fine details in the eagle's talons. Fields are entirely unabraded too. Overall, a thoroughly pleasing offering for collectors who can relish in strict originality and natural toning. Previously sold by GFRC June 2021 when housed NGC holder with edge view insert and CAC approval. Our consignor has crossed the coin into a CACG Legacy holder with this work being done for the buyer.
Seated 10C 1837 Seated 1837
No Stars, Small Date
MS66+
PCGS
25239874
F-103
Gem $30000 Finest PCGS Certified, Superb Gem Original, Gerry Fortin Collection, Ex. Simpson and O'Neal Collections. An exceptionally preserved gem with both sides fully struck with complete hair and leaf details. The surfaces are entirely pristine without a single tick or anomaly. Frosted ivory luster is predominant along with splashes of russet, blue, and iridescent toning. The Large Date variety can be identified by a flat top 7 digit. F-103 with the 7 digit pointing between two denticles. This lot is the PCGS Coin Facts plate coin and finest graded. The CDN CAC price guide ranges from $16,200 (MS66) to $50,400 (MS67) as reference. This lot was acquired prior to the GFRC Newtown Liberty Seated Dime Collection auction sale with purchase price noted in the Sales Archive. Housed in PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) Dupont hologram holder with CAC approval. A long list of noteworthy pedigrees includes The Jim O'Neil Collection, The Bob Simpson Collection, and GFRC's Woodlands and Newtown clients. PCGS #4562.
Seated 10C 1837 Seated 1837
No Stars, Large Date
MS66
PCGS
25337764
F-101c
Gem $15000 Gem Original, Newtown Collection. Steely luster imparts active cartwheels across the surfaces of this Large Date, No Stars piece. A moderate spray of olive and charcoal patina covers both sides, highlighted by considerable flash that is thoroughly consistent with the MS66 CAC designation. The 1837 F-101c is coin #1 on the Top-100 list and exhibits heavy die clashing with elevated obverse die cracks. While not as arresting as the 1839 F-105c "Pie," the die deterioration is advanced and easily apparent without a glass. The dies are slightly rotated as expected for all later die states of the F-101 die pair. The CAC census notes two examples in MS66, with only a pair of pieces higher, both at MS67. The guide value is $15,000. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
Seated 10C 1838 Seated 1838
No Drapery, Large Stars
MS62
CACG
618292545
F-113
Choice $985 Reverse Die Flaw, Near-Gem at Grade, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. The new CAC Grading holders are constructed of a plastic that appears to be more translucent that the competitors. The 1838 F-113 Seated dime is intricately detailed in the GFRC photographs. I suspect the clear plastic allows us to view this beautifully toned dime at its finest. This dime features a bold reverse die flaw and is the plate coin with The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference. Housed in new CAC Grading (2023) holder and straight graded consistent with CAC approval standards.
Seated 10C 1842O Seated 1842-O
VF20
PCGS
27402664
F-104
Choice $300 Scarce Small O, Early Die State, Crusty Coin Gray, Choice Original. A quick check of the GFRC Sales Archives will highlight the scarcity of this 1842-O small O variety offering. The highest graded F-104 handled is VF30 and none with CAC approval. If Seated dime die varieties are a passion, then adding this example to represent the small O mintmark warrants consideration. Surfaces are fully choice and covered with crusty coin gray patina. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.6 (2013-2014) holder with CAC approval.
Seated 10C 1852O Seated 1852-O
MS62
PCGS
28148598
F-101
Choice $3500 Challenging New Orleans Date, Hammered Strike, Unquestionably Choice, New Orleans Collection. After purchasing the finest known 1852-O dime from the Gerry Fortin Collection, the New Orleans Collection is releasing this noteworthy duplicate given its low CAC approved census. Only 25 have been stickered in all grades with Mint State examples amounting to slightly more than a handful. This MS62 example presents a hammered strike with every device intricately detailed including bold die chips surrounding stars 3 through 5. The surfaces are frosted with a natural light gray patina on both sides. A 10x inspection found unblemished surfaces with two obverse rim exclusions as made. This lot is worthy of a JUST BUY IT NOW recommendation and certainly belongs in an advanced collection. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.6 (2013-2014) holder with CAC approval.
Seated 10C 1859 Seated 1859
MS67
PCGS
81875227
F-107
Gem HOLD
$7500
New March 30! Exceptional Luster, Gem Original, Gerry Fortin Collection.. Worthy of the "luster bomb" designation as exceptional silky frost radiates from the surfaces of this amazingly preserved superb gem. The hammered strike is equally extraordinary with every minute die detail sharply transferred and defined. The 1859 Philadelphia issue is well known among type collectors as a source for high grade Mint State superb gems. An opinion further validated by a CAC approved total of ten in MS67 with a single example finer. F-107, a die pairing that is frequently encountered for ultra-high-grade survivors. Acquired October 22 courtesy of the Newtown Collection. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #4619.
Seated 10C 1859 Seated 1859
MS65
NGC
1875970007
F-103
Gem $3250 Extra 9 in Gown, Gem Original, Cleveland Collection.. The Cleveland Collection is releasing this 1859 F-103 gem Seated Dime that originated from the Fortin core set collection during November 2022. It is an excellent example of a With Stars misplaced date. The bottom loop of the extra 9 digit in the gown was evident in Kam Ahwash's Encyclopedia for 14 years until Fortin discovered its existence during 1991. This is a popular variety that is listed as #46 in the Top 100 Varieties set and also included in the Top 25 Misplaced Date set. Let's get back to the offered example. Crusty coin-gray patina covers both side of this gem along with speckled ebony-gray at the stars and legend. Strike is complete with elevated motifs, especially the reverse wreath leaves. Surfaces are entirely unabraded. Purchased by Fortin during February 2007 from Jason Carter and employed as the F-103 plate coin with The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference. Housed in NGC Gen 17 (2004-2008) holder with CAC approval.
Seated 10C 1863 Seated 1863
MS67
PCGS
42608326
F-101a
Gem $21500 Finest Known, Gem Original, Gerry Fortin Collection.. The second lot in the Fortin Collection to enjoy the "finest known" title with its corresponding beauty and an issuance of 14,000, the smallest dime mintage since 1804. Mirror fields offer extraordinary reflectance while the peripheral blues and rose shades "float" over pristine surfaces. The strike is fully impressed with sharp wire rims. F-101a, a business strike from proof dies. The PCGS price guide plate coin for those that seek an alternate TruView perspective. The CDN CAC price guide suggests $10,900 which requires introspection as the PCGS guide at $22,500 is a better estimate of market value. Acquired February 2022 via private treaty and a continuation of the Fortin focus on locating exceptional Civil War issues . Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2024) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #4637.
Seated 10C 1863S Seated 1863-S
MS63
PCGS
30032523

Choice $10000 Condition Census San Francisco Civil War Date, Brilliant Frosted Luster, Complete Strike, Osprey Collection. Consignor Price Reduction. Locating any of the San Francisco Civil War Seated dime dates in CAC approved Mint State is always noteworthy. The issues from 1861 through 1867 are well known for having been heavily circulated in western frontier commerce. Few strictly original Mint State survivors are known and an acquisition prize for passionate collectors of the series. I well know myself. The Osprey Collection is proud to present the Tom Bender specimen that flew below the radar screen at a recent Heritage auction. A superb example with granular frosted luster and a complete strike. The ebony specks in the upper left obverse field are a further testament to the incredible originality. Those pursuing the finest Liberty Seated collections should take note of this opportunity. CAC population is 27 in all grades. There are three approved at the offered grade with two finer, one of which is housed in the Fortin Collection. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2022) holder with CAC approval and Tom Bender Collection pedigree on label.
Seated 10C 1864 Seated 1864
MS66
PCGS
35690560
F-102a
Gem $15000 Gem Original, Newtown Collection. Lightly mirrored, reflective luster penetrates the thick colorful toning of this Civil War piece. Aqua and russet patina predominate, with neon shades additionally present above the figure of Liberty. F-101a, with a defect at the upper right of O(NE), the same reverse die as used in 1863. Clashing is evident beneath DIME. This piece is tied for finest known at CAC with three other pieces. The overall CAC population is 24 pieces, and the CAC price guide is $7,200. Ex. GFRC. This piece represent yet another exceptional gem from the Newtown consignor, a pedigree that will long be remembered among Seated dime specialists. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
Seated 10C 1864S Seated 1864-S
MS66
PCGS
25271175
F-101
Gem HOLD
$29000
New March 30! CAC Tied Finest Known, Gem Original, Gerry Fortin Collection.Ex. BigMo, Gardner, Northern Bay. The effort to assemble the potentially finest run of San Francisco Civil War era issues culminated with the purchase of this superb gem. A gem brilliant specimen that is finest certified at PCGS while tied for finest at CAC. Granular mint frost is pervasive with an undistrubed velvet-silk presentation under angleed lighting. An exceptional strike, for a San Francisco issue, with fully detailed motifs. F-101 and a lone die pairing with a mintage of 230,000. CAC has certified 22 coins total, including two pieces at MS66 and none finer. The CAC price guide indicates a value of $28,800. Legend Rare Coin Auctions, July 2020 BigMo Auction Sale, Lot 64. Ex. Eugene Gardner, and Northern Bay Collections. Housed in PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) Dupont hologram holder with CAC approval. PCGS #4640.
Seated 10C 1864S Seated 1864-S
VF35
CACG
163455730
F-101
Choice $845 Choice Preservation, Crusty Gray, So Pleasing!. This 1864-S Seated dime is yet another CACG acquisition from the Whitman show and earns a Choice quality rating. Folks, they don't come much nicer than this piece at the certified grade. The key is strictly original surfaces that are protected by a uniform gray skin. This is an evenly worn example with essentially unabraded surfaces. An opportunty to add a rock solid San Francisco Civil War date to a collection. Housed in new CAC Grading (2023) holder and graded consistent with CAC approval standards.
Seated 10C 1867 Seated 1867
MS67
PCGS
38519788
F-102
Gem $17500 New March 30! Tied for Finest, An Exceptional Gem, Gerry Fortin Collection.. 1867 brought the lowest Philadelphia mintage with 6,000 struck. Mint State survivors are available in all grades with this lot being tied for finest at PCGS and CAC. An exceptional example with intense prooflike reflectance and colorful rose shaded centers surrounded by peripheral blues as struck with conspicuously striated dies. Partial wire rims are noted with a full obverse strike and near complete reverse other than the upper left wheat grains. F-102, with business strike from a single die pairing with a heavily clashed obverse only. Acquired via private treaty with no known auction records, though the lot is featured as the PCGS price guide plate coin. The CAC price guide value is listed at $17,300 for reference. A side-by-side comparison with the Simpson specimen could be a revealing exercise. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #4645.
Seated 10C 1868 Seated 1868
PR66CAM
PCGS
25011392
F-104
Gem $3750 New March 3! Cameo Designation, Gem Original, Evergreen State Collection.. The Evergreen State proof Seated dime release continues with a lucious 1868 F-104 specimen. This proof variety is easily recognized by a high date that slopes downward coupled with a weak date punch. A second proof die pair is known with bold misplaced digits in the gown folds and is easily distinguishes from the more available F-104. This piece exhibits brilliant mirrors with the cameo effect being readily apparent under a bright light. Images accurately illustrate the greenish obverse hues with rose being more prevalent on the reverse. Pristine fields are 100% hairline free with sharp edge lettering throughout. Wire rims are consistent with proofs of this era. The CAC census is 13 approved with a fair market guide value of $4200 as reference. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.6 (2013-2014) holder with CAC approval.
Seated 10C 1870 Seated 1870
MS66
PCGS
07797169
F-101a
Gem $8500 New March 30! Tied for Finest, Gem Original, Gerry Fortin Collection, Ex. Bender.. The epitome of originality and tied for finest known. Blended jade-green and sun-gold hues are predominant on the obverse, with incremental blues on the reverse. Lightly mirrored with substantial steely radiance and vibrant cartwheels. Partial wire rims and a scrupulously detailed strike are further noted. F-101a, a business strike from proof dies as noted by a die crack between the ribbon ends. A challenging date overall with the CAC census listing 23 approved. This lot is one of three stickered at the MS66 level with a price guide value of $10,500. Heritage Auctions, January 2023 FUN U.S. Coins Signature Sale, Lot 3382. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2024) holder with CAC approval. The label documents the Bender Collection pedigree. PCGS #4651.
Seated 10C 1870S Seated 1870-S
VF30
NGC
2126593021

Choice HOLD
$2850
New April 22! So Rare This Choice! Natural Coin Gray, CAC Approved. The 1870 San Francisco issue is unquestionably in the same league as the 1871 through 1874 Carson City dates in terms of locating strictly original examples that have been properly handled. A limited mintage of 50,000 is the starting point for explaining the date's present day rarity in circulated grades as nearly all saw extensive usage in western frontier commerce. Confirmation is easily obtained when checking the GFRC Sales Archive with a single piece being CAC approved, That piece is the recently auctioned PCGS MS65 specimen from the Gerry Fortin core dime collection. Fortunately, GFRC has gained access to one of the four CAC approved examples across all circulated grades with two being only VG10 and a lone AU50. This choice survivor is toned a natural coin gray with near pristine surfaces. The CAC price guide requires a serious amount of reconsideration, however the lack of any reported sales by the major auction houses provides no basis for an update. An incredible opportunity for those building a choice Liberty Seated dime collection. Housed in new large font NGC holder with CAC approval.
Seated 10C 1872 Seated 1872
MS65
PCGS
81252594
F-102
Gem $2750 Gem Original, Gerry Fortin Core Collection Duplicate.. A wonderful gem Philadelphia strike that approaches the upper bounds of Mint State availability with its CAC approval. The CAC population includes only 4 at grade with 3 finer. This 1872 dime is simply superb with frosty rose gold patina across the obverse and lighter gold on the reverse. Strike is absolutely hammered including fully defined grains in the upper left wreath. Unabraded with brilliant frosted luster. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
Seated 10C 1872CC Seated 1872-CC
EF45
PCGS
43801561
F-101
Choice $23500 New March 30! CAC Condition Census, Near-Gem Original, Gerry Fortin Collection.. "Condition Census", a term credited to Dr. William Sheldon, arrives at a coin value through listing the top five survivors in sequential order. The 1872 Carson City issue is the most frequently encountered within the 1871-CC though 1874-CC date span. However, choice survivors are very rare without a single Mint State specimen with CAC green bean. Darker violet-gray shades are noted on this naturally toned example with olive orange-gray noted at the reverse borders. Well preserved surfaces are undisturbed and entirely pleasing. The strike is typical of the issue as variability is the rule. CAC reports 17 approved in all grades with a single AU58 finer. The CAC price guide suggests $17,300 as fair value which is a conservative number given the ongoing collector demand. Acquired via private treaty during late 2023. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2024) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #4657.
Seated 10C 1873S Seated 1873-S
With Arrows
MS64+
PCGS
25233863
F-101
Gem $5500 Gem Original, Oregon Beaver Collection.. Steely-frosted cartwheels reveal varied russet shades, more heavily on the reverse, which additionally exhibits a splash of charcoal patina. This is a fully struck example with complete ribbon detail. F-101, with the thin-style mintmark. Just two die pairs were used to produce nearly half a million circulation strikes in this year. CAC notes 25 pieces total, with three coins finer, the highest at MS66. The CAC value in MS64 is $3,820 and advances to $10,500 in MS65. The bidders will decide how closely to approach the MS65 price (this coin previously sold at $5,500 in the Branch Mint Collection sale), but in any case, this piece presents a compelling combination of aesthetic appeal and exceptional technical grade, separated from finest known status by only a point and a half. Housed in a PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) Dupont hologram holder and CAC approval.
Seated 10C 1873S Seated 1873-S
MS64
PCGS
07447774
F-101
Gem $4850 Small Thin S, Brilliant Frosted Luster, Swirling Cartwheels, Gem Original, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. For several decades, I could not make a decision on whether I liked the F-101 or F-102 PCGS MS64 CAC dimes better, in my reference collection, to the point of releasing one back into the marketplace. The F-101, as offered today, presents lovely frosted surfaces and swirling cartwheels that are accentuated under a bright light. The F-102 specimen is darker with partially mirrored fields and has won the 1873-S spot in the core set. Back to the F-101 then. This die pairing is found in early and late die states with the primary die state diagnostic being die erosion. This lot is a late die state specimen with obvious erosion under the date digits and weak reverse wreath devices. Regardless of the die erosion, the luster is entirely brilliant as one would expect from a gem survivor. This lot was purchased January 2006 and later CAC approved during 2014 and has served at the F-101 plate coin withing The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference. Total date CAC approved population presently stands at 25 pieces with 6 at the MS64 level and only 3 finer. The PCGS and CAC guides are understated for this date given the rarity. My cost basis for this lot is $100 less than the offer price while paying $5500 for the remaining F-102 in the core collection. This is an important opportunity for the astute collector. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval.
Seated 10C 1874CC Seated 1874-CC
With Arrows
EF45
PCGS
50089237
F-101
Gem $58000 New April 14! Key Date, Gem Original, Gerry Fortin Collection.. All 1874-CC dimes have a die crack through the mintmark as the prime diagnostic. On this example, the die crack continues through the right wreath and exits to the rim at 2:00. Undoubtedly, the key date in the Liberty Seated Dime series with 10,817 struck. A rarity when considering few strictly original survivors are extant. Nearly all are problematic with porosity or restoration efforts. The Fortin specimen exhibits light to moderate olive golden-gray patination with an ancient mark above DIM(E) being the only anomaly. Of vital importance is the unquestionable originality presenting a multi-decade opportunity for the astute numismatist. F-101 from a single die pair and the plate coin within The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collector online reference. CAC has approved 16 coins in all grades with five finer. The CAC price guide lists $46,100 at the offered graded and $72,000 in AU50. Heritage Auctions, September 2003 Long Beach Sale, Lot #6403. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.1 (2002-2004) holder with CAC approval.
Seated 10C 1874S Seated 1874-S
With Arrows
MS66
PCGS
06756784
F-101
Gem $15500 New March 30! Finest Micro S Known, Gem Original, Gerry Fortin Collection.. After careful research of all CoinFacts auctions records dating back to 2005, this F-101 Micro S dime is the finest known for its variety. Recent sales of MS66/MS66+ examples via Gardner, Bender, and others have been exclusively the F-102 Small S with a weakly hubbed reverse or the F-102a with late die state die erosion. An impressively lustrous example under bright light with spinning cartwheels and light golden-brown patination with pristine surfaces. Essentially fully struck though the left wreath devices are weakly hubbed, an issue for both 1874-S reverse dies. As with many other Fortin lots in this GFRC event, this coin has been employed as the plate within the Fortin Liberty Seated Dime online reference. CAC reports 18 approved examples in all grades with none finer. Acquired August 2009 via Carter Numismatics. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval and no upgrade attempts for a (+) designation. PCGS #4670.
Seated 10C 1876 Seated 1876
PR65
PCGS
07227094
F-103
Gem $975 New March 3! Bold Strike, Gem Original, Evergreen State Collection.. Aquamarine-blue shades decorate this gem 1876 proof issue along with golden hues at the rims. In particular, the reverse presents a toning arc with similar shades and light gray hues in the more lightly toned upper left region. The overall strike is complete with razor-sharp wire rims. A surprisingly challenging proof Seated dime issue with CAC approval and strict originality. From a mintage of 1,150 piece, only 31 total have been approved in PR, PRCAM, and PRDCAM. At the PR designation, this Evergreen State specimen has a price guide estimate of $1000 with only five better. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2025) holder with CAC approval.
Seated 10C 1876 Seated 1876
PR64CAM
PCGS
82156370
F-103
Choice $1250 New March 3! Cameo Designation, Near-Gem Original, Evergreen State Collection.. We continue the Evergreen State proof dime auction sale with the second of three 1876 date pieces. This near-gem cameo designated lot displays watery mirrors and light copper hues on the obverse with a more haloed presentation on the reverse. Frosted devices are appropriately framed by the contrasting fields. The strike is nearly complete as With Legend proof issues still suffer weakness at the upper left reverse wheat grains. A few wispy hairlines within the obverse right field are consistent with the certified grade. A challenging date regardless of 1,150 being produced when fully choice. F-103 with reverse die doubling on DIM(E). Only 13 examples with a Cameo designation have been approved at CAC with four finer. The CAC price guide estimates market value at $950 which is understated and needs reconsideration by the CDN staff. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
Seated 10C 1876CC Seated 1876-CC
Type 1 Reverse
AU58
PCGS
29797557
F-119
Choice HOLD
$525
New March 27! Doubled Die Reverse, Brilliant Frosted Luster, Well Prepared Surfaces, CAC Approved. The 1876-CC Seated dime date is replete with doubled die reverses, all found on the Type 1 reverse. This example has been listed as F-119 with additional die cracks to aid with attribution. The obverse is paired with a second reverse die with the strike and devices being sharp and well defined as compared to the commonplace occurrence of poorly maintained or fully rusted obverse dies for the issue. Granular frosted luster has a silky texture under a bright light. A complete strike adds to the eye appeal. A few scattered obverse micro-lines are consistent with the grade. Housed in PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) holder with CAC approval.
Seated 10C 1877 Seated 1877
Type 2 Reverse
PR66
PCGS
29851939
F-101
Gem $2000 New March 3! Exceptional Proof Example, Sharp Brilliant Radiance, Bold Wire Rims, Evergreen State Collection.. 1877 Liberty Seated dime proof strikes were accomplished with the Type 2 reverse hub design. This exceptional example presents powerful watery radiance from undisturbed fields. Angled lighting showcases a classic proof presentation with center rose and peripheral sky-blue. What a color contrast as the reverse center is toned a blended rose-aquamarine then surrounded with rose-gold at the borders. A consistent and fully executed strike further enhances the eye appeal. The CAC census is limited to 25 examples stickered without a Cameo designation and one has to wonder why PCGS withheld this designation. Housed in PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) Dupont hologram holder with CAC approval.
Seated 10C 1877CC Seated 1877-CC
Type 2 Reverse
MS66+
PCGS
42140031
F-110
Gem $4250 Superb Gem, Frosted Luster, Fully Struck, Golden-Gray Patina, Shattered Reverse. As a dealer, I see a host of Seated coins with many being subjected to past poor treatments. On occasion, a superb gem with perfectly original surfaces appears. So was the case at Summer FUN 2021 and the purchase of this 1877-CC Type2 F-110 dime. Steely fields and natural reflective luster are initial highlights during bright light inspection. Toning is a combination of silver-gray with peripheral gold plus aquamarine on the obverse. Strike is hammered when considering the die pairing and shattered reverse. What appeals to me the most is the thick natural patina that is semi-transparent to the underlying luster. Trust me on this piece, it is a exceptional example for the grade, else I would not have added to GFRC inventory. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2021) holder with CAC approval.
Seated 10C 1877S Seated 1877-S
MS65
PCGS
55457544
F-111
Gem $4950 New April 25! Magnificent Gem, Granular Frosted Luster, Vibrant Cartwheels, Rare Die Pairing. GFRC is thrilled to be offering one of the finest 1877-S dimes extant along with being a rare R5 die pairing per my research as published in the Liberty Seated Dime die variety online reference. This is a magnificent gem with granular frosted luster and vibrant cartwheels. A speckled natural gray patina overlays the obverse while the reverse is a lighter uniform gray with gold and rose shades appearing under angled lighting. The surfaces are meticulously preserved too! Now let's move on to the importance of this die pairing in terms of rarity. The F-111 variety is the last of the three different reverse die pairings (F-109, F-110, F-111) with Obverse 7. Reverse C, which was previously paired with the F-103 obverse, shows die wear and erosion at the denticles. There is considerable weakness in the lower left ribbon end and wreath leaves. The reverse die may have been polished after the F-103 die pairing. This is only the fourth F-111 example handled by GFRC with the next finest being a PCGS MS62 CAC example sold during May 2018. Clearly, the finest known F-111 extant. CAC has approved only 22 examples in all grades with three finer. The estimate CAC market value is currently $4900 which recognizes the 1877-S date rarity in full gem. An important offering that belongs in one of the finest Seated dime collections being assembled. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2025) holder with CAC approval.
Seated 10C 1880 Seated 1880
MS67+
NGC
5751313001
F-102a
Gem $3800 Broken 18(80), Condition Census Example, Steely Frosted Luster, CAC Approved. 1880 Seated dime mintage was limited to 36,000 and fairly consistent with its 1879 and 1881 peers. Many collectors view these three consecutiver mintage years as a continuum. This newly consigned example is an exquisite superb Gem with steely-frosted radiance with brilliant mirrors under a bright light. The mirrors are no surprise as circulation strike were accomplished from reused proof dies. Surfaces are essentially untoned with light gold at the borders. A late date issue and an exceptional condition census specimen. F-102a with broken 8 and 0 digits in the date punch. PCGS has graded two at MS67+ with two finer. The price guide is $5000 as reference. Previously Stacks Bowers November 2022 where it realized $3600. Housed in new large font NGC holder with CAC approval.
Seated 10C 1880 Seated 1880
MS66+
PCGS
25004984
F-102a
Gem $2400 New April 14! Low Mintage Circulation Strike, Partially Mirrored, Gem Original, Sheffield Collection. Three die pairs were employed for the 1880 Philadelphia dime issue, only two of which were used for circulation strikes. The F-102 die pairing can be located as a proof strike followed by the F-102a circulation strike as is the case with this Sheffield Collection offering. Since the dies were reused, it is not uncommon to see partially mirrored fields for well preserved F-102a survivors. This example radiates mirrored reflectance that is not impeded by the orange-rose patination. Accurately graded with unquestionably originality. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.6 (20013-2014) holder with CAC approval.
Seated 10C 1882 Seated 1882
MS65+
CACG
993009577
F-101a
Gem $875 New April 14! Repunched 2, Superior Presentation, Gem Original, Sheffield Collection. Rich frosted luster and golden aquamarine toning are the highlights of this gem 1882 F-101a dime. This piece was struck from proof dies that were re-employed for circulation strikes. Surfaces exhibit granular mint bloom that is consistent on both sides. A bright light review reveals frosted luster that is partially muted by the dense patina. Cartwheels are active, more so on the reverse. Repunching on the 2 digit is evident under the top ball and below the base. An unquestionable gem that is so close to full MS66. Housed in new CAC Grading holder and graded consistent with CAC approval standards.
Seated 10C 1883 Seated 1883
PR67
PCGS
38736559
F-103
Gem $2600 New March 3! Gem Original, Evergreen State Collection.. Liberty Seated dime proof mintage increased to 1039 pieces during 1883 with the date being well represented in the CAC census. CAC has approved 8 examples at the lofty PR67 grade with an additional 7 with Cameo designation. This Evergreen State example is a strong testament to this grade level as the surfaces are absolutely pristine resulting in undisturbed bright light viewing. The brilliant mirrors offer watery textures and the peripheral copper-gold provides the appropriate framing that we expect from superb gem proofs. The strike is typical of the issue with limited wire rims. The CAC price guide suggests $2600 as current market value. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
Seated 10C 1883 Seated 1883
MS64
CACG
993083029
F-109
Choice $625 New April 14! Repunched and Broken 3, Pastel Shades, Gem Eye Candy, Frosty Luster, Active Cartwheels, Sheffield Collection. A wicked nice 1883 Liberty Seated dime as we say in Downeast Maine. Worthy of its CACG near-gem certification with pastel coloring on both sides. Orange, gray, aquamarine shades decorate the obverse while the reverse offers a fiery rose center with orange surrounding the outer wreath devices. Frosted luster, while being immediately evident under a bright light, is move prevalent on the reverse. Surfaces are completely unabraded. Struck from the F-109 die pairing with partial lower loop on the 3 digit and repunching at the upper loop. Housed in new CAC Grading holder and graded consistent with CAC approval standards.
Seated 10C 1885 Seated 1885
PR67CAM
PCGS
43567900
F-101
Gem $3500 New March 3! Cameo Designation, Exceptional Gem, Reflective Brilliance, Evergreen State Collection.. An exceptional 1885 Liberty Seated dime proof strike with nicely contrasted cameo eye appeal. This gorgeous gem was originally part of a complete 1885 proof set which has been holdered and dispersed. Though the images indicate classic center to edge copper gold toning, any angled light exposes deeply reflective mirrors with substantial undisturbed brilliance. A thin peripheral blue arc on the obverse is icing on the cake. This is an amazing offering that needs in-hand inspection to be appreciated. Or you can trust this description as I'm in love with this premium proof strike. CAC has approved 13 at the certified grade with one finer and a price guide value estimate at $3500. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2025) holder with CAC approval.
Seated 10C 1887S Seated 1887-S
MS64
PCGS
5790890
F-114
Gem $750 Doubled UNITED, Gem Original, Heavily Frosted, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection.. Flashy luster and swirling cartwheels are difficult to miss when first inspecting this GFRC-Gem rated 1887-S Seated dime. Not only is the eye appeal exceptional, but the F-114 doubling at UNITED add another dimension as a reason for adding to an advanced Seated collection. Purchased during July 2003 as part of the die variety research effort that resulted in the publishing of The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference. A complete strike further enhances the eye appeal. My favorite 1887-S dime other than the piece in the core Liberty Seated dime set. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.0 (1998-2002) holder with CAC approval.
Seated 10C 1888 Seated 1888
MS65
NGC
1665790002
F-120
Gem $950 New March 5! Two Sets 18 Digits Misplaced in Lower Shield, Brilliant Frosted Luster, Swirling Cartwheels, Gem Original. First announced by Dr. Tim Cook in the LSCC's June 2009 E-Gobrecht issue, the 1888 F-120 die variety presents two sets of 18 digits easily seen in the lower shield with shield line #7-8 bisecting the 18 digits. Traces of extraneous digits are also visible on the lower gown area above and to the right of the pendant. This extraneous digits will wear quickly and mostly likely will disappear on EF or lower examples. Dr. Cook is now releasing a magnificent F-120 example graded NGC MS65 along with a CAC green bean. The Gem Mint State grade and complete strike present all the artifacts of this important variety including the extraneous digits on the gown folds. This is a brilliant steely-frosted example with sharp reflectance and swirling cartwheels under a bright light. The reverse toning is exceptionally pleasing with orange center flanked partial blues at the border. I've got to call a JUST BUY IT NOW recommendation as this piece is truly special for Liberty Seated dime enthusiasts. Housed in new large font NGC holder with CAC approval.
Seated 10C 1889 Seated 1889
MS65
NGC
958035003
F-110
Gem $985 Repunched 889, Gem Original, Golden-Aquamarine Patina, Brilliant Frosty Luster, Vibrant Cartwheels, Well Struck, Accurately Graded, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. A difficult 1889 Philadelphia die variety with repunching inside the lower loops of 88 and above the tail of the 9 digit. First listed by Fortin. This offering has to be one of the finest examples extant as I've seen few in my collecting career. Gem original surfaces are covered with semi-transparent golden-aquamarine patina. Frosty luster is brilliant with bold cartwheels during bright light viewing. The F-110 plate coin at The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors. Housed in old NGC holder with standard ring insert. Purchased April 2003 and in the Fortin collection since that time. I really hate to let this one go but all die variety dimes must be eventually sold.
Seated 10C 1889 Seated 1889
MS65
NGC
274161010
F-126
Gem $850 Misplaced 18 in Shield, Superb Eye Appeal, Colorful Frosted Luster, Fresh CAC Approval, Indiana Collection. This 1889 F-126 Seated dime offering is an important opportunity for the die varieties enthusiast. The misplaced 1 and 8 digits in the shield are bolding defined and so satisfying. A late die state strike with obverse die erosion and die cracks in the legend and reverse wreath. Under a bright light, frosted luster is consistent with its gem status. An obverse rose center is framed by aquamarine at the borders while the reverse is toned a consistent aquamarine with hints of peripheral gold. A truly fine example of this major misplaced date variety. Housed in NGC Gen 5 (1992-1995) Fatty holder with fresh CAC approval obtained by GFRC. This lovely piece is ready to move into an advanced collection.
Seated 10C 1889 Seated 1889
MS64
NGC
3102384011
F-120
Gem $475 Gem Original, Cartwheel Luster, Aquamarine/Rose Patel Toning, Conservative Grading.. A gem original 1889 Philadelphia struck dime that is so deserving of CAC approval. Glowing cartwheel luster couple with pretty pastel colors dominate the eye appeal. Obverse strike is nicely executed while the reverse die is weak and cracked resulting in some shallow relief to the reverse strike. This piece is essentially blemish free and atttractive with GFRC images unable to capture and illustrate the overall beauty. Housed in newer NGC holder.
Seated 10C 1890 Seated 1890
MS64
NGC
956006002
F-121
Gem $595 Sharply Sloping Date, Brilliant Frosted Luster, Gem Eye Appeal. I could not resist adding this 1890 F-121 dime to inventory after being bought back from a well known client. Though a "common date", this dime possesses the hallmarks of a full gem. Luster is brilliant and frosty with vibrant cartwheels. Strike is nearly complete while the surfaces were meticulously preserved and are unabraded. Surfaces are toned various shades of copper-gold and add much charm. The F-121 die variety captures a sharply downward sloping date that is an eyeball variety. This is a well balance gem at a fair offer price for type. Housed in NGC Gen 7 (1997-2000) holder,
Seated 10C 1890S Seated 1890-S
Doubled Die Obverse
MS63
PCGS
42676352
F-102
Choice $850 Doubled Die Obverse, Brilliant Frosted Luster, Vibrant Cartwheel, Choice Overall, Indiana Collection. The Indiana Collection is back with an important Liberty Seated dime release that fans of the series should seriously consider. To drive home that point, let's go with a JUST BUY IT NOW recommendation as I'm thoroughly impressed with this lot for multiple reasons. Firstly, this is the finest F-102 double die obverse specimen that I've handled. Obverse die doubling in evident in multiple locations including the horizontal shield lines, throughout AMERICA and below Liberty's foot. Actually, the easier diagnostic point for the F-102 is a long diagonal die scratch in the base and lower gown. This die scratch is clearly visible above the 90 in the date. Second is the frosted surfaces that present brilliant radiance under a bright light along with vibrant cartwheels. Finally, the eye appeal is superb with copper-gold at the borders. Though the 1890-S double die obverse has never been promoted or included in the Top 100 Varieties, it is a really cool doubled die in the series. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2024) holder with CAC approval.
Seated 10C 1891 Seated 1891
MS64
PCGS
21507312
F-108
Choice $650 Near-Gem Original, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection.. Lightly mottled russet and lilac patina covers the frosty obverse of this last year of issue Philadelphia piece, while the more untoned reverse exhibits reddish-brown color at the right rim. F-108, the plate coin in the Fortin web-book, with stray detail in the lower loop of the 9, and reverse die cracks. Strike is typical, with reverse softness at K10. The CAC census notes 157 pieces total, with a price guide value of $530. Although not a challenging date, this remains an affordably priced example with substantial luster and original surfaces. Housed in a PCGS Gen 4.1 (2002-2004) holder with CAC approval. Note, there are lines on the holder to the upper right on both sides.
Barber 10C 1896 Barber 1896
PR64CAM
PCGS
36911463

Choice $900 Near-Gem Original, Cameo Proof Strike.. Frosty devices rise above the mirrored fields, revealing a “black and white” Cameo effect as the piece is tilted under a light. A sharp strike imparts strongly impressed design elements, and the bow knot is completely split. A few wispy lines, detectable with a glass, are present in the right, obverse field. Proof Barber dimes form a 24-coin series, dated from 1892-1915, and the low CAC populations dictate that full sets remain remarkably elusive. Still, many of these pieces are available at price points under $1,000. CAC has approved 32 pieces in all grades, five examples in PR64 Cameo, and 23 coins finer. The CAC price guide value is $842. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #84880
Barber 10C 1903 Barber 1903
PR64
PCGS
82997413

Gem $900 Gem Original, Proof Strike.. This colorful, CAC-approved example will immediately grab the eye, as the vibrant rim patina contrasts with untoned centers. Intense blue-green shade fills the legend and wreath, surrounding rings of maroon hue on both sides. The in-hand appeal is consistent with the images, and the next owner will not be disappointed. CAC notes 37 examples in all grades, 11 coins in PR64, and 19 pieces in higher grades. The CAC price guide assigns a value of $780, and a higher bid would not surprise us. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #4887
Barber 10C 1907 Barber 1907
MS64
PCGS
34466059

Gem HOLD
$315
New April 19! Brilliant Frosty Luster, Vibrant Cartwheels, Gem Original, Pikes Peak Collection. A thoroughly pleasing 1907 Barber dime with brilliant frosted luster and ample cartwheels. Surfaces are pristine including a completely defect free cheek. Hints of gold are noted with some ebony-gray specks. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) special D.L.Hansen Collection holder with CAC approval. A marvelous release from the Pikes Peak Collection.
Mercury 10C 1916D Mercury 1916-D
G06
PCGS
47434791

Choice $1800 New March 2! Key Date, Rich Coin-Gray Patina, CAC Approved. Taken in trade at the 2025 Atlanta ANA show. Deeper coin gray surfaces with bold device and mintmark details at the certified grade. Image forthcoming shortly but rest assured this 1916-D Mercury is fully choice to GFRC standards. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2025) holder with CAC approval.
20 Cents
Seated 20C 1875CC Seated 1875-CC
AU55
NGC
370500004
BF-2
Choice $1925 Superb Preservation, Steely-Frosted Luster, CAC Approved. An unquestionably original 1875-CC BF-2 double dime with that is superbly pleasing under a bright light. Rich coppr-gold patina is consistent across the obverse while the more lightly toned reverse has golden splashes in the fields and hints of blue across the eagle. The overall strike is typical for the issue. Housed in NGC Gen 7 (1997-2000) holder with CAC approval. Please note that the holder plastic has a few scratches at the lower obverse. I've done my best to edit those out.
25 Cents
Capped Bust 25C 1818 Capped Bust 1818
EF40
PCGS
39253438
B-10
Choice $1650 Excellent Type Candidate, Thick Crusty Gray, Choice Surfaces, CAC Approved, Sooner Collection. Reverse Die State 3, The 1818 Capped Bust quarter issue is ideal for type collectors as 361,000 were produced that year, a substantial output for that period. Though relativiely available, all Capped Bust quarters are scarce when strictly original. Thick crust is the perfect description for this Sooner Collection release that was previously sourced from GFRC back in March 2023 at the Spring Baltimore show. Note the "dirt" on Liberty, especially her cheek, and covering the reverse eagle as a testament to the unquestionable originality. Surfaces are unblemished during a carefuly 10x review. Both dies are lightly clashed with a vertical die crack through the 2 digit. This lot comes highly recommended... Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
Seated 25C 1842O Seated 1842-O
Small Date
VG08
PCGS
14131393
Briggs 1-A
Choice $1500 Rare Small Date, Natural Coin Gray, Choice Surfaces, New Orleans Collection. The growing popularity of the 1842-O Small Date quarter can be directly tied to its inclusion in the Top 25 Variety set as published by Greg Johnson in the LSSC's Gobrecht Journal and listed as a collecting objective in the GFRC Open Set Registry. That set was added to www.seateddimevarieties.com for simplistic referencing including a pricing guide. This New Orleans Collection duplicate is fully choice with natural coin-gray patina. A premium example with honest wear and essentially unabraded surfaces. Separately the Large and Small Date punches for this date can be challenging at times. A key marker is the sharp of the 1 digit flag. The Large Date has a pointed flag while the Small Date has a blunt flag. The CAC census stands at 36 with a price guide value at $1500. An excellent entry point for this four figure die variety. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval and the Small Date attribution on the label.
Seated 25C 1843O Seated 1843-O
Large O
F15
PCGS
29806057
Briggs 3-F
Choice $1500 Large O, Choice Original, Scarce Die Variety, Crusty Gray Patina, Accurately Graded. Listed separately by Briggs as 3-F and the lone 1843 reverse die with a Large O mintmark. Later captured by the Cherrypickers Guide and listed as FS-501. Always found in lower circulated grades with the finest PCGS holdered being an AU53 example. This Fine 15 example is noteworthy for its strict originality and choice surfaces. Crusty gray patina covers both sides. CAC approval is absolutely warranted due to originality and accurate grading. Overall, an essentially unimprovable example for the collector wishing to fill the #5 spot, in a Top 25 Varieties set. Housed in a PCGS Gen 5.0 Dupont hologram holder with CAC approval. The PCGS label reads, "Large O FS-501 (FS-001.5)".
Seated 25C 1856 Seated 1856
AU50
PCGS
2849756

Choice $265 Crusty Coin Gray, Choice Original, Worn Holder. Consignor Buyout, Price Reduction. A popular date for type given its availability through AU58. This example is covered with medium crusty gray patina with underlying steely fields. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.0 (1998-2002) holder with CAC approval. Please note the holder is well worn with haze spots that are evident on the images.
Seated 25C 1857 Seated 1857
MS66
PCGS
20211414

Gem HOLD
$4500
Unquestionably Gem, Exceptional Bright Light Viewing, Sharp Steely Frosted Luster. A gorgeous gem that MUST BE VIEWED in-hand to be appreciated! Sadly, the GFRC images are unable to capture the viewing transition when placed under a bright light. The in-hand greens and rose shift to mostly light blues with a huge peripheral gold ring that is absolutely enthralling. What other superlatives can be used to describe this gem? Eye appeal and luster is of a higher grade with a contact mark by star 5 that most likely account for the certified grade. Luster is sharp and brilliant from steely surfaces. Once again, I must ask for clients to trust this description rather than the images. Photographing high grade gems with lightly contrasted patina brings its illustration challenges. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval.
Seated 25C 1858S Seated 1858-S
VF35
PCGS
26549025

$3250 Semi-Key Date, Low CAC Population, Perfectly Original, CAC Approved. Well recognized as one of the Liberty Seated quarter semi-key dates, of many, this 1858-S offering also brings a very low CAC population. Only 22 are approved in all grades with six finer above this well preserved VF35 specimen. Though 121,00 were struck, only 2 survived in Mint State 62. I particular like this example due to its strict originality and bold strike. Coin gray patina is augmented by a lighter patch that extends to the reverse. The reverse toning is a bit thicker containing rose hues along with traces of peripheral gold. Head details are complete along with all star point being connected. This piece offers consideration detail and viewing pleasure at the certified grade. Destined for placement in an advanced collection. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.5 (2012-2013) holder with CAC approval.
Seated 25C 1859O Seated 1859-O
EF40
PCGS
31626283

Choice $785 Better New Orleans Date, Crusty Gray, Steely Fields, CAC Approval. The 1859 date is a semi-key in the New Orleans quarter series, with a mintage of 260,000 pieces. The CAC census provides validation of this fact with only 21 pieces stickered and 2 CACG holdered. Even gray surfaces are the epitome of originality, with gun metal blues being readily apparent under a bright light . Dirt is located within the reverse olive leaves and shield as a testament to the strict originality. Strike is typical with some weakness in the stars. The overall circulated eye appeal in pleasing which some generate significant collector interest. Housed in PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) holder with CAC approval.
Seated 25C 1867 Seated 1867
EF40
PCGS
25661827
Briggs 1-A
Choice $1985 Low Mintage Philadelphia Issue, Natural Crusty Gray Patina, Meager CAC Population. The 1867 quarter sits amid a run of low-mintage Philadelphia dates, struck during a period when hard money was scarce and paper substitutes filled the void. Only 20,000 pieces were struck in this year, and, like the 1866 quarter, business strikes are more desirable than proofs. Fortunately, the business strikes are easily distinguished due to weakness in the obverse shield ribbon. That is clearly the case here, with several letters of LIBERTY indistinct. This piece reveals natural crusty gray patina on both sides. Regardless of time during post-Civil War commerce, this piece is essentially unabraded with "dirt" noted in the obverse shield and surrounding the stars and reverse denomination. Strike is sharp for the issue. The CAC census reports 24 pieces approved in all grades with 4 graded by CACG. The CAC price guide is $2000 as the offered grade.
Seated 25C 1872CC Seated 1872-CC
VF25
PCGS
42823925
Briggs 1-A
Choice HOLD
$16755
Rare Low Mintage Carson City Date, Olive Gray-Rose Patina, CAC Approved. Astute Liberty Seated quarter collectors are well aware of the importance of CAC approved Carson City dates arriving to market. This 1872-CC example is one of only 15 approved by CAC in all grades. Mintage was limited to 22,850 with most certified survivors clustered between G04 and F15 grades. This fresh GFRC buyback features natural surfaces that are toned a rose-gray with peripheral olive colored highlights. Surfaces are well preserved with only a few ancient lines in the lower right obverse field. This specimen offers strong details not just for the grade, but for the issue. About 65 to 90 examples are believed to survive, according to Rusty Goe (2020). Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2022) holder with CAC approval. Previously sold August 2022 with the sales record in the Sales Archive.
Seated 25C 1875 Seated 1875
AU55
PCGS
32459493
I
Choice HOLD
$365
New April 19! Near-Gem Original, Pikes Peak Collection. A liberal splash of deep gray and olive patina fills the obverse of this Philadelphia piece, while gold shades cover the eagle, surrounded by auburn and blue-green color in the legend. Residual luster radiates from the protected areas. Well-struck, with most star points evident. Type I reverse, with the bases of STATES close. The CAC population is 58 pieces across all grades. Large quantities of quarters poured from the Mints in the mid-1870s, but remarkably few survive with a good degree of originality. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval. Ex, Eclectic Collection, GFRC Online Auctions May 2022.
Seated 25C 1875CC Seated 1875-CC
F15
PCGS
60138597

Choice HOLD
$895
New March 27! Difficult Carson City Date, Crusty Gray, Choice Surfaces, CAC Approval. 1875 Carson City struck Liberty Seated quarters present a continuous challenge to locate and stock. These will be found either well circulated or in high Mint State grades. CAC has approved only 32 pieces in all grades with a handful between VG08 and VF30. This Fine 15 example is a CAC pop 1 obviously deserves its green bean approval. Surfaces are covered with a thick crusty gray-brown skin along with minimal abrasions given the amount of time in circulation. In important offering for that difficult to fill hole in many circulated date and mintmark sets. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.0 (1998-2002) holder with CAC approval.
Seated 25C 1876 Seated 1876
MS65
PCGS
81328669
II
Gem $1750 New March 28! Gem Original, Frosted Luster, Ideal for Type, Island Lake Collection.. This Centennial-year quarter exhibits medium skin with dusty gray obverse patina, while the flashy reverse reveals sea-green shades at the eagle, surrounded by thick russet-maroon color in the legend. Most star points are evident. Type II reverse, with the bases of STATES separate. Collectors of US silver coins enjoy a wide array of toning patterns, and this piece is an attractive representative of the various possibilities. CAC has approved 127 pieces in all grades combined. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval. Ex. Eclectic Collection with prior record in the Sales Archive.
Seated 25C 1891 Seated 1891
AU58
NGC
2452091004

Choice $350 New April 19! Great Type Candidate, Untoned Frosty Luster, Choice Surfaces, Pikes Peak Collection. A lovely 1891 Seated quarter with frosted radiance under a bright light. While the obverse is untoned, light gold hues are noted on the upper reverse. Light rub is noted on the high points and within the fields. Struck with late die state dies with heavy reverse die cracks connecting the denomination with olive leaves and arrow heads. A quality release from the Pikes Peak Collection. Housed in NGC Gen 17 (2004-2008) holder with CAC approval.
Barber 25C 1892 Barber 1892
MS65
PCGS
27231276

Gem $975 Ideal Type Piece, Superb Eye Appeal, Frosted Luster, Swirling Cartwheels. At GFRC, we handle a steady stream of 1892 Barber quarters with the exceptionally pleasing examples being easily noted. This new Whitman Baltimore purchase was a no-brainer given the superb eye appeal along with naturally toned surfaces, swirling cartwheels, and frosted luster. The preservation is exquisite and is nicely captured by my images. I like this piece so much that a JUST BUY IT NOW shout out is appropriate. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.6 (2013-2014) holder with CAC approval.
Barber 25C 1892O Barber 1892-O
Type 1 Reverse
MS64
PCGS
28551877

Choice $950 Near-Gem, Frosted Luster, Pristine Surfaces, Die Cud at Base. Frosted luster is prevalent throughout this most attractive 1892-O Barber quarter with hints of steely radiance on the reverse. Under a bright light, the cartwheels are satisfying. Quite notable are the pristine surfaces that entirely blemish free. Obverse toning is limited to copper-gold at the periphery while the reverse sports light rose-gold with greenish hues at the center. Please note the die cud at the left edge of the bottom of the bust. This piece is so close to gem with just a tad more obverse luster pushing this one to a full GFRC-Gem quality rating. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.6 (2013-2014) holder with CAC approval.
Barber 25C 1892O Barber 1892-O
Type 2 Reverse
AU58
PCGS
34961962

Choice $475 New April 19! Type 2 Reverse, Choice Original, Frosty Cartwheel Luster, Superb Eye Appeal, Pikes Peak Collection. 1892 brought a transition year for the Barber quarter reverse hub design with both Type 1 and Type 2 hubs employed circulation strikes in Philadelphia and New Orleans. For the Type 2 Reverse, the primary pickup point is the left wing end and its placement over UNIT(E)D and completely blocking that letter. This Pikes Peak release is a solid AU58 specimen with light rub on the cheek. This is a brilliant frosted example with thick mint bloom on both sides. Bright viewing is pleasing with nice cartwheel auction. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
Barber 25C 1893 Barber 1893
PR66CAM
CACG
26926007

Gem $2725 Superb Eye Appeal, Watery Mirrored Fields, Peripheral Copper-Gold, Port Matilda Collection. There are certain coins that cross my desk and immediately secure a "wow" reaction when first viewed. I'm calling a JUST BUY IT NOW recommendation for this superb 1893 proof Barber quarter to grab your attention as the coin in hand is much better than suggested by the images. The watery mirrors a brilliantly reflective without distractions under a bright light. Device are nicely frosted and provide the appropriate contrast with the mirrored fields to secure a cameo designation. A superior piece that has been conservatively graded. Housed in new CAC Grading holder and graded consistent with CAC approval standards.
Barber 25C 1896O Barber 1896-O
EF40
PCGS
33042220

Choice $845 Better Early Date, Circulated Cameo Eye Appeal, Natural Coin Gray. Though considered a much better date, GFRC has been fortunate in selling two 1896-O Mint State examples during 2023 and replacing those with this lovely CAC approved EF40. Surfaces are toned a natural coin gray with thicker "crust" on the obverse. The contrast between the darker gray fields and lighter devices is moderate but still described as partial circulated cameo. Strike is complete and impressive under a 10x. Fields are unabraded too. Overall, a premium example worthy of consideration for a circulated Barber quarter project. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
Barber 25C 1896S Barber 1896-S
VG08
PCGS
09567706

Choice $1550 Key Date, Natural Coin Gray, Choice Surfaces, Wayward Collection. With a "tiny" mintage of 188,039, the 1896-S date is rare in all grades and enjoys Barber quarter key date status. CAC has approved several hundred with most being the AG3 to G6 grades. This accurately graded VG08 exhibits unmolested surfaces that are toned a natural coin grade. Rims and fields are well preserved and unabraded. The CDN CAC priced guide is $1500 with only 27 approved. Beyond this grade, the pricing premium accelerates. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval.
Barber 25C 1897S Barber 1897-S
VF20
PCGS
16897607

Choice $895 Much Better Date, Natural Coin Gray Finish, Choice Overall, CAC Approval. A much better San Francisco issue with mintage of 542,229. This is a well preserved specimen with natural coin gray patina that is softened with hints of gold, especially at the stars and legend. Fields are surprisingly unabraded given the time in circulation. A perfect example for the grade that is consistent with CAC expectations. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval.
Barber 25C 1899 Barber 1899
AU55
PCGS
32400022

Choice $285 New April 19! Vibrant Cartwheels, Rich Frosty Luster, Hammered Strike, Pikes Peak Collection. If flashy frosted radiance and vibrant cartwheels are your numismatic passion, then this Pikes Peak 1899 Barber quarter belongs in a numismatic cabinet. An untoned example with hammered strike. Obverse devices including the stars are presented in high relief. Reverse tail feathers are completely impressed. Bright light viewing exposes tons of brilliant frosty luster from surfaces that are completely unabraded. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 holder with CAC approval. Ex. Port Matilda Collection.
Barber 25C 1899S Barber 1899-S
EF40
PCGS
84785481

Choice HOLD
$345
New April 19! Choice Original, Gray Toned Fields, Circulated Cameo Eye Appeal, Accurately Graded, Pikes Peak Collection. Choice original surfaces are immediately noted on this noteworthy Pikes Peak 1899 San Francisco quarter. The contrast between dark gray fields and lighter main device results in lovely circulated cameo appearance. Under a bright light, the fields shift to greenish hues with gold at the immediate borders. Accurately graded and housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval. The CAC census stands at 32 examples in all grades. Previously part of the amazing Iowa Collection of strictly original and evenly matched Liberty Seated and Barber quarters.
Barber 25C 1901O Barber 1901-O
VF25
PCGS
16200676

Choice $700 Semi-Key Date, Natural Coin Gray, Well Preserved and Unabraded, CAC Approved. The little brother to the famous 1901-S key date, this 1901 New Orleans strike is perfectly preserved for the grade. Surfaces a completely choice and unabraded. Coloration is natural coin gray with with hints of peripheral gold under a bright light. An ideal example for the grade with low CAC population. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval.
Barber 25C 1903 Barber 1903
EF45
PCGS
25197775

Choice $150 New April 19! Choice Original, Light Gray Surfaces, Residual Cartwheel Luster, Conservative Grading, Pikes Peak Collection. Let's start the description with a JUST BUY IT NOW recommendation as this lovely 1903 Barber half is not your typical EF45. One immediately sees an AU50 upon examination due to residual cartwheel luster that is quite pleasing. Surface are covered with a thin layer of gray-gold patination that validates the strict originality. Under 10x, the surfaces are unabraded. Conservatively graded and housed in a PCGS Gen 4.5 (2012-2013) holder with CAC approval.
Barber 25C 1904 Barber 1904
AU53
NGC
3892405007

Choice $195 Gun Metal Gray-Blue Patina, Bright Light Eye Appeal, Choice Surfaces, CAC Approval. A most attractive 1904 Barber quarter with coveted CAC approval. In-hand gray toning shifts to colorful blue centers surrounded by rose and peripheral gold. Fields retain steely reflective surfaces and luster. Overall, a very pretty piece that is sure to please the new owner. Housed in newer NGC holder with edge view insert along with CAC approval.
Barber 25C 1908O Barber 1908-O
AU58
PCGS
43280979

Choice $450 New April 26! Encrusted Golden Patination, Frosted Luster, Poor Man's Collection. Another tranche of originality arrives with this 1908-O Barber quarter courtesy of the Poor Man's Collection. Our consignor is back with a host of choice and gem rated type and Barbers coins for your consideration. This lot features a thick golden patination on the obverse with similar shades on the reverse, though much more transparent to the underlying luster. Under a bright light, the reverse cartwheels are vibrant and pleasing. Strike is complete with just high point rub. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2025) holder with CAC approval.
Barber 25C 1909 Barber 1909
AU58
PCGS
43280980

Choice $285 Granular Frosted Luster, Light Crusty Gold, Gem Eye Appeal. Let's go with a JUST BUY IT NOW recommendation for this near-gem rated 1909 Barber dime. This is a perfectly original example with granular frosted luster and a light crusted golden skin. The premium eye appeal is quite convincing and will delight fans of the series. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2024) holder with CAC approval.
Barber 25C 1909S Barber 1909-S
AU50
PCGS
80492399

Choice $360 Better San Francisco Date, Gorgeous Steely Luster, Choice Surfaces. A top shelf 1900 San Francisco struck Barber quarter that is sure to please the new owner. Steely fields still retain reflective luster and cartwheels during bright light inspection. Overall toning is light gray with golden highlights. Strike is fully executed with minimal wear for the certified grade. A premium example that easily warranted CAC approval. A popular lot that makes its fourth price list appearance including a release from the Island City Collection auction. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
Barber 25C 1910 Barber 1910
MS61
PCGS OGH
4599036

Choice $360 New April 19! Choice Original, Radiant Luster, CAC Approval, Pikes Peak Collection. Ex. Labelman87 Collection. Grading coins at the AU58/MS61 level can sometimes be more art than science, but it's clear in this case the graders were attracted by the radiating luster. Light, golden toning is highlighted by maroon rims, particularly on the obverse at stars 1 to 3. A few lines are evident on Liberty's cheek, but the story here is the mint bloom evident even in the usual problem areas of Liberty's cap, cheek, and bust truncation. Housed in a PCGS Gen 3.1 (1993-1996) old green holder with CAC approval.
Barber 25C 1913D Barber 1913-D
AU55
PCGS
81187941

Choice $315 New April 20! Soft Frosted Luster, Choice Original, Pikes Peak Collection. An attractive 1913-D Barber quarter that fully deserves its CAC green bean. Soft steely-frosted luster radiates from the obverse while the reverse is toned an orange-gold. Bright light viewing is special with vibrant cartwheels which are well beyond what my images can illustrate. A strong offering for the grade from the Pikes Peak Collection that is guaranteed to please. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
Barber 25C 1916D Barber 1916-D
AU58
NGC
1843796018

Choice $275 New April 20! Steely-Frosted Presentation, Swirling Cartwheels, Near-Gem Original, Pikes Peak Collection. This Near-Gem quality rated 1916-D quarter offers superior luster and swirling cartwheels for starters. A well above average AU58 example that is consistent with the overall Pike Peaks quality being released during Easter weekend. Radiance falls into the steely-frosted realm with hints of blue hues under a bright light. Surfaces are essentially unabraded. This is a lot of viewing please at the offer price. Housed in newer NGC holder with edge view insert and CAC approval.
Standing Liberty 25C 1917D Standing Liberty 1917-D
Type 1, Doubled Die Reverse
MS64FH
PCGS
45966671
FS-801
Choice $5995 Doubled Die Reverse, Condition Census, Full Head, Frosted Luster, CAC Approved. GFRC is excited to be offering a condition census 1917-D Type 1 Doubled Die Reverse Standing quarter for your consideration. This offering is the second finest known as the CAC population report indicates a single example finer at MS65FH. The reverse doubling is located to the left of E PLURIBUS with a long vertical die crack from the rim through S(T)ATES to the I in AMERICA. Surfaces are pristine and present granular frosted luster under a bright light. Given the Full Head designation, the strike is complete with bold shield rivets. This lot originates from a consignor. Both PCGS and CAC have not documented a price guide value at this lofty grade level. I was able to locate a PCGS guide number of $2750 at AU58 for a non-FH example as a reference point. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2022) holder with CAC approval and Type 1 DDR FS-801 variety attribution on the label. Please be aware that the CAC population report does not list this MS64FH example. I've contacted CAC and requested that this omission be corrected.
Standing Liberty 25C 1923S Standing Liberty 1923-S
EF45
PCGS
28459201

Choice $2050 Better Standing Liberty Sate, Steely Frosted Luster, Peripheral Gold, CAC Approval. 1923 San Francisco struck Standing quarters amounted to 1,360,000. However, heavy circulation has limited availability for the host of collectors who pursue this 20th century series. This CAC approved example is impressive for its residual luster than emanates from fields best described as steely-frosted. Wear on the highest points is limited leaving bold devices. Peripheral copper-gold on the obverse nicely framed the light center. Surfaces are free of any notable marks. Overall a premium piece and worthy of CAC approval. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.6 (2013-2014) holder.
Standing Liberty 25C 1929 Standing Liberty 1929
MS64FH
PCGS
22103949

Choice $825 Full Head Strike, Brilliant Frosted Luster, Swirling Cartwheels. A well preserved 1929 Standing quarter that is fully struck with the outer and inner shield circles boldly outlined. Two rivets lack full separation while the head is complete. Bold strikes on later date mintages can be challenging to locate. This is a brilliant frosted example with faint peripheral gold that extends into the obverse. CAC has approved 39 at the certified grade with a 50% CDN guide price jump to the next grade. CAC MS64FH is $815 as reference. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval. The holder is well worn at the upper obverse and at the lower reverse. Two reverse haze spots are evident on the GFRC image.
Standing Liberty 25C 1930S Standing Liberty 1930-S
AU55
CACG
537727391

Choice HOLD
$150
New April 20! Choice Original, Pikes Peak Collection. Typically of what CACG will holder in terms of strict originality. Sharp frosted luster is consistent on both sides with minimum rub at the certified grade. Housed in new CAC Grading holder and graded consistent with CAC approval standards.
50 Cents
Capped Bust 50C 1817 Capped Bust 1817
Punctuated Date
AU50
CACG
660804182
O-103b
Choice $2750 Punctuated Date, Late Die State O-103b, Unquestionably Original, CACG Holder. I continue to be impressed by the meticulously strict CACG grading standards as showcased by this 1817 O-103b Punctuated half dollar. The originality is beyond question with just a touch of surface "crud" as evidence. The undisturbed fields are steely coin gray with gold and aquamarine shades at the borders. The edge strike is substantial with sharp elevated star points but also with weak hair curls. Residual reflectance, under a bright light, is considerable. The punctuated date features a die dot between the 1 and 7 digits. During this later die state, the dot becomes faint but still viewable with a 10x. Housed in new CAC Grading holder and graded consistent with CAC approval standards.
Capped Bust 50C 1831 Capped Bust 1831
AU58
NGC
1271210012
O-108
Choice $1000 New March 9! Steely-Frosted Luster, Golden-Brown Surfaces, Near-Gem Original, Sheffield Collection. The AU58 grade is enthusiastically pursued by collectors given the eye appeal value at a substantial discount to Mint State 62/63 graded example. This well preserved 1831 O-108 is lots of viewing fun under a bright light with its golden steely-frosted radiance and undisturbed fields. Fully struck stars, with eleved center points, nicely complement the bold center devices. As with many open collar struck halves of this era. the reverse horizontal shield lines are partial. Overall, the eye appeal is superior for ongoing viewing enjoyment. This piece has the GFRC JUST BUY IT NOW recommendation to garner attention. Housed in NGC Gen 7 (1997-2000) holder with CAC approval.
Capped Bust 50C 1833 Capped Bust 1833
AU58
PCGS
43621468
O-105
Choice $985 New April 4! Popular Everyman Grade, Orange-Gray Toning, Choice Surfaces, Evergreen State Collection. This Evergreen Collection release is a choice 1833 O-105 half struck with late die state dies as evidenced by metal flow lines throughout the fields. Under a bright light, surfaces radiate a soft frosted luster with strong radiance on the lightly toned reverse. Unquestionably original with light rub. CAC has approved 90 at the certified grade with a price guide value at $950. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2025) Gold shield holder with CAC approval.
Seated 50C 1839 Seated 1839
With Drapery
MS65
PCGS
32707208
WB-5
Gem $25500 With Drapery, Gem Original, Newtown Collection, Ex. Pogue.. A stellar pedigree accompanies this Gem half dollar, which traces the coin to both the Pogue and Pryor collections. Although lacking the 1853-O No Arrows half, the Pryor collection included just about everything else, including an MS-64 1878-S and a complete, Mint State set of Carson City halves. A quick tilt of the present coin reveals blue and rose-copper patina, and the eye appeal is strong. A few stars are softly impressed, while most of the eagle claws are sharp. WB-5, with a die lump just beneath the drapery to the right side. This piece is tied for finest known at CAC, which notes 65 coins total, including five pieces certified at MS65 and no examples finer. Previously from the Pogue V sale (Stack’s Bowers, January 2017), lot 5027, where it sold for $21,150. Earlier from the Pryor collection, there sold by Bowers & Merena (January 1996), lot 98, at $3,080. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) PCGS holder with special Pogue label pedigree. The label reads D. Brent Pogue Collection, WB-102 Seated Drapery. Ex. GFRC January 2023, at $24,500. PCGS #6232.
Seated 50C 1840 Seated 1840
Reverse of 1839
MS64+
PCGS
81471362
WB-1
Gem $8000 New March 30! Gem Original, Newtown Collection.. A brilliant figure of Liberty emerges from the crusty fields, framed by deeper blue patina at the periphery. The overall preservation level is exceptional, and this near-condition census piece will serve as an upgrade to all but the most advanced sets of Liberty Seated half dollars. Stars to the left are weakly impressed, while the eagle claws are well-defined. WB-1, with reverse die cracks. CAC reports 76 coins overall, with three coins at MS64, four pieces in MS65, and four at the MS66 level. The CAC price guide progresses from $4,350 in MS64 to $11,200 in MS65. Pricing a “plus” attribute is somewhat more art than science, and, in this case, the bidders will decide the appropriate increment above the MS64 value. Ex. Osprey collection (GFRC, June 2021), at $8,500. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #6234.
Seated 50C 1840O Seated 1840-O
MS63+
PCGS
06613793
WB-11
Gem $6500 New March 28! Satiny Luster, Premium Second Year Issue, Gem Original, Ex.Newtown Collection.. Consignor Price Reduction - Satiny luster flows from both sides of this highly original piece, while an exceptional strike delivers well-defined star points and full claw detail. The lightly toned surfaces reveal only a few ticks, consistent with the grade level. WB-11, with the reverse die crack, although not advanced, easily matching the Bugert plate coin. CAC reports 54 coins total, with three pieces in MS63, two coins at MS64, and a single outlier at MS66. The CAC price guide advances from $6,750 in MS63 to $11,400 in MS64. Ex. Newtown Liberty Seated Half Dollar Collection Sale (GFRC, January 2025) where it realized $7,500. Housed in a PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval.
Seated 50C 1845 Seated 1845
MS64
PCGS
43779810
WB-2
Choice HOLD
$12000
Near-Gem Original, Tied Finest at CAC, Newtown Collection.. The CAC census continues to reveal surprises, with ostensibly common dates being surprisingly scarce when originality is considered. CAC has certified 29 examples of the 1845 half, and this piece stands as king of the hill with two other pieces at the MS64 level, and none finer. The situation is nearly as challenging at PCGS, which has certified four coins at MS64, a single example at MS64+, and none higher. The present coin exhibits thick patina, with rose colored fields and intense blue shade in the protected areas of the obverse. Characteristic softness is evident at the eagle’s left leg. W-2, with the high date slanting downward and die lump atop (STA)T(ES). The CAC price guide value is $12,000. Ex. Rare Coin Wholesalers. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2024) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #6248.
Seated 50C 1849 Seated 1849
MS64
PCGS
25262963
WB-11
Gem $6000 Gem Original, Newtown Collection.. Medium crust reveals gold and copper patina as this Philadelphia piece is examined under a bright light. Ample luster is partially reflective, and the overall eye appeal easily earns the GFRC Gem rating. WB-11, with repunching in the 1 and effaced detail at the reverse shield point. The left leg of the eagle is softly impressed. CAC has certified 53 coins overall, with 11 pieces at MS64 and a single coin finer, at MS65. The CAC price guide is $6,000, jumping to $15,100 at MS65. Ex. Washington State Collection, via GFRC, February 2022, at $5,250. Housed in a PCGS Gen 5.0 holder with CAC approval. PCGS #6262.
Seated 50C 1850 Seated 1850
MS65+
PCGS
50073544
WB-4
Gem $55000 Condition Census, Gem Original, Newtown Collection.. Production of silver coinage began falling in 1850, as increasing supplies of gold caused an imbalance in the valuation of silver. Congress corrected the problem only with the Coinage Act of 1853, leaving the Mint to coin a decreasing supply of silver bullion in the intervening years. This low-mintage piece exhibits liberal copper and aqua patina, and the overall eye appeal merits the GFRC Gem designation. Ample luster imparts slight reflectivity to the surfaces. Stars are sharp, while the left claws remain separated, if faintly so. WB-4, with a tine to the upper left of 1. CAC has approved 28 coins total, with a single coin in MS65 (the present coin) and only one piece finer, at MS67. The CAC price guide value is $36,000 (CAC does not price plus grades), while the PCGS value at the MS65+ level is $60,000. Ex. GFRC, August 2023, at $53,000. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #6264.
Seated 50C 1850O Seated 1850-O
MS65
PCGS Rattler
2255047
WB-3
Gem $16500 Gem Original, Newtown Collection.. Frosty luster showcases scattered copper patina on the obverse, while the reverse features a cross-section of gray color across the eagle’s head and right wing. A hammered strike delivers completely defined eagle claws and star centers. WB-3, with die lumps beneath the ribbon extending from the rock. CAC has approved 31 coins in all grades, with three pieces in MS65 and just two examples higher, both in MS66. The CAC price guide assigns a value pf $14,400 in MS65, advancing to $36,000 in MS66. Ex. GFRC, January 2024, at $17,000. Housed in a PCGS Gen 1.2 (1986-1989) old rattler holder with CAC approval. PCGS #6265.
Seated 50C 1851 Seated 1851
MS63
PCGS
6605178
WB-6
Choice HOLD
$5500
Choice Original, Newtown Collection.. Bold cartwheel luster activates transparent gold and rose patina as this Philadelphia example is rotated under a bright light. Obverse fields are slightly reflective while the reverse is frostier. Stars to the left are sharper, while the claw separation is easily evident. The surfaces are clean for the grade and the overall eye appeal is wholesome. WB-6, with the foot of the second one below the 5. The 1851 issue is especially desirable as silver coinage production decreased prior to Coinage Act of 1853 – indeed, the Philadelphia Mint struck just over 200,000 pieces in this year. CAC has certified 21 coins total, including two pieces at MS63 and three examples finer. The CAC price guide indicates a value of $5,700. Ex. GFRC (March 2017) at $5,750. Housed in a PCGS Gen 4.0 (1998-2002) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #6266.
Seated 50C 1852 Seated 1852
MS65
PCGS
81341524
WB-2
Gem $21500 Gem Original, Newtown Collection Ex. Bender.. Golden-tan color covers both sides of this GFRC-rated Gem example. The strike is strong, with only star 7 soft, while the reverse is hammered throughout. CAC has approved 21 coins total, including three at the MS65 level, and none higher. The situation at PCGS is nearly as challenging, with five coins at MS65, one piece in MS66, and none finer. WB-2, with underlying lines in the reverse shield. Note, obverse diagonal lines reveal heavy die polish, as struck. This is a much better date among Seated halves, with a mintage of 77,130 pieces. The CAC guide value is $18,000. This piece will not represent a casual purchase for most collectors, and the opportunity to acquire a CAC “top pop” rightly calls for careful consideration. Ex. Tom Bender Collection (Heritage Auctions, February 2023), lot 3746, at $21,600. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2024) holder with CAC approval. The label documents the Bender Collection pedigree. PCGS #6268.
Seated 50C 1855 Seated 1855
With Arrows
MS64
PCGS
33290557

Choice $4500 New March 30! Near-Gem Original, Newtown Collection.. Dusty gray patina reveals bits of underlying silver color, more so on the reverse. Light crust is evident around the protected portions of the eagle. Typically struck, with several soft stars. The 1855 Philadelphia With Arrows issue is not rare but remains more challenging than the 1853 and 1854 issues. This is an ideal selection for a type collector seeking additional rarity beyond common date status. CAC has certified 33 coins in all grades, a lower total among Seated halves, with four pieces in MS64 and four examples finer. The PCGS price guide is $5,100. Ex. Regency Auction 26 (Legend, May 2018), lot 573, realized $3,877.50. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #6281.
Seated 50C 1856 Seated 1856
MS65
PCGS
36832920
WB-1
Gem $8000 Gem Original, Newtown Collection.. Luster booms from the surfaces of this Philadelphia piece, easily penetrating the medium skin. Speckled tan, ocean green, and slate patina blanket the obverse, while smoky gray hue more evenly covers the reverse, along with olive shades in the protected areas. The luster is not fully conveyed by the images, and the next owner of this GFRC-rated Gem example will be pleased. Strike is typical, with softness in the right stars. The Gardner coin, graded PCGS MS66 CAC and arguably the finest known, exhibits similar striking characteristics. WB-1, easily attributed by the spiked 1. CAC has certified 41 pieces in all grades, two coins at MS65, and just two examples finer, both at MS66. The CAC price guide value is $7,500. Ex. Oregon Beaver (GFRC, November 2023), at $8,000. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #6287.
Seated 50C 1856O Seated 1856-O
MS65
PCGS
50003724
WB-13
Gem $5850 New March 30! Gem Original, Newtown Collection.. A bold crescent of charcoal patina fills the stars, contrasting strongly with the brilliant center, while the reverse reveals copper shades to the lower right. Satiny luster flows from both sides, and the eye appeal is strong. Star centers are easily distinct, while claw joints to the left blend together. CAC has approved 92 pieces total, with ten coins in MS65 and just three examples finer. WB-13, with a die crack at Liberty’s shoulder and a vertical die line in the reverse shield horizontals. The CAC price guide is $5,250, a reasonable level given the advanced placement in the condition census. Ex. Pinnacle Rarities. Housed in a PCGS Gen 4.1 (2002-2004) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #6288.
Seated 50C 1857O Seated 1857-O
MS64
PCGS
34329349
WB-1
Gem $7500 New March 30! Gem Original, Newtown Collection.. A medium dusting of crust covers both sides, more heavily on the reverse. The originality is immediately apparent, with antique, hairline-free surfaces easily visible under the skin. Star centers are sharp while separation of the left claw joints is evident, if weakly so. WB-1, with the date sloping down and a large mintmark. CAC has approved but 28 coins in all grades, a lower total among Seated half dollars, four pieces in MS64, and no examples finer. PCGS notes nine coins at MS64 and no pieces higher. The CAC price guide value is $7,900. Ex. Heritage (January 2018, lot 3720), at $6,000 – a prescient purchase on the part of the consignor, who was able to acquire this top-pop PCGS/CAC example at an attractive price. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #6291.
Seated 50C 1858 Seated 1858
MS65
PCGS
12615672

Gem $5250 New March 30! Gem Original, Newtown Collection, Ex. Gardner.. Swirling ebon and gold patina fills the fields of this Philadelphia piece, while protected areas of the obverse reveal an outline of steel-gray color. Gem luster is somewhat subdued at first glance but is easily evident under a light. Strike is typical, with stars 4-8 soft. CAC notes 126 coins in all grades, nine pieces at MS65, and two examples finer, both at MS66. The CAC price guide assigns a value of $5,200 in MS65, a reasonable level for a coin removed from top-pop status by only a single point. Ex. Heritage (May 2022, lot 3518), at $5,040, previously from Gardner IV (Heritage, October 2015), lot 98671, where it realized $4,230. Housed in a PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #6293.
Seated 50C 1858O Seated 1858-O
MS64
PCGS
36167037
WB-14
Choice $3250 New March 30! Near-Gem Original, Newtown Collection.. Frosty luster highlights the even gold and olive patina evident on both sides. A few of the protected areas reveal lighter silver-steel color, and the overall eye appeal is excellent. Strike is typical, with weakness in the eagle’s left leg. WB-14, with the date sloping upward and the mintmark tilted to the left. Production in this year was ample, and Bill Bugert identifies 41 die marriages for the issue. Despite the production level, exceeding seven million pieces, CAC has certified only 115 coins total, three examples in MS64, and six pieces finer. The CAC price guide indicates a value of $3,600 in MS64. Ex. Heritage (November 2018, lot 3689), at $2,640. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #6294.
Seated 50C 1858O Seated 1858-O
AU55
PCGS
32689121
WB-22
Choice HOLD
$525
New April 20! Repunched Date, Near-Gem Original, Pikes Peak Collection. A near-gem 1858-O WB-22 repunched date half that deserves a JUST BUY IT NOW recommendation. The piece excels under a bright light as the obverse presentation is a bullseye aquamarine center surrounded by yellow and then orange gold. Reverse is equally pretty with golden blue shades. Steely radiance is also noted, especially on the reverse as the toning is lighter. The repunched digit between the final 58 digits is bold and easily seen with 10x. A few stray contact marks preclude a GFRC-Gem rating though the eye appeal is at that level. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval. The label lists "RPD WB102" as the attribution.
Seated 50C 1859O Seated 1859-O
MS63
PCGS
21786106
WB-7
Gem HOLD
$2850
New March 30! Gem Original, Newtown Collection.. Light gold centers give way to concentric rings in the stars and legend, a favored “look” among collectors of silver coins. Maroon and aqua patina intermingles at the rims, and the eye appeal is exceptional. A powerful strike effectively brings up the star centers, feathers, and claw knuckles. While the 1859-O is a common date within the Liberty Seated half series, the visual attraction of the present coin rises well above that usually seen. WB-7, with the date sloping down and 9 centered above two dentils. CAC has approved 74 pieces total, five examples in MS63, and ten coins finer. The CAC price guide is $2,400, and a stronger result at auction will not be a surprise. Ex. Seal Beach (GFRC, April 2019), realized $2,600. Housed in a PCGS Gen 4.2 (2004-2005) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #6297.
Seated 50C 1860 Seated 1860
EF40
CACG
773083545

Choice HOLD
$485
New April 22! Low Mintage Philadelphia Date, Choice Steely Fields, CACG Holder. The "price guides" are frankly a mess for 1860 Philadelphia strikes and obviously understated. The guides treat this date as common when in fact the low mintage and lack of survivors results in the opposite. Total CAC approved population is a meager 27 pieces total with another 8 certified by CACG which is the case with this offering. How can this be a common date? The coin itself is a marvelous example with deep blue-gray patination and sharp reflective luster during bright light inspection. Worthy of a JUST BUY IT NOW call out for those serious about their Liberty Seated half dollar collecting projects. Housed in new CAC Grading holder and graded consistent with CAC approval standards.
Seated 50C 1860O Seated 1860-O
MS65+
PCGS
43203571
WB-5
Gem $8000 New March 30! Gem Original, Newtown Collection.. Generous frost highlights the olive-gold patina evident in the stars and legend. The obverse exhibits more intense color while the reverse toning is largely confined to the protected areas. A complete strike fully impresses the star points and eagle claws. WB-5, with a crack to the right of star 8, and a large mintmark tilted to the right. This is the Type II hub, with a long base of L in HALF. CAC notes 75 pieces total, five coins in MS65, and three examples in MS66. The CAC price guide is $6,750 in MS65 and rises to $25,900 in MS66, while PCGS quotes $7,000 in MS65, $8,500 in MS65+, and $22,500 in MS66. Ex. Rare Coin Wholesalers. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2024) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #6300.
Seated 50C 1860S Seated 1860-S
MS64
PCGS
47451989
WB-1
Choice $15000 New March 30! Near-Gem Original, Newtown Collection.. Frosty silver surfaces lead to attractive toning at the rims, an effective more fully appreciated with in-person inspection. The strike is exceptional, with the stars rising well above the plane of the planchet. WB-1, with a low date and large mintmark. This piece is tied for top honors at CAC and PCGS, and, given the overall eye appeal, will draw significant attention. CAC has approved but 22 coins total, two pieces in MS64, and no examples higher. The situation at PCGS is similarly challenging, with eight grading events in MS64 and none finer. The CAC price guide is $9,750, while PCGS indicates a value of $18,500. The rare coin market is not perfectly efficient, and price guides struggle to reflect the true market value of thinly traded items. As PCGS Coin Facts indicates, the “market velocity” of the 1860-S half in MS63/MS64 grades is less than one piece per year. In this case, the sale of this same coin in 2023 represents the most important data point. Ex. Regency Auction 61 (Legend, November 2023), lot 131, realized $14,687.50. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2024) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #6301.
Seated 50C 1861 Seated 1861
CSA Scott Restrike
MS64
PCGS
50013710

Gem $7950 CSA Scott Restrike, Gem Original.. Consignor Pricing Reduction - One of the initially struck 500 pieces by J.W. Scott in white metal to test the reconditioned Confederate half dollar reverse die and extremely well preserved. The GFRC-Gem rated specimen is flawless with the surfaces providing an intricate view of the rusted condition of the Confederate reverse circa 1879. Under a bright light, both sides are partially mirrored with eye catching radiance. The coloration is a silver-gray. This lot belongs in an advanced numismatic cabinet as heads and shoulders above the many survivors being offered in today's market. The CAC census is currently 17 pieces with only two finer. The CDN CAC guide is $8,600 as reference. This lot is worthy of the reserve and will be a highlight of a Civil War era collection. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.6 (2013-2014) holder with CAC approval. The label reads CSA Scott Restrike.
Seated 50C 1863 Seated 1863
MS64
PCGS
13565456
WB-7
Choice $5000 New March 30! Near-Gem Original, Newtown Collection.. The scarcity of Seated coinage with original surfaces has long been known to specialists, but the CAC census, now in its seventeenth year, offers quantitative proof of the situation. This Civil War-dated half dollar is a typical example, with only 26 pieces reported by CAC across all grades. Even gray and olive surfaces host silver patches in the stars and legend, with additional shades of blue-gray at the rims and protected areas. Luster is frosty, with swirling cartwheels. Nicely struck, as is the rule for 1863 halves, with only a touch of softness in the eagle’s left leg. This is a better Philadelphia date, with just over half a million pieces struck. CAC has certified two pieces in MS64 and five finer examples. The CAC price guide value is $2,750. The PCGS price guide weighs in at $3,000, but the more controlling point is the complete lack of recent sales, with PCGS Coin Facts listing no sales since 2013. The previous GFRC sale is more in line with current values. Ex. GFRC (Sunset Collection, March 2021), realized $5,275. Housed in a PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #6309.
Seated 50C 1866S Seated 1866-S
With Motto
MS65+
PCGS
43300428
WB-9
Gem $18250 New March 30! Gem Original, Newtown Collection. Ex. Eliasberg.. Blazing surfaces reveal touches of gold patina on both sides, and the frosty flash is fully consistent with the assigned grade if not more so. Indeed, the visual “pop” is more impressive than conveyed by the images, and this piece requires in-person viewing to fully appreciate the radiant luster. A few tiny bits of crust are evident here and there. Stars are soft, while the eagle claws are sharp. WB-9, with traces of 8 and 6 in the obverse dentils. CAC notes 22 examples total, one coin in MS65 (the present piece), and a sole example finer, at MS66. The CAC price guide value at MS65 is $15,100, rising to $25,900 in MS66. The PCGS census is equally challenging, with one coin in MS65, one piece in MS65+ (the present example), and one finer coin at MS66. Ex. Regency Auction 48 (Legend, October 2021), lot 115, at $17,625, previously from the Eliasberg Collection (Bowers & Merena, April 1997), lot 2004, at $9,350. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2024) holder with CAC approval. The label documents the Eliasberg pedigree. PCGS #6320.
Seated 50C 1867S Seated 1867-S
EF45
CACG
66868467
WB-8
Choice $550 New March 21! Stone Cold Original, Natural Coin Gray Patina, Saw Mill Run Collection. A later die state WB-8 example with natural coin gray toning and well preserved surfaces. Conservative abounds with this Saw Mill Run Collection offering. The reverse die is well worn at this point with eroded mintmark and obvious die cracks from AMERIC(A) to the arrow heads. Housed in new CACG holder and graded to strict standards employed for CAC stickering approval. A no-brainer purchase for fans of strict originality.
Seated 50C 1868S Seated 1868-S
MS64+
PCGS
34815113
WB-8
Choice $7000 New March 30! Near-Gem Original, Newtown Collection.. Silver-gray centers lead toward subtle rose and gold patina at the rims, which exhibit scattered crust on both sides. Frosty luster is ample for the grade, and a light source immediately activates the near-Gem flash. WB-8, with recut stars to the left and a small mintmark. This is an early die state without advanced die cracks. Stars to the left are soft, while the reverse detail is excellent throughout. CAC has approved 29 examples, with three coins in MS64 and a single piece finer, at MS65. PCGS notes two coins in MS65 and one example finer at MS66. The CAC price guide indicates a value of $6,600 in MS64 and $15,100 in MS65. Ex. Heritage (October 2018, lot 3055), at $5,040. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #6324.
Seated 50C 1874 Seated 1874
With Arrows
MS64
NGC
3603430010

Choice $3650 With Arrows, Choice Original.. A near-gem Seated half dollar lot which is ideal for an advanced collection of the series or for type. Copper-rose patina overlays the obverse while bluish-gold appears on the reverse. This 1874 half is so close to fully struck with only the left facing eagle claw not being completely raised. Uniform frosted luster is activated with angled lighting. A stray ancient line between stars 11 and 12 is seen with 10x. CAC has approved seven at grade with eight finer. Housed in newer NGC holder with edge view insert and CAC approval.
Seated 50C 1875CC Seated 1875-CC
MS64
PCGS
29969962
WB-4
Choice $7500 Near-Gem Original, Newtown Collection.. Medium skin blankets both sides of this Carson City issue, and the originality is strong. Protected areas retain lighter color, around the stars, date, and legend, while the fields are crustier. WB-4, with a low date and medium CC punched high. Strike is typical, with softness beneath the eagle. Although production was just over a million pieces, collector demand for anything “CC”-related is strong, and the CAC certification only increases the desirability of this present piece. CAC has approved 71 pieces in all grades, 11 coins in MS64, and four examples higher, all in MS65. The CAC price guide value is $6,300. Ex. Rare Coin Wholesalers. Housed in a PCGS Gen 5.0 holder with CAC approval. PCGS #6350.
Seated 50C 1875S Seated 1875-S
MS66+
PCGS
36073607
WB-11
Gem $7500 Gem Original, Newtown Collection.. Radiant luster flows easily from the surfaces of this GFRC-rated Gem, with cartwheels readily activated by even moderate light. Smoky grey and russet patina covers the fields, with deeper shades evident at the rims , while centers retain original silver color. The strike is near complete, with claw joints separated if faintly so. WB-11, with the date punched to the right and a small mintmark tilting right. CAC has certified 66 coins total, with ten pieces in MS66 and two examples finer, both in MS67. The CAC guide value is $6,000, a reasonable level, given only the pair of MS67 coins besting the present example. Ex. Great Collections (March 2020), at $5,625. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #6351.
Seated 50C 1876S Seated 1876-S
MS66
PCGS
09181398
-
Gem $8000 Gem Original, Newtown Collection.. Abundant, frosty luster radiates from the surfaces of this GFRC-rated Gem example, with hints of rose and gold color at the rims. The near-finest known status is easily reinforced by the overall flash, which is substantial. Slight reflectivity is evident as the coin is tilted under a light. A hammered strike sharply defines the stars, while the feather and claw details are easily distinct. In this cataloguer’s opinion, strike becomes more of a controlling factor as the technical grade is elevated, as any weakness in the strike becomes amplified by strong luster and the absence of surface marks. This coin is all there, in terms of luster, strike, and virtually smooth fields. CAC notes 45 examples total, with three pieces in MS66 and only a single coin finer at MS66+. The CAC guide value is $9.750. Ex. Heritage (July 2022, lot 3107), realized $7,800. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2024) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #6354.
Seated 50C 1877 Seated 1877
MS66+
PCGS
45243280

Gem HOLD
$6750
Exceptional Eye Appeal, Superb Gem, Oustanding Type Candidate, Osprey Collection. Consignor Price Reduction. An exceptionally beautiful 1877 Seated half that would boldly complement the finest early silver type sets under construction. This piece would also fit in nicely for those seeking premium Mint State halves. Unfortunately, the GFRC images are unable to accurately illustrate the granular frosted luster that actively interacts with the rose-gold and peripheral blue shades. Angled lighting further exposes the vibrant cartwheel action. As also expected from a gem graded 66+, the strike is all there. The darker thin lines in the right obverse field are toning lines. CAC has approved and graded 78 in all grades, not a surprise given the high mintage. At the offer grade, 14 have been approved with 3 finer. The PCGS MS66+ grade is well represented by this example and then some. Yet another superb find by the Osprey Collection. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2023) holder.
Seated 50C 1877 Seated 1877
MS66+
PCGS
82248342

Gem $6700 New April 24! Gem Original, Oregon Beaver Collection.. Consignor Price Reduction - Booming, frosty luster flows from the glass-smooth surfaces of this GFRC-rated Gem example. Centers are untoned and lead toward russet patina that intensifies at the rims. This is the preferred “look” of many collectors, as the brilliant silver color in the central devices contrasts with evolving shades in the fields. The toning scheme on both sides is virtually identical, a characteristic associated with originally preserved pieces. Star centers are well defined, while most of the claws exhibit separation if faintly so. The CAC census includes 75 pieces total, with only three coins finer, all in MS67. PCGS counts but four pieces at the MS67 level, reinforcing the rarity of this issue in the highest grades. The CAC price guide value is $7,500, while PCGS quotes $8,000. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
Seated 50C 1877 Seated 1877
MS66+
PCGS
16134761
-
Gem $7250 Gem Original, Newtown Collection.. Flashy, ice-white frost blankets the central devices, leading toward concentrated mauve and blue-green patina at the rims. Stars and claws are sharp while some detail beneath the eagle is weak, which is due to polished dies rather than a soft strike. An oft-repeated technical point, which is applicable here, is that the lowest point on the coin is the highest point on the die. A couple bag marks are evident at the left shoulder, but the first and best impression is the ample luster. CAC records 87 coins total, 14 examples in MS66, and three pieces finer, all in MS67. The CAC price guide value is $7,500, advancing to $12,000 in MS67. Ex. Heritage (July 2022, lot 3737), realized $6,120, an informed purchase given the advanced placement in the condition census. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #6355.
Seated 50C 1877S Seated 1877-S
MS66+
PCGS
36782849
WB-32
Gem $6750 Gem Original, Newtown Collection.. The Newtown consignor consistently hits the sweet spot in the value profile, with exceptional pieces that are near finest known examples, but at a fraction of the price. CAC has certified 130 coins in all grades, including eight examples in MS66, one piece in MS66+, and a single example finer, in MS67. The CAC price guide value is $4,750 in MS66, rising to $11,000 in MS67 (CAC does not price plus grades). The MS67 coin is in the D. L. Hansen collection and not likely to appear anytime soon, leaving a handful of pieces in the MS66 grades. This coin exhibits original, medium skin, with mixed russet and silver color in the centers and scattered charcoal patina in the stars and legend. Frosty luster is consistent with the technical grade. WB-31, with a diagonal die line through W(E). This is the Type II reverse, with closed bud. Well struck, with most of the claw detail evident. Ex. Great Collections (March 2020), at $6,750. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #6357.
Seated 50C 1885 Seated 1885
MS65
PCGS
41344564

Gem $5750 Gem Original, Newtown Collection.. This is a piece that has to be seen in-hand to fully appreciate the deeply original surfaces and swirling cartwheels. Medium to thick rose skin covers both sides and leads toward blue crescents at the rims. The frosty luster is fully Gem and further highlights the old-time color of this low-mintage example. Star centers are completely delineated, while a few of the claw joints meld as one. CAC has approved 28 pieces in all grades, with three coins finer. The CAC guide price is $6,000, a reasonable level for a near-finest known example. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2022) holder with CAC approval.
Barber 50C 1894S Barber 1894-S
AU58
CACG
898449091

Choice HOLD
$850
New March 28! Superb Preservation, Steely Fields, Light Gray Patination. If strictly originality is your overriding collecting goal, then this newly acquired 1894-S Barber half warrants close inspection and contemplation. Bright light inspection reveals steely fields and corresponding reflectance on both sides. A light dirty gray patination screams originality. A nearly complete strike is also noted with only the center reverse exhibiting weakness at the upper right shield and wing interface. Ideal at the certified AU58 grade for selective collectors. CAC has approved 36 in all grades while CACG has certified 9 in total. Housed in new CACG holder and graded to strict standards employed for CAC stickering approval. The label captures the Rev Dr. James G.K. McClure pedigree.
Barber 50C 1906 Barber 1906
MS64+
PCGS
39503931

Gem $1625 Gem Eye Appeal, Brilliant Frosted Luster, Dancing Cartwheels, Peripheral Toning, CAC Approval. GFRC Price Reduction. If searching for a gem 1906 Barber half in better Mint State grades, this new offering warrants close review and consideration. This piece was added to inventory for its overall eye appeal driven by brilliant frosted luster, dancing cartwheels, and light peripheral gold and copper shading. Surfaces are essentially unabraded with the (+) grade degrade for faint luster breaks on the lower neck. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
Barber 50C 1908 Barber 1908
AU55
PCGS
43029337

Choice $595 Choice Original, Ex. Blackpoint Collection. Consignor Buyout - Price Reduction. Emerald and sea-green patina fills both sides of this Philadelphia piece, along with crusty bits scattered on both sides. The survival of higher-grade business strikes of this era was somewhat a matter of chance, as most collectors of the period preferred to assemble runs of proof examples, which were sold by the Mint for a minimal markup. Conversely, the Mint today views the annual proof set as an opportunity to extract increasing sums from the collecting public. GFRC humbly suggests that classic coins such as the present example might represent a better collecting value. CAC notes 47 pieces in all grades, with a price guide value of $515 in AU55. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2023) holder with CAC approval.
Barber 50C 1909 Barber 1909
MS64
NGC
3572904007

Choice $1550 Creamy Frosted Luster, Vibrant Cartwheels, Hints of Gold Toning, Accurately Graded. This 1909 Barber half is far from a rarity but certainly brings on the eye appeal for those building an advanced type set. Granular textured surfaces radiate creamy frosted luster that is consistent on both sides. Cartwheels are active as expected for the certified grade. Strike is complete with high relief eagle wingtips and fully defined tail feathers and claws. Tiny ebony specks in the upper right obverse attest to the strict originality. Another 2022 Fall NH Coin Expo purchased that belonged on the GFRC price list. Housed in newer NGC holder with edge view insert and CAC approval.
Barber 50C 1910S Barber 1910-S
AU55
PCGS
42520576

Choice $825 So Choice, Frosted Luster, Peripheral Gold, Pleasing in All Ways. How I wish that more Barber halves could possess the eye appeal of this attractive 1910-S example. Both sides offer tightly textured frosted luster under angled lighting. Toning is a dirty gold with darker shades at the peripheries. Strike is essentially complete. Overall, a coin that will please the serious fan of the largest Barber denomination. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 holder with CAC approval.
Walking Liberty 50C 1916D Walking Liberty 1916-D
MS65
PCGS
44394843

Gem $3250 First Year Denver Design Issue, Pretty Golden-Rose Shades, Gem Original. The 1916 Philadelphia and Denver struck Walking Liberty halves have comparable rarity in the higher Mint State grades. I could not resist adding this notable gem Denver example to inventory. A well frosted example with radiant luster and the expected cartwheels given a moderate golden patina that turns to rose closer to the peripheries. If luster and superb eye appeal are your cup of tea, this new offering might warrant a closer look. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2023) holder with CAC approval.
Walking Liberty 50C 1921D Walking Liberty 1921-D
VG10
PCGS
6616202015

Choice $700 Key Date, Natural Coin Gray, Choice Surfaces. The 1921-D and 1921-S are the unquestioned key dates within the Walking Liberty half dollar series. The 1921-D sports the lowest mintage of the series and is even rare in the lower circulated grades. GFRC located this perfectly original example at the Summer Baltimore show for inventory. One can never have enough 1921-D example in inventory, right? Surfaces are toned a natural coin gray. Housed in new large font NGC holder with CAC approval.
Early Commems 50c 1925 Early Commems 1925
MS64
PCGS
11842392

Choice $200 Lexington-Concord Sesquicentennial, Near-Gem Original, Well Preserved. The 1925 "Lexington" issue commemorates two famous battles fought during 1775 with a Minuteman on the obverse and the Old Beltry at Lexington on the reverse. This near-gem example is very well preserved and quite pleasing. Rich granular frosted luster is consistent on both sides. Golden hues are more predominant on the obverse. Surfaces are pristine. A superior example. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval.
Early Commems 50C 1925S Early Commems 1925-S
MS65
PCGS
83285036

Gem $1250 New April 16! California Diamond Jubilee, Gem Original, Evergreen State Collection. Another highlight of the Evergreen State Silver Commemorative collection, this 1925-S California strike is an unquestionably gem with the typical granular frosted luster that originates from unmolested surfaces. Under a bright light, the obverse exhibits bisected toning with orange hues on the lower right hand side with the balanced being subtle blues. The upper reverse is also toned with the same orange shades though with a lighter presentation. The CAC guide indicates $1200 as fair market value. An indeed candidate for an advanced early silver commem set. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
Walking Liberty 50C 1934S Walking Liberty 1934-S
MS63
PCGS
12860733

Choice $1300 Choice Original, Sheffield Collection.. The run of "rare" San Francisco dates in Mint State concludes with the 1934-S issue. This date is nearly as rare as the 1833-S which is also offered by the Sheffield consignor in our Two Fine Gentlemen auction event. Pastel yellow-blue, aquamarine, and gold are overlaid on frosted surfaces with the obverse toning being denser. Regardless, the frosted radiance is substantial under angled lighting while the cartwheels are equally vibrant. Strike is complete with fully formed vertical skirt lines, outreached hand, and Liberty's cap. With a 10x, a few scattered micro-ticks are noted but of no consequence. Only 11 examples have been CAC approved at the offer grade with 173 stickered in all grades. The CDN CAC guide is $1230 as reference. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2024) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #6594
Early Commems 50C 1935 Early Commems 1935
MS65
PCGS
21913934

Gem $1100 New April 16! Hudson, New York Sesquicentennial, Rich Mint Bloom, Solid Gem, Evergreen State Collection. The Hudson, as it is fondly called, is a silver commem issued during 1935 that marked the 150th anniversary of the founding of Hudson, New York. Named after the explorer Henry Hudson, 25,265 pieces were struck. The reverse flagship, the Half Moon, reminds me of the 1892-1893 Columbian reverse given the commonality of early sailing ship designs. This example warrants its CAC green bean as perfectly original. A thick mint bloom, which coats both sides, scream originality. Active cartwheels are noted under a bright light. "Creamy" is the appropriate term for the radiance. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.3 (2004) holder with CAC approval.
Early Commems 50C 1936 Early Commems 1936
MS66+
PCGS
46734685

Gem $1300 New April 16! Gettysburg, Exceptional Gem, Evergreen State Collection. The Battle of Gettysburg Anniversary commemorative design is truly special with images of Union and Confederate veterans as prepared by Frank Vittor. Mintage was a reasonable 26,928. This super gem survivor radiates brilliant frosted luster and exceptional overall eye appeal. This piece completely stands out in the new consigned Evergreen State Collection and warrants a JUST BUY IT NOW presentation. Under a bright light, the wide borders have acquired a light golden patina which further adds to the charm. The CAC guide indicates $1000 as fair market value at the MS66 level jumping to $1850 in full MS67. Talk to me if you wish to own this marvelous gem. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2025) holder with CAC approval.
Early Commems 50C 1936 Early Commems 1936
MS66
PCGS
19338641

Gem $245 New April 22! Cleveland Centennial, Brilliant Frosted Lsuter, Gem Original, Pikes Peak Collection. A special commemorative issue that marked the centennial celebration of Cleveland, Ohio which took place at the Great Lakes Exposition held during 1936. This issue is often seen with superior surfaces and thick brilliant frosted luster as is the case with this Pikes Peak Collection release. A superb gem is every regards. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval.
Early Commems 50C 1936 Early Commems 1936
MS64
PCGS OGH
9658039

Choice $190 New April 22! Arkansas Centennial, Brilliant Mint Luster, Near Gem Original, Pikes Peak Collection. The commemorative issue marked the 100th anniversary of the admission of Arkansas in the Union. Issue from 1935 through 1939 with all three mints involved in the strikings. This superior example, from the Pikes Peak Collection, exhibits brilliant frosted luster from essentially untoned surfaces. A quality example for the discriminating collector. Housed in PCGS Gen 3.1 (1993-1998) holder with CAC approval.
Early Commems 50C 1936S Early Commems 1936-S
MS67
PCGS
44822414

Gem $575 New April 19! Columbia SC, Sesquicentennial, Superb Preservation State, Evergreen State Collection. Souvenir half dollars helped finance the celebrations marking the sesquicentennial of the founding of Columbia SC in 1786. This commemorative was struck at all three mints and offered in sets. The mintage is reported at 8,007, a low number as compared to present day standards. The Evergreen State Collection has released this notably well preserved gem with its granular frosted finish and just a touch of golden toning at the peripheries. Surfaces are entirely pristine with boldly struck devices. This piece is the epitome of originality and warrants placement in another advanced early silver commemorative set being assembled. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2025) holder with CAC approval.
Walking Liberty 50C 1937D Walking Liberty 1937-D
MS65
PCGS
32694671

Gem $865 Brilliant Frosted Luster, Gem Original.. GFRC Buyback, Price Reduction. The 1937-D and 1937-S Walking Liberty dates are equally scarce in Mint State with mintages of 1,676,000 and 2,090,000. Truly original and undipped examples are scarce in full gem based on CAC approval rates. CAC has approved 103 Denver strikes at the MS65 grade. This example screams originality with its brilliant frosted luster and faint copper-gold toning. Bright light exposure releases frosted luster and vibrant cartwheels. Strike is nearly complete with just a touch of definition weakness at the thumb. Surfaces are pristine with some die polished lines seen during 10x review. A classic gem that warranted close scrutiny. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #6602
Walking Liberty 50C 1938 Walking Liberty 1938
MS66+
NGC
6604045003

Gem $850 Gem Original, Cumberland County Collection.. This gorgeous 1938 half offers brilliant frosted luster and swirling cartwheels under a bright light. A fully struck specimen with deeply impress skirt lines, a high relief outreached hand and head that will please the most stringent strike fanatics. The pristine surfaces beg the question of why this "CCC" lot not certified to the next level. This is a compelling offering that warrants several bids to locate a suitable pricing level. CAC price guide is $685 at MS66 with an increase to $2250 in "7". Housed in new large font holder with CAC approval. PCGS #6604
Walking Liberty 50C 1938D Walking Liberty 1938-D
MS66+
NGC
6819810005

Gem $2635 A Gem "Luster Bomb", Lakeland Collection. Consignor Pricing Reduction. If assembling a top end Walking Liberty half dollar collection, this 1938-D example need immediately consideration. Simply stated, this is a gem "luster bomb" that drips frosted radiance under lighting. The strike is 100% complete with deeply impressed vertical skirt lines and a complete right facing hand. Under a 10x, the obverse fields are striated with that polishing also seen on the reverse but to a lessor degree. I've got to give this lot a JUST BUY IT NOW recommendation. The CAC price guide indicates $2700 at the certified grade. Our offer price for an MS66+ is more than fair. Housed in new large font NGC holder with CAC approval.
Early Commems 50C 1938 Early Commems 1938
MS64
NGC
610876002

Gem $495 New April 22! Daniel Boone Bicentennial, Heavily Frosted, Gem Original, Pikes Peak Collection. The Daniel Boone Centennial silver commem was issue for five year, starting in 1934, with all three mints striking the 1935 to 1938 dates. The Pikes Peak release is quite impressive given its rich mint bloom and resulting frosted luster under a bright light. A superior example that readily deserves its green bean. A limited mintage of 2,100 pieces further adds to the allure. Housed in NGC Gen 9 (2001-2003) holder with CAC approval.
Walking Liberty 50C 1939 Walking Liberty 1939
PR67+
PCGS
38971245

Gem $2150 Gem Original Proof, Cumberland County Collection.. The "CCC" proof Walker procession continues with this immaculate gem 1939 example. Starting in 1939, proofs were more frequently saved and properly preserved leading to the quality level seen here. Surfaces are pristine behind a thin layer of toning that results in a lower contrast white appearance. Strike is also complete but not as sharp as the early "CCC" proof dates. For reference, the CDN CAC guide is $1240 jumping to $8250 in full "67". Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #6639.
Walking Liberty 50C 1939S Walking Liberty 1939-S
MS67
NGC
6819623003

Gem $1650 Gem Original, Cumberland County Collection.. This 1939-S "CCC" lot is yet another piece to secure the GFRC "luster bomb" designation given its deep sparkling radiance that is entirely undisturbed on both sides. Cartwheels are equally notable and enticing. The surfaces are fully pristine as expected for this grade level. Strike is bond with the thumb partially defined. An exceptional lot that perfectly balanced across GFRC's evaluation criteria. The CDN CAC suggests $1580 as fair value, but this lot warrants a strong reserve for it greatness. Housed in new large font NGC holder with CAC approval. PCGS #6608.
Walking Liberty 50C 1940 Walking Liberty 1940
PR65
PCGS
49742467

Gem HOLD
$675
Gem Original Proof, Sharply Reflective, Lightly Toned. 1940 Walking Liberty half dollar mintage increased to 11,279 rendering this date as a type coin or for those who are attempting a date set from 1936 through 1942. Interestingly, PCGS has yet to certify a single example as Cameo or Deep Cameo, probably due to how the dies were basined without highly mirrored fields. This FUN show purchase is typical of the issue with moderate mirrors and the appearance of a faint white toning. The fields are pristine consistent with the certified grade along with a complete strike including deeply impressed vertical skirt lines and fully defined lower right facing hand details. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
Walking Liberty 50C 1943D Walking Liberty 1943-D
MS67+
NGC
6275089002

Gem $1695 Brilliant Frosted Luster, Gem Original.. GFRC Buyback, Price Reduction. Approaching "perfection" best describes this superb gem 1943-D Walking Liberty half dollar. Creamy mint frost covers both sides along with faint gold patina that is a touch deeper at the rims. Thick frosted luster appears when placed under angled lighting along with vibrant cartwheels. Strike is hammered with all device details deeply impressed including the topmost skirt lines and thumb. Finally, the surfaces are pristine without tiny abrasions during 10x review. The certified MS67+ grade and CAC approval place this lot at the condition census as CAC has yet to approve a single MS68. Pricing a coin at this quality level is challenging. The PCGS price guide number at MS67+ is $2750 with auction records consistent with the reserve price. A superb gem for those building the finest registry sets. Housed in new large font NGC holder with CAC approval. PCGS #6619
Walking Liberty 50C 1946D Walking Liberty 1946-D
MS66
PCGS
45845896

Gem $220 New April 20! Tradition Super Gem Eye Appeal, Rich Mint Bloom, Pikes Peak Collection. The current Pikes Peak Collection release offers two 1946-D halves with completely different personalities. This example is a traditional gem with rich frosted luster and light gold on the obverse and subtle blues on the reverse. A bold strike is noted with complete vertical skirt lines. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2025) holder with CAC approval.
Walking Liberty 50C 1946D Walking Liberty 1946-D
MS65
NGC
330349007

Gem HOLD
$160
New April 20! Sparkling Frosted Luster, Gem Original, Pikes Peak Collection. A gorgeous 1946-D Walker that offers sparkling frosted luster with peripheral gold borders. Though a common date, the eye appeal is spectacular and far from common with a JUST BUYT IT NOW recommendation warranted. Housed in NGC Gen 5 (1992-1995) holder with CAC approval.
Franklin 50C 1958D Franklin 1958-D
MS66
NGC
2028019092

Gem $110 Rainbow Toned Obverse, Gem Original, Bart Chapman Collection.. Consignor Price Reduction. Bart's passion for beautifully toned silver coinage also extended into the 20th century. This Franklin half perfectly fits into his collection due to the natural rose-gold toning that transitions to greens and gold at the upper obverse. Luster is frosted brilliant which further enhanced the bright light viewing experience. This is a lot of coin at a reasonable opening reserve. Housed in newer NGC holder with edge view insert and CAC approval.
1 Dollar
Draped Bust $1 1800 Draped Bust 1800
AMERICAI
VF30
CACG
374176870
BB-192
Gem $4850 AMERICAI Die Variety, Natural Coin Gray, Gem at Grade. The popular 1800 "AMERICAI" variety consists of a die defect that appears as the letter "I" immediately following the legend AMERICA on the reverse. The AMERICAI die flaw is considered a major variety in the Bust Dollar series, as it is visible to the naked eye. Two obverse dies are paired with this reverse die and listed as BB-191 and BB-192. GFRC is pleased to be offering a superbly preserved specimen that is housed in a CAC Grading holder and graded consistent with CAC approval standards. Images were captured from cellphone rather than traditional GFRC Nikon Coolpix 995 photography and accurately illustrated the gem condition at the VF30 certified grade. Unabraded steely surfaces are noted under a bright light. The obverse strike is complete on the left with start points along with a well defined reverse. This Draped Bust dollar is on of the nicest handled by GFRC with just the right amount of light crust. Immediately available.
Trade $1 1875S Trade 1875-S
AU53
PCGS
20623476

Choice HOLD
$675
New April 20! Perfectly Original and Choice, Steely Reflectance, Pikes Peak Collection. The 1875-S Trade dollar is recognized for having a high mintage of 4,487,000 and is ideal as a type coin given a lack of date premium. This lightly worn example is well preserved with steely fields overlaid with grayish-gold coloration. The presentation is consistent on both sides with soft radiance under a bright light. The originality is quite compelling with a fair offer price. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval.
Morgan $1 18788TF Morgan 1878-8TF
MS65
PCGS
46283806

Gem $3250 Scarce in Full Gem, Mirrored Fields, Gorgeous Toning, First Class Eye Appeal. For those not intimate with the Morgan dollar series, the 8 Tail Feather variant was a hub die error as eagles do not have 8 tail feathers. Only 3/4 of a million were struck with the date being scarce in full gem. This Summer Baltimore new purchase certainly qualifies as a notable gem given the mirrored fields, sharp reflective luster, and gorgeous toning. The bright light visuals are eye catching including swirling cartwheels. If in the market for a truly special first year Morgan strike, please give this gem toner special attention. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2023) holder with CAC approval.
Morgan $1 18788TF Morgan 1878-8TF
MS64
PCGS OGH
6489191

Choice $815 Near-Gem Original, Natural Frosted Luster, Well Preserved, Scenic Lakeview Collection. Consignor Price Reduction - This first 1878 Morgan dollar issues comes with the 8 Tail Feather reverse which is ornithologic impossible as bald eagles have 7 tail feathers. Mintage with the erroneous reverse amount to 750,000 before the 7 tail feather reverse was introduced into production. This survivor sports natural frosted luster with faint gold coloration that is synonymous with strict originality. Surfaces are essentially unabraded with a single contact mark at the junction of Liberty's jaw and neck. An excellent example for type with that all important green bean. Housed in PCGS Gen 3.0 (1990=1993) old green holder with CAC approval.
Morgan $1 1878S Morgan 1878-S
MS64
PCGS
37833000

Choice $425 Dual Sided Toning, Brilliant Frosted Luster, Swirling Cartwheels, Perfectly Original. Since starting the GFRC business, there has always been an affinity for toner Morgans. Over time, I've been hand selecting CAC approved toners with coloration that is consistent with originality expectations. Let's face it, there are ample amounts of retoned Morgans out in the market with what I consider to be unnatural colors. This 1878-S example offers the classic obverse aquamarine, copper-gold, and blues on the obverse and delineated green and copper-gold on the reverse that could have paper origins. Accurately graded with brilliant frosted luster and swirling cartwheels. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
Trade $1 1878S Trade 1878-S
EF45
CACG
466142799

Gem HOLD
$725
New April 26! Superb Gem, 100% Natural Surfaces, Poor Man's Collection. Typical of the Poor Man's Collection consignments, this 1878-S Trade dollar is one of the finest at the EF45 grade that I've handled. There is no question that CACG has the knack for identifying some of the best preserved coins within the numismatic market. This piece warrants an immediately JUST BUY IT NOW call out! Housed in new CAC Grading holder and graded consistent with CAC approval standards.
Morgan $1 1880S Morgan 1880-S
MS65PL
PCGS OGH
9385506

Gem $465 Fully Prooflike, Brilliant Reflectance, Swirling Cartwheels, Superb Eye Appeal.. Swirling cartwheels are difficult to miss when placing this gorgeous 1880-S Morgan under a bright light. The fields are sharply mirrored with few abrasions, a difficult feat to achieve given the mirrored fields that amplify any imperfections. This lot appears way better in-hand than as illustrated by GFRC images. Housed in PCGS Gen 3.0 (1990-1993) old green label holder with CAC approval. Please note that the old holder has plastic haze between Liberty's chin and stars 1 and 2 that clouds the presentation.
Morgan $1 1880S Morgan 1880-S
MS66
CACG
253897991

Gem $425 Superb Gem, Partially Mirrored, Spinning Cartwheels, Super Eye Appeal, Gerry Fortin Collection. This superb gem 1880-S Morgan is just back from CACG grading after residing in my bank box since 1989. The fields are mirrored, as many are found of this date. Brilliant reflectance is must pleasing while the cartwheels are a spinning thrill under a bright light. The cheek is pristine consistent with the certified grade. The peripheral toning augments the overall eye appeal. Housed in new CAC Grading (2023) holder and graded consistent with CAC approval standards.
Morgan $1 1880S Morgan 1880-S
64Star
NGC
4266023004

Gem $400 Partially Mirrored, Brilliant Reflective Luster, Swirling Cartwheels, Gem Eye Appeal. This 1880-S Star rated Morgan is an unquestionable gem with exceptional eye appeal. Both NGC and CAC have certifications have noted this fact. This is one of those "wow" coins that will be a prize in a type set or a regular Morgan dollar set. It is more than appropriate to issue a JUST BUY IT NOW recommendation to do this coin justice. Housed in newer NGC holder with edge view insert and fresh CAC approval. Previously sold by GFRC October 2021 and back to the price list at the prior sale price.
Morgan $1 1886S Morgan 1886-S
AU55
PCGS
46903364

Choice $395 Low Mintage San Francisco Date, Golden-Gray Frosted Luster, Swirling Cartwheels, CAC Approval. Faint golden-gray obverse patina is transparent to the underlying steely luster on this lightly circulated 1886-S Morgan. The reserve patina is deeper with the same obverse hues. This color consistency validates the originality. The low 750,000 piece mintage has made this a popular date since the B. Max Mehl auction sales of the early 20th century. This date remains scarce as few were found in the 1982-1964 Treasury bag release. A notable example with much character that is sure to please the new owner. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2023) holder with CAC approval.
Morgan $1 1891S Morgan 1891-S
AU58
CACG
947413357

Choice $140 New April 20! Strict Originality, Choice Surfaces, Pikes Peak Collection. A bit better San Francisco date with light gray patination and a hint of rub. This Pike Peak Collection release is the epitome of an unmolsted Morgan dollar with ample frosted radiance. Housed in new CAC Grading holder and graded consistent with CAC approval standards.
Morgan $1 1893CC Morgan 1893-CC
AU58
CACG
166763855

Choice $6500 Morgan Key Date, Frosted Luster, Cheek Rub, Strict Originality. GFRC is proud to be offering a key date 1893-CC Morgan freshly graded by CAC Grading. This piece exhibits steely-frosted radiance and vibrant cartwheels. Light rub is seen on Liberty cheek along with two minor blemishes of no consequence. The strict originality is validated by traces of gold patina throughout the reverse and extends into the obverse. My images have enhanced the bluish shades while the CAC Grading images amplify the golden hues. An important lot that will draw considerable attention by the host of Morgan collectors who aspire to own CAC approved pieces in their collection. Housed in a new CAC Grading (2023) holder and graded consistent with CAC approval standards.
Morgan $1 1893O Morgan 1893-O
MS61
PCGS
36276435

Choice $6875 New March 24! Key Date, Rare Grade, Frosted Luster, Swirling Cartwheels, Choice Overall, Scenic Lakeview Collection. Consignor Price Reduction - The 1893-O dollar is the lowest mintage New Orleans Morgan dollar as only 300,000 piece were struck. Survivors are scarce in all grades while this key date becomes rare in Mint State with CAC approval. This offered example presents frosted luster and swirling cartwheels when view under a bright light. Accurately graded as the abrasions are concentrated on the obverse at the cheek. The reverse image lacks some definition due to holder haze. CAC has approved a total of 373 in all grades with the majority being circulated. Only 10 have been approved at the certified grade, a small number given the widespread demand for Morgan dollars. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
Morgan $1 1897S Morgan 1897-S
AU58
PCGS
49756201

Choice $145 New April 27! Mirrored Fields, Golden Overlays, Choice Original, Pikes Peak Collection. This 1897-S Morgan warrants consideration due to nicely mirrored fields that are boldly reflective under a bright light. The cartwheels are equally pleasing. Worthy of a GFRC Near-Gem quality rating with only mid-right obverse field wear holding back a full Gem assignment. Let's go with a JUST BUY IT NOW recommendation to make the point. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2025) holder with CAC approval.
Morgan $1 1898S Morgan 1898-S
AU58
PCGS
47531318

Choice $525 Attractive Slider, Steely Radiance, Vibrant Cartwheels, Light Gold Patina. Another better San Francisco strike that has been carefully handled with limited rub on the cheek. Under the desk lamp, steely radiance is noted along with swirling cartwheels. The cheek is unblemished and pleasing. A well balance Morgan that is worthy of a CAC only collection. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2023) holder with CAC approval.
Morgan $1 1899O Morgan 1899-O
MS67
PCGS
43342737

Gem $3400 Stunning Eye Appeal, Gorgeous Frosted Luster, Peripheral Gold, A Superb Gem, Scenic Lakeview Collection. Consignor Price Reduction - Fresh CAC approval! Though 1899 New Orleans strikes will be found with proof like and deep cameo proof like surfaces, this gorgeous example is just the opposite. This superb gem is covered with granular mint frost that is continuous and entirely undisturbed. Creamy frosted luster radiates from both sides when placed under angled lighting. Peripheral gold adds incremental character. PCGS has certified 235 at grade with this example being on the top quartile for certain. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2023) holder with CAC approval.
Morgan $1 1900S Morgan 1900-S
MS62
PCGS
47531320

Choice $745 Steely Fields, Swirling Cartwheels, Treasury Release?. Steely fields offer brilliant radiance on this 1900 San Francisco struck Morgan that was probably part of the ongoing Treasury releases that culminated in multiple bags arriving to the market during the early 1960s. This is unquestionably choice with steely radiance and swirling cartwheels. Obverse chatter, consistent with bag storage, is accurately captured by the assigned grade. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2023) holder with CAC approval.
Morgan $1 1902O Morgan 1902-O
MS65
NGC
4305484010

Gem $345 Noteworthy Eye Appeal, Granular Frosted Luster. Swirling Cartwheels, A Gem Two-Sided Toner. This gem rated 1902-O Morgan provides a pleasant viewing experience given its granular frosted luster and swirling cartwheels. Both sides are bathed with intermixed aquamarine, and golden hues. Under a bright light, the cartwheel action is self evident and eye catching. The CAC price guide for a "regular" MS65 stickered example is $310 as reference. Housed in new large font NGC holder with CAC approval.
Morgan $1 1902S Morgan 1902-S
MS63
PCGS
1463388

$1275 Superb Original Toning, Frosted Luster, Accurately Grade, CAC Approval. Light copper-gold and peripheral obverse blues provide for an above average viewing experience as compared to omnipresent frosty white examples. Frosted luster has a light granular texture while the cartwheels become vibrant under a bright light. This piece is accurately graded given the contact points on the lower neck. However, this is an eye appeal play for those who love their Morgans with colorful original skins. A better late date San Francisco strike with lots of character. Housed in PCGS Gen 3.1 (1993-1998) old green holder with CAC approval.
Peace $1 1927 Peace 1927
MS64+
PCGS
45455779

Choice $865 Steely Radiance, Swirling Cartwheels, CAC Approved, Scenic Lakeview Collection. Consignor Price Reduction - This 1927 Philadelphia strike has the right "pizazz" under a bright light as the steely luster is notable and welcomed. Also important with any large Mint State silver piece are the swirling cartwheels which this piece excels at. The obverse center strike is partial as is typical of the issue. Under a loupe and lamp, the lower obverse toning spots present golden hues. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2024) holder with CAC approval.
Gold
Gold G$1 1857
Type 3 Indian Princess
AU53
NGC
5853109002

Choice $525 New April 19! Choice Original, Honey-Gold Coloration, CAC Approval, Pikes Peak Collection. Tough as a date, the 1857 is one of the common gold dollars and is ideal for a gold type set and the Type 3 Indian Princess slot. This Peaks Pike example was original source from GFRC given its well preserved surfaces layered with classic honey green-gold patination. The residual luster is quite impressive under a bright light. Housed in new large font NGC holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$1 1862
Type 3 Indian Princess
MS63
PCGS
08616965

Choice $950 Rich Honey Green-Gold, Frosty Luster, Ideal for Date Set, CAC Approved. Rich honey-gold coloration is consistent on both sides of this 1862 Type 3 Indian Princess. Bright light exposure activities thick frosted luster and moderate cartwheels, an important feat for such a small coin. The strike is complete with the usual haloing on the lower reverse. A few hairlines are noted in the left obverse field which lines up with the technical grade. During in-hand viewing, this appearance is that of a higher grade. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$1 1872
Type 3 Indian Princess
MS63
PCGS
37721658

Choice $3250 Rare Low Mintage Issue, Partially Mirrored, Yellow-Gold, A Near-Gem, CAC Approved. A top quality 1872 Type 3 gold piece that is consistently difficult to acquire by gold dollar collectors. A rare date when fully choice given the low mintage of only 3,500. This new acquisition is fully struck with deeply impressed motifs, partially mirrored fields, and an overall yellow-gold coloration. David Akers opines that, "The 1872 is one of my favorite dates in the gold dollar series. Except for the 1875, it is the scarcest date after 1870 and is really very rare in choice condition." The rarity is easily corroborated by checking the CAC census with only 17 approved in all grades. The CAC price guide stands at $3,300 at the offered graded and jumps to $4,500 at the MS64 level. A compelling offering for those assembling a $1 gold set. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$1 1887
Type 3 Indian Princess
MS63
PCGS
45322083

Choice $950 New April 5! Choice Original, Island City Collection.. GFRC Client Buyout and Price Reduction - Frosty yellow-gold surfaces reveal hints of rose patina and scattered bits of red-copper color. Most one-dollar pieces of this decade migrated quickly into collector hands, and high-grade survivors are the rule. As a result, highly lustrous and completely detailed examples, such as the present coin, are available to today’s collector at reasonable price points. CAC has certified 119 coins total, with 101 pieces finer. The CAC price guide value is $1,100 in MS63. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2023) holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$10 1881-O
Liberty
EF45
CACG
306392274

Choice HOLD
$4150
Underappreciated Low Mintage New Orleans Issue, Circulated Copper Green-Gold, Strict CACG Grading. Only 8,350 $10 gold pieces were struck during 1881 at the New Orleans mint. This is an underappreciated, low mintage date with a peak population at the EF grade level per the PCGS price guide. Looking at the CAC guide the census is 32 with seven in EF. Pricing premium escalate quickly in AU with hand full in Mint State. This 2025 FUN show acquisition is well preserved with coppery green-gold coloration and residual steely reflectance under angled lighting. The fields are minimally abraded given the time in circulation. Fully choice and guaranteed to please the new owner. Housed in new CACG holder and graded to strict standards employed for CAC stickering approval.
Gold G$10 1884-S
Liberty
MS63
PCGS
44552728

Choice $5650 New March 7! Condition Rarity, Tied Finest at CAC, Frosted Luster, Honey Green-Gold. This newly consigned 1884 San Francisco struck $10 Liberty gold piece warrants attention for its grade rarity and pleasing eye appeal. Mintage for the date is 124,250 with few survivors being sufficiently choice to secure a CAC green bean. Only 25 pieces have been approved with this offering being tied for finest along with two other examples, indicating that the mintage was mishandled with surfaces marks being the rule. The overall presentation is dominated by frosted luster and honey green-gold coloration. Vibrant cartwheels are noted with angled lighting. The strike is fully executed while light chatter in noted consistent with the certified grade. The CAC price guide suggests $6,250 as fair market value for reference. An important opportunity to secure a finest known $10 gold Liberty piece at an attractive price. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$10 1898
Liberty
MS64+
PCGS
45595744

Choice $3650 So Close to Gem, Honey-Gold, Sparkling Frosted Luster. What a surprise when reviewing the CDN CAC guide and population reports. 1898 Philadelphia $10 gold could be considered a better date as only 60 have been approved in all grades versus a mintage of 812,130. This newly consigned example is approaching the condition census given its noteworthy preservation. Coloration is the typical honey-gold while the surfaces are covered with micro-textured mint frost. The resulting luster is brilliant with commensurate charwheels. Two scattered obverse ticks are consistent with the (+) certified grade rather than full gem. CAC guide jumps to $8750 at the MS65 grade. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2022) holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$10 1899
Liberty
MS61
PCGS
3300457

Choice HOLD
$1725
Orange Green-Gold, Granular Frosted Luster, Well Struck, CAC Approved. A top notch quality 1899 $10 eagle return to the price list after time in a Maine collection. Let's start with the fact that the eye appeal is that of a higher grade with rich orange green-gold colors and granular frosted luster. A 10x review found some field chatter and a faint mark on the cheek that fits with the conservative grading of the mid-1990s. Fully choice and certain to please the new owner. Housed in PCGS Gen 3.1 (1993-1998) holder with CAC approval. Please note that the horizontal obverse lines are on the holder.
Gold G$10 1901-S
Liberty
MS65
PCGS
44282692

Gem $4600 High End Type Possibility, Repunched 1, Granular Frosted Luster, Pretty Honey-Gold, Osprey Collection. Consignor Price Reduction. 1901 San Francisco strikes are consider to be a "common date" and an ideal selection for type given adequate availability. This newly consigned Osprey Collection specimen is an unquestionable gem with micro-granular frosted luster and honey-gold coloration. Strike is fully executed. The 1 diigt is obviously repunched at the base though PCGS does not list as a recognized die variety. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$10 1932
Indian
MS65
NGC
259246001

Gem $6200 Gem Original, Osprey Collection.. Consignor Price Reduction. Indian tens are among the favorite gold coins in the U.S. series, with relatively uncluttered designs that exhibit arresting iconography. A sweeping headdress graces the figure of Liberty, while a fierce eagle proclaims the unity of the country and its strength in the Almighty. Clearly, America is not to be messed with. This example features warm yellow patina, and the luster easily qualifies for the Gem uncirculated designation. The CAC price guide is $7,000 in MS65, with a strong jump to $21,900 at MS66. Housed in pristine NGC Gen 5 (1992-1995) holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$2.5 1854-O
Liberty
EF45
NGC
3891583012

Choice $1150 Classic Copper-Green Gold, Well Preserved, CAC Approved. 1854 brought the distinction of the $2.5 gold denomination being struck at all five mints of that era. The Dahlonega and San Francisco issues are brutally difficult to locate while the Charlotte is not far behind in rarity. This leaves the New Orleans issue as being available for branch mint collectors. Though the mintage is only 153,000, the date is seen with some frequency. This new GFRC offering is readily noted for its classic copper-green gold coloration and smooth surfaces. The circulated eye appeal is all there and pleasing. Housed in NGC Gen 17 holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$2.5 1857
Liberty
AU53
CACG
650219513

Choice $850 Challenging "Common Date", Choice Original, Honey-Green Gold, Fresh CACG Grading. 1857 Philadelphia struck $2.5 gold amounted to 214,130 pieces resulting in numismatic experts viewing the date as "common". However, when fully choice, this date is challenging given that CAC has stickered only 41 in all grades while CACG has holdered two examples, one of which is being offered here. The premium nature is unquestionable with well preserved surfaces that are every so lightly worn. Coloration is a traditional honey green-gold. The CAC price guide is $925 as reference. Perfect as a pre-Civil War era type piece and much more difficult that the 1852, 1853, and 1854 Philadelphia issues and even the 1854-O . Housed in new CAC Grading holder and graded consistent with CAC approval standards.
Gold G$2.5 1862
Liberty
AU58
NGC
3311124012

Choice $3650 Important Civil War Issue, Light Frosty Luster, Green-Gold Coloring, Pristine Surfaces. Consignor Price Reduction. An important Civil War era Liberty $2.5 gold offering that is challenging in all grades. Mintage was limited to 98,508 with question marks concerning the amount that was actually released into east coast circulation during a period when all silver and gold specie disappeared from commerce due to hoarding. This pristine 1862 survivor warrants close scrutiny for inclusion in an advanced $2.5 gold set. Surfaces scream originality with their natural green-gold coloring and light frosted texture. Surfaces are entirely unabraded and so pleasing with darker "dirt" in some protected areas. Strike is also complete. Housed in newer NGC holder with edge view insert and CAC approval.
Gold G$2.5 1868
Liberty
AU58
NGC
3386564002

Choice $2450 Low Mintage Philadelphia Date, Partially Mirrored, Rich Honey-Gold Coloration, Choice and Rare. CAC approval has unquestionably differentiated U.S. gold with strictly original example of the scarcer early dates having low census populations. Case in point in the 1868 $2.5 quarter eagle with a mintage of only 3,600. CAC has approved ten in all grades with seven at the AU58 level and a single MS62 certified example being finer. Offered today is one of the AU58s that is a real sweetheart. Let's start with partially mirrored fields on both sides and the sharp reflective luster that is activated under a bright light. The overall coloration is a pleasing rich honey-gold. The strike is 100% complete with finely detail center hair curls and eagle feathers at the wing tips. Two lines are noted in the lower right obverse field which are amplified against a mirrored surface backdrop. The CDN price guide is $1700 and jumps to $3250 at the "MS60" level. Housed in NGC 25 (2008) holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$2.5 1880
Liberty
AU58
NGC
3316954002

Gem $2500 Gem Original Offering, Yellow Gold, Partially Mirrored Fields, CAC approved. The 1880 $2.5 gold issue is yet another lower mintage later date that continues to be underrated in the current marketplace. With a mintage of 2,960, this date is scarce in all grades. I was compelled to reward this exceptional example with a GFRC-Gem quality tating. Maybe I am enchanted by the mirrored fields that exhibit sharp reflectance under a bright light. Also compelling is the complete strike and unabraded surfaces with light rub consistent with the certified grade. Coloration falls into the honey yellow-gold realm. The CAC census currently stands at 25 stickered with a CDN price guide number being quoted as $2,250. There is a 50% pricing premium at MS62. Housed in NGC 25 (2008) holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$2.5 1888
Liberty
MS65
NGC
3514764004

Gem $5250 Near Finest Known, Richly Frosted Gem, CAC Approved. Mintage for the 1888 $2.5 issue increased to 16,001 as compared to the limited five digit production of prior years. Survivors in the lower Mint State grades are readily available with the date become very scarce in full gem. GFRC is pleased to be offering a CAC approved specimen at the lofty MS65 grade with a single example finer. The CAC price guide lists $5,600 as fair market value for reference. This lot is a "luster bomb" with rich honey-gold mint bloom on both sides. Under a bright light, the frosted radiance and cartwheels are thoroughly pleasing. The peripheral strike is hammered with raised stars and elevated reverse legend though the eagle's left leg feathers are weakly defined. Worthy of careful consideration. Housed in newer NGC holder with edge view insert and CAC approval.
Gold G$2.5 1888
Liberty
MS64
NGC
4116837002

Gem $2100 Deeply Frosted Radiance, Honey Yellow-Gold, Gem Original, CAC Approved. The Liberty $2.5 gold series is replete with low mintage dates that would bring huge premiums if found in high demand smaller sliver denominations. This 1888 Philadelphia issue is an example with only 2,960 struck. The date is naturally scarce overall due to mintage though, in MInt State, the issue is available. Survivors with completely unmolested surfaces are always in demand. Offering here is a GFRC-Gem rated example with hammered strike and with deeply impressed device details. Under a bright light, the frosted radiance is brilliant and intense. Coloration falls into a honey yellow-gold spectrum. The CDN CAC price guide is $2,250 as reference. Housed in a new NGC holder with edge view insert and CAC approval.
Gold G$2.5 1888
Liberty
MS63
NGC
2572945003

Choice $1200 Rich Frosted Luster, Deep Honey-Gold, Choice Surfaces, CAC Approved. Another late date $2.5 Liberty gold release from an old time collection that warrants a JUST BUY IT NOW recommendation. Why? The thick frosted luster is thoroughly pleasing as is the classic honey-gold coloration. Under a bright light, the frosted radiance takes on a sparkling texture. This is a well preserved example with just a touch of obverse field chatter to the right of the hair curls that was captured in the certified grade. Otherwise, the visual presentation is that of a higher grade. The CAC census for the date currently stands at 67 stickered with 38 finer. Priced slightly below the CDN CAC price guide. Housed in NGC 25 (2008) holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$2.5 1894
Liberty
MS64
PCGS
48049929

Gem $4450 Very Scarce Low Mintage Date, Steely-Frosted Radiance, Light Honey Gold, Gem Original. Only 4,000 quarter eagles were struck during 1894 resulting in this date being quite scarce, especially with gem preservation. This example exhibits steely-frosted fields that are stunning under a bright light. The radiance is undisturbed with crisp reflectance. The strike is deeply impressed on both sides with high relief devices throughout. Coloration is a light honey green-gold with the baseline green hues appearing under a bright light. There are no surface abrasions worthy of mention. CAC has approved 33 in all grades with a price guide value currently listed as $4.500. This little gem is guaranteed to please the new owner. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2024) holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$2.5 1895
Liberty
MS64
PCGS
38596965

Choice $2530 Eye Appeal of Higher Grade, Near-Gem Original, Oregon Beaver Collection.. Consignor Price Reduction - Every coin that crosses the GFRC desk has its special characteristics. In the case of this near-gem 1895 $2.5 quarter eagle, brilliant luster and eye appeal are that of a higher grade. Obverse fields are lightly mirrored and offer reflective radiance. Reverse fields are frosted with corresponding bright light appearance. Overall luster was so intense that the standard contrast application, during GFRC image processing, was dampened to accurate capture visual effects. The assigned MS64 grade is a function of faint obverse chatter in the field and on the cheek. Frankly, the luster far outweighs any contact marks. Limited mintage of 6,000. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$2.5 1899
Liberty
MS63
PCGS
47029030

Choice $885 Glowing Satiny Luster, Honey-Gold, Choice Surfaces, Oregon Beaver Collection. The Oregon Beaver is releasing another tranche of duplicates with this lovely 1899 $2.5 gold piece being one of the value highlights. Placing this piece under a bright light releases glowing satiny luster that is consistent on both sides. So is the honey green-gold coloration that screams originality. The strike is complete with sharp wingtips and hair curls. The CAC census stands at 98 stickered with not a single piece in a CACG holder. At the offer grade, the CDN CAC guide is $885 as reference and the offer price. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2024) holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$2.5 1906
Liberty
MS63
PCGS
43773788

Choice $825 Rich Honey-Gold, Frosted Luminous, Near-Gem Original, Scenic Lakeview Collection. GFRC images should well convey the attractive nature of this 1906 $2.5 gold piece. Rich honey-gold is complemented by brilliant frosted luster. Part of the bright light routine is checking cartwheel action. This piece does just fine with nicely rotating reflectance. A few micro-ticks in front of the face holds this piece back from a GFRC-Gem quality rating. Fairly priced and worthy of a JUST BUY IT NOW recommendation for the overall quality. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2023) holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$2.5 1912
Indian
AU55
PCGS
26858271

Choice $650 Residual Satiny Luster, Honey Green-Goal, Light Wear, CAC Approved, Scenic Lakeview Collection. Satiny luster and pristine surfaces are the highlights of this near-gem quality rated 1912 $2.5 Indian. A green-gold coloration is consistent on both sides while the surfaces are close to pristine. Light wear is seen on the high points. The CAC green bean rewards the overall quality and eye appeal. Perfect for a type or date set collection. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.5 holder (20012-2013) holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$2.5 1914-D
Indian
MS63+
PCGS
83528297

Choice $2650 Scarce Indian $2.5 Issue, Steely-Satiny Radiance, Wonderful Eye Appeal, CAC Approved. With a limited mintage of 448,000 pieces, the 1914-D issue ranks as the third rarest within the $2.5 Indian gold series. Its scarcity is relative as there are still an ample amount of Mint State survivors. In these situations, collectors need to focus on procuring premium examples with bold luster and unquestionable originality. Such is the case for this newly consigned example. This is the first time that I use the term steely-satiny to describe a coin but it is fitting. The main center incused devices are satiny under a bright light while the surrounding fields have steely reflectance. Surfaces are essentially unabraded and more than consistent with the certified grade. Coloration is a consistent rich honey-gold. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$2.5 1925-D
Indian
MS60
NGC Fatty
179395024

Choice HOLD
$750
Popular Type Date, Honey Yellow-Gold, Steely Luster, Osprey Collection. During the early TPG days, the MS60 grade assignment was much more common that today. This new Osprey Collection offering is from that era and has been CAC approved since the grading is quite conservative. Steely luster is quite reflective under angled lighting. A combination of orange and yellow-gold are intermixed. This is a common type with no rarity premium and ideal for type. Housed in NGC Gen 4 no line brown label Fatty holder with CAC approval. Please note that the reverse plastic has a diagonal line and some type of glue residue that I'm unable to remove.
Gold G$2.5 1926
Indian
MS64+
PCGS
83884743

Gem $1250 Rich Honey Green-Gold, Satiny Luster, Gem Original, CAC Approved. The 1926 $2.5 Indian issue is well known for having the best eye appeal within the series per David Akers. This newly consigned example certain meets that standard with thick satiny luster and a hammered strikes. Coloration is a honey green-gold. The cheek is free of notable abrasions as are the fields. The offer price is consistent with the (+) certified grade while the coin itself is so close to full gem. This is a lot coin for the money and undoubtedly will please the new owner. Completely fresh to market from an old time collection. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$2.5 1926
Indian
MS63
NGC Fatty
246889004

Choice HOLD
$795
Inexpensive CAC Approved Type, Pristine Fatty Holder, Brilliant Satiny Luster, Honey-Gold. Shimmering satiny luster is quite eye catching when placing this Indian $2.5 under a bright light. Surfaces are essentially unabraded with a single contact mark on the cheek worthy of mention. This lovely gold piece is housed in a pristine NGC Gen 5 (1992-1995) no line brown label Fatty holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$2.5 1927
Indian
MS64+
PCGS
83884744

Gem HOLD
$1250
Thick Satiny Luster, Gem Eye Appeal, CAC Approved. A superb 1927 $2.5 Indian that offers rich satiny luster and uniform honey gold coloration. Under a bright light, this little gold piece has tantalizing satiny luster and the eye appeal of a full gem. 10x inspection notes a single contact mark on the check that probably corresponds with the (+) grade. If considering this lot, why not include one or more of the other 1926 through 1929 dates as so well matched. Completely fresh to market from an old time collection. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$2.5 1928
Indian
MS64
PCGS
83884750

Choice HOLD
$1050
Near-Gem Original, Steely Fields, Uniform Honey-Gold, CAC Approved. An impreessive 1928 $2.5 Indian gold piece with steely luster that becomes readily apparent under a bright light. Coloration is honey-gold with just a hint of green at the right angled lighting angle. The strike is bold with fully impressed bonnet feathers. A few faint contact marks within the obverse fields precluded a (+) grade as assigned to the balance of the this newly consigned lot. Visually pleasing and fits in well as a date run with the 1926 through 1929 lot being offered by our consignor. This lot is completely fresh to the market. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$2.5 1929
Indian
MS63
PCGS
46575372

Choice HOLD
$835
Ideal for Type, Honey Green-Gold, Satiny Luster, CAC Approval. I'm thoroughly enjoying the luster on this 1929 $2.5 Indian and believe you will too! Well preserved surfaces are colored a medium honey green-gold. The luster in intriguing as quite dense and with a satiny texture. A fine candidate for a Mint State gold type set. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2022) holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$20 1859-S
Liberty
AU50
CACG
866227227

Gem $4850 New March 29! Doubled Die Obverse. Rich Copper Orange-Gold, Gem Original, Island Lake Collection. This 1859 San Francisco struck Type 1 Liberty $20 gold piece is truly differentiated among its peers for multiple reasons. First is the dual sided finish with a mirrored obverse and brilliantly frosted reverse. Second is the deep orange-gold toning that is quite scarce for early $20 gold. Finally, this example is the Cherrypickers Double Die Obverse which is now listed separately in the PCGS and CACG price guides. Bold die doubling is visible on LIB(ERTY) and quite cool. The originality is unquestionable with nearly unabraded surfaces. A premium double eagle offering, from the Island Lake Collection, that warrants a JUST BUYIT NOW shout out. I've seen enough $20 gold to recognize a truly "differentiated" specimen. Housed in new CACG holder and graded to strict standards employed for CAC stickering approval. Doubled Die Obverse, FS-101 is listed on the label.
Gold G$20 1877
Liberty
MS61
PCGS
42653702

Choice $4600 Scarce Philadelphia Date, Small CAC Population, Brilliant Frosted Luster, Honey-Gold Coloration. GFRC Price Reduction. There are many surprises among the $20 Liberty double eagle gold dates. 1877 Philadelphia strikes might be considered to be a sleeper with CAC approval. From a mintage of 397,650, CAC has approved only 54 pieces in all grades. A scarce date that is heads and shoulders above the so-called common dates of that era. Premiums jump dramatically at the MS62 level with only two pieces at the full choice level. This premium example featured well balance eye appeal including brilliant frosted luster and vibrant cartwheels. Coloration is a uniform honey-gold. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2022) holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$20 1899-S
Liberty
MS63
PCGS
25287350

Choice $4750 New April 22! Attractive Honey-Gold, Partially Mirrored Radiance, Swirling Cartwheels, CAC Approved. With all the current attention on $20 U.S. gold due to a sharp increase is gold spot pricing to $3400, GFRC is thrilled to be offering a Near-Gem 1899 San Francisco struck Liberty with lightly mirrored fields and the corresponding reflective radiance. Both sides are equally mirrored as this lot was probably struck with freshly polished dies. Coloration is a deep honey gold. Bright light inspection was thoroughly pleasing as the view is undisturbed as the fields are surprising limited to just a touch of chatter. Liberty cheek is free of an obviously distractions. A conservatively graded example that is certain to please the collector. CAC has approved 186 is all grades, a low number for a date with a mintage of 2,010,300. The CAC guide is $5,500 as reference. Housed in PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) Dupont hologram holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$20 1904
Liberty
MS65+
PCGS
45843108

Gem $6000 Gem Type Offering, Brilliant Frosted Luster, Honey Green-Gold, Swirling Cartwheels, CAC Approved. How can advanced type collectors go wrong with this gem 1904 St. Gaudens on an eye appeal and value basis? Handling gem double eagle gold is always a pleasure for the opportunity to view brilliant frosted luster and undisturbed fields under the office desk lamp. This is a honey green-gold example with swirling cartwheels. Strike is complete with high relief stars and E PLURIBUS UNUM deeply impressed on the reverse. The offer price is our client's purchase price and quite credible considering the CAC guide is $5,500 in MS65 and jumping to $23,000 at the MS66 level. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2025) holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$20 1911-S
St Gaudens
MS65
NGC
1742857002

Gem $7400 Unquestionable Gem, Light Orange-Gold Coloration, Scarce at Grade, Osprey Collection. Consignor Price Reduction. A low mintage (775,750) issue that quickly becomes scarce at the full gem level. The Osprey Collection is back to the price list with this 1911-S NGC MS65 specimen that is CAC approved. The green bean is not surprising given the brilliant frosted luster that visually presents a micro-granular texture. The obverse is entirely unabraded and a joy to inspection under bright light. A few micro-ticks were seen on the reverse with 10x. Coloration is a light orange-gold which I often describe as honey-gold. Housed in NGC Gen 9 (2001-2003) holder.
Gold G$20 1924
St Gaudens
MS66+
NGC
3563707002

Gem $5750 Extraordinary Type Candidate, Superb Gem Original, Yellow-Gold Coloration, Frosted Luster, CAC Approved. As $20 Saint gold moves up the scale to lofty Mint State grades, the pricing premiums also increase dramatically. Astute collectors should carefully weigh luster, strike, and marks when contemplating fair value. The 1924 issue is unquestionably a superb gem and ideal for an advanced type set, given the offer price. An intricately detailed strike is noted as my eyes immediately focus on Liberty's head details, which are fully define. The surrounding fields are pristine for an undistracted viewing experience. Frosted luster is continuous with smooth fields and swirling cartwheels. This piece is falls into the yellow-gold realm. A careful 10x review noted a single mark above the eagle's head that requires mention. From an old time collector with a discriminating eye for premium quality. Housed in newer NGC holder with edge view insert and CAC approval.
Gold G$3 1854
Princess
AU50
NGC
3334002017

Choice $1750 $3 Princess Type, Honey Green-Gold, Steely Luster, CAC Approved. Above average steely luster is immediately noted when first checking this 1854 $3 Princess. Peripheral mint frost remains on both sides with a concertration of honey-gold. Centers are classic green-gold. An arcing line is noted by (ST)ATES did not bother CAC as the originality is unquestionable. A "common" date that is ideal for type with its CAC approval. Housed in NGC Gen 17 (2004-2008) holder.
Gold G$3 1878
Princess
AU58
PCGS
46515842

Choice $2650 Ideal for $3 Gold Type, Brilliant Frosted Luster, Honey Green-Gold Coloration, CAC Approval. 1878 Philadelphia struck $3 gold was produced to the tune of 82,304 pieces, a fairly low number by silver coinage standards but not for $3 gold. This "high" mintage leads to not date or rarity premium and perfect candidate for a U.S. gold type set. Next is the fact that this is a premium example that warrants a JUST BUY IT NOW recommendation. Frosty luster is thoroughly eye catching as are the smooth green-gold fields. The kind CAC staff agreed and awarded this piece a green bean. I'm tight on this coin so please consider my profit as a finder's fee. This one is 100% guaranteed to please. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2023) holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$3 1882
Indian Princess
EF45
PCGS
43164646

Choice $4350 New March 29! Tiny Mintage, Well Preserved, Light Wear, Choice Surfaces, Island Lake Collection. Outside of the 1854 and 1878 Philadelphia issues, the $3 Indian Princess gold series is quite challenging due to a host of lower mintage dates. Take for example the 1882 date with a mintage of 1,500. CAC has approved 36 in all grades with the majority being AU58 and better since this date barely circulated. The Island Collection is releasing a lightly circulated EF45 survivor with amazingly unabraded surfaces for the time in circulation. It is almost a miracle to view the obverse hair curl wear surrounded by pristine fields. The reverse offers a similar presentation. Steely luster remains and is sharp at the borders when viewed with angled lighting. The CAC guide is $4,100 with only two approved at this offered grade followed by four in AU55 with a premium that jumps to $5,750. Let's wrap up this description with a JUST BUY IT NOW recommendation for the astute collector. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2025) holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$3 1889
Princess
AU58
NGC
6677754009

Choice $4300 Final Year Design issue, Honey Green-Gold, CAC Approved. Consignor Price Reduction. 1889 brought the final production for the venerable $3 Princess gold design by John Longacre. Mintage was a scant 2,300 pieces though the date was saved as a mementos of a terminated denomination. Choice examples are challenging but can be located with patience. The 2023 Pittsburgh ANA event saw the purchase of this choice example as part of a larger gold deal. One immediately notes the natural honey-green gold coloration and steely reflectance from a well made survivor. Surfaces are free of distractions too. Fully choice and certain to please as this date is infrequently seen. Housed in new large font NGC holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$5 1847
Liberty
AU58
PCGS
41000918
MPD FS-302
Choice $2450 Misplaced 1 Digit, Cracked Obverse, Steely Frosted Luster, Honey Green-Gold, CAC Approved. FS-302 documents a dramatic misplaced date variety, as an errant 1 digit protruding from the front of Liberty's neck at the junction with the bust. This is a late die state example of the FS-302 attribution with a bold vertical crack from11:30 to the top of the coronet at the letters TY in LIBERTY, then down to the rim at the 4 digit in the date. Steely-frosted surfaces are originally toned in deep honey-gold with background green-gold shades. A marvelous die variety example along with certification at the AU58 grade and CAC approval. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2024) holder with a green bean. The PCGS label captures the variety as MPD FS-302.
Gold G$5 1880
Liberty
MS64
PCGS
34160615

Choice $1350 Honey-Gold, Brilliant Frosted Luster, Osprey Collection. Yet another Osprey Collection offering that would be ideal for a Mint State level U.S. gold type set. Surfaces emit glowing frosted radiance while a bright light exposes the expected honey green-gold coloration. Vibrant cartwheels add to the visual delight. Two obverse contact marks hold this lovely half eagle from a higher grade though the visual appeal is stronger. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$5 1880-CC
Liberty
VF20
NGC
5742591018

Choice $2675 Bettter $5 Carson City Date, Natural Copper-Gold, Choice Surfaces. The 1880-CC $5 gold piece is on the lower end of the survival scale when reviewing the CAC population report. A total of 65 examples have been approved with the bulk of the distribution between EF45 and AU58 at substantially higher premiums. If wishing to own a piece of early Carson City issued gold, this moderately worn example presents a compelling entry point. Surfaces are entirely original with the expected copper-gold patina. A few circulation marks attest to the fact that this lot did circulate in the early frontier period. Housed in new large font NGC holder with CAC approval. The CDN CAC guides stands at $2620 for reference.
Gold G$5 1881
Liberty
MS63
PCGS
39615137

Choice HOLD
$1000
Glowing Frosty Luster, Orange-Gold Coloring, Type Set Candidate. CAC gold continues to be in high demand. Luckily, Hound Dog Dan is able to locate choice gold with excellent eye. This 1881 $5 half eagle offers glowing frosty luster and swirling cartwheels from orange-gold toned surfaces. Strike is complete. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2021) holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$5 1888-S
Liberty
MS63
CACG
46044320

Choice $6150 Condition Census Offering, Frosted Luster, Honey-Gold Presentation, Fully Choice, CACG Holder. Since sporting a mintage of 293,900, the 1888-S $5 gold date is often treated as a "common date" in lower grades though one could argue that the date is scarce in all grades as a starting point. The situation shifts dramatically in Mint State where this date becomes very rare at the choice grade level. GFRC is pleased to be offering this CAC Grading example at the MS63 certified level. Only three examples have been stickered along with this CACG holdered specimen. The CDN CAC report indicates only one finer at MS64 without pricing guidance. This under appreciated example offers choice surfaces and glowing frosted luster. Under a bright light, the honey green-gold presentation is immediately evident. Worthy of serious consideration by U.S. gold collectors who seek an under appreciated rarity. Housed in new CAC Grading (2023) holder and graded consistent with CAC approval standards.
Gold G$5 1891
Liberty
MS64
PCGS
41436481

Choice $3750 Rare Uncirculated, Superb Rose-Gold Coloring, Completed Strike, Near-Gem. 1891 Philadelphia $5 gold strikes were limited to 61,360 pieces in an era of massive silver coinage output. Most survivors are found with abrasions and/or light wear. At the MS64 level, this grade becomes rare and even more so with CAC approval. PCGS has not certified a single gem specimen, therefore MS64 and MS64+ graded examples are as good as it gets. GFRC is pleased to be offering one of the MS64 certified survivors that also has CAC approval. An infrequently seen rose-gold coloring is consistent on both sides. Bright light inspection is a joy given the brilliant frosted luster that explodes off the surfaces. Strike is 100% complete and rounds out the checklist for a designating this offering a near-gem. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2021) holder. Previously sold by GFRC during June 2021 for $4350.
Gold G$5 1893
Liberty
MS64
NGC
6088561136

Choice $1225 Brilliant Frosty Luster, Completed Strike, Ideal for Type, CAC Approval. Part of a small hoard recently purchased by GFRC. This 1893 $5 gold piece offers rich frosty luster and swirling cartwheels. Coloring is light orange-gold with hints of rose. Accurately graded with minimal abrasions. Housed in new large font NGC holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$5 1893
Liberty
MS64
NGC
6088561032

Choice $1225 Brilliant Frosty Luster, Completed Strike, Rose-Gold Coloring, Ideal for Type, CAC Approval. Part of a small hoard recently purchased by GFRC. This 1893 $5 gold piece offers rich frosty luster and swirling cartwheels. Coloring is light rose-gold. Accurately graded with minimal abrasions. Housed in new large font NGC holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$5 1893
Liberty
MS64
NGC
6088561157

Choice HOLD
$1225
Brilliant Frosty Luster, Completed Strike, Ideal for Type, CAC Approval. Part of a small hoard recently purchased by GFRC. This 1893 $5 gold piece offers rich frosty luster and swirling cartwheels. Coloring is light orange-gold with hints of rose. Accurately graded with minimal abrasions. Housed in new large font NGC holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$5 1895-S
Liberty
MS62
PCGS
41453606

Choice $3750 Rare in Mint State, Few Finer CAC Approved, Sparkling Frosted Luster, Osprey Collection. Consignor Price Reduction. Another San Francisco $5 gold date that sports a reasonable mintage but is rare in choice Mint State. Even in the late 19th century, west coast coinage had few collectors to selectively "put pieces away" for the long term. As a result, the 1895-S date brings a substantial premium when CAC approved. All but 9 of the 45 approved are at the circulated level. The Osprey Collection is offering a choice example that exhibits pretty sparkling frosty luster and swirling cartwheels. Coloration is a light honey-gold. Scattered field chatter accounts for the certified grade. Only four are finer. Fairly priced for the rarity. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2022) holder with CAC approval. The label captures the Fairmont Collection pedigree.
Gold G$5 1905
Liberty
MS64+
NGC
6331828001

Gem $1500 Superb Type Offering, Granular Frosted Luster, Honey-Gold Coloration, Osprey Collection. The 1905 $5 gold issue is ideal for type since there is no date premium associated with a mintage of 302,200. This date is considered slightly scarcer than "common" for those who keep track of gold date rarity. The Osprey Collection has hit a homerun with this example purchased at the Pittsburgh ANA. Tightly textured frosted luster is softly brilliant and thoroughly pleasing under a light source. Coloration is a uniform honey-gold with "dirt" free surfaces. Strike is bold and complete. The MS64+ grade is technically accurate as there is scattered field chatter, however the overall eye appeal won the day at CAC. Housed in new large font NGC holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$5 1906-D
Liberty
MS63
PCGS OGH
6521190

Gem HOLD
$1050
Superb Eye Appeal, Gem Original, White Pine Collection. This GFRC-Gem rated 1906-D strike is a perfect storm of desirability including CAC approval including the old green holder that is a testament to conservative grading standards and ultimate freshness. The overall eye appeal is superb with rich caramel-gold hues. The strike is complete and the surfaces are essentially unabraded. Don't think too hard and JUST BUY IT NOW. Housed in PCGS Gen 3.1 (1993-1998) old green holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$5 1909
Indian
MS64
PCGS
46569876

Gem $4150 Better Philadephia Date, Rich Honey-Gold, Sparkling Frosted Luster. Sparkling frosted luster is the highlight of this gem 1909 half eagle. The application of angled lighting, with my desk lamp, allows the surfaces to radiate light in all directions. Coloration is a rich honey-gold with background greens. A touch of chatter in the upper right reverse field holds this one back from a certified gem opinion. This is a really pretty piece that is certain to please. CAC price guide is $4120 which is consistent with the offer price. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2023) holder.
Gold G$5 1909
Indian
MS63+
PCGS
38932261

Choice $2475 Choice Original.. Consignor Buyout, Price Reduction. Clean fields are the hallmark of this near-MS64 example, with only minor chatter present. Scattered shades of ebon color frame the central figures, highlighting the bold Indian and defiant eagle. Luster is exceptional for the grade and the plus designation is clearly warranted. CAC notes 397 coins in all grades, with 114 pieces finer. The CAC price guide value in MS63 is $2,440, advancing to $4,120 in MS64. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2022) holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$5 1909-D
Indian
MS64
NGC
6331754003

Choice $2800 Ideal Type Coin, Brilliant Satin Luster, Honey Green-Gold, Osprey Collection. Consignor Price Reduction. The 1909-D $5 Indian is common in Mint State, thus an ideal candidate for type or date set formation. When working with short series, locating those with superior eye appeal should be goal. This Pittsburgh ANA new purchase will fit the bill nicely with its satiny reflectance and uniform honey green-gold presentation. Overall strike is sharp with nicely detailed devices. Overall, a well balance example that would be perfect for type or other collecting goals. Yet another strong offering by the Osprey Collection. Housed in new large font NGC holder with CAC approval.
Gold G$5 1909-D
Indian
MS63+
PCGS
45336597

Choice $1685 Glowing Satiny Luster, Eye Appeal of a Higher Grade, Honey-Gold Coloration, CAC Approval. This new offering is a perfect $5 Indian type coin given its glowing satiny luster and vibrant cartwheels. The strike details on the headband feathers are quite impressive as are the reverse eagle feathers being deeply impressed. Coloration is honey-gold with no visual distraction under a bright light. 10x review reveals some scattered field chattered above the eagle's head which most likely accounts for the (+) grade rather than near-gem certification. CAC approval is fully warranted. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2023) holder.
Gold G$5 1910
Indian
MS64
PCGS
43926251

Choice HOLD
$4150
Glowing Satiny Luster, Honey Green-Gold, Near-Gem Preservation, CAC Approved. The 1910 Indian Head $5 date is the more challenging Philadelphia issue among its peers validated by the CAC population report. At the MS64 grade, the 1910 and 1914 dates have 69 and 62 examples approved respective with other dates being more available. This new purchase is very well preserved and so close to a full GFRC-Gem quality rating. Crisp satiny luster establishes a notable "glow" when activated by the office desk lamp. Surfaces are essentially unabraded on this honey green-gold colored example. If building a premium Indian $5 gold set, this piece would easily establish itself as a long term keeper. As reference, the CDN CAC guide is $4500 with a jump to $18,600 in full gem. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2023) holder with CAC approval. The label captures the Fairmont Collection pedigree.
Gold G$5 1912
Indian
MS63
NGC
6453767003

Choice $2550 Great Type Candidate, Steely-Frosted Luster, Honey-Gold, Well Preserved Surfaces. 1912 dated Indian $5 gold is known for its sharp luster and strong strikes. Yet another Summer Baltimore addition, this honey-gold colored example fits the bill. The obverse is pristine while there is one mark at the upper left reverse that is evident in the images. A premium example that is offered at a completive price to the CAC price guide. Housed in new large font NGC holder with CAC approval.
World
There are currently no coins for sale fitting this criteria.