Seated Dime AU-MS Price List - Gerry Fortin Rare Coins

Date	Grade	TPG	Top 100 Variety	GFRC Rating	Price	Description
1837	PF63	NGC 6356937005	F-101	Choice	$13750	Rare No Stars Proof Strike, Sharp Reflective Luster, Gorgeous Ring Toning, Hammered Strike, Osprey Collection. If searching for a proof No Stars dime for type, your choice is limited to the 1837 F-101 issue. Reported mintage is 30 pieces with the PCGS Price Guide indicating that 25-30 are known. The Osprey Collection is back with a gorgeous example that should garner immediate attention. This is a no question proof strike given several factors. First are the sharp reflective fields that are consistent with proof strikes. Second are the thin wire rims on both sides. Third is the incredible strike that is much sharper than seen on business strikes. Finally there is a lint mark below the cap that provides further validation. Circular or ring toning consists of center rose surrounded by wide blue peripheral rings. The early F-101 die state is easily verified by repunching on the bottom of the 7 digit. This piece is grade limited by one line in the middle left field. Housed in new large font NGC holder and ready for inclusion into an advanced proof coinage collection.
1837 No Stars, Small Date	AU Details	PCGS 80503428		Original	$850	Small Date, Perfectly Original, Deep Gray-Blue Obverse Toning Spot, Massachusetts Collection. This perfectly original 1837 F-102 Small Date continues to be the die variety plate coin at The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference. The Massachusetts Collection (Coulombe Family on Open Set Registry) purchased this lovely raw dime back in 2015 for me. During the tenure in his collection, a PCGS grading submission resulted in an AU Details, Environmental Damage opinion. Let's walk through this dime carefully. Surfaces are lightly frosted consistent with the issue. Toning is a natural coin gray-gold that is consistent on both sides. The blue-gray area to the left of Liberty is most likely dried ink dating back a century or more. When I first purchase this piece in the early 1990s, this blue-gray region did not bother me as it provided unique character to the piece. Of course, PCGS will take the safe route and certify as a Details specimen. The question comes down to the coin itself as strictly original with lovely frosted luster. Would you like to own this web-book plate coin? It is way more pleasing that a dipped out white AU straight graded by PCGS that is all too common in the marketplace. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with F-102 No Stars, Sm Date attribution on the label.
1837 No Stars, Large Date	MS66	PCGS 25337764	TOP #1 F-101c	Gem	$15000	Gem Original, Newtown Collection. Steely luster imparts active cartwheels across the surfaces of this Large Date, No Stars piece. A moderate spray of olive and charcoal patina covers both sides, highlighted by considerable flash that is thoroughly consistent with the MS66 CAC designation. The 1837 F-101c is coin #1 on the Top-100 list and exhibits heavy die clashing with elevated obverse die cracks. While not as arresting as the 1839 F-105c "Pie," the die deterioration is advanced and easily apparent without a glass. The dies are slightly rotated as expected for all later die states of the F-101 die pair. The CAC census notes two examples in MS66, with only a pair of pieces higher, both at MS67. The guide value is $15,000. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
1837 No Stars, Large Date	MS62	NGC 6058204002	F-101	Choice	$1400	Large Date, Speckled Copper-Gold, Soft Steely Luster, Choice Surfaces. 1837 brought the first year of Christian Gobrecht's Liberty Seated design to the half dime and dime denominations. For dimes, a single large date die pair was used for proof and circulation strike. Business strike will be found with a consistent 23 degree clockwise rotation. GFRC has just purchased this accurately graded F-101 die state example with steely fields and speckled copper-gold toning on the obverse plus center aquamarine shades on the reverse. A pleasing example with unblemished surfaces. Housed in new large font NGC holder.
1837 No Stars, Small Date	MS61	NGC 1923602009	F-103	Original	$1650	Small Date, Old Album Obverse Rainbow Toning, Original Surfaces, Well Struck, Upstate New York Collection. For fans of old album rainbow toning, this 1837 F-103 dime is worthy of consideration. The full rainbow spectrum is available on the obverse including a colorful arc at the upper rim that proceeds to Liberty's midsection. The balance of the obverse is rose and deep blue. Reverse has a thin ring of peripheral blue that transition to light gold across the remaining surfaces. Strike is hammered with bold devices. This F-103 example comes with a reverse rotated 5 degrees left. Overall, a fairly graded piece given an old dipped before being placed in a high sulfur paper album for a decade or more. Housed in newer NGC holder with edge view insert. A quality consignment from the Upstate New York Collection.
1837 No Stars, Large Date	AU55	PCGS 2717121	F-101b	Original	$950	New May 19! Large Date, Near-Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection.. We open the Steven Vitale Liberty Seated Dime Collection offerings with this 1837 F-101b lot. This large date specimen was struck with later die state dies given the pie shaped die cracks on the lower obverse. A light silver-gray patina covers both sides while the underlying luster is steely. The presentation is struck original and exactly as expected for the date. Some faint lines in the lower right obverse field preclude a full Choice quality rating. Overall eye appeal is pleasing at the certified grade. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.0 (1998-2002) holder
1838 No Drapery, Large Stars	MS66	NGC 2041752002	F-113	Gem	$5650	Reverse Die Flaw, Second Pairing, Gem Original, Osprey Collection. The Osprey Collection returns to the GFRC price list with a silky high grade 1838 Large Stars dime for consideration. This richly original example features blended steel-gray and champagne-pink patina on both sides. Strike is hammered with high relief stars regardless of the dies being significant eroded. Silky luster manages to radiate through a fairly thick patina. Surfaces are entirely unabraded and smooth and. The F-113 attribution points (reverse die flaw and die erosion below date) are easily seen. A well preserved candidate to represent the short lived No Drapery design in a high grade Mint State type set. Housed in newer NGC holder with CAC approval.
1838 No Drapery, Large Stars	MS64	NGC 331520001	F-105	Gem	$2000	New May 7! Reverse Die Flaw, Gem Original, Ex. Gerry Fortin Collection.. As we continue to move "up the Gerry Fortin Collection ladder", this 1838 F-105 is begrudgingly released. An absolute gem with intense frosty luster decorated by rose-gold coloring. Cartwheels sizzle with the slightest holder rotation during bright light inspection. A hammered strike and entirely unabraded surfaces further enhance the eye appeal. This piece is the F-105 web-book plate coin at The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference. Sure the asking price includes a substantial premium over the guides. This offering is an incredible gem and is well worth MS65 level monies. With some crackout and upgrade efforts, this piece will eventually find its way into an MS65 holder. Housed in NGC Gen 7 (1997-2000) holder with CAC approval.
1838 No Drapery, Large Stars	AU53	PCGS 28715622	TOP #9 F-111	Choice	$450	Cracked Obverse #3, Near-Gem, Steely Gray Surfaces, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. Liberty Seated Dime Top 100 Variety Set collectors might consider the acquisition of this well preserved 1838 F-111 dime. This variety was previously listed by Greer as Shattered Obverse #3 in his important DLRC Press guidebook on the series. This near-gem example was purchased directly from Greer way back during February of 1995 as a raw piece and subsequently graded during 2015. I know for certain that this one has not been to CAC. An impressive example with steely gray fields surrounded by peripheral copper-gold. Strike is complete, which is typical for this date. Many of the 1838 Philadelphia dime dies eventually cracked as die steel quality was and issue through the mid-1840s. The F-111 plate coin within the Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference. Yes, this one is not inexpensive but the quality and bold bisecting obverse die crack warrants a premium. Housed in PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) Dupont hologram holder.
1838 No Drapery, Small Stars	AU53	PCGS 13606683	F-101a	Choice	$500	Small Stars, Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection.. A classic example of the later Small Stars die state with a bold die crack through the left stars and reaching down into the date. Dies are worn with light "orange peel" surfaces leading to a satiny frosted appearance. Luster is more than adequate at the certified grade while surfaces are unabraded. Please note that the rim mark on the upper reverse is a strike through error and not post mint damage. Fully choice and strictly original. Please consider a strong bid for this lovely F-101a. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder.
1838-O No Stars	AU50	PCGS 04202803	F-102	Original	$995	New May 1! Mottled Blue-Rose Toning, Residual Frosted Luster, New Orleans Collection. 1838 saw the first dime coinage at the new New Orleans mint. Those strikes were accomplished with a No Stars obverse dated 1838 while the Philadelphia mother mint had already adopted the No Drapery with Stars design replacement. This well preserved example showcases the second F-102 die pairing with eroded dies and a full defined mintmark. Mottled rose-blue covers the obverse while the reverse has traditional ring toning. Under a bright light, the residual frosted luster presents a nice glow. A late die state strike with heavy metal flow lines on both sides. From the New Orleans Collection. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder.
1839 No Drapery	MS65	NGC 2037607024	F-104b	Gem	$2750	Terminal Die State, Crusty Gray Old 2x2 Paper Toning, Ex. "Col" E.H.R Green Collection, now Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. Ex: "Col." E.H.R. Green. The obverse of this terminal die state 1839 F-104b die has three lengthy die cracks, the heaviest between star 2 and the 3 and migrating across the shield and through the date. This intricately struck, unabraded, and satiny gem original survivor has deep old 2x2 paper envelope toning with mahogany-brown, steel-gray, and forest-green coloration. Housed in 2013 generation NGC holder with edge view insert and special Eric P. Newman pedigree label. This is a particular difficult coin to photograph. Potential buyers may wish to visit CoinFacts and the November 2013 Heritage auction listing and accompanying images.
1839 No Drapery	MS62	NGC 5742516011	F-106c	Choice	$725	Cracked Obverse, Rotated Reverse Left 18 Degrees, Gorgeous Toning, Frosted Luster, Upstate New York Collection. Price Reduction - Serious eye appeal arrives with this 1839 F-106c Liberty Seated dime offering. Frosted luster highlights peripheral aquamarine-gold that surrounds obverse center rose. Strike is complete but not sharp as the F-106c die pairing features a well worn and cracked die pair. Reverse die misalignment is 18 degrees left. The progressive obverse die crack at 12:00 from rim through Liberty's head down to neckline becomes stronger and more visible during the F-106c die state. Another significant die crack starts at the rim to the right of star 10 and joins stars 11 through 13. The reverse exhibits multiple cracks to the rim. This new offering brings a highly detailed late die state variety with beautiful toning. How can you pass up the combination? Housed in new large font NGC holder with edge view insert.
1839-O No Drapery	MS66+	PCGS 34585955	F-104a	Gem	$17500	Gem Original, Newtown Collection. Pleasing shades of powder blue evenly cover both sides of this early New Orleans dime. A band of russet patina encircles the obverse, while the reverse exhibits bits of similar color within the legend. The overall eye appeal is compelling, and the new owner will be justifiable proud of an aesthetically pleasing, near-finest known piece. F-104a, with star 8 repunched and a bisecting reverse die crack running through DIME. The CAC census notes 64 pieces in all grades, with three examples higher, all at MS67. The CAC price guide value is $14,400. Ex. Branch Mint Collection, a Liberty Seated type set consisting of ultra-high grade examples, offered by GFRC in 2021. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
1839-O No Drapery	AU53	PCGS 28687059	F-105	Original	$600	Near-Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection.. Brilliant frosted luster is readily evident on this 1839-O F-105 lot. One of the more available die pairing for New Orleans strikes of that year, the dies will show progressive wear and terminal die start obverse cracks. This Steven Vitale piece was struck by interim die state dies. Strike is complete given the sharp star center points and wreath leaves. Wear is visible on the higher points along with faint hair lines in the obverse fields. Well preserved though luster dominates the certified grade. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.6 (2013-2014) holder.
1839-O No Drapery	AU50	raw	TOP #14 F-108	Market Acceptable	$850	Huge O Variety, Rare Grade, Top 100 Varieties #14, Details Grade. Definitely a rare grade for the 1839-O Huge O reverse variety when AU details remain. This specimen easily grades AU+ but has dark verdigris covering the obverse stars and date regions coupled with the entire reverse. The dark surfaces were result in a PCGS grade designation of AU Details code 97 (environmental) if holdering were to be attempted. Few examples are know at this grade level and a truly problem free specimen would be priced in the $2000+ range. Offers are welcomed as the dime is listed to sell.
1840-O	AU58	NGC 451481005	F-101 R6	Choice	$5000	Choice Original, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection.. The New Orleans Mint first struck Liberty Seated dimes during 1838 without stars followed by stars being added to the No Drapery hub during 1839 and 1840. The 1840 strikes have proven to be very challenging in AU or higher grades due to extensive circulation in the deep south. Those specimens that are graded AU58 and Mint State infrequently appear on the market. This F-101 specimen is a truly important release from the Gerry Fortin Reference Collection since being struck by early die state dies with a Large O reverse. Most F-101 survivors were struck with lapped dies that significantly reduced the relief of major devices. Those are designated as the F-101a die state. This F-101 example is one of the few seen during my research career therefore an R6 rarity rating is justified. Soft frosted luster and light gold patina are the primary visual attributes along with strict originality that was rewarded with a CAC green bean. Purchased July 2008 during a Bowers & Merena Baltimore sale. Housed in NGC Gen 17 (2004-2008) holder with CAC approval.
1840-O No Drapery	AU50	PCGS 30630411	F-108	Choice	$1400	Small O, Eroded Dies, Satiny Luster, Orange-Gray Patina, Newtown Collection. Both obverse and reverse dies are eroded with radial metal flows lines in the denticles. The reverse area surrounding AM(ERIC)A is heavily eroded with multiple die crack through the legend lettering. This example features a orange-gray "skin "with more uniform orange-rose on the reverse. Strike is complete. A few ancient micro-ticks are seen in the fields and fully toned. 1840 New Orleans strikes continue to be very scarce in AU and rare in Mint State. Housed in PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) Dupont hologram holder. Previously from the Birmingham Collection and sold in the Newtown Collection. Now back on the market after a five year hiatus.
1841	MS66	PCGS 25612093	F-110a	Gem	$7500	Proof Dies, Gem Original, Newtown Collection. Steely, frosted luster imparts exceptionally active cartwheels that rotate vibrantly under a light source. Light splashes of maroon patina cover both sides atop the steel-gray fields, and the eye appeal is stunning. One is tempted to introduce a "Gem Plus" level to the GFRC rating system, but we'd prefer to simply let the coin speak for itself. F-110a, with a slight upward slope in the date. The reverse legend, which might appear sharp at first glance, is actually less lightly impressed than other 1841 dimes, which tend to exhibit deep relief in this portion of the design. CAC has approved 41 pieces in all grades; this piece is tied with two other coins for finest-known at MS66. The CAC price guide value is $7,500. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
1842	MS65	NGC 3381721004	F-105	Gem	$3450	Brilliant Frosted Luster, Vibrant Cartwheels, Light Gold Toning, Gem Eye Appeal, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. The recent Newtown Liberty Seated dime purchases have brought about a number of Fortin core set duplicates. This lovely gem 1842 F-105 dime will certainly please the new owner given its sparkling frosted luster and vibrant cartwheels. Once again, strike is completely executed. Overall eye appeal is "all there" with originality, luster, and strike combining into a superb presentation under angled lighting. Purchased October 2010 for the Fortin core Seated dime set along with becoming the F-105 plate coin at The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference. CAC has approved five at the certified grade with three finer. Housed in newer NGC holder with edge view insert and CAC approval.
1842	MS63	ANACS 2632470	F-103a	Original	$725	Obverse Rim Cud, Rainbow Toning, Challenging Variety, Top 100 Variety, Copper Harbor Collection. A lovely Mint State obverse cud 1842 F-103a dime is being released by the Copper Harbor Collection. The F-103a variety features are large rim cud adjacent to stars 3 through 5. This example resides in old white ANACS holder with intermixed rainbow toning throughout obverse and reverse. A no question Mint State example that offers glowing luster plus golden and blue shades. One must inspect this piece in hand to appreciate as the toning patterns are difficult to describe. A well struck dime with deeply impressed obverse devices and just a touch of weakness on the upper left reverse leaves. There are no blemishes whatsoever.
1842	AU50	ANACS 1372907	F-104 R4	Choice	$285	Better Variety, Open 84 Digits, Crusty Original, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. All 1842 Seated dime obverse dies will be found with a bold date punch except F-104. The obverse and reverse die pairing features shallow devices that could have resulted from aggressive die lapping. I've only seen several examples across the years with this offering being the first located and acting as the web-book plate coins since 2004. The reverse die crack through AMERICA is nice and bold under 10x. Dark crusty gray patina with embedded lighter silhouettes around the motifs. Surfaces are unabraded too. Housed in ANACS old white holder.
1842-O	AU50	PCGS 21948764	F-101	Original	$900	New May 2! Challenging Higher Grade, Frosted Luster, Near-Choice Original, New Orleans Collection. Strike issues are an ongoing collector challenge for 1842-O dimes. Many will be located with partial strikes or from lapped dies. The F-101 die pairing presents the best chance for locating a well struck example. This New Orleans Collection is a typical F-101 with a fully formed head while the center motif is weak. Weakness in the reverse wreath and bow knot can also be expected. A Medium O mintmark is present on the F-101 reverse. It is positioned right and centered vertically, with a right tilt of 7 degrees. Traces of pitting, due to a rusted die, is seen around the bow know and around the letters ST(ATES OF AME)RICA. This survivor retains its frosted luster along with a light copper-gold patina. Micro-ticks are noted on both the obverse and reverse. These micro-ticks is quite common for the date with researchers unable to provide an explanation for their occurrence. A cool branch mint Seated dime with a long story to tell. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.3 (2005) holder.
1843	MS66	PCGS 24705267	F-102a	Gem	$6150	Gem Original, Newtown Collection. The 1843 F-102a is a distinct variety with extensive die cracks and is listed in the Top-100 Varieties as #25. Half dollars of 1843 similarly exhibit die cracks, and clearly the Philadelphia Mint experienced problems with die preparation and/or striking in this year. Regardless, this is one the finest survivors of the issue. The CAC census notes five pieces in MS66 with none higher, while PCGS reports three coins in MS66, with a single piece finer at MS66+. Rich toning is evident on both sides, with aqua and maroon patina throughout. The northeast quadrant of the obverse, and the corresponding portion of the reverse, are more lightly shaded. This example is a PCGS Coin Facts plate coin. The CAC price guide is $6,750. Housed in a PCGS Gen 4.5 (2012-2013) holder with CAC approval.
1843	MS63	PCGS 11228809	F-101	Choice	$875	Repunched 3, Gorgeous Rose-Gray Patina and Frosted Luster, Complete Strike. A gorgeous 1843 F-101 example with old time natural toning and frosted luster. In hand inspection suggests a thick rose gray patina which is accurate. However, that patina is semi-transparent and partially melts away during bright light assessment. The result is a colorful rose display as enhanced by the background frosted luster. Cartwheels are moderate due to the thick patina. Most important is a complete strike with the repunching above the top of the 1 digit being visible with 10x. Strict original, fully choice, and then some. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder.
1843	MS61	NGC 3413567002	F-104	Choice	$535	New April 26! Repunched 8, Deep Gray Coloring, Peripheral Ebony Shades, Choice Surfaces, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. The 1843 F-104 obverse can be attributed by a bold date punch that nearly touches the base. The date punch is positioned at DR -2C and on well struck examples, faint repunching can be seen at the lower left base of the 8 digit. The repunching at the base of the 8 digit can be seen on this fully struck Mint State example but will take careful inspection. Gray patina is the dominant coloring with darker shades at the obverse periphery and embedded center rose on the reverse. The choice original 1843 F-104 dime was employed as the plate coin within The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collection commonly known as the web-book. Housed in newer NGC holder with edge view insert. Purchased at a Heritage Auction March 2013 and offered at that purchase price.
1845	MS65	NGC 449087001		Gem	$2350	Brilliant Frosted Luster, Bold Strike, Peripheral Gold, Accurately Graded. 1845 brought a substantial increase in Liberty Seated dime production after the anemic 72,500 pieces struck in 1844. Six obverse and seven reverse dies have been documented for a production of 1,755,000 minted. The F-105 and F-105a web-book listings documents a die pairing that is available. The infrequently seen F-105a die state captures crossing reverse die cracks at STAT(E)S as is the case with this lovely gem survivor. Brilliant frosted luster is consistent on both sides along with peripheral gold. Strike is well executed for the date with only a touch of weakness on the lower right stars. Die scratches can be seen to the left of the base of the pole with 10x as the strike is powerfully detailed. Accurately grade and housed in new large font NGC holder. Hand selected by the Osprey Collection.
1845	MS61	NGC 3887987007	F-104a	Original	$415	Late Die State, Aquamarine Coloration, Near-Choice. A late die F-104 example with lapped obverse die that removed date repunching. The resulting F-104a die state can be attributed by a reverse die crack through S(T)ATES. The offered example is from my reference collection and the F104 plate coin at The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference. Near choice surfaces are covered with light aquamarine shades that expose golden hues under a light source. Strike is completely executed. The darker vertical streak in the right obverse field is a toning line with some verdigris present at the date. Housed in newer NGC holder with edge view insert.
1845-O	AU50	PCGS 90062686	F-101a R4	Original	$3650	Original, Very Scarce Grade Level, Gun Metal Gray Patina, Hammered Strike, Underrated.. GFRC has the pleasure of handling this important 1845 New Orleans dime graded PCGS AU50 for a third time. This example has an exceptional strike with bold head and hair curls, star centrils and lower body definition on the obverse while the reverse offers full wreath leaves. Secondly, this piece has natural gun metal gray patina that is uniform and just a tad deeper on the reverse. The coloring is very consistent in hand and under bright light. GFRC images are accurate for one of the finer examples to come to market. Housed in new PCGS Gen 6.0 holder with D.L.Hansen pedigree label. Previously sold during June 2017 and December 2019 at the $4150 level. GFRC has been able to repurchase this example at an attractive price and passing the savings to the next owner.
1848	AU55	PCGS 30718074	F-101	Choice	$450	New April 13! Early Die State, Mottled Gray Patina, Steely Reflective Fields. Complete Strike, Massachusetts Collection. This 1848 dime is an excellent example of the F-101 early die state whereby the unfinished area within the ribbon bow is evident but not the vertical die crack through the left stem. Surfaces are strictly original and present steely reflective luster when viewed under a bright light. The mottled obverse toning is not as dark as on the images, so please keep this in mind if considering a purchase. Strike is complete with bold devices. Freshly graded by the Massachusetts Collection consignor without a CAC submission. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2023) holder.
1849-O Large O	AU50	PCGS 82690112	F-101	Choice	$875	Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection.. As a rule, 1849 New Orleans dimes are often seen with problematic surfaces and weak strikes. The F-101 large O die pairing, in particular, is notorious for partial heads. What a pleasant surprise when first laying eyes on the Vitale lot! This is a unquestionably premium example with lightly crusted golden silver-gray patina and a bold strike. All but the top of Liberty's head is completely impressed with full wreath leaf views. It does not get better than this for a F-101. Reddish-gold "dirt" is evident in the protected areas as a testament to the strict originality. Worthy of a strong bid as the winner will be pleased. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder.
1851	MS64	PCGS 13589740	F-103	Choice	$2250	Choice Original, Newtown Collection. Steely, frosted luster is easily evident, but not quite sufficient to achieve CAC certification. This piece is richly toned, with even lilac and violet patina underlaying bits of pumpkin and lemon-gold color at the rims. Production of dimes in this year was substantial, over a million pieces, but many were no doubt melted as silver became more valuable in relation in gold, which was a result of massive discoveries of the yellow metal in the western United States. F-103, with a high date descending downward, and die flashing around the ribbon loops. The PCGS population report indicates 13 pieces in MS64, with seven examples finer. The PCGS price guide value is $2,500 in MS64. Housed in a PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder.
1851-O	AU58	PCGS 82128697	F-101	Original	$3500	Rare Grade, Bold Early Die State Strike, Untoned, Twin Lakes Collection. Consignor Price Reduction. 1851-O dimes have been underrated for years in AU55 or better. Most are either white and frosty or having funky toning colors. This Twin Lakes example falls in the frosty lot with white luster and active cartwheels. Light rub is seen on the left breast therefore the grading is accurate. After years of research, only a single die pair has been identified for the date. The dies were used extensively and lapped along with way. This example was struck during a middle die state most of the drapery remains. PCGS population is all of four pieces at grade. An important offering from the Twin Lakes Collection. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder.
1851-O	AU55	PCGS 35269710	F-101	Original	$2650	Very Rare Choice AU, Original Reflective Surfaces, Deep Gray-Aquamarine Toning, Bright Light Eye Appeal. The rarity of the 1851-O date at the AU and Mint State grade levels is finally being understood by the numismatic community. The Liberty Seated Collectors Club and GFRC have been driving forces in raising that awareness. GFRC is pleased to be offering a freshly graded specimen with deep gray-aquamarine patina on both sides. Most pleasing are the reflective fields during bright light inspection. The obverse fields are substantially mirrored with center rose surrounded by a thin blue arc before shifting to gold at the stars. The weakly struck head does not bother me as typical for the date. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 holder and sure to please the new owner. Sold in late 2019 and recently bought back for inventory.
1851-O	AU53	PCGS 21526436	F-101	Original	$2350	Rare Grade, Frosty Luster, Polished Die State, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. The 1851-O Liberty Seated dime date has finally been recognized for its rarity in AU grades or better. CoinFacts auctions records for this date are barren consistent with the lack of availability. GFRC is pleased to be offering an AU53 example that was purchased during 2004 and is finally being released from the confines of a bank box. This is a late die example struck from a heavily polished obverse die. Surfaces are brilliant frosty with corresponding luster. Strike is complete though much of the center motif details have been effaced. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.1 (2002-2004) holder.
1852	MS65	NGC 344257009	F-101	Gem	$2950	Kamal Ahwash Plate Coin, Superb Gem, Frosted Luster, Hammered Strike, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. I'm finally letting go of one of the remaining Kamal Ahwash plate coins in my collection. This 1852 F-101 dime is Kam's plate on pages 117-118 within his Encyclopedia of United States Liberty Seated Dime 1837-1891 reference. This piece was purchased October 1999 and cherish since that time. Brilliant frosted luster radiates during angled lighting review regardless of the copper-gold patina. Strike is all there will complete motifs and elevated rims. Surfaces are entirely unabraded. This numismatically important piece was further used as the F-104 plate coin within The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference. A true gem in every sense of the word and ready for the next curator to take proper care of this piece. Housed in NGC Gen 7 (1997-2000) holder with CAC approval.
1852	MS63	PCGS 40802651	F-103	Choice	$650	Crusty Natural Patina, Hammered Strike, Impressive Eye Appeal, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. Strike is a critical factor when collecting early type. The beauty of Christian Gobrecht's engraving artistry can be seen with this heavily detailed 1852 F-103 dime. Surfaces are uniformly frosted with obverse luster being subdued by a crusty golden-brown-aquamarine skin. The F-103 die variety can be attributed by the 1 digit nearly touching the base. This lovely example is employed as the F-103 plate coin at The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors, or commonly known as the web-book. Freshly graded and housed in new PCGS Gen 6.1 holder.
1852-O	AU53	PCGS 21852896		Choice	$985	Popular New Orleans Date, Natural Surfaces, Frosted Luster, Rose-Gold Patina, Massachusetts Collection. The Massachusetts Collection is releasing a lovely 1852-O dime for conisderation. This is a popular date with a limited mintage of 430,000. 1852 brought the final year of silver arbitrage whereby New Orleans struck silver coinage was exported to Europe and melted. The bullion was subsequently returned to America at a profit. The 1852-O quarter and half dollar dates are much scarcer than their mintages would suggest while a portion of the dime production was probably also involved. The surfaces on this survivor are strictly original with granulat mint frost surrounding the devices. Bright light viewing exposes frosted luster that is more concentrated on the obverse. Both sides are toned rose-gold with deeper shades throughout the reverse. Strike is typical for the issue. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2022) holder.
1853 With Arrows	MS66	PCGS 21012267	F-119	Gem	$3650	With Arrows Type, Rim Cud 6:00 - 7:00, Brilliant Frosted Luster, Hammered Strike, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. A marvelous 1853 With Arrows dime that has been part of the Fortin core Liberty Seated Dime collection since July 2007. This piece held a special spot in the core collection due to eye appeal and a cool obverse rim cud from 6:00 - 7:00. Surfaces are heavily frosted along with a hammered strike. The resulting luster is intense with dancing cartwheels. Not immediately obvious from the GFRC images is a subtle light gold patina that validates the strict originality. This offering has been and will continue to be the F-119 plate coin at The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with a few plastic haze spots seen on Liberty's left facing arm and within the center gown folds.
1853	MS66	PCGS 44349098		Gem	$3350	Brilliant Frosted Luster, Swirling Cartwheels, True Gem, Fort Lauderdale Collection. This Fort Lauderdale Collection release is an unquestionable gem with thick frosted luster and swirling cartwheels. The date and arrows placement indicates that this piece was struck by a Hubbed Arrows & Date obverse die. Both sides are covered with thick original mint bloom. Strike is needle sharp from lightly clashed dies. Fields are unabraded as would be expected at the grade level. Freshly graded without a CAC submission. This is a very pretty coin. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2022) holder.
1853 With Arrows	MS65+	NGC 6058664012		Gem	$2375	Hubbed Arrows & Date, Thick Frosty Luster, Amazing Originality, CAC Approval. A strikingly original 1853 Liberty Seated dime strike with a Hubbed Arrows and Date obverse die. 1853 dimes struck with a fully hubbed die can be easily recognized with practice. The date and arrow positions are fixed along with the working die hubbing strength being consistent throughout the die. This is the case for the latest Osprey Collection offering. Note how the date and arrow device were lightly transferred along with the other motifs. This is an amazingly well preserved example with old time silver gray patina and granular frosted luster that is brilliant with angled lighting. 100% struck with cool wire-like rims. Perfect for type or inclusion into an advanced date and mintmark set. Accurately graded and housed in new large font NGC holder with CAC approval.
1853 Huubbed Arrows & Date	MS65	NGC 1939302001		Choice	$1350	With Arrows Type, Thick Frosted Luster, Faint Gold. The date and arrows positions on this 1853 Arrows dime are consistent with the fixed placement of the arrows and date from a new master hub die. 1853 brought a huge production ramp with lower silver weight planchets leaving the chief engraver and assistants overworked. A new master hub was created with the date and arrows included in the overall design leading to die prep simplification. This example has few diagnostics. Surfaces are layered with even mint bloom. Bright light review exposes brilliant frosted luster and some hints of gold. Cartwheels are pleasing. Overall strike is best described as "hammered" along with unabraded surfaces. A quality piece for a type set with some cool history. Housed in new large font NGC holder.
1854 With Arrows	MS61	PCGS OGH 4599101		Choice	$450	New May 24! Frosted Luster, Fully Struck, Golden Toning, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. Frosted luster is equally distributed on both sides of this lovely 1854 With Arrows dime. Strike is completely executed. Speckled gold patina is more predominant near the peripheries. Purchased January 2002 at the Winter FUN show as part of the Seated dime research project. This offering continued to be employed at the F-110 plate coin at The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference. Housed in PCGS Gen 3.1 (1993-1998) holder and worthy of a trip to CAC if the economics work.
1855 With Arrows	MS65	PCGS 28606975		Gem	$3000	Gem Original, Newtown Collection. Steely luster and vibrant cartwheels grace the surfaces of this With Arrows example. The obverse exhibits a splash of sea-green patina, while bits of original steel-gray color are present here and there. The only mark of note is a field tick inside of star 5. The strike is all there, with completely full head and bow detail. PCGS notes five pieces in MS65, with nine coins higher. This represents the final year of the With Arrows type, and, following the massive production spike in 1853, mintages fell considerably. The CAC guide value is $3,750. Housed in a PCGS Gen 4.6 (2013-2014) holder with CAC approval.
1856 Small Date	MS65+	PCGS 31090762	F-116	Gem	$4500	Gem Original, Newtown Collection. Throw out the price guide on this piece, as it is certainly to sell for substantially more than the suggested CAC value of $2,550. Brilliant, frosted luster fills the centers of each side, both of which lead toward pleasing rim toning. Russet crescents surround the figure of Liberty, while the wreath is framed by a ring of maroon and intense blue-green color. The strike is full, and the overall eye appeal is superb. The CAC population is seven pieces in MS65, with five coins finer. Ex. Tom Bender Collection. Housed in a PCGS Gen 4.5 (2012-2013) holder with CAC approval.
1856 Large Date	MS64	PCGS 38522105	F-104	Choice	$4350	Choice Original, Newtown Collection. Russet and sea-green patina mixes on the obverse of this Large Date example, while the reverse is less intensely toned. The strike is soft, with star points present if not fully sharp. A few lines in the left obverse field are noted. F-104, with digits touching the base, while the reverse die is perfect with no distinguishing characteristics. Philadelphia pieces of this date come with both large and small dates, while the branch Mint obverse dies all featured small digit punches. This piece is tied with two other coins for finest-known at CAC, which reports 24 pieces in all grades. The CAC guide value is $4,500. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
1857	PF64	NGC 685163003	F-101	Gem	$4250	New May 7! Gem Original Proof, Ex Pittman-Fortin.. This boldly reflective example of the early 1857 proof rarity sports the coveted Pittman Collection pedigree and was off the market since 2002 in the Gerry Fortin reference collection. Recently repurchased and a noteworthy addition to the CAC-Only auction sale. Watery mirrored fields offer brilliant clarity and reflectivity. This is an absolutely hammered strike with all devices being sharply struck and defined in high relief. A transparent thin golden film covers both sides. Housed in NGC Gen 7 (1997-2000) holder with CAC approval. A GFRC lot that offers strict originality, overall eye appeal and quality consistent with the Pittman pedigree and status as the F-101 plate coin within The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference.
1857	MS66	PCGS 43796091	F-104	Gem	$3750	Gem Original, Newtown Collection. Steely, granular luster hosts lilac patina on both sides, with additional shades of blue-green and gold evident on the obverse. The dynamic cartwheels are active and above average for the grade. Both sides reveal die polish, an effect also present on quarters of this year. F-104, although the die chips at stars 3-6 are not present as this portion of the coin is softly struck. The CAC population is 44 in all grades, and this example is tied for finest-known with three other MS66 coins. The CAC guide value is $3,750. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2022) holder with CAC approval.
1857-O	MS67	NGC Fatty 148656001	F-107a	Gem	HOLD $8000	Gem Original, Newtown Collection. Brilliant, steely luster imparts dancing cartwheels, and the eye appeal is off the charts. Dappled, midnight blue patina graces both sides, with splashes of original silver color evident underneath. Hints of lilac hue are evident within the shield and wreath. The strike is complete with sharp stairs and strong bow detail. F-107a, with a die crack connecting the rock and rim. This piece is tied for finest-known at CAC with one other coin. CAC has graded 51 examples in all grades. Purchased from GFRC and previously from the James Stack collection (Stack's, January 1990, lot 113, realized a strong $25,300). This coin truly has it all - exceptional eye appeal, superior technical grade, and provenance among the finest collections. Examples from the Gardner collection are infrequently exceeded, but in the case the bragging rights easily go to this MS67 piece, which supersedes the Gardner coin (MS66) in both grade and eye appeal. The CAC guide value is $8,250, and the GFRC sales archive notes a sale price of $8,500 in August 2018. Housed in a NGC Gen 4 (1989-1991) no line brown label Fatty holder with CAC approval.
1857-O	MS64	PCGS 33880066	F-106	Choice	$900	Choice Original, Newtown Collection. Satiny luster radiates from both sides of this lightly toned New Orleans piece. Misty streaks of coffee patina traverse the obverse, while the reverse reveals a fine spray of maroon color. Nicely struck, with solid detail in the head and bow. F-106, with a medium level date and weak dentils to the southeast, as well as the corresponding northeast quadrant of the reverse. PCGS notes 31 pieces in MS64 with 28 coins finer. The PCGS price guide is $1,100. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder.
1857-O	MS62	NGC 678748004	F-103	Original	$485	Original Surfaces, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. The 1857-O F-103 plate coin within The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors web-book. Housed in NGC Gen 7 (1997-2000) holder. Full description shortly.
1858-S	AU50	PCGS 32657490	F-103	Choice	$2500	Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection.. The superb 1858-S example should garner substantial attention and bidding. One of the three low mintage 1850s dates, choice survivors are terribly difficult to locate. This Vitale Collection lot is well beyond my expectations for the F-103 die pairing, usually seen with a weak obverse strike. Unabraded surfaces have been meticulously preserved while the toning is a natural rose-gray with peripheral gold highlights. Unquestionably original and deserving of aggressive bidding. Don't let this GFRC-Choice rating example get away! Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder.
1859	PR64	PCGS 50064684	F-102	Choice	$1850	New April 17! Near Gem Original, Crusty Gray Patina, Active Mirrors, Fully Struck, Former Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. At GFRC, we like our Liberty Seated coinage, including proofs, to have 100% natural surfaces and crusty gray patina where possible. This is the case for this near gem 1859 proof strike. Sourced from a Heritage auction during November 2003 due to the atypical crusty obverse toning with incremental gray patina on the reverse. Under the toning are active mirrors. Strike is absolutely hammered. 1859 proofs were struck from two different obverse dies labeled as F-101 and F-102 in the "web-book". F-101 is the more common of the two proof dies while F-102 accounts for about one in five of the proof dimes seen. This F-102 obverse presents a medium level date while F-101 exhibits a upward sloping. This F-102 dime continues to be the proof plate coin within The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Die Variety Collectors online reference. Previously sold to a client who has decided to liquidate his Seated dime proof set, therefore resulting to the price list. This is an atypical proof example for fans of crusty originality. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.1 (2002-2003) holder.
1859	MS66	PCGS 34127309	F-107	Gem	$3950	Splendid Eye Appeal, Steely Frosted Luster, Incredible Strike, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. This gorgeous 1859 F-107 dime certainly presents all the hallmarks of a superb gem. Acquired during 2011 and a resident of the my core Liberty Seated dime set until recently graded with a spectacular Newtown Collection piece. This dime is incredibly well balanced. Luster is best described as steely with frosted textures. Strike is absolutely hammered with elevated motifs on both sides. Rose-gray and blue toning should be readily evident from the images. This is a potential selection for the With Stars position in a high end type set or finding a home in an advanced date and mint mark project. Regardless of your collecting goal, this lovely gem will meet expectations. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
1860	MS64	PCGS 03606412	F-101a	Gem	$950	Business Strike from Proof Dies, Steely Frosted Luster, Vibrant Cartwheels, Eye Appeal, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. Yet another case where GFRC photography leaves much to be desired. The gorgeous 1860 F-101a dime has fabulous steely frosted luster with some mirror reflectance under angled lighting. This is to be expected as circulation strikes were made from the proof die pair with the (a) die variety suffix. The holder is also old and worn which further detracts the camera with plastic haze spots. Trust me that this piece is worthy of its gem quality rating. If not promptly sold, I will cross this one into the new CAC Grading holder to let the visuals properly "breath" as the toning is a pretty deep rose-blue. As a reminder, this is the F-101a plate coin within The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder.
1860	MS64	NGC 366908007	TOP #47 F-106	Choice	$900	Doubled Lips, Brilliant Frosted Luster, Near-Gem, Top 100 Varieties, Lakeland Collection. 1860 Philadelphia struck Seated dimes included one obverse die with notable die doubling. That doubling is easily seen within the legend lettering and along with Liberty having "double lips" as every important variety needs a catchy name. This "doubled lips" example showcases the new James Longacre design hub with a delicately engraved central device that is easily prone to wear. Surfaces are covered with continuous mint bloom leading to brilliant frosted luster and swirling cartwheels. An ideal candidate for inclusion in the Top 100 Liberty Seated dime die variety set courtesy of the Lakeland Collection. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2023) holder.
1860-S	MS63	PCGS 60158271	F-102	Choice	$9500	Choice Original, Newtown Collection. Steely gray surfaces underlay mottled russet patina, with additional shades of gold color evident on the reverse. The fields are perfectly original and hairline-free, while the overall flash is consistent with the assigned grade. F-102, with the date punched to the left, much closer to the tip of the shield than the F-101. The CAC census indicates 33 pieces total, with three coins at MS63 and four examples finer. The PCGS report is not far behind, with five coins noted at MS63 and four pieces higher. The CAC guide value is $9,900. Uncirculated examples of Liberty Seated branch Mint pieces prior to the 1870s are typically challenging, as collectors of the period cared little about mintmarks. Certain branch Mint issues are completely unknown in Mint State, while others, such as the present coin, are numbered in the single digits. Housed in a PCGS Gen 4.2 (2004) holder with CAC approval.
1861 Type 1 Obverse	MS66+	PCGS 81962495	F-103	Gem	$4250	Gem Original, Newtown Collection. Brilliant, frosted luster booms from the largely untoned surfaces of this Legend Obverse example. Swirling cartwheels highlight a few flecks of charcoal patina, and the overall flash is easily consistent with the near-Superb Gem technical grade. F-103, with the date and ONE DIME lightly impressed. CAC notes four pieces at MS66 with none higher. The introduction of new hubs beginning in 1859 solved some striking issues and created others. The bow knot is now nicely detailed, but the stalk to the upper left is soft. Regardless, the exceptional luster is easily the first focal point of this appealing Philadelphia piece. The CAC price guide value is $3,000. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
1861 Type 2 Obverse	MS65	PCGS 29561164		Choice	$1250	Near-Gem Original, Dallas Collection.. Multi-hued rim toning reveals concentric rings of evergreen and russet patina that surround frosty centers on both sides. Die polish lines are evident, as struck, and a few horizontal hairlines are present in the right obverse field. The head is fully formed, while the upper left portion of the reverse is softly impressed. Type II obverse, with three sets of verticals above shield ribbon. The overall eye appeal is strong, and the colorful rim toning delivers the “look” preferred by many collectors. Housed in PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) Dupont hologram holder.
1861-S	MS62	PCGS 38969894	F-102	Choice	$10500	Choice Original, Newtown Collection. Brilliant, frosted luster hosts the barest hints of lemon-yellow and russet toning, while moderate cartwheels are consistent with the MS62 designation. This is a semi-key issue, produced to the extent of 172,500 pieces. As is typical, uncirculated examples of early San Francisco pieces are challenging, with 11 total Mint State pieces reported by PCGS. At the MS62 level, PCGS notes three examples with five pieces finer. F-102, with the first 1 in the date centered over two dentils. The PCGS price guide gives a value of $6,000 in MS60 and $22,500 in MS63. Uncirculated branch Mint pieces are among the most desirable examples within the Liberty Seated series, and the condition rarity of this piece will create significant interest. Ex. GFRC. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder.
1863-S	MS63	PCGS 30032523		Choice	$10500	Condition Census San Francisco Civil War Date, Brilliant Frosted Luster, Complete Strike, Osprey Collection. Locating any of the San Francisco Civil War Seated dime dates in CAC approved Mint State is always noteworthy. The issues from 1861 through 1867 are well known for having been heavily circulated in western frontier commerce. Few strictly original Mint State survivors are known and an acquisition prize for passionate collectors of the series. I well know myself. The Osprey Collection is proud to present the Tom Bender specimen that flew below the radar screen at a recent Heritage auction. A superb example with granular frosted luster and a complete strike. The ebony specks in the upper left obverse field are a further testament to the incredible originality. Those pursuing the finest Liberty Seated collections should take note of this opportunity. CAC population is 27 in all grades. There are three approved at the offered grade with two finer, one of which is housed in the Fortin Collection. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2022) holder with CAC approval and Tom Bender Collection pedigree on label.
1863-S	MS61	NGC 4333591036	F-101	Original	$3950	Challenging Civil War S-Mint, Brilliant Frosted Luster, Peripheral Gold, Mountaineer Collection. As the Civil War raged in the eastern United States, the San Francisco Mint was busy generating small denomination coinage for west coast commerce. 1863 strikes were the lowest for the 1861 to 1865 period at 157,500. The arrival of a Mint State example to market is always noteworthy as is the case here. This is a frosted example that emits reasonable luster that is consistent with the grade. Light peripheral copper-gold frames the untoned centers. There is a scratch in the upper left wheat that deserves mention along with a few obverse micro lines. Strike is better than average with complete gown line, clasp, along with a nearly complete head definition. Housed in new large font NGC holder.
1864	MS66	PCGS 35690560	F-102a	Gem	$15000	Gem Original, Newtown Collection. Lightly mirrored, reflective luster penetrates the thick colorful toning of this Civil War piece. Aqua and russet patina predominate, with neon shades additionally present above the figure of Liberty. F-101a, with a defect at the upper right of O(NE), the same reverse die as used in 1863. Clashing is evident beneath DIME. This piece is tied for finest known at CAC with three other pieces. The overall CAC population is 24 pieces, and the CAC price guide is $7,200. Ex. GFRC. This piece represent yet another exceptional gem from the Newtown consignor, a pedigree that will long be remembered among Seated dime specialists. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
1864-S	AU55	PCGS 31594082	F-101	Original	$1500	Civil War San Francisco Issue, Thick Frosted Luster, Speckled Gray Toning, Twin Lakes Collection. Consignor Price Reduction. When any of the Civil War San Francisco dates appear on the market in higher AU grades, collectors will take notice. Such is the case for the Twin Lakes 1864-S offering. This piece features thick mint bloom across both sides resulting in a frosted luster experience during bright light inspection. Some specked gray appears on the obverse periphery while the reverse less so. Strike is typical of the issue with weak head details. An obverse line in the lower wreath precludes a higher quality rating. Housed in PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) holder.
1867	MS66	PCGS 27350656	F-102	Gem	$5500	Gem Original, Newtown Collection. Rich evergreen and aqua patina fills the fields of this low-mintage piece, produced to the extent of only 6,000 pieces. Surfaces are lightly mirrored, and the die clashing in the obverse fields confirms the business strike designation. Collectors of the 19th century generally preferred proofs, but the situation evolved as numismatists began to appreciate the differences between proofs and Mint State pieces. With the census data available to today's collectors, it is clear that Mint State pieces are decidedly more desirable. This is a nicely struck example, with a completely full head and definition in the bow knot. F-102, with a downward sloping date and die doubling to the right of the wreath. CAC has certified eight pieces in MS66 and four higher, all at MS67. The CAC guide value is $6,750. Housed in a PCGS Gen 4.6 (2013-2014) holder with CAC approval.
1867-S	MS62	PCGS 31940984	F-102	Choice	$3150	Important San Francisco Date, Brilliant Frosted Luster, Choice Original, City By The Bay Collection. Ex. Newtown Collection. Steely, frosted luster produces vibrant cartwheels atop the surfaces of this semi-key San Francisco piece. Russet patina inhabits the left portion of each side, while lilac shades are present to the right. The strike is soft, with flatness evident at the head. F-102, with a high date and die defect in the upper left portion of (DI)M(E). The San Francisco Mint struck 140,000 pieces in this year, and Mint State survivors are few. PCGS notes a single piece in MS62 and eight coins finer, the highest at MS65. Housed in a PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) Dupont hologram holder.
1867-S	AU50	PCGS 39489448	F-102	Original	$1500	Scarce Date & Grade, Olive-Rose Patina, Near Choice Original, AuburnNY Accordian Collection. 1867 brought the final year of low mintage Liberty Seated dimes at the western frontier San Francisco Mint. A total of 140,000 pieces were struck for local commerce. Few survivors are known in AU or better grades. Current PCGS population in all AU grades is a scant 18 pieces with some being resubmissions. GFRC is pleased to be offering an AU50 example from the AuburnNY Accordian Collection. Surfaces are near-choice and covered with an olive-rose patina that is consistent on both sides. Struck with later die state dies as die erosion and die clashing are seen under 10c loupe. Strike is typical for the date with some weakness at the head and upper left reverse wreath. Bright inspection reveals some residual steely luster under the toning. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 holder. If attempting to build a Seated dime date/mintmark set, this piece would fit in nicely due to originality.
1867-S	AU50	PCGS 20743589	F-102	Original	$1750	Rare Grade, Soft Steely Luster, Original, City By The Bay Collection. Arriving from the City By The Bay Collection is an original 1867-S duplicate that should garner promptly attention. Pervasive grey-rose patina is layered on both sides. Traces of mint frost are seen in the protected areas including the around the reverse motifs. Angled lighting presents soft steely luster. A few micro marks and lines are evident. A mintage of only 140,000 that circulated extensively in the western frontier. PCGS has certified only five at grade with no CoinFacts auction records since 2012. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.5 (2012-2013) holder.
1868	MS64	PCGS 82960254	F-101	Choice	$1350	Near-Gem Original, Newtown Collection. Thick, frosted luster covers the untoned fields, with only a bit of smoky patina evident at the date. Bright surfaces suggest an old dipping, precluding CAC consideration, but the coin remains well within the PCGS standard. The strike is excellent, with a full head and sharp sprigs within the wreath. F-101, with die clashing behind the date and circular lathe lines evident within the central figure. Lathe lines are unusual on 19th century coinage and clearly point a finger at the engraver, who normally would have smoothed these out before submitting the die to the coiner. PCGS has approved 15 coins in MS64 with 11 pieces finer. The PCGS price guide value is $1,500. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder.
1868	AU58	PCGS 35602489	F-111	Choice	$450	Scarce Grade, Frosty White, Complete Strike, Twin Lakes Collection. Consignor Price Reduction. I really don't think that 1868 Philadelphia strikes secure the respect deserved in AU or better. Many struck found their way to Europe and returning in rolls with problem surfaces. This Twin Lakes AU58 example needs to garner attention for its rich frosted luster and complete strike. Cartwheel action is vibrant and better than expect for the certified grade. Surfaces are untoned with a high probability of being dipped at one point. Please have a close look at the images if in the market for this date. Few better have appeared on the GFRC price list. PCGS population is only 4 at grade. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder.
1868-S	MS63	PCGS 83647445	F-101	Choice	$2500	Rare Grade, Satiny Luster, Speckled Ebony-Rose, City By The Bay Collection. Low Civil War era San Francisco mintages continued during 1868 with only 260,000 pieces struck. As with all issue from 1861 through 1868, the appearance of Mint State examples is noteworthy in today's market. PCGS has certified only 6 at the MS63 level. This example features satiny luster which is typical of the issue given heavily worn dies and metal flow lines into the denticles. Faint ebony-rose speckled toning is evident on the obverse while the less so with faint gold. Strike is complete, though not bold, again consistent with the issue and die state. Fans of the Liberty Seated dime series are presented with an important opportunity based on this City By The Bay Collection release. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder.
1869-S	MS63	PCGS 39592221	F-102	Choice	$1385	Important San Francisco Reconstruction Era Date, Brilliant Frosty Luster, Complete Strike, City By The Bay Collection. 1869 brought the inauguration of Ulysses S. Grant as president of the United States along with Wall Street operators attempting to corner the gold market which nearly took down the entire U.S. economy in what became known as Black Friday. On the west coast, Seated dime production rose to 450,000 pieces with a few more coins being saved in Mint State condition. This important survivor is a City By The Bay Collection duplicate and is being released to the market. Its brilliant frosted luster is readily evident under angled lighting along with moderate cartwheels. Strike has been fully executed on this F-102 die pairing with a small thin S mintmark. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with 10 certified at grade.
1869-S	AU50	PCGS 36240357	F-102	Choice	$525	New May 7! Near-Gem Original, Oregon Beaver Collection.. An exceptionally well preserved 1869-S F-102 example with crusty gray patina on both sides. Mint frost surrounds the legend, reverse wreath and is found inside the gown folds. Residual luster has a steely texture. Reverse die is starting to exhibit die erosion that results in thick "orange peel" fields during later die states. Fully struck without any blemishes worthy of mention. CAC has only approved a total of 30 in all grades with two at the AU50 level. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
1869-S	AU50	PCGS 20419957	F-101	Original	$485	Underrated Date/Grade, Strictly Original, Gun Metal Gray, Accurately Graded.. A no question original 1869 San Francisco strike with uniform gun metal gray patina that includes faint rose under bright light. Surfaces are essentially blemish free with only a tiny mark at O(N)E being shared for full accuracy. A challenging date in AU grades that is so underrated in AU and above grades. CoinFacts indicates that only (4) examples have been graded by PCGS at the AU50 level with (3) in AU53. Auction records at this grade level at almost non existent. PCGS price guide is $500 at AU50 level for reference. Handled for a second time at GFRC after being recently upgraded in an advanced collection. Housed in older PCGS blue label holder with standard ring insert. If building a Seated dime set, please don't miss this opportunity.
1871-S	MS64	NGC 1620394003	F-102	Choice	$5500	Challenging Date and Grade, Partially Mirrored, Golden Reflective Luster, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. It pains me to release this choice original 1871-S dime that has been in the reference collection since purchased from Jason Carter at the 2002 Winter Fun show. This date has a small mintage of 320,000 coins with few MInt State survivors known. Adding to the challenge are the three die pairings with weak S reverses. This F-102 example was struck with left over dies from 1869 and 1870 with the reverse being smartly polished before usage resulting in low relief devices. The die polishing leads to partially mirrored fields and lightly frosted motifs. The obverse is also proof like but not the extent of the reverse. Bright light viewing exposes the mirrored fields and light golden-green coloration. I've held on to this dime for years as an upgrade was never located. This is the F-102 plate coin at The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference. Housed in NGC Gen 9 (2001-2003) holder with a CAC attempt. The fields are much too mirrored and atypical for CAC approval.
1872	AU Details	PCGS 37567993	TOP #58 F-109	Original	$650	Scarce Proof Strike, Misplaced 2 Digit in Base, Greer Plate Coin, Original Surfaces, Ancient Rim Filiing, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. Brian Greer plate coin. The 1872 F-109 and F-109a die varieties features a misplaced 2 digit in base. F-109 catalogs the very scarce proof strike while F-109a captures subsequent circulation strikes. This variety was discovered by Kam Ahwash, as a proof strike, and first listed by Greer. It is further listed as part of the Top 100 Varieties set. The offered example was purchased directly from Brian Greer during December 1992 and has remained in raw condition in my collection until recent grading. A no question proof strike that would grade PF62. However, there is an ancient rim filing below the date that is completely toned over and was not noticed until the piece came back with a PCGS Details grade. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 holder with Rim Damage, AU Details. The 1872 F-109 plate coin at The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors commonly known as the Seated Dime web-book. The 1872 F-109 variety is also listed in the Top 100 Varieties set. Definitely a piece of numismatic history regardless of the ancient rim filing.
1872	MS65	PCGS 81252594	F-102	Gem	$2750	New May 7! Gem Original, Gerry Fortin Core Collection Duplicate.. A wonderful gem Philadelphia strike that approaches the upper bounds of Mint State availability with its CAC approval. The CAC population includes only 4 at grade with 3 finer. This 1872 dime is simply superb with frosty rose gold patina across the obverse and lighter gold on the reverse. Strike is absolutely hammered including fully defined grains in the upper left wreath. Unabraded with brilliant frosted luster. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
1873 No Arrows, Open 3	MS61	PCGS OGH 7426198	F-102	Choice	$950	Choice Original, Newtown Collection. Steely fields reveal moderate luster, consistent with the lower-MS designation. Marks are minimal, and the surfaces are exceptionally smooth for the grade. A background of silver-gray patina underlays light gold color within the figure of Liberty, while high points are more deeply shaded. The No Arrows, Open 3 coins were struck between February and March 1873, after the date style changed and before the April 1st Coinage Act resulted in the addition of arrows at the date, to signify a minor change in weight. F-102, with a die line through the husk at the far right. The PCGS population is one piece in MS61, with 19 coins higher. The PCGS price guide value is $1,000 in MS60, going up to $2,250 in MS63. Ex. Birmingham Collection, via GFRC. Housed in a PCGS Gen 3.0 (1990-1993) green label holder.
1873 No Arrows, Open 3	AU55	NGC 679039015	F-103	Choice	HOLD $475	Open 3, Brilliant Frosted Luster, Slightly Better Die Pairing, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. 1873 No Arrows Open 3 dimes just don't get any respect… With a mintage of only 60,000, one would expected a higher valuation. But some varieties, even in the Redbook, are not pursued as aggressively as others. Fortin research has identified four obverse and reverse dies with multiple die marriages indication small production runs if the stated mintage is accurate. The F-103 die pairing captures Obverse 2 and Reverse C together. A low date (the 1 digit almost touches the denticle) and some sheild die lines are the first attribution step. This offering is the F-103 plate coin within the Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference and offers brilliant frosted luster active cartwheels. Light wear on the high points and scattered micro-marks are consistent with the grade. I know for certain that this dime has not be to CAC but the limited toning probably precludes a green bean. Fairly priced for the Open 3 variety. Housed in NGC Gen 7 (1997-2000) holder. 1999 Summer ANA
1873 No Arrows, Closed 3	AU55	PCGS 82197164	F-103a	Choice	$225	Repunched Date, Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection.. This is a wholesome 1873 F-103a lot with easily observed reverse die cracks. The digits in the date exhibit obvious repunching. Repunching is seen at the bottom left of each digit. There is a diagonal die line in the lower right gown. Examples of the F-103 die paring are typically seen with strong strikes, including full heads, regardless of die state. This Vitale Collection example offers frosted luster that is somewhat muted by a moderate crust of silver-gray patina. Surfaces are nearly unabraded and pleasing. A solid example that will please the winning bidder. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder.
1873 With Arrows	AU50	ANACS OWH 780668	F-112	Original	$250	Die Scratch In Wreath, Lightly Mirrored Fields, Rose-Gold Toning, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. 1873 With Arrows Reverse K is notable for having a bold die scratch across the lower right wreath oak leaves. This reverse is paired with two obverse dies. Offered here is the second die pairing with the obverse die position shift right. This pleasing AU example exhibits rose-gold coloration and lightly mirrored fields. Surfaces are unabraded. Purchased at the 2002 FUN show and hiding in the bank box after being upgraded. Yet another reference collection piece that needs a new home. Housed in ANACS old white holder.
1874 With Arrows	AU50	raw	F-102	Choice	$210	Choice Original, Misplaced Digit in Denticles, Light Gray, Silver Luster.. I've studied this dime carefully given the PCGS opinion of Code 97 Environmental Damage/AU Details. The fields and devices are nearly problem free with no obvious signs of porosity or marks. Due to paper envelope storage, the surfaces have acquired a deep rose gray patina that is darker on the obverse than reverse. Rims are bold and indicates that this dime saw limited circulation. My assessment is that this dime is not strictly original due to the surface "sheen". A circulated dime that is strictly original should offer dull gray or gray/brown surfaces rather than the glossy gray/rose coloring seen here. Having said that, this piece should be "market acceptable" due to rarity and the essentially mark free surfaces. A stereo microscope review with bright light source reveals some extremely faint surface porosity that was not seen with a 10x loupe.
1875	MS66+	PCGS 25684934	F-121	Gem	$1500	Gem Original, Newtown Collection. Rich, frosted luster imparts swirling cartwheels atop the untoned fields of this flashy piece. Well-struck, with a near-complete head and split bow knot, if not fully so. F-121, the so-called "chin whiskers" variety with die flashing beneath the chin, and radial die lines to the right of the shield. CAC notes 18 pieces in MS66 and eight higher, all in MS67. The CAC guide value is $1,150. While the population at this grade level is higher than many other Seated dimes, the flip side is that a near-Superb Gem 19th century piece can be acquired at a reasonable cost. Ex. Winesteven Collection, via GFRC purchase. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
1875	MS65	PCGS 18084393	F-103	Gem	$675	Excessively Rusted Obverse, Gem Original, Newtown Collection. The 1875 F-103 die pairing is easily attributed by an excessively rusted obverse die. This PCGS MS65 example presents gem surfaces including frosted cartwheel luster. Obverse is toned an even copper gold while the reverse is covered by a thick gray skin. Device details, within the GFRC images, are limited by an excessively rusted obverse die while the darker reverse toning provides limited contrast between fields and motifs. Fairly graded and housed in PCGS 2015 Ge 5.0 Dupont hologram holder with CAC approval.
1875	MS64	PCGS 38778751	F-106	Choice	$625	Rare Misplaced 5 in Base Variety, Reflective Luster, Near-Gem. As a collector assembling the later published The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors, I searched for over a decade for the 1875 F-106 misplaced 5 in the base specimen. The Greer plate coin was the only example known to me. Since operating GFRC, I've seen a few others including an MS65 specimen. I remain thrilled to be handling this lovely MS64 example for a second time. A fully struck specimen with lightly mirrored fields and a semi-transparent layer of faint gray-rose patina. The misplaced 5 digit is well defined in the base. I'm going with a JUST BUY IT NOW recommendation at the asking price. Treat yourself and add this special offering to a collection! Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder.
1875	AU55	PCGS 81637666	F-118	Choice	$150	Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection.. A colorfully toned 1875 dime that secured a spot in the Vitale Collection auction sale though being a lower priced offering. Fully choice with steely fields under the thick patina. Perfect as a With Legend type piece or other collecting reason that could garner a bid. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder.
1875-CC In Wreath	MS65	PCGS 02251270	F-111a	Gem	$3400	Gem Original, Newtown Collection. This Mintmark in Wreath example exhibits glowing, satiny luster and vibrant cartwheels, exceptionally so for an MS65 example. Surfaces reveal original silver patina, with varying sprays of maroon color at the rims. F-111a, with a high date sloping down from left to right, and a vertical die crack extending from the corn ear to the right. A rim cud is developing above the wreath opening at the top. The CAC population in MS65 is 11 pieces, with five coins in higher grades. The CAC price guide value is $3,300. The eye appeal of this example is strong for the grade, and a more aggressive price point is easily warranted. Ex. GFRC. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
1875-CC In Wreath	AU50	PCGS 33780134	F-107b	Original	$385	Near-Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection.. 1875-CC dimes have been one of my favorite dates since the early days of constructing The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Variety Collectors which was released during 2004. This In Wreath F-107b specimen was a pleasant surprise as few have been seen in several decades. The F-107b designation documents a greased fill die event where Liberty's head and shoulder are effaced to different degrees as the grease was worked out of the coin press. The Vitale specimen has a partial head with divot at the neck plus a partial shoulder. The reverse die crack in the left wreath is bold and consistent with the variety. Surface emit a silky frost with ample brilliance at the certified grade. Light gold patina is also present. A wonderful example of a rare die state that is worth aggressive pursuit. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder.
1876 Type 1 Reverse	MS64	NGC 332855013		Gem	HOLD $500	New May 24! Partially Mirrored Fields, Exceptional Toning, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. A marvelous 1876 Type 1 F-111 dime that was purchased February 1996 from a younger Jason Carter who was working for Heritage at the time. Jason would review incoming shipments and pull the better Seated dimes and ship to me for the die variety research effort. This example offers partially mirrored fields with gorgeous toning. Centers are bluish-gray and surrounded by peripheral gold. Surfaces are close to pristine too. This piece has not been to CAC but has a very strong chance of approval based on its origins and overall quality. Also found as the plate coin within The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference. Housed in NGC 5 (1992-1995) holder with the reverse hologram label completely intact since residing in a bank box for decades.
1876-CC	MS64+	PCGS 38184992	F-132	Gem	$1650	New May 7! Gem Original, Oregon Beaver Collection.. Generous luster radiates from the surfaces of this GFRC-Gem dime, and the in-hand flash is considerable. Bits are maroon color are scattered at the rims, complemented by brilliant centers. Well-struck, with separation evident in the hair braids. F-132, a distinct variety with the date sharply sloping downward. CAC has certified 100 examples total, with 16 coins finer. The CAC price guide value is $1,420 in MS64 and $1,950 in MS65. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
1876-CC Type 1 Reverse	MS64	PCGS 38669512	F-101	Choice	$900	Heavily Rusted Obverse, Near-Gem Original, Lightly Toned. A spectacular example of the 1876-CC F-101 die pairing with excessively rusted obverse and cracked reverse. With it's hammered strike, this near-gem specimen displays all obverse diagnostics including every minute rust pit, center die bulging, and rim cuds throughout the extreme periphery. Reverse die cracks are immediately evident under a 10x loupe. Faint speckled rose-gold coloring is seen at the obverse legend and date. A wonderful offering for the die variety specialist. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 holder and add to The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors as the new F-101 web-book plate coin.
1876-CC Type 1 Reverse	MS62	PCGS 21620019	F-116	Original	$595	Lightly Rusted Die, Doubled Die Reverse, Rich Frosty Luster, Near Choice Original, Hammered Strike, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. The 1876-CC F-116 die pairing presents yet another set of Carson City dies that are lightly rusted. This variety is straightforward to attribute by the die rust and boldly doubled I in DIME. The centennial Liberty Seated dime offers rich frosty luster and a hammered strike. Surfaces are steely gray and perfectly original. The F-116 plate coin within The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online web-book. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.1 (2005) holder. No CAC attempt. From the Gerry Fortin Referene Collection.
1876-CC Type 1 Reverse	MS62	PCGS 21549290	TOP #74 F-111	Choice	$1000	Misplaced 76 Digits, Choice Original, Satiny Cartwheel Luster, Eye Appeal Consistent with Higher Grade, Top 100 Varieties, Newtown Collection. Price Reduction June 2020 - Ex. Central California Collection. Misplaced 76 Digits in Gown die variety that is always popular with collectors. This lovely example offers satiny cartwheel luster that is consistent with a higher grade level. Obverse is covered with thin rose, aquamarine and blue patina while the reverse is mostly aquamarine and rose. Why the MS62 assigned grade? There are a few wispy hairlines in the right obverse field that were grade limiting against 1990s grading standards but allowed today up to the MS64 grade level. This dime is conservatively graded and housed in old PCGS blue label holder that dates back to the late 1990s. While residing in the Central California and Newtown Collections, this piece was never submitted to CAC and will heading for a review during the next GFRC submission. A choice duplicate from the Newtown Collection that will be pleasing to the new owner. Also an important die variety within the Top 100 Varieties set.
1876-S Type 1 Reverse	MS64	PCGS 21700876	F-124	Choice	$700	F-124 Web-Book Plate Coin, Complete Strike, Frosty Golden Luster, Scarce Grade, Underrated in Mint State, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. The identification of 1876 San Francisco dies is an ongoing process that will continue for years due to large mintage. The F-124 die pairing was identified during October 2017. The presence of a huge die blog defect on Liberty's lower leg was quite evident during routine inspection. The F-124 reverse die has either been weakly hubbed or was lapped at some point in its life. The offered example is the 1876-S Type 1 Reverse F-124 plate coin at The Definitive Resource for the Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors aka, Seated dime web-book. A well balanced near-gem MInt State example with frosty golden luster and swirling cartwheels. Strike is complete with bold obverse device and center reverse. The left and right wreath devices were most likely poorly hubbed during working die preparation. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.1 (2002-2004) holder. Old time quality will please the new owner.
1876-S Type 1 Reverse	MS64	PCGS 13006413	F-115	Choice	$650	Underrated in Mint State, Copper-Gold Patina, Frosted Luster, Dallas Collection. Where are all the Mint State 1876-S dimes given a mintage of over 10,000,000? Yes, this date is underrated with only 24 pieces certified at the offered grade. The issue circulated heavily along with poor strikes. The Dallas Collection is releasing a copper-gold toned example with granular frosted luster. Cartwheel action is vibrant, especially on the lighter toned reverse. Doubling on the center reverse is the primary attribution point for F-115 along with date placement. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder.
1876-S Type 1 Reverse	MS64	PCGS 21524321	F-123	Choice	$800	Thick Frosted Luster, Complete Strike, Near-Gem, Ex. Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. 1876 San Francisco strikes are yet another case where present day survivors, in choice Mint State, are a tiny fraction of the overall mintage. With a mintage of over 10 million, hundreds of Mint State pieces should have been graded at this point. However, the total CAC approved population stands at 37 with seven at the MS64 level indicating that most went into circulation and remained there for years. This near-gem survivor was purchased May 2004 and has been a long-term guest in the Fortin bank box. CAC approval was secured during 2014. This is a frosted piece with golden obverse shades and bluish green on the reverse. Strike is above average for the date as many were minted from worn dies. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.1 (2003-2004) holder with CAC approval. A fresh GFRC buyback.
1876-S Type 1 Reverse	MS62	NGC 563400004	F-108	Original	$300	Crusty Original, Steely Fields, Above Average Strike, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. Another Fortin reference collection offering that needs a new home. The Type 1 reverse F-108 example presents thick crusty surfaces that are overlaid on top of steely fields. Angled lighting reveals some muted steely luster. 1876-S dime are notorious for being weakly or partially struck includes the use of reworked dies. This example was struck from pristine dies and is unabraded. The thick patina and muted luster resulted in the technical grade. Fairly priced. Housed in NGC Gen 7 (1997-2000) holder. August 2002
1877 Type 1 Reverse	MS64	PCGS 41468390		Choice	$650	Lazy D(I)ME, Thick White Mint Frost, Brilliant Luster, Vibrant Cartwheels, Massachusetts Collection. Ex. Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. This Massachusetts Collection duplicate has a storied past as the 1877 Type 1 reverse F-107 plate coin within The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference. It was sold into this collection followed by being crossed by the consignor into a new PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2022) holder. The original GFRC description reads as follows; "1877 Philadelphia strikes have a huge mintage of over 7,000,000 but locating choice Mint State examples will be challenging. One would expect to see many offered on the market place at any one time but that is not the case. Offered here is a brilliant frosted example from my reference collection and the Type 1 reverse F-107 web-book plate coin. Strike is hammered with bold devices including upper reverse wreath grains and the corn ears. Under a light source, cartwheel luster is quite vibrant." The F-107 die variety can be easily attributed by a lazy I in DIME. Purchased January 2001 and in the Fortin collection until being sold during December 2018.
1877 Type 2 Reverse	MS64	NGC 581570422	F-103	Choice	$535	Brilliant Frosted Luster, Bold Strike, Creamy Silver with Hints of Gold, Near Gem, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. A well struck 1877 Type 2 F-103 arrives to the market after being sheltered in a bank box since early 2001. This dime brings tons of frosted luster along with unabraded fields other than a single roller line on the upper left obverse. Dazzling cartwheels further aid overall eye appeal. Part of the Fortin reference collection and the F-103 plate coin within The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online resource. Fairly priced towards finding a new home. Housed in NGC Gen 7 (1997-2000) holder,
1877-CC Type 2 Reverse	MS66+	PCGS 42140031	F-110	Gem	$4250	Superb Gem, Frosted Luster, Fully Struck, Golden-Gray Patina, Shattered Reverse. As a dealer, I see a host of Seated coins with many being subjected to past poor treatments. On occasion, a superb gem with perfectly original surfaces appears. So was the case at Summer FUN 2021 and the purchase of this 1877-CC Type2 F-110 dime. Steely fields and natural reflective luster are initial highlights during bright light inspection. Toning is a combination of silver-gray with peripheral gold plus aquamarine on the obverse. Strike is hammered when considering the die pairing and shattered reverse. What appeals to me the most is the thick natural patina that is semi-transparent to the underlying luster. Trust me on this piece, it is a exceptional example for the grade, else I would not have added to GFRC inventory. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2021) holder with CAC approval.
1877-CC Type 2 Reverse	MS66+	PCGS 82248282		Gem	$4500	Gem Original, Newtown Collection. Brilliant centers lead to pleasing pastel shades of blue and rose at the rims, and the overall eye appeal is strong. Dancing cartwheels radiate from the frosted luster, producing in-hand flash that is substantial. This is an unlisted variety, with a die crack across the wreath opening. CAC has certified 22 pieces in MS66 and two coins higher, both at MS67. The CAC price guide value is $4,220. This is an exceptional piece that will draw significant interest. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval and D.L. Hansen pedigreed label.
1877-S	MS64	NGC 1951344013		Choice	$875	Repunched Date, Steely-Frosted Luster, Peripheral Orange-Gold, Top 100 Varieties. Though sporting a mintage of over two million, 1877 San Francisco strikes are darn difficult in Choice AU and especially Mint State. Recently acquired in trade is this important F-101 example in NGC MS64. This is a brilliant piece with steely frosted luster and a ring of gold at the rims. Adding to the delight is a full strike, which is not always a certainty for this date. The repunching above the feet of the 1 digit is crystal clear while the reverse has a polished die weakness in the lower left wreath. The PCGS and CAC guide agree that a premium example is valued at $1500, therefore this choice example is more than fairly priced. Housed in NGC Gen 14 (2004-2007) holder.
1877-S	AU50	PCGS 33809779	F-101	Choice	$135	Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection.. A nicely original example of the 1877-S F-101 die pairing. The F-101 repunching is visible above the left and right feet of 1 digit and within the lower loop of the 8 digit on earlier date state examples. This Vitale Collection lot does not exhibit the repunching under 10x so bid accordingly. Surfaces are tone an even antique gray with soft frosted luster. Choice surfaces are pleasing. Note the dark area surrounding the reverse denomination is surface "dirt". Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder.
1878 Type 2 Reverse	PR65	PCGS 33723041	F-101	Gem	$985	New May 24! Reflective Mirrors, Even White, Complete Strike. 800 proof strikes were produced in 1878 with all being coined from a single Type 2 reverse die pairing. This accurately graded survivor offerings essentially unblemished surfaces with brilliant reflectance. An even white colored example with boldly struck motifs. All 1878 proof strikes will have die rust pits in the lower right gown and a die line in the lower right wreath. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2023) holder.
1878 Type 2 Reverse	MS66	PCGS 40880804	F-109	Gem	$3500	Gem Original, Newtown Collection. Partially mirrored fields reveal brilliant luster and swirling cartwheels, while the frosty devices contrast nicely with the semi-prooflike surfaces. Both sides are nearly untoned, with only a few bits of copper color evident, mostly at the high points. F-109, with a die line in the gown above the pendant. Nicely struck, with strong bow detail. CAC report three coins in MS66, two examples in MS67, and a single piece finer at MS68. The CAC price guide in MS66 is $1,880. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2022) holder with CAC approval.
1878-CC Type 2 Reverse	AU Details	ANACS 5048617	TOP #79 F-104	Market Acceptable	$625	Polished and Cracked Reverse, Top 100 Varieties #79, Charcoal Gray Patina, Well Struck, Conservative Grading, Lakewood Collection. The 1878-CC F-104 die variety results when a heavily lapped and shattered reverse die from 1877 (Type II Reverse A) is paired with one of the two known obverse dies for Carson City strikes. 1877-CC Type II Reverse A die was previously paired with at least two obverse dies during 1877 production. During the pairing with the 1877-CC F-110 obverse, the reverse die is severely cracked. Kam Ahwash speculates that the reverse die shattered, taking away the lower left ribbon and part of the bottom of the left maple leaf. After studying the 1877-CC Type II Variety 110 coin and several 1878-CC shattered reverse coins, I believe that this die was severely polished or lapped throughout its face to produce the remaining coinage needed in 1878. There is reduction in details throughout die relief, not only in the lower left wreath area. A shattering or cracking of the die in the lower wreath would have produced retained metal, instead we find a smooth polish surface with little device details in the lower left wreath. Please check 1878-CC Variety 102 and 103. Both Reverse B and C also exhibit similar weakness in the lower left wreath and left ribbon area. I suspect that all three Type II reverse dies may have been left over from 1877 and were polished or lapped before being put into service for 1878 coinage. The offered F-104 example, from the new Lakewood Collection consignor, features charcoal gray obverse toning along with steely residual luster. The reverse is 100% original with residual luster and light gray coloring. Overall strike is well executed. Housed in ANACS gold label holder and AU55 Details: Scratched - Corroded designation. I'm not in agreement with the Scratched and Corroded opinion. This piece has no signs of corrosions whatsoever and the few reverse hairlines are not worthy of a Scratched designation. The obverse has probably seen a light clean while the reverse is strictly original. The F-104 die pairing is a Top 100 Variety entry. Locating examples at the AU grade level with full defined features, as is the case here, will prove to be challenging. This piece has been net priced to a level that I believe is fair.
1878-CC Type 2 Reverse	AU53	PCGS 06640153	F-103	Choice	$1400	Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection.. This is an exceptional example of the 1878-CC F-103 die variety with a lapped reverse die resulting in weakly defined left wreath devices. For 1878 Carson City strikes, three left over 1877 Type 2 reverse dies were lapped to accomplish the balance of the year's coinage demand. Those reverse dies are consistent weak with at least a full grade difference between obverse and reverse when located in circulated grades. The F-103 is the rarest of the 1878-CC Type 2 reverse die pairings with few extant in Mint State. Steely fields are covered with a base layer of gunmetal blue-gray patina along with overlaid gold on the obverse legend and reverse wreath. Surfaces are basically unabraded except for an ancient contact mark on Liberty's head. Other than the big four Carson City dates and the 1846, I believe this 1878-CC lot is one of the most important offering of the Steven Vitale Collection. Please bid accordingly. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.5 (2012-2013) holder.
1881	PR63	PCGS 1125912	F-101	Gem	HOLD $960	New May 7! Gem Proof Strike, Gold CAC Approval.. This 1881 F-101 proof strike is yet another example of the early conservative grading that was realized during the PCGS and NGC start-up era. Brilliant reflectance is consistent on both sides and lights up blue and rose toning. At the Proof 63 grade, one should expect field hairlines but this is not the case for this fully struck example. Actually, the fields are well preserved and hairline free leading to a CAC Gold bean outcome as this lot is obviously much better than the certified grade. Housed Gen 1.2 (1986-1989) Rattler holder with Gold CAC approval.
1881	MS66	PCGS 30000442	F-101a	Gem	$4500	Heavily Frosted Surfaces, Creamy White Luster, Vibrant Cartwheels, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. A superb gem 1881 F-101a business strike with thick mint bloom resulting in creamy brilliant white luster. The vibrant cartwheels are equally compelling during bright light inspection. Strike is complete as is the case for nearly all Fortin core set pieces. Purchased during December 2003 and becoming the plate coin at The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference. 1881 Philadelphia strikes are much more difficult to locate than the prior 1879 and 1880 dates. This fact is also present for Mint State specimens. CAC has approved 18 for those dated 1881 as compared to 64 and 33 respectively for 1879 and 1880 issues. Therefore the 1881 date trades at a higher premium with superb gem certification. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.0 (1998-2002) holder with CAC approval.
1882	AU58	NGC 3832832029	F-109	Choice	$150	Better Philadelphia "Common Date", Frosty Luster, Choice Surfaces, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. Purchased during the 1999 World's Fair of Money ANA show and employed as the F-109 plate coin within the Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference. Accurately graded with frosted luster and natural gray patina. A thoroughly wholesome example that is properly illustrated by GFRC images. Housed in newer NGC holder with edge view insert.
1883	PR63	PCGS 34260899	F-103	Choice	$525	New May 15! Fully Struck, Mirrored Fields, Accurately Graded. 1883 proof Seated dime coinage is reported to have been produced with 1,039 pieces struck. This nice survivor presents mirrored fields and a complete strike. Two proof die pairings have been identified at www.seatedimevarieties.com with this F-103 variety being the more common. This example offers reflective luster that is readily available under bright light with field chatter being the grade limiter. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder.
1883	MS65	NGC 3887987021	F-118	Gem	$550	Steely Frosted Luster, Swirling Cartwheels, Hints of Gold, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection . The outgoing flow of Seated dime research pieces continues from the Fortin Collection towards ongoing upgrading of the core collection. This lovely 1883 dime exhibits granular frosted luster and swirling cartwheels. Angled lighting exposes steely fields and partial reflectance. A faint gold patina attests to the originality. Obverse strike is complete while the reverse has the usual weakness at the upper left wheat grains. Housed in newer NGC holder with edge view insert. The F-118 plate coin at The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Collectors online reference.
1884	MS67	PCGS 07420497	F-105	Gem	$2500	Gem Original, Newtown Collection. Glowing, satiny luster reveals silver-gray surfaces that exhibit a fine spray of maroon patina. As expected for the grade level, ticks are virtually non-existent and require a glass to locate. Despite the heavy production of Morgan dollars, the Mint responded to demands for small change and continued to strike dimes in ample quantities through the remainder of the Liberty Seated series. F-105, with a downward sloping date and die cracks at the exterior of the wreath. CAC notes 11 pieces in MS67, with a single example finer at MS68. The CAC price guide value is $3,000. Housed in a PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval.
1884	MS64	PCGS 10081852	F-102	Gem	$485	Gem Luster and Eye Appeal, Partial Mirrors, CAC Approval Potential, Sooner Collection. A gem 1884 Philadelphia struck Liberty Seated dime with superb reflective luster, mint frost through the primary devices that results in substantial eye appeal. Partially mirror fields generate intense luster and swirling cartwheels. This new Sooner Collection offering is mostly untoned though a thin arc of peripheral copper-gold toning validates the unquestionable originality. Surfaces are unabraded and pleasing. obverse strike suffers from typical head weakness as is common for the issue. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder.
1884-S	MS64	PCGS 30103852	F-104	Gem	$1500	Gem Original, Newtown Collection. Dancing cartwheels radiate from the brilliant, steely luster, highlighting rich russet, blue, and rose patina. A few hidden obverse lines hold back the technical grade, but the eye appeal is fully consistent with an MS65 designation. F-104, with the 1 centered over two denticles and a small mintmark. This piece has not been attempted at CAC. PCGS notes 17 pieces in MS64 with four examples higher. The PCGS price guide is $2,000 in MS64 and $5,500 in MS65. Ex. GFRC. Housed in a PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) Dupont hologram holder.
1884-S	MS63	PCGS 1392622	F-104	Choice	$1300	Small S, Sharp Steely Luster, Rose-Blue Coloration, Completed Strike, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. If strict old time originality is your cup of tea, please consider this wonderful 1884-S F-104 Mint State example. Clearly a better San Francisco date but not in the league of the 1885-S. Mintage is 564,969 with Mint State survivors being scarce. For example, PCGS has only certified 10 at the offered grade. Since housed in PCGS Gen 3.0 (1990-1993) old green holder, it might be one of the earliest examples graded at the grade. Purchased during March 2003 as part of the Seated dime research project. I've held back this one for a long time as just enjoy the sharp steely fields that are layered with rose-blue skin that screams originality. If looking for a flashy coin, this one is not for you as the skin mutes some of the luster though a bright light while exposes partial mirrors. Finally, this is the F-104 plate coin within the Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference.
1885	MS65	PCGS 21542895	F-107	Gem	$750	Gem Original, Bold Frosty Luster, Eye Appeal, Massachusetts Collection.. What a pleasing With Legend Liberty Seated dime! Motifs and fields are heavily frosted along with exhibiting a transparent faint gold patina. Strike is exceptional with complete head details and all reverse wreath elements being crisp. How I love fully struck With Legend dimes as many will be seen with partial heads and missing details in the upper left wheat grains. Dies are so lightly clashed. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.1 (2002-2003) holder.
1885	MS65	PCGS 25025400	F-104	Gem	$725	Misplaced 8 in Denticles, Gem Original, Newtown Collection. A gem F-104 Misplaced Date in Denticles die variety example. The top of an extra 8 digit is visible in the denticles directly below the normal 8 digit. This example features brilliant frosty luster and active cartwheels. Strike is essentially complete with hammered reverse devices but some weakness at the top of Liberty's head. Given that most Type 2 obverse hub strikes are generally weakly struck, this offering is above average. There are no surface abrasions worthy of mention. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.6 (2013-2014) holder with CAC approval.
1886	PR64CAM	PCGS 3758747	F-103	Choice	$925	New May 7! Near-Gem Proof, Cameo Designation. Ex. Gerry Fortin Reference Collection.. The mintage for the 1886 proof Seated dime date is quite easy to remember at 886 pieces. How clever huh? Seriously, this former Gerry Fortin reference collection dime was purchased at the 2004 August ANA show and subsequently CAC approved. This is a near-gem example with sharp reflective mirrors and light gold toning. Fields are hairline free which is the basis for the green bean sticker. This lot remains as the 1886 F-103 proof strike plate coin at The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.0 (1998-2002) holder with CAC approval.
1886	MS67	PCGS 32515469	F-113	Gem	$2900	Gem Original, Newtown Collection. Swirling cartwheels flows from the steely, frosted luster of this late-date Philadelphia piece. Medium gray patina hosts blue-green color at the rims, while light copper color is additionally evident within the wreath. F-113, with a defect in the shield at the second vertical line. This piece is tied for top honors at CAC with seven others. The CAC price guide is $3,000, a remarkably accessible price point for an example with none finer known. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
1886	MS65	PCGS 3756017	F-115	Gem	$750	Gem Original, Lustrous Pastel Toning, Fully Struck, Former Birmingham Collection.. This is the second time that GFRC has the pleasure to offer this lovely 1886 Seated dime. Initially sold out of the Birmingham Collection and now upgrade and back on the market. Pastel toning is the highlight with intermixed aquamarine, gold and rose coloring on the obverse and mottled gray, ebony and rose on the reverse. Bright light viewing exposes the luster and accentuates the colors. The overall strike is crisp with no signs of weakness. Same for blemishes as none were seen. If this dime has just a bit more flashy luster, then it would be a candidate for MS66 designation. In the current PCGS holder, it is accurately graded. Housed in old blue label PCGS holder with standard ring insert; serial number 3756017.
1886	MS65	PCGS 25268924	F-117	Gem	$650	Brilliant Satiny Luster, Vibrant Carthweels, Rose-Aquamarine Toning, Unquestionable Gem, Lakeland Collection. A fantastic 1886 F-117 offering that is consistent with the web-book plate coin. Why this piece has no CAC green bean is a mystery as it should! Die erosion produces "orange peel" surfaces resulting in brilliant satiny luster along with serious cartwheel action. Strike is 95% complete regardless of the die condition. Coloration is rose-aquamarine that melts under a bright light to expose lighter surfaces. Fully unabraded and pleasing. Housed in PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) Dupont hologram holder.
1886	MS61	NGC 3887987035	F-114	Choice	$225	Brilliant Frosted Luster, Vibrant Cartwheels, Eye of Higher Grade, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. Not one of the Fortin web-book plate coins but still a thoroughly pleasing example of the F-114 die pairing. Surfaces are heavily frosted leading to robust luster and vibrant cartwheels. Overall eye appeal is that of a higher grade though a mark in the obverse right field most likely accounts for the certified grade. Attractively priced. Housed in newer NGC holder with edge view insert.
1886	AU58	NGC 3832832039	F-116	Choice	$135	Choice Original, F-116 Web-Book Plate Coin, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. Complete description is forthcoming. Housed in newer NGC holder with edge view insert.
1886-S	AU53	PCGS 30626161	F-101	Original	$450	Near-Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection.. Brilliant frosted luster and light copper-gold toning are noted on this original 1886-S dime. Struck from the F-101 die pairing, which accounts for nearly all of the issue. Mint frost is evident in the protect areas. Several obverse hairlines preclude a higher GFRC quality rating. Housed in PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) Dupont hologram holder.
1887	PR66	PCGS 25303192	F-101	Gem	$900	Gem Original.. Price Reduction. Rich color is the hallmark of this late-date proof example, with nearly the entire spectrum represented at one point or another. The obverse exhibits deep maroon, russet, lemon, and aqua shades, while the reverse is more deeply toned with purple, blue, and burgundy patina. The strike is soft in several areas, including the head, AM(ERICA), and the ribbon. F-101, with the date punched high and sloping slightly downward, one of two proof dies for this year. PCGS has certified only three pieces finer, two at PR67 and a single piece at PR67+. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder.
1887	PR64	PCGS 85100429	F-101	Choice	$685	Choice Original, Watery Proof Fields, Light Gun Metal Gray Patina, Fully Struck, Accurately Graded, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. An absolutely original 1887 proof dime with watery mirrored fields. As in the case with most proof Seated dime, bright light viewing is required to release the natural coloring and reflective mirrors. In the case of this 1887 specimen, a light source exposes subtle sky blue and light gold on the obverse. These same colors are more pronounced on the reverse and quite attractive. A 10x loupe inspection revealed several die polish lines on the reverse that should not be mistaken for hairlines. Accurately graded and off the market for several decades. Freshly graded and housed in 2015 style PCGS holder. From the Gerry Fortin Liberty Seated Dime Reference Collection.
1887	PF65	NGC 1609507010	F-101	Gem	$1050	Watery Mirrors, Golden Peripheral Toning, Cameo Appearance, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. This is a lovely 1887 proof strike that has been the web-book plate coin at The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors since 2004. Purchased for its brilliant reflective luster and watery mirrors. Surfaces are toned a faint gold with darker shades at the periphery. Fully struck with the diagnostic die scratch through rightmost shield and lower gown folds. Housed in NGC Gen 7.0 (1997-2000) holder with standard ring insert.
1887	MS63	NGC 3739118002	F-113	Choice	$235	Attractive Golden Shades, Frosted Luster, Vibrant Cartwheels. A nicely preserved 1887 Philadelphia struck dime with pleasing golden shades and frosted luster. Luster is consistent on both sides with vibrant cartwheels during bright light inspection. Partial wire rims are noted along with "dirt" surrounding the date and lower wreath devices. Unquestionably original and pleasing. A solid F-113 example with die clashing. Housed in newer NGC holder with edge view insert.
1887	MS62	NGC 4141554002		Choice	$210	Aquamarine-Rose Patina, Brilliant Frosted Luster, Near-Gem. An unlisted 1887 Seated dime with superior eye appeal at the certified grade. If you passion is beautifully toned sliver coinage and vivid bright light eye appeal, this dime is for you!. Angled lighting exposes bright luster with frosted textures. Intermixed aquamarine-rose toning baths each side with the rose component stronger on the reverse. Completely struck with die cracks on both sides as future diagnostic points. Yes, this is a common date but in uncommon condition. Housed in newer NGC holder with edge view insert.
1887-S	MS66	PCGS 37466747	F-110	Gem	$1200	Gem Original, Steven Vitale Collection.. A single MS66 certified dime graces the Vitale Collection with fresh grading and unfortunately, an incorrect PCGS attribution. This gem 1887-S dime was struck from the F-110 die pairing and exhibits brilliant frosted luster and swirling cartwheels consistent with a superb gem certification. Intermixed rose, gold, and greens are semi-transparent to the underlying luster. Pristine surfaces are consistent with the assigned grade. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. The label documents the die variety as RPM FS-501, F-117 which is incorrect. This is not a repunched mintmark die variety.
1887-S	MS62	NGC 3887987037	F-116	Choice	$225	Hammered Strike, Rose-Gray Toning, Steely Luster, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. Fully choice with bold hammered strike and rose-gray toning. Reverse toning is a tad lighter and exposes more of the underlying steely luster. Traces of a misplaced top loop of an 8 digit appears to be present between the scroll and the immediate gown fold to the right of the shield. This artifact could be a die scratch but the shape does match the top loop of an 8 digit. Well preserved and the F-116 plate coin at The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference. This piece is finally returning to the market place after over two decades in a bank box. Housed in newer NGC holder with edge view insert. No CAC attempt has been made given the offering price point.
1888-S	MS66	PCGS 39743083		Gem	$4850	Gem Original, Newtown Collection. Moderate, steely luster produces swirling cartwheels as this San Francisco piece is rotated under a light. Gray fields hide subtle maroon color in the protected areas of the obverse, while the rims are more intensely shaded with evergreen patina. The reverse reveals blue color behind the wreath, with subtle lilac hues evident at the center. Unlisted in the Fortin web-book, with a level date and thick mintmark. Tied for finest known at CAC with six other coins. The CAC guide value is $6,750, not inexpensive, but still a reasonable value with no finer survivors known. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2022) holder with CAC approval.
1889	MS65	PCGS 45061352		Gem	$675	Glowing Satiny Luster, Superb Bright Light Eye Appeal, Lakeland Collection. A marvelous 1889 unlisted Seated dime that warrants a JUST BUY IT NOW recommendation. When I first laid eyes on this piece, the immediate thought was a CAC submission given the gem surfaces, glowing satiny luster, and oh, the beautiful toning. This dime brings on the eye appeal. The GFRC images suggest obverse finger print toning which is correct. However, my images are again worse case with the coin in hand showcasing more uniform obverse toning. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2022) holder.
1889	MS65	NGC 958035003	F-110	Gem	$985	Repunched 889, Gem Original, Golden-Aquamarine Patina, Brilliant Frosty Luster, Vibrant Cartwheels, Well Struck, Accurately Graded, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. A difficult 1889 Philadelphia die variety with repunching inside the lower loops of 88 and above the tail of the 9 digit. First listed by Fortin. This offering has to be one of the finest examples extant as I've seen few in my collecting career. Gem original surfaces are covered with semi-transparent golden-aquamarine patina. Frosty luster is brilliant with bold cartwheels during bright light viewing. The F-110 plate coin at The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors. Housed in old NGC holder with standard ring insert. Purchased April 2003 and in the Fortin collection since that time. I really hate to let this one go but all die variety dimes must be eventually sold.
1889	MS64	NGC 3102384011	F-120	Gem	$475	Gem Original, Cartwheel Luster, Aquamarine/Rose Patel Toning, Conservative Grading.. A gem original 1889 Philadelphia struck dime that is so deserving of CAC approval. Glowing cartwheel luster couple with pretty pastel colors dominate the eye appeal. Obverse strike is nicely executed while the reverse die is weak and cracked resulting in some shallow relief to the reverse strike. This piece is essentially blemish free and atttractive with GFRC images unable to capture and illustrate the overall beauty. Housed in newer NGC holder.
1889 Doubled Die Reverse	MS63	PCGS 21300803	TOP #89 F-122	Choice	$700	New May 7! Double Die Reverse #3, Choice Original, Top 100 Varieties.. Lustrous silver surfaces admit occasional shades of smoky gray patina in the protected areas, highlighted by hints of gold color here and there. Nicely struck, with a near full head and distinct detail in the left stalk. F-122, the doubled die reverse, most notably apparent at the upper left leaf, but additionally evident in O(NE) and elsewhere. The reverse die is shared with F-106, and this is a visually compelling variety, #89 on the Top-100 list (http://www.seateddimevarieties.com/major_100_table2.htm). CAC has certified 75 pieces overall. Housed in a PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval.
1889	AU58	PCGS 04430546	F-105	Choice	$235	Doubled Die Reverse #2, Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection.. Doubled Die Reverse #2 is one of five 1889 Liberty Seated dime reverse dies with obvious die doubling. The doubling on #2 is located on the outer left edge of (O)NE along with doubling on the outer edges of the maple leaves. This example is perfectly original and choice at the assigned grade level. Both sides offer uninterrupted frosty cartwheel luster. The obverse is toned in golden brown shades while the reverse is essentially untoned. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder. The PCGS label reads, "DDR FS-801 (FS-005.3)". This Vitale Collection lot is also the F-105 "web-book" plate coin at The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors. Ex. Gerry Fortin reference collection.
1889-S	MS64	PCGS 43181572	F-108	Choice	$1400	Near-Gem Original, Newtown Collection. Steely surfaces reveal light, crusty gray patina with a few deeper shades at the rim, while the reverse reveals additional, even rose color. A few marks are hidden within the figure of Liberty. F-108, with an even date and the mintmark centered under the bow knot. The CAC pop report notes six pieces in MS64, six coins in MS65, and two examples in MS66. The CAC price guide value is $1,420. This is a pleasing example for the money, attractively toned and reasonably close to the top of the census. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2022) holder with CAC approval.
1889-S	AU55	PCGS 81637668	F-104	Original	$225	Near-Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection.. Brilliant frosted luster and vibrant cartwheels are the highlight of this 1889-S F-103 Small S mint marked dime. Cartwheels are vibrant and pleasing. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder.
1890	MS67	PCGS 25357604		Gem	$3000	Gem Original, Newtown Collection. Frosted luster imparts a swirling cartwheel effect as this example is flipped under a light. Russet centers host ample amounts of electric blue patina at the rims. This variety is unlisted; a downward sloping date may assist in future classification. The strike is soft, with the head not fully defined, and this may also be characteristic of this particular die pair. Tied with seven other pieces for highest graded at CAC, typical of the Newtown consignment, which includes a number of pieces at the top of the census. The CAC price guide value is $3,000. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.6 (2013-2014) holder with CAC approval.
1890	MS64	NGC 956006002	F-110	Gem	$550	Misplaced Digit in Denticles, Brilliant Frosted Luster, Gem Eye Appeal. I could not resist adding this 1890 F-110 dime to inventory during the FUN show. Though a "common date", this dime possesses the hallmarks of a full gem. Luster is brilliant and frosty with vibrant cartwheels. Strike is nearly complete while the surfaces were meticulously preserved and are unabraded. Surfaces are toned various shades of copper-gold and add much charm. The F-110 die variety captures a misplaced digit in the denticles which is visible with a 10x. This is a well balance gem at a fair offer price for type. Housed in NGC Gen 7 (1997-2000) holder,
1890	AU50	PCGS 13935293	F-106	Original	$300	Misplaced Date, Original, Steven Vitale Collection.. This lot is the rare Four Misplaced Digits In Lower Gown die variety. The top loops of four digits are visible in the lower gown. The left and right outer digits appear to be the top loops of an 8 and 0 digits and are positioned directly above the final date punch. The two inner misplaced digits appear to be the top loops of a 9 and 0 punch. Chris Pilliod first published this spectacular misplaced date in the Gobrecht Journal. I consider the 1890 F-106 MPD to be one of the key varieties within the Seated Dime misplaced date series and also within the Top 100 Varieties set. The Vitale example is noted to have partially mirrored fields. Their reflectance is limited by scattered field abrasions thus the GFRC-Original quality rating. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.6 (2013-2014) holder. The label documents the die variety as MPD FS-302.
1890-S	MS65	NGC 139702009	F-108a	Gem	$2150	Small S, Late F-108a Die State, Brilliant Frosty Luster, Web-Book Plate Coin, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection . The 1890-S F-108 Small S obverse die can rarely be found in a later die state with crossing die cracks through the date digits. One die crack starts at the top oval of the 8 digits and proceeds left through top of 1 digit, into the base and the rock where it terminates. A second die crack starts at the rim below the base of 1 digit and proceeds right through the lower loop of 8 digit, the top loop of 9 digit and into the base. The F-108a die state was discovered during 2014. Up until that time, this die state had not been seen on the limited number of F-108 Small S examples reviewed; most were found in lower circulated grades. The F-108a die state is considered to be very rare and is rated as R7. Since 2014, no other examples have been reported. This offering is the important discovery piece and the 1890-S F-108a plate coin at The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors aka the web-book. Gem surfaces exhibits large amounts of brilliant frosty luster and shimmering cartwheels. In hand inspection of this rare gem is recommended to appreciate the beauty not captured on GFRC images. Housed in newer NGC holder with edge view insert.
1890-S	MS64	PCGS 30035618	F-114	Choice	$1050	(a)Medium S, Brilliant Luster, Swirling Cartwheels, Frosted Devices, Fully Struck, Newtown Collection. Liberty Seated dime collectors should pay special attention to the release of this duplicate 1890-S F-114 dime from the Newtown Collection. I'm having a great time viewing this piece under a lights source. A fantastic strike greets me along with mirrored fields on both sides. The main devices have a frosted finish leading to cameo effects. Faint mottled rose toning covers a portion of the obverse while the reverse is mostly untoned. There are a few reverse field ticks mentioned for 100% accuracy. Overall, eye appeal and luster are excellent reasons for adding this Newtown duplicate to your collection. Accurately graded and housed in older PCGS Gen 4.1 (2002-2004) holder.
1890-S	MS63	PCGS 37677073	F-105	Choice	HOLD $650	New May 26! Scarce Small S Mintmark, Choice Original, Mottled Blue-Rose Toning, Frosty Cartwheel Luster, Well Struck, Massachusetts Collection.. The 1890 Small S mintmark is recognized as being very scarce as nearly all 1890-S dime will be found with the taller Medium S mintmark of 1888 and 1889. Locating a 1890-S Small S mintmark in Mint State is an ongoing challenge for passionate die variety collectors. This mintmark size variety is listed the Ultimate set on the GFRC Open Set Registry. This Small S F-105, from the Massachusetts Collection, sports brilliant frost luster and is perfectly original. In hand viewing and GFRC images might suggest muted luster and mottled toning. That is definitely not the case with luster being crisply reflective with bold cartwheels. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder.
1890-S	AU55	PCGS 30624389	F-102	Original	$185	Double Die Obverse, Original Ebony Gray Patina, Residual Luster, Accurately Graded, West Coast Collection. Housed in 2014 generation PCGS holder. Full description shortly.
1890-S	AU53	PCGS 32280554	F-108	Original	HOLD $275	Near-Choice Original, Steven Vitale Collection.. Only two of the fourteen documented 1890-S reverse dies were punched with a Small S mintmark. The F-108 variety has the Small S to the far left while the other is nicely centered. I've seen this second mintmark size occasionally listed in price guides as a special variety. Clearly much rarer than the Medium S with Greer and Fortin assigning an R5+ rarity rating for the Small S in EF/AU. Steely frosted luster is able to radiate through the light golden gray toning with angled lighting on this example. The reverse is fully struck with boldly defined motifs and pristine fields. The obverse has a weaker strike with a few contact marks. Housed in PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) Dupont hologram holder. The label documents the die variety as F-108, Small S.
1891	PR64CAM	PCGS 3705077	F-101	Gem	$900	New May 7! Gem Proof Strike, Ex. Gerry Fortin Reference Collection.. An old friend returns to this GFRC CAC-Only auction event. Formerly in the Gerry Fortin Reference Collection and employed as the 1891 F-101 plate coin at The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference. This offering is a gem proof strike with crisp watery mirrors on both sides. The resulting reflective luster and cartwheels are both substantial and eye catching. Strike is hammered with all motifs deeply impressed. A true cameo that warranted CAC approval. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.0 (1998-2002) holder. Originally purchased during May 2002 and being released into the marketplace for a second time via GFRC.
1891	MS66	PCGS 3481301	F-129	Gem	$895	Gem Original, Flowing Satiny Luster, Mottled Steel-Violet Reverse, Gerry Fortin Core Date/Mintmark Set Duplicate. An outstanding final year Legend obverse Liberty Seated dimes purchased at the April 2004 CSNS HA sale for $1040. Since that purchase, this satiny original dime has been housed in my core date and mintmark set. MS66 Seated dimes have seen price reductions since 2004 with this duplicate being priced accordingly. Satiny surfaces offer golden peripheral toning on the obverse and mottled steel-violet hues across the entirety of the reverse. Completely fresh to market and seeking a new home in an advanced Liberty Seated dime collection. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.0 (1998-2002) with blue label and barcode on the reverse.
1891 Double Die Obverse	MS63	PCGS 38778755	F-109	Choice	$1500	Rare Double Die Obverse, Condition Census, Frosty Luster, Active Cartwheels, Top 100 Varieties Set, Indiana Collection. This 1891 F-109 Double Die Obverse is a rare Top 100 Varieties Set offering that is in the condition census. This example, from the Indiana Collection is one grade level (PCGS MS63) behind the two finest known examples graded PCGS MS64. This die variety remains elusive and is rarely cherrypicked. Examples arriving to market are typically released from die variety collections. An absolutely wonderful example with bold brilliant frosty luster and active cartwheels. Strike is complete including heavy obverse die clashing that is a key diagnostics for cherry-picking this variety. Die doubling is readily evident on the vertical shield lines and CA on AMERICA. Liberty Seated Dime die variety specialists should take special note of this offering. Freshly graded and housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 holder with an incorrect F-102 attribution in the label. It should be F-109. This is either a PCGS die variety attribution or mechanical label error.
1891	AU58	raw	F-115	Market Acceptable	$195	Retained Cud at 11:00, Frosty Luster, Faint Reverse Hairlines, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. A Liberty Seated Dime web-book 1891 F-115 plate coin with a reverse cud at 11:00. Surfaces retain brilliant frosty luster on both sides. The reverse is lightly hairlined when carefully viewed under 10x loupe along with bright light inspection. The reverse cud is fully formed and delineated with shelf metal on all three sides. As usual, GFRC is meticulous with accurate descriptions of its raw coin offerings. Yet another Seated cud dime from the Gerry Fortin reference collection.
1891 Doubled Die Obverse	AU55	PCGS 40802657	F-109	Choice	$525	Doubled Die Obverse, Frosty Luster, Golden Patina, Heavy Die Clashing, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. The 1891 Double Die Obverse die pairing is an elusive entry in the Top 100 Seated Dime Varieties set. Few examples have been seen during my years of hunting down this variety. This new offering is the last of the two examples that I have been able to locate during several decades of searching. A typical example with heavily frosted surfaces and brilliant luster. Nearly fully struck with just a touch of weakness at the top of Liberty's head. Die doubling is seen throughout the shield and at AMERI(C)A. All F-109 examples are typically clashed with heavy die clash lines behind the primary Liberty devices and within the wreath on the reverse. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 holder "F-109 Doubled Die Obv" attribution on the label.
1891-O	MS66	PCGS 50260168		Gem	$3850	Gem Original, Newtown Collection. Superb luster highlights blue-green centers framed by rose shading at the rims. Strong cartwheel actively dances as the coin is tilted, rotating around the colorful surfaces. The reverse might well grade MS67, were it not for micro-chatter south of M. Regardless, the luster atop the wreath is mesmerizing and it difficult for this cataloger to put the coin down. CAC has certified nine examples in M66 with none higher, while PCGS has 17 coins in MS66 and three in MS67. There won’t be any bargains in the Newtown sale – these coins are the not the sort to “slip through,” but this piece, with a CAC guide of $3,420, represents a quite reasonable value given that it is tied for finest known at CAC. This was the frontline coin in the Gene Gardner set (Heritage 6/2014, lot 30283, realized $2,820). Housed in a PCGS Gen 4.2 (2004) holder with CAC approval.
1891-O	MS65	PCGS 06863725		Gem	$1000	Gem Original, Newtown Collection. Vibrant cartwheels flow from the frosty luster, revealing steel and light gold patina on both sides. CAC has approved 40 coins in all grades with seven pieces finer. The 1891-O dime is rich in varieties, with 32 die marriages reported to date, and this example appears to be unlisted, though a number of reverse die cracks are noted. Housed in a PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder. Note, a few scuffs on both sides of the holder are evident in the images.
1891-S	MS61	NGC 4189140014	F-109	Choice	$225	Copper-Gold Coloring, Frosted Luster, Super Eye Appeal, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. A pretty 1891-S Liberty Seated dime with copper-gold coloring that is backlit by sharp frosted luster. The upper wreath is weak as struck. Accurately graded as a few wispy hairlines on the reverse are noted. A favorite for the 1891-S date varieties and the plate coin at The Definitive Resource for Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference. Housed in newer NGC holder with edge view insert.

Liberty Seated Dimes

AU and Mint State Business and Proof Strikes

To Order: Contact Gerry by Phone (207-329-9957) or Email using the shopping cart ()