Seated Dime AU-MS Price List - Gerry Fortin Rare Coins

Date	Grade	TPG	Top 100 Variety	GFRC Rating	Price	Description
1837 No Stars, Small Date	MS66+	PCGS 25239874	F-103	Gem	$30000	Finest PCGS Certified, Superb Gem Original, Gerry Fortin Collection, Ex. Simpson and O'Neal Collections. An exceptionally preserved gem with both sides fully struck with complete hair and leaf details. The surfaces are entirely pristine without a single tick or anomaly. Frosted ivory luster is predominant along with splashes of russet, blue, and iridescent toning. The Large Date variety can be identified by a flat top 7 digit. F-103 with the 7 digit pointing between two denticles. This lot is the PCGS Coin Facts plate coin and finest graded. The CDN CAC price guide ranges from $16,200 (MS66) to $50,400 (MS67) as reference. This lot was acquired prior to the GFRC Newtown Liberty Seated Dime Collection auction sale with purchase price noted in the Sales Archive. Housed in PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) Dupont hologram holder with CAC approval. A long list of noteworthy pedigrees includes The Jim O'Neil Collection, The Bob Simpson Collection, and GFRC's Woodlands and Newtown clients. PCGS #4562.
1837 No Stars, Large Date	MS66	PCGS 25337764	TOP #1 F-101c	Gem	$15000	Gem Original, Newtown Collection. Steely luster imparts active cartwheels across the surfaces of this Large Date, No Stars piece. A moderate spray of olive and charcoal patina covers both sides, highlighted by considerable flash that is thoroughly consistent with the MS66 CAC designation. The 1837 F-101c is coin #1 on the Top-100 list and exhibits heavy die clashing with elevated obverse die cracks. While not as arresting as the 1839 F-105c "Pie," the die deterioration is advanced and easily apparent without a glass. The dies are slightly rotated as expected for all later die states of the F-101 die pair. The CAC census notes two examples in MS66, with only a pair of pieces higher, both at MS67. The guide value is $15,000. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
1837 No Stars, Small Date	MS65	PCGS 21314594	F-104	Gem	$12500	New May 18! No Stars, Small Date, Gem Original, Gerry Fortin Collection.. An extraordinary gem in all regards as both sides are draped in warm frosted luster with rose-red and sea-green toning. The surfaces are fully pristine other than a single tick to the left of the clasp. The reverse was previously clashed with a Large Date obverse and presents die clash marks below DI(ME) and across the ribbons and stems. The Small Date punch can be easily distinguished by a round top 7 digit. The Small Date is the better of the two 1837 date punch varieties with the CAC census reported at 59 examples with only five finer. The CDN CAC guide is presently $11,900 as reference. Heritage Auctions, 2003 Long Beach Sale, Lot #330. Housed in original PCGS Gen 4.1 (2002-2004) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #4562.
1838 No Drapery, Large Stars	MS66	NGC Fatty 244567016	F-111a	Gem	$4950	Cracked Obverse #3, Top 100 Varieties, Superb Gem Example, Sheffield Collection. A richly original example toned in a soft mottling of steel-blue, golden-rose, champagne-pink and olive-gray patina. The strike is fully executed with surfaces that are exceptionally smooth and well preserved. Frosted luster is noted under a bright light. An excellent candidate to represent the brief Liberty Seated, No Drapery dime design in a high grade Mint State type set. F-111a and previously listed as Shattered Obverse #3 by Greer and included in the Top 100 Varieties set. The obverse features a bold bisecting crack meandering through Liberty's portrait and the reverse is cracked through the letters AT in STATES into the wreath. Housed in a pristine NGC Gen 5 (1992-1995) holder.
1838 No Drapery, Large Stars	MS63	PCGS 3737124	F-104	Choice	$995	Cracked Obverse, Rich Frosted Luster, Peripheral Copper-Gold, Evergreen State Collection. The 1838 Liberty Seated dime date is well known for its three major cracked obverse die varieties along with a vertically cracked reverse. Not often recognized as being in the same league of importance is the F-104 die pairing with its cracked obverse. In this case, the die crack is not bisecting but rather, two bold cracks originating at the rims at 7:00 and 2:00. This Evergreen State collection release presents a late die state example with the die cracks as advanced as I've seen during years of researching and dealing. The steely-frosted luster is brilliant under angled lighting with the right obverse field die crack being seen without a loupe. The overall strike is hammered while unabraded surfaces round out the positive attributes. A choice example that will pleased the selective collector. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.0 (1998-2002) holder.
1838 No Drapery, Small Stars	MS63	PCGS 60192235	F-101a	Choice	$1350	New May 11! Small Stars, Tough Grade, Typical Frosted Luster, Late Die State, Choice Overall, Indiana Collection. Consignor Price Reduction - The 1838 F-101 Small Stars die pairing demonstrates die preparation workmanship issues during the years of the design. Firstly, the obverse die was erroneously punched with the smaller half dime star punch. During working die creation, the reverse is obviously doubled in the left wreath and at (O)NE (D)IME. Initial strikes occurred with the obverse die cracking at Liberty's head and progressive die cracking down through the left field stars and into the date. Eventually, a reverse die crack forms at STATE(S OF AMER)ICA. I would occasionally see Small Stars dimes in the 1990s but their appearance frequency has dropped appreciable in the current market. Locating example in Mint State grades further increases the collecting challenge. This new release example, from the Dr. Tim Cook Collection, exhibits typical frosted surfaces with light grayish toning with darker shades on the reverse. The die state is F-101 with the obverse die crack fully extended into the date. An unquestionably original piece to consider at a fair offer price. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder.
1838 No Drapery, Large Stars	MS62	CACG 618292545	F-113	Choice	$985	Reverse Die Flaw, Near-Gem at Grade, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. The new CAC Grading holders are constructed of a plastic that appears to be more translucent that the competitors. The 1838 F-113 Seated dime is intricately detailed in the GFRC photographs. I suspect the clear plastic allows us to view this beautifully toned dime at its finest. This dime features a bold reverse die flaw and is the plate coin with The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference. Housed in new CAC Grading (2023) holder and straight graded consistent with CAC approval standards.
1838 Partial Drapery	AU58	NGC 3334663015	TOP #7 F-108a	Choice	$1000	Partial Drapery, Frosted Luster, Light Gray Patina, Choice Original, Cleveland Collection. The Cleveland Collection is releasing this lovely 1838 Partial Drapery dime acquired from GFRC way back during the 2013 business start-up time frame. This is a frosted example with thick obverse luster and very light toning. The reverse features consistent frosted luster and slightly deeper gray shades. A choice example with full strike that is listed in the Top 100 Varieties set as entry #7. Housed in newer NGC holder with edge view insert. The label does not capture the Partial Drapery F-108a attribution. Last sold by GFRC July 2013 and listed in the Sales Archive.
1838	AU58	raw		Gem	$750	New April 28! Vertically Cracked Reverse, Beautifully Toned Surfaces, Bold Radiance, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. One of the more colorfully toned plate coins within the Liberty Seated dime die variety online reference, this 1838 F-103a dime is a superb portrayal of the vertically cracked reverse variety as listed in the Top 100 Varieties. This example is the F-103(a) die state with a partial vertical crack. Spectacular eye appeal is readily evident from the images as deep obverse rose toning is nicely framed by blues at the borders while the reverse is entirely blue other than a small center rose dot. This is a sharp lustrous example with more reverse radiance due to the lighter toning. Following is the die variety description from the web-book, "Reverse B begins to crack and, in this middle die state, exhibits a long vertical die crack starting at O(N)E, down through D(I)ME and through the left ribbon bow loop. The die crack finally exits the rim at about 6:00. On Obverse 2, Stars 1, 8, 9 and 12 are repunched and there are no obvious signs of die degradation. Definitely a conversation piece that has been in Fortin reference collection since October 2001.
1839 No Drapery	MS65	NGC 2037607024	F-104b	Gem	$2750	Terminal Die State, Crusty Gray Old 2x2 Paper Toning, Ex. "Col" E.H.R Green Collection, now Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. Ex: "Col." E.H.R. Green. The obverse of this terminal die state 1839 F-104b die has three lengthy die cracks, the heaviest between star 2 and the 3 and migrating across the shield and through the date. This intricately struck, unabraded, and satiny gem original survivor has deep old 2x2 paper envelope toning with mahogany-brown, steel-gray, and forest-green coloration. Housed in 2013 generation NGC holder with edge view insert and special Eric P. Newman pedigree label. This is a particular difficult coin to photograph. Potential buyers may wish to visit CoinFacts and the November 2013 Heritage auction listing and accompanying images.
1839 No Drapery	MS62	NGC 5742516011	F-106c	Choice	$725	Cracked Obverse, Rotated Reverse Left 18 Degrees, Gorgeous Toning, Frosted Luster, Sheffield Collection. Notable eye appeal arrives with this 1839 F-106c Liberty Seated dime offering. Frosted luster highlights peripheral aquamarine-gold that surrounds obverse center rose. Strike is complete but not sharp as the F-106c die pairing features a well worn and cracked die pair. Reverse die misalignment is clockwise 18 degrees. The progressive obverse die crack at 12:00 from rim through Liberty's head down to neckline becomes stronger and more visible during the F-106c die state. Another significant die crack starts at the rim to the right of star 10 and joins stars 11 through 13. The reverse exhibits multiple cracks to the rim. This new offering brings a highly detailed late die state variety with beautiful toning. How can you pass up the combination? Housed in new large font NGC holder with edge view insert.
1839-O No Drapery	MS62	PCGS 13344755	F-105	Choice	HOLD $1400	New June 3! Large O, Rich Frosted Luster, Completely Fresh to Market, Indiana Collection. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder. Another fresh release from the Dr. Tim Cook Collection that immediately sold upon being showcased in the Daily Blog.
1839-O No Drapery	AU50	raw	TOP #14 F-108	Market Acceptable	$850	Huge O Variety, Rare Grade, Top 100 Varieties #14, Details Grade. Definitely a rare grade for the 1839-O Huge O reverse variety when AU details remain. This specimen easily grades AU+ but has dark verdigris covering the obverse stars and date regions coupled with the entire reverse. The dark surfaces were result in a PCGS grade designation of AU Details code 97 (environmental) if holdering were to be attempted. Few examples are know at this grade level and a truly problem free specimen would be priced in the $2000+ range. Offers are welcomed as the dime is listed to sell.
1840 Drapery	AU Details	PCGS 32697387	F-101	Cleaned	$650	Drapery Type, Rare Grade, Silver Gray, Light Clean. The 1840 Drapery date is recognized as being quite challenging in AU and downright rare in Mint State. A long time client is releasing this AU Details example with a complete strike. Residual luster is evident under a bright light though the surfaces exhibit light hairlines from an old clean. A great filler opportunity until a choice original example can be located. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2025) holder.
1840-O	AU53	NGC 4717899002	F-109a	Original	$1035	Thick Crusty Patina, Cracked Reverse, Original Surfaces, City By The Bay Collection. Consignor Price Reduction. 1840 brought the third year of Liberty Seated dime production at the New Orleans mint with ongoing quality issues. The F-109a was struck during that period by eroded and cracked dies. As a result, the obverse device details are weakly defined, especially at the date. Multiple radial die cracks through the legend are noted on the reverse. This is an unquestionable crusty example with thick brownish gray patina. A new release from the City By The Bay Collection. Housed in new large font NGC holder.
1843 Doubled Date	AU58	PCGS 30447869	TOP #25 F-102	Choice	$520	New May 21! 1843/1843 Double Date. Early Die State, Fully Struck, Choice Overall. Consignor Price Reduction - The 1843/1844 double date has been a long standing die variety that was separately listed in Coin World's CoinValues for years. As a result, it was included in the Top 100 Varieties set. This lot is the return of the Cleveland Collection example back to the marketplace. GFRC previously sold this example during early 2021 with the record in the Sales Archive. This was a choice original duplicate with both sides being toned with circular maroon-gray patina. This piece is an early strike with bold definition of the rotational repunching above the 18 digits and the right of the 3 digit. A fully struck example with bold motifs. Housed in PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) Dupont hologram holder. Die variety collectors should hurry on this one.
1849	MS65	NGC 3019023001	F-101	Gem	$3350	Gem Original, Frosty Cartwheel Luster, Light Rose Patina, Hammered Strike, One of the Finest Extant, Sheffield Collection. Ex. Bender and Massachusetts Collections, this magnificent 1849 Seated dime is a rarity in Gem Mint State. Released from the Bender Collection, when Tom was still actively upgrading his Liberty Seated Dime set via GFRC and other sources. Now this lot return to the price list courtesy of the Sheffield Collection. This eye appealing NGC graded MS65 specimen offers vibrant cartwheel luster emanating from thick frosted surfaces. Strike is deeply impressed with high relief obverse and reverse devices. A light violet skin covers the obverse while the reverse toning being more peripheral, but with the same shades. Accurately graded and housed in newer NGC holder. Definitely a prize for the passionate Liberty Seated dime collector.
1849-O	MS64	PCGS 05625131	F-101b	Gem	$19000	New May 18! CAC Tied Finest, Large O, Gem Original, Gerry Fortin Collection.. The challenge in locating gem Mint State New Orleans dimes continues with the 1849 date. Of the 300,000 struck, few Mint State survivors are known. The PCGS population stands at eleven certified with four CAC approved. The struggle is further exacerbated by poor mint workmanship, including weak strikes coupled with rusted and lapped dies. Based on research background, this example was acquired during May 2006 via Legend Numismatics.as one of the finest survivors to arrive at the market in modern times. The preservation is exceptional with steely-frosted luster that is consistent on both sides. Natural rose, aquamarine, and blues shades are a testament to the strict originality. F-101 with a Large O mintmark and a die pairing notorious for partial strikes. Though Liberty's head is not fully struck, this example is likely condition census for strike robustness. Tied for finest at CAC with a price guide value listed at $17,300. Housed in an as acquired PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with 2014 CAC approval. PCGS #4592.
1850-O	MS67 Star	NGC 1748227002	F-103	Gem	HOLD $25000	New May 18! Tied Finest Known, Exceptional Gem, Gerry Fortin Collection.. The Fortin Collection presents the finest 1850 Small O dime which shares the title with a PCGS certified Large O example. Granular mint frost dominates the obverse while the reverse mint bloom is in the steely realm. Once again, a hammered strike was a purchase imperative. All devices are intricately detailed with sharp hair curls and facial characteristics. The overall eye appeal is exceptional, thus being recognized with an NGC Star designation. Photographing this dime proved to be challenging due to the intense center luster that is framed by darker peripheral copper-gold. F-103, the lone Small O die pair of that year. Greer indicates that the Small O is the scarcest of the three mintmark sizes followed by the Medium O, and finally the Large O. Acquired August 2004 via Carter Numismatics as a present to me upon releasing The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference at that summer ANA event, A well hidden break in the right obverse field luster precluded CAC approval. Housed in NGC Gen 14 (2003-2004) holder. PCGS #4594.
1853 Hubbed Arrows & Date	MS65	NGC 3103683041	F-102	Gem	$1450	Orange-Rose Patina, Thick Frosted Luster, Gem Original, Sheffield Collection. Thick frosted luster radiates from orange-rose toned surfaces on this 1853 Hubbed Arrows & Date F-102 dime. Both sides offer undisturbed surfaces and continuous luster during bright light inspection. This dime was struck by heavily eroded dies including two obverse die cracks that validate the die variety. A crack through the left end of the left arrow and secondly, a die crack through Liberty's head, are readily evident with 10x. I like this coin at the assigned grade and plan to move it into the web-book as an upgraded plate coin. Fairly priced for the overall quality. Housed in newer NGC holder with edge view insert.
1853 No Arrows	AU55	PCGS 37847804	F-101	Original	$1250	No Arrows, Creamy Frosted Luster, Early Die State, Near-Choice Original. The 1853 No Arrows dime remains elusive in all grades other than Mint State. 1853 was a transitional year for American coinage. Early in 1853, the Philadelphia Mint produced 95,000 dimes under the old weight standard of 2.67 grams. Subsequently that year, the planchet weight was reduced to 2.49 grams. To signify the change, engravers initially hand punched arrows on either side of the date, and proceeded to strike over 12 million pieces. Since issued by the Philadelphia mint, there were enough local collectors to save some No Arrows Mint State example with the balance reaching circulation. Circulated survivors are infrequently offered with this AU55 certified presented as an opportunity. This is a lightly frosted example with a complete strike. Under a bright light, faint gold surrounds the stars and reverse legend. A mark by the hair curls precludes a full Choice quality rating. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder.
1853-O	AU55	raw	F-105	Market Acceptable	$475	Lapped Dies, Frosted Luster, Peripheral Gold, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. Another reference collection release, this 1853-O F-105 can be identified by a weakly hubbed thin date with very open 5 digit along. The weakness of the reverse legend suggests die polishing, through the Large O mintmark and wreath are strongly detailed with an obvious die clash behind DI(ME). A horizontal die crack appears at the rim above ST(A)TES and connects STAT(ES) before exiting to the rim above O(F). A small rim cud forms at the die crack exit point. The F-105 variety with its cracked reverse is scarce and will take diligent searching to locate. This example was purchased March 2002 and published within the Liberty Seated Dime web-book and yet another plate coin. The Market Acceptable rating results from horizontal obverse hairlines meaning this piece will not straight grade. Priced accordingly.
1854-O	AU55	ANACS 4557837	TOP #39 F-103	Market Acceptable	$525	Cracked Obverse at Date, Oblique Mintmark, Top 100 Variety, Cleveland Collection. Serious fans of the Liberty Seated dime Top 100 Varieties set should take heed of this new Cleveland Collection release. The 1854-O F-103 die pairing carries an R5 rarity rating and is a very challenging die pairing to locate. This example is cracked at the date with a tiny retained cud. Die cracks also connect all of the stars. This lot is mostly white with some peripheral gold on the obverse. The left obverse field in uneven with several depressions that are unexplained. These artifacts were acceptable to ANACS graders but must be called out with a GFRC market acceptable quality rating. Housed in newer yellow label ANACS holder.
1856 Small Date	AU55	PCGS 30447902	F-102	Choice	$235	New May 16! Small Date, Colorful Patination, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. The 1856 Small DateF-102 die pairing is fairly easy to locate in circulated and Mint State grades. There is a die defect to the left of the pendant on Liberty's gown. This die defect is an important diagnostic in conjunction with the date position. For consideration is a choice Fortin collection duplicate with colorful patination. The strike is complete with steely-frosted luster under a bright light. Housed in PCGS Gem 5.0 (2015) holder.
1856 Small Date	AU Details	PCGS 30447888	F-105	Choice	$150	New May 16! Small Date, Choice Original Gray, Reverse Planchet Flaw, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. This offering is a choice original 1856 Small Date F-105 dime which is the lapped obverse die state of the F-111 die pairing where the repunched 18 digits are easily noted. I could not believe that PCGS assigned a details opinion for a perfect original Seated dime with a reverse planchet flaw as struck. The planchet flaw runs through both E's in the denomination and up to (O)F. Priced at AU50 CDN bid towards locating a new home. This is assuredly a conversation piece. Housed in PCGS Gem 5.0 (2015) holder. The label reads Genuine Planchet Flaw - AU Details
1856 Small Date	MS66	NGC 6815787008	F-113	Gem	$3900	Gem Original, City by The Bay Collection.. This near-finest known example reveals crimson and lime patina across the figure of Liberty, while the reverse exhibits deep auburn and copper color to the right. The luster is strong as expected for the grade level, and the in-hand flash is readily apparent. F-113, with an upward slope in the date. Strike is typical, with softness in the bow. Note, diagonal lines on both sides indicate roller marks on the planchet, as struck. NGC has certified 139 coins total, with six examples at MS66 and only a single piece finer, at MS67. The NGC price guide value is $5,625 in MS66, not inexpensive, but a fair value for an attractively toned example near the top of the grading pyramid. Housed in a new large font NGC holder. PCGS #4609.
1859	PR64	PCGS 50064684	F-102	Choice	$1485	New April 28! Near Gem Original, Crusty Gray Patina, Active Mirrors, Fully Struck, Former Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. Consignor Price Reduction. At GFRC, we like our Liberty Seated coinage, including proofs, to have 100% natural surfaces and crusty gray patina where possible. This is the case for this near gem 1859 proof strike. Sourced from a Heritage auction during November 2003 due to the atypical crusty obverse toning with incremental gray patina on the reverse. Under the toning are active mirrors. Strike is absolutely hammered. 1859 proofs were struck from two different obverse dies labeled as F-101 and F-102 in the "web-book". F-101 is the more common of the two proof dies while F-102 accounts for about one in five of the proof dimes seen. This F-102 obverse presents a medium level date while F-101 exhibits a upward sloping. This F-102 dime continues to be the proof plate coin within The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Die Variety Collectors online reference. Previously sold to a client who has decided to liquidate his Seated dime proof set, therefore resulting to the price list. This is an atypical proof example for fans of crusty originality. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.1 (2002-2003) holder.
1859	MS65	NGC 1875970007	F-103	Gem	$3250	Extra 9 in Gown, Gem Original, Cleveland Collection.. The Cleveland Collection is releasing this 1859 F-103 gem Seated Dime that originated from the Fortin core set collection during November 2022. It is an excellent example of a With Stars misplaced date. The bottom loop of the extra 9 digit in the gown was evident in Kam Ahwash's Encyclopedia for 14 years until Fortin discovered its existence during 1991. This is a popular variety that is listed as #46 in the Top 100 Varieties set and also included in the Top 25 Misplaced Date set. Let's get back to the offered example. Crusty coin-gray patina covers both side of this gem along with speckled ebony-gray at the stars and legend. Strike is complete with elevated motifs, especially the reverse wreath leaves. Surfaces are entirely unabraded. Purchased by Fortin during February 2007 from Jason Carter and employed as the F-103 plate coin with The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference. Housed in NGC Gen 17 (2004-2008) holder with CAC approval.
1860	PR66CAM	PCGS 21231151	F-101	Gem	$3650	Cameo Designation, Gem Original, Evergreen State Collection.. 1860 brought the introduction of the Longacre-Paquet Liberty Seated dime redesign. This new obverse design (Type 1) lasted only through 1861 before being promptly replaced with a more robust design (Type 2) that was less "delicate" and subject to rapid wear. The 1860 proof obverse exhibits a group of horizontal die lines starting from the sixth stripe in the shield and moving right, under the scroll at LIBE(RTY), and ending at the fold in Liberty's gown line. This superb gem example presents an opportunity to study the delicate design features. Accurately designated as a cameo given the heavily frosted main devices that are surrounded by mirrored fields. The PCGS certification is accurate as surfaces are entirely unabraded and free off the faintest hairlines. Mirrors are sharp with faint amounts of whitish-gray toning at the date and on the upper obverse. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.1 (2002-2004) holder.
1860	MS64	PCGS 03606412	F-101a	Gem	$950	Business Strike from Proof Dies, Steely Frosted Luster, Vibrant Cartwheels, Eye Appeal, Ex. Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. Yet another case where GFRC photography leaves much to be desired. The gorgeous 1860 F-101a dime has fabulous steely frosted luster with mirror reflectance under angled lighting. This is to be expected as circulation strikes were produced from a proof die pair with the (a) die variety suffix being added for the circulation strike. The holder is also old and worn which further detracts the camera with plastic haze spots. Trust me that this piece is worthy of its gem quality rating. As a reminder, this is the F-101a plate coin within The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference. Returning to the price list courtesy of the Sheffield Collection. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder.
1861 Type 2 Obverse	PR65	PCGS 26161284	F-101	Gem	$2500	Superb Eye Appeal, Brilliant Mirrors, Gem Original, Evergreen State Collection.. All 1861 dated proofs were struck with a Type 2 obverse design. The report mintage of 1,000 pieces is suspect as many went unsold and were melted. This notable survivor is an unquestionable gem with brilliant mirrors that "pop" under a bright light. The obverse reflectance is overlaid with aquamarine-rose centers and a gorgeous yellow-gold ring at the borders. Deep rose covers the reverse center with a transition to aquamarine-blue at the wreath with a hint of gold at the extreme rims. The fields are pristine other than three faint hairlines in the right obverse field. The eye appeal is consistent with the Evergreen State Collection's efforts to locate proof strike with pleasing toning and overall eye appeal. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.5 (2012-2013) holder with no auction records that could be located.
1863	AU Details	PCGS 32697383	F-101a	Cleaned	$1350	Tough Civil War Philadelphia Issue, Business Strike, Brilliant Reflective Surfaces, Cleaned. Mintage for the 1863 Philadelphia struck dimes is reported at 14,000 pieces, a small quantity for that era. This newly released example resides in a AU Details holder with the F-101a business strike validation due to weak reverse strike and rounded obverse legend lettering, another characteristic for separating business strikes from proofs. The surfaces are sharply reflective with faint hairlines in the fields. GFRC images accurately capture the in-hand appearance. A perfect filler of a truly key date in the Liberty Seated dime series. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2025) holder.
1863	MS67	PCGS 42608326	F-101a	Gem	$21500	Finest Known, Gem Original, Gerry Fortin Collection.. The second lot in the Fortin Collection to enjoy the "finest known" title with its corresponding beauty and an issuance of 14,000, the smallest dime mintage since 1804. Mirror fields offer extraordinary reflectance while the peripheral blues and rose shades "float" over pristine surfaces. The strike is fully impressed with sharp wire rims. F-101a, a business strike from proof dies. The PCGS price guide plate coin for those that seek an alternate TruView perspective. The CDN CAC price guide suggests $10,900 which requires introspection as the PCGS guide at $22,500 is a better estimate of market value. Acquired February 2022 via private treaty and a continuation of the Fortin focus on locating exceptional Civil War issues . Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2024) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #4637.
1864	MS66	PCGS 35690560	F-102a	Gem	$15000	Gem Original, Newtown Collection. Lightly mirrored, reflective luster penetrates the thick colorful toning of this Civil War piece. Aqua and russet patina predominate, with neon shades additionally present above the figure of Liberty. F-101a, with a defect at the upper right of O(NE), the same reverse die as used in 1863. Clashing is evident beneath DIME. This piece is tied for finest known at CAC with three other pieces. The overall CAC population is 24 pieces, and the CAC price guide is $7,200. Ex. GFRC. This piece represent yet another exceptional gem from the Newtown consignor, a pedigree that will long be remembered among Seated dime specialists. Housed in a PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
1865	PR65CAM	PCGS 36936680	F-102	Gem	$2650	Cameo Designation, Brilliant Mirrors, Gem Original, Evergreen State Collection.. This 1865 Cameo Proof dime offers a window into the preparation of proof planchets. Those planchets were reported to be buff with a polishing cloth. Frequently, I will see proof strikes with a struck through "lint mark" that validates the proof status. This newly consigned example is quite special with at least eight lint marks scattered throughout the obverse while the reverse is pristine. Please have a look at the obverse image to note the multiple lint marks in the upper fields as a starting point. Under a bright light, the mirrors are sharply brilliant and pleasing. There is a hint of gold toning at the peripheries. The Cameo designation is certainly warranted based on the overall presentation. A conversation piece concerning the presence of lint marks on early proof coinage. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2025) holder.
1867	MS67	PCGS 38519788	F-102	Gem	$17500	Tied for Finest, An Exceptional Gem, Gerry Fortin Collection.. 1867 brought the lowest Philadelphia mintage with 6,000 struck. Mint State survivors are available in all grades with this lot being tied for finest at PCGS and CAC. An exceptional example with intense prooflike reflectance and colorful rose shaded centers surrounded by peripheral blues as struck with conspicuously striated dies. Partial wire rims are noted with a full obverse strike and near complete reverse other than the upper left wheat grains. F-102, with business strike from a single die pairing with a heavily clashed obverse only. Acquired via private treaty with no known auction records, though the lot is featured as the PCGS price guide plate coin. The CAC price guide value is listed at $17,300 for reference. A side-by-side comparison with the Simpson specimen could be a revealing exercise. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval. PCGS #4645.
1867-S	AU50	PCGS 20743589	F-102	Original	$1500	Rare Grade, Soft Steely Luster, Original, City By The Bay Collection. Consignor Price Reduction. Arriving from the City By The Bay Collection is an original 1867-S duplicate that should garner promptly attention. Pervasive grey-rose patina is layered on both sides. Traces of mint frost are seen in the protected areas including the around the reverse motifs. Angled lighting presents soft steely luster. A few micro marks and lines are evident. A mintage of only 140,000 that circulated extensively in the western frontier. PCGS has certified only five at grade with no CoinFacts auction records since 2012. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.5 (2012-2013) holder.
1868	PR66CAM	PCGS 25011392	F-104	Gem	$3750	Cameo Designation, Gem Original, Evergreen State Collection.. The Evergreen State proof Seated dime release continues with a lucious 1868 F-104 specimen. This proof variety is easily recognized by a high date that slopes downward coupled with a weak date punch. A second proof die pair is known with bold misplaced digits in the gown folds and is easily distinguishes from the more available F-104. This piece exhibits brilliant mirrors with the cameo effect being readily apparent under a bright light. Images accurately illustrate the greenish obverse hues with rose being more prevalent on the reverse. Pristine fields are 100% hairline free with sharp edge lettering throughout. Wire rims are consistent with proofs of this era. The CAC census is 13 approved with a fair market guide value of $4200 as reference. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.6 (2013-2014) holder with CAC approval.
1868-S	MS63	PCGS 83647445	F-101	Choice	$2500	Rare Grade, Satiny Luster, Speckled Ebony-Rose, City By The Bay Collection. Low Civil War era San Francisco mintages continued during 1868 with only 260,000 pieces struck. As with all issue from 1861 through 1868, the appearance of Mint State examples is noteworthy in today's market. PCGS has certified only 6 at the MS63 level. This example features satiny luster which is typical of the issue given heavily worn dies and metal flow lines into the denticles. Faint ebony-rose speckled toning is evident on the obverse while the less so with faint gold. Strike is complete, though not bold, again consistent with the issue and die state. Fans of the Liberty Seated dime series are presented with an important opportunity based on this City By The Bay Collection release. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder.
1869 Short Flag 1	AU58	raw	F-103	Original	HOLD $825	New April 25! Short Flag 1, Rare Grade, Steely Surfaces, Bold Strike, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. The 1869 F-103 Short Flag 1 die variety is the easiest of the three business strike Short Flag 1 obverse dies to locate. However, in AU or better, any Short Flag 1 example is a notable find as quite rare. This offer example is the plate coin within The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference and is the second finest business strike example of a Short Flag 1 dime that has been handled by GFRC. Note the full head and the completeness of the obverse strike. Typically, business strike Short Flag 1 dimes are seen with weak strikes and flat heads. A marvelous specimen with steely fields and considerable eye appeal.
1870	PR66CAM	PCGS 09945870	F-103	Gem	$3350	Gem Original, Evergreen State Collection.. The Evergreen State Collection continues to release top rate proof Seated dimes including this 1870 F-103 which is illustrated as a CoinFacts plate coin. This is a sharply detailed example with the first S in STATES showing incomplete detail due to excessive die polishing. A bold die crack connects the ribbon ends and validate the variety attribution. The fields are brightly mirrored and reflective with pale gold toning being noted during in-hand inspection which are also captured by GFRC illustrations). Surfaces are unabraded with heavy die polish lines in the right obverse field. Frosty devices contrast boldly against the mirrored fields. The PCGS population is 5 in PR66 Cameo with a single finer, Last auction appearance is CSNS U.S. Coins Sale (Heritage 4/2018), Lot 3220 and previously FUN Signature (Heritage, 1/2014), Lot 4006. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2025) holder.
1871-S	MS65+	PCGS 06863865	F-101	Gem	HOLD $17000	New May 18! Second Finest Known, Repunched Date, Gem Original, Gerry Fortin Collection, Ex. Bender.. This 1871-S repunched date example is close to unimprovable given its status as the second finest known at PCGS and CAC. Rich granular frosted luster is brilliant with faint gold at the obverse rims. The reverse radiance is equally captivating with beautiful blue and mauve patina and swirling cartwheels. The design elements are sharply struck, including Liberty's head, the denomination, and the grains in the corn and wheat stalks, areas that are often weak. A few minute chatter marks on the reverse above ONE account for the grade while the obverse is unquestionably pristine. F-101 with bold repunching above the 18 digits and a Small Weak S mintmark. The PCGS price guide plate coin. CAC reports two at the MS65 grade with a single finer. The CAC guide lists $15,800 as fair value without a value for the (+) grade. Acquired via private treaty. Ex. Heritage Auctions, February 2023 Long Beach Signature Sale Lot# 3656 (Tom Bender), Jason Carter (5/2009), and Eugene Gardner Part II (Heritage 10/2014), Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2024) holder with CAC approval. The label documents the Bender Collection pedigree. PCGS #4655.
1871-S	MS62	PCGS 20431793	F-102	Choice	$2650	New June 10! Rare Mint State F-102 Example, Crisp Frosted Luster, Notable Cartwheels, Indiana Collection. The Indiana Collection has released a Mint State 1871-S F-102 dime that is a significant event for die variety collectors. The F-102 die pairing features a reverse that is always found weak at the denomination and at the lower inner left and right leaves. This reverse die was previously employed by the San Francisco mint to strike coinage in 1869 and in 1870 and was most likely polished of lapped prior to generating its final coinage. This example resides in a PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with old time grading. Frosted surfaces are decorated with hints of gold. Under angled lighting, the luster is crisp with vibrant cartwheels. Within The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference, an R5 rarity rating has been assigned as most surviving 1871-S examples in Mint State are from the F-101 die pairing.
1872 Misplaced Date	PR65	PCGS 45745479	F-109	Gem	$2250	Misplaced Date, Gem Original, Evergreen State Collection.. As a Top 100 listed variety, the 1872 F-109 die pairing features the base of a 2 digit erroneously placed into the base. Both proof and circulation strikes were struck with this pairing with proof strikes being more elusive. This GFRC-Gem rated proof example offers brilliant reflectance from copper-gold toned surfaces. The lettering sharpness and overall strike, though not as pronounced as issues from 1860s, is typical and well produced. Under a bright light, the presentation is undisturbed with sharp mirrors. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2025) holder. The label documents the die variety attribution as F-109, MPD.
1872 Misplaced Date	PR63	PCGS 03137867	F-109	Choice	$995	Proof Strike, Misplaced and Repunched Date, Top 100 Varieties, Lakeland Collection. Consignor Pricing Reduction. What a surprise to have not one but two 1872 F-109 proof strikes in one consignment. This example is properly graded with even mirrors and reflectivity. Consistent with proofs of this era, the strike is complete with partial wire rims. With a 10x, faint hairlines can be located in the lower right field along with one line on the reverse below the denomination. The grading is fair for this lot. This variety is easily identified by the base of the 2 digit that is mistakenly punched into the rock directly below the pendant. Secondly, the 7 and 2 digits have been repunched. An opportunity to acquire a challenging Top 100 Variety at a fair price. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. The label documents the F-109 attribution.
1872 Misplaced Date	PF66	NGC 6064099005	F-109	Gem	$1980	Challenging Proof Strike, Misplaced and Repunched Date, Top 100 Varieties, Lakeland Collection. Consignor Pricing Reduction. The 1872 F-109 is a difficult but rewarding proof variety to locate. First, the base of the 2 digit is mistakenly punched into the rock directly below the pendant. Secondly, the 7 and 2 digits are repunched. Repunching is visible at the bottom of both digits. The variety was discovered by Kam Ahwash and first listed by Greer. It is further listed as part of the Top 100 Varieties set. An example of this variety, grading PCGS PF65 Cameo, brought $2760 at the Heritage Central States Signature auction during May 2004. Fast forward to 2024 where the Lakeland Collection has released a PF66 example with fully documented variety holder. This piece is a joy to view under a bright light given the undisturbed mirrors and sharp radiance. There is a tiny link mark to the right of Liberty's head otherwise the fields are unabraded or hairlined. This lot belongs in an advanced Top 100 Variety collection. Housed in new large font NGC holder with special Top 100 Varieties label. The label reads 1872/72 MPD TOP-100 F-109.
1872	AU Details	PCGS 37567993	TOP #58 F-109	Original	$650	Scarce Proof Strike, Misplaced 2 Digit in Base, Greer Plate Coin, Original Surfaces, Ancient Rim Filiing, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. Brian Greer plate coin. The 1872 F-109 and F-109a die varieties features a misplaced 2 digit in base. F-109 catalogs the very scarce proof strike while F-109a captures subsequent circulation strikes. This variety was discovered by Kam Ahwash, as a proof strike, and first listed by Greer. It is further listed as part of the Top 100 Varieties set. The offered example was purchased directly from Brian Greer during December 1992 and has remained in raw condition in my collection until recent grading. A no question proof strike that would grade PF62. However, there is an ancient rim filing below the date that is completely toned over and was not noticed until the piece came back with a PCGS Details grade. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 holder with Rim Damage, AU Details. The 1872 F-109 plate coin at The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors commonly known as the Seated Dime web-book. The 1872 F-109 variety is also listed in the Top 100 Varieties set. Definitely a piece of numismatic history regardless of the ancient rim filing.
1872	MS65	PCGS 81252594	F-102	Gem	$2750	Gem Original, Gerry Fortin Core Collection Duplicate.. A wonderful gem Philadelphia strike that approaches the upper bounds of Mint State availability with its CAC approval. The CAC population includes only 4 at grade with 3 finer. This 1872 dime is simply superb with frosty rose gold patina across the obverse and lighter gold on the reverse. Strike is absolutely hammered including fully defined grains in the upper left wreath. Unabraded with brilliant frosted luster. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
1873 With Arrows	PR64CAM	PCGS 38143027	F-102	Choice	$1650	With Arrows, Cameo Designation, Near-Gem Original, Evergreen State Collection.. Handling the Evergreen State Proof Seated Dime Collection has been an eye opening experience even for this seasoned researcher and cataloger. Case in point is the 1873 proof issue with 800 produced. When reviewing the CAC census, the low number stickered suggests that premium survivors are very challenging to locate most likely due to mint workmanship issues. This lot is noted for its very thick wire rims and mirrored fields that exhibit a soft granular texture during 10x inspection. Under a bright light, the mirrors are sufficiently brilliant against the frosted motifs. Copper-gold toning is noted on the left obverse and fully encompassing the reverse borders. This near-gem is fairly reserved for its scarcity. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder.
1873 Doubled Die Obverse	AU53	NGC 6635747001	TOP #60 F-103	Original	$7500	High Grade Doubled Die Obverse, Bold Shield Doubling, Light Gray, Peripheral Gold. From Europe comes a high grade 1873 Arrows F-103 Doubled Die Obverse dime for die variety specialist consideration. This NGC AU53 example is fresh to market, to my knowledge. The doubling on the upper right shield is dramatic with a second counter clockwise rotated hubbing. Few examples are known at such a high grade level where the doubling is readily prominent and easily enjoyed. This new specimen offers even light gray surfaces along with a band of peripheral gold on both sides. Surfaces are steely reflective when placed under a bright light. A complete strike is readily evident on the obverse, which is critical for this variety while the reverse is weakly impressed at the upper left wheat grains. The two finest known examples are the Garner specimen which GFRC recently sold for $18,500 and an white NGC MS61 example which I have lost track of. During April 2018, the third finest known example, from the Gerry Fortin Reference Collection, was sold at $7000. This piece graded PCGS AU55 without CAC approval. Freshly graded and housed in new large font NGC holder.
1873 With Arrows	AU50	raw	F-111	Original	HOLD $275	Micro Left Arrow, Steely Radiance, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. The ongoing release of the remaining Fortin reference collection Seated dimes continues with this 1873 With Arrows F-111 with a micro left arrow punch. Both arrows are undersized, with the left arrow being smaller than the right arrow. Remember that unlike the 1853, 1854 and 1855 hubbed arrows and dates, the date and arrows on 1873 obverse dies were manually punched. Manual punching lead to variations in placement and size of the arrows, as is demonstrated by the weakly punched arrows on F-111. The reverse also features a prominent die scratch into the lower right wreath. I have found this die pair to be very difficult to locate above VF grade. Steely fields offer sharp radiance under a bright light. A complete strike is also noted. A few scattered lines account for the GFRC quality rating. Purchased November 2006 and employed as the plate coin with The Definite Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference.
1873-S With Arrows	MS64+	PCGS 25233863	F-101	Gem	$5500	Gem Original, Oregon Beaver Collection.. Steely-frosted cartwheels reveal varied russet shades, more heavily on the reverse, which additionally exhibits a splash of charcoal patina. This is a fully struck example with complete ribbon detail. F-101, with the thin-style mintmark. Just two die pairs were used to produce nearly half a million circulation strikes in this year. CAC notes 25 pieces total, with three coins finer, the highest at MS66. The CAC value in MS64 is $3,820 and advances to $10,500 in MS65. The bidders will decide how closely to approach the MS65 price (this coin previously sold at $5,500 in the Branch Mint Collection sale), but in any case, this piece presents a compelling combination of aesthetic appeal and exceptional technical grade, separated from finest known status by only a point and a half. Housed in a PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) Dupont hologram holder and CAC approval.
1873-S	MS64	PCGS 07447774	F-101	Gem	$4850	Small Thin S, Brilliant Frosted Luster, Swirling Cartwheels, Gem Original, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. For several decades, I could not make a decision on whether I liked the F-101 or F-102 PCGS MS64 CAC dimes better, in my reference collection, to the point of releasing one back into the marketplace. The F-101, as offered today, presents lovely frosted surfaces and swirling cartwheels that are accentuated under a bright light. The F-102 specimen is darker with partially mirrored fields and has won the 1873-S spot in the core set. Back to the F-101 then. This die pairing is found in early and late die states with the primary die state diagnostic being die erosion. This lot is a late die state specimen with obvious erosion under the date digits and weak reverse wreath devices. Regardless of the die erosion, the luster is entirely brilliant as one would expect from a gem survivor. This lot was purchased January 2006 and later CAC approved during 2014 and has served at the F-101 plate coin withing The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference. Total date CAC approved population presently stands at 25 pieces with 6 at the MS64 level and only 3 finer. The PCGS and CAC guides are understated for this date given the rarity. My cost basis for this lot is $100 less than the offer price while paying $5500 for the remaining F-102 in the core collection. This is an important opportunity for the astute collector. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder with CAC approval.
1874 With Arrows	AU53	raw	F-113	Choice	$325	New April 24! Downward Sloping Date, Steely Luster, Light Silver-Gray, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. A solidly original 1874 With Arrows dime that was purchased October 2003 as part of a substantial Liberty Seated dime die variety research project. Practically unabraded surfaces are well preserved with steely fields and moderate reflective luster. The Liberty Seated Dime online reference F-113 plate coin with downward sloping date, while both arrows are in the same horizontal plane and point outwards along that plane. The time has come to release another web-book plate coin back to the market place.
1874	AU53	raw		Original	$265	New April 28! Challenging Die Pairing, Steely-Frosted Luster, Aquamarine Gold Toning, Few Hairlines. If colorfully toned silver coinage is your passion, then this 1874 With Arrows F-115 dime may be for you. Both sides feature steely-frosted luster under a bright light. Aquamarine, rose and gold are blended on both sides. Please note that there are some hairlines in the left obverse field which have been accounted for in the offer price.
1874 With Arrows	AU50	raw	F-102	Choice	$210	Choice Original, Misplaced Digit in Denticles, Light Gray, Silver Luster.. I've studied this dime carefully given the PCGS opinion of Code 97 Environmental Damage/AU Details. The fields and devices are nearly problem free with no obvious signs of porosity or marks. Due to paper envelope storage, the surfaces have acquired a deep rose gray patina that is darker on the obverse than reverse. Rims are bold and indicates that this dime saw limited circulation. My assessment is that this dime is not strictly original due to the surface "sheen". A circulated dime that is strictly original should offer dull gray or gray/brown surfaces rather than the glossy gray/rose coloring seen here. Having said that, this piece should be "market acceptable" due to rarity and the essentially mark free surfaces. A stereo microscope review with bright light source reveals some extremely faint surface porosity that was not seen with a 10x loupe.
1874-S With Arrows	MS62	PCGS 83583163	F-102a	Choice	$1900	With Arrows Type, Satiny Luster, Choice Original, City by The Bay Collection.. The 1874-S Seated dime issue was struck with two distinctly different reverse dies. The first is the scarcer F-101 Micro S along with the more available F-102 Small Thin S reverse. The latter reverse saw more time in the minting presses as example with die erosion and cracks can be located. Such is the case for this City By The Bay Collection release. Both sides present a satiny appearance, under bright light, with some light reflectivity. The overall strike is quite strong though the weakness at the top of Liberty's head is commonplace. More important are the well struck devices on the reverse as I have seen some flat and ugly F-102a examples in my travels. This offering is definitely worthy of your consideration for a date and mintmark set. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2005-2011) holder.
1875	PR65CAM	PCGS 20215971	F-101	Gem	$1350	Cameo Designation, Gem Original, Evergreen State Collection.. 1875 proof coinage includes the Indian cent, the Seated dime, quarter, and half dollar coupled with the Trade dollar. Of the 700 dimes struck, few have risen to the lofty gem cameo certification. This Evergreen State Collection specimen is fully struck with brilliant mirrors. The surfaces are mostly untoned with a trace of gold at the borders. The fields are pristine and without hairlines or lint marks. Undeniably, this lot was struck with the F-101 die pairing based on date position and an arcing die line to the top left of (O)NE. Thought the Fortin online reference reports repunching at the 1 digit, this specimen does not exhibit this anomaly. PCGS has certified 12 at this grade with 14 finer. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2025) holder.
1875	MS64	NGC 3609725003	F-105	Choice	HOLD $485	New May 16! Repunched 18, Early Die State, Crusty Gray Patina, Near-Gem Original, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. This 1875 F-105 repunched date variety remains scarce after years of searching and cherrypicking attempts by collectors and is considered to be at least R4 in original VF or better grades. The 1 and 8 digits in the date are repunched with the repunching being most visible below the base and the flag of the 1 digit and, with close inspection, at the left hand side of the top outer loop of the 8 digit. This example is an early die state without the die crack that connects the bottom of the date digits. The reverse is also in an early die state without die cracks. Please note that the upper left segment of D(I)ME is fully hubbed on the working die but the right segment is very weak. This is the only occasion where I have seen this type of hubbing anomaly. A crusty near-gem Mint State example with soft frosted luster and thick golden tainted gray patina throughout. Housed in newer NGC holder with edge view insert.
1875	MS62	raw	F-109	Choice	HOLD $295	New April 24! Repunched 1, Rusted Die, Thick Frosted Luster, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. A thoroughly pleasing example of the 1875 F-109 die variety with a rusted obverse die and repunching below the 1 digit in the date. There is significant die cracking on both obverse and reverse die through the date, legend, and wreath edges. This is a ftosted example with brilliant luster under a bright light. Light gold patination is noted at both the obverse and reverse borders along with a bold strike. Employed as the F-109 plate coin with the LIberty Seated Dime die variety online reference. A few subtile micro lines in the left obverse field are consistent with the assigned grade.
1875	MS62	PCGS 55469028	F-107	Choice	$950	New June 3! Misplaced Date, Top 100 Varieties, Bold Strike, Steely Luster, Indiana Collection. Opportunity strikes for fans of the Liberty Seated dime series, and in particular the Top 100 Varieties. Dr. Tim Cook has just released four fresh to market holding with the 1875 F-107 being notable for the top of a 1 digit protruding from the denticles. A well struck example with fully defined obverse motifs and nearly complete obverse wire rim. Under a bright light, the fields are steely-frosted on both sides. A thin golden patination is also noted. One of the most popular die varieties in the Seated dime series. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2025) holder with MPD FS-301, F-107 die variety attribution on the label.
1876	PR65	PCGS 07227094	F-103	Gem	$975	Bold Strike, Gem Original, Evergreen State Collection.. Aquamarine-blue shades decorate this gem 1876 proof issue along with golden hues at the rims. In particular, the reverse presents a toning arc with similar shades and light gray hues in the more lightly toned upper left region. The overall strike is complete with razor-sharp wire rims. A surprisingly challenging proof Seated dime issue with CAC approval and strict originality. From a mintage of 1,150 piece, only 31 total have been approved in PR, PRCAM, and PRDCAM. At the PR designation, this Evergreen State specimen has a price guide estimate of $1000 with only five better. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2025) holder with CAC approval.
1876	PR64CAM	PCGS 82156370	F-103	Choice	$1250	Cameo Designation, Near-Gem Original, Evergreen State Collection.. We continue the Evergreen State proof dime auction sale with the second of three 1876 date pieces. This near-gem cameo designated lot displays watery mirrors and light copper hues on the obverse with a more haloed presentation on the reverse. Frosted devices are appropriately framed by the contrasting fields. The strike is nearly complete as With Legend proof issues still suffer weakness at the upper left reverse wheat grains. A few wispy hairlines within the obverse right field are consistent with the certified grade. A challenging date regardless of 1,150 being produced when fully choice. F-103 with reverse die doubling on DIM(E). Only 13 examples with a Cameo designation have been approved at CAC with four finer. The CAC price guide estimates market value at $950 which is understated and needs reconsideration by the CDN staff. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
1876	PF64+Cameo	NGC 4251078017		Gem	$1000	Gem Original, 1876 Proof Set, Pre-Whitman Baltimore Offering. Housed in new large font NGC holder with Rev. Dr. James G.K. McClure pedigreel listed on the label. Full descriptions forthcoming if not sold at the 2024 Winter Whitman Baltimore show.
1876-CC	AU Details	CACG 491141012	F-116	Original	$185	New May 16! Lightly Rusted Die, Frosted Luster, Absolutely Original, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. Honestly, I don't know what the CACG graders were thinking when examining this 1876-CC F-116 dime during the start-up phase of this new grading service. The piece is 100% original with bold frosted luster and light wear on the high points. The luster is uniform on both sides. Priced at a tad below AU bid and worth a grading shot at the other TPGs if you can get the coin out of its CACG holder.
1876-S Type 1 Reverse	MS64	PCGS 21700876	F-124	Choice	$700	F-124 Web-Book Plate Coin, Complete Strike, Frosty Golden Luster, Scarce Grade, Underrated in Mint State, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. The identification of 1876 San Francisco dies is an ongoing process that will continue for years due to large mintage. The F-124 die pairing was identified during October 2017. The presence of a huge die blog defect on Liberty's lower leg was quite evident during routine inspection. The F-124 reverse die has either been weakly hubbed or was lapped at some point in its life. The offered example is the 1876-S Type 1 Reverse F-124 plate coin at The Definitive Resource for the Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors aka, Seated dime web-book. A well balanced near-gem MInt State example with frosty golden luster and swirling cartwheels. Strike is complete with bold obverse device and center reverse. The left and right wreath devices were most likely poorly hubbed during working die preparation. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.1 (2002-2004) holder. Old time quality will please the new owner.
1876-S Type 1 Reverse	MS64	PCGS 13006413	F-115	Choice	$650	Underrated in Mint State, Copper-Gold Patina, Frosted Luster, Dallas Collection. Where are all the Mint State 1876-S dimes given a mintage of over 10,000,000? Yes, this date is underrated with only 24 pieces certified at the offered grade. The issue circulated heavily along with poor strikes. The Dallas Collection is releasing a copper-gold toned example with granular frosted luster. Cartwheel action is vibrant, especially on the lighter toned reverse. Doubling on the center reverse is the primary attribution point for F-115 along with date placement. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder.
1877 Type 2 Reverse	PR66	PCGS 29851939	F-101	Gem	$2000	Exceptional Proof Example, Sharp Brilliant Radiance, Bold Wire Rims, Evergreen State Collection.. 1877 Liberty Seated dime proof strikes were accomplished with the Type 2 reverse hub design. This exceptional example presents powerful watery radiance from undisturbed fields. Angled lighting showcases a classic proof presentation with center rose and peripheral sky-blue. What a color contrast as the reverse center is toned a blended rose-aquamarine then surrounded with rose-gold at the borders. A consistent and fully executed strike further enhances the eye appeal. The CAC census is limited to 25 examples stickered without a Cameo designation and one has to wonder why PCGS withheld this designation. Housed in PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) Dupont hologram holder with CAC approval.
1877 Type 2 Reverse	PR65CAM	PCGS 20369185	F-101	Gem	$2250	Cameo Designation, Intense Reflectivity, Gem Original, Evergreen State Collection.. 1877 saw a reduction in proof strikes to only 510 pieces. This lower mintage correlates to a single digit PCGS Cameo population. This lovely Evergreen State Collection example brings intensely reflective mirrors and essentially untoned surfaces. Fields are entirely unabraded and hairline free. There are a few subtle whitish rings at Liberty's head and near the cap. Strike is completely executed. If in the market for gem Cameo designated proofs, this offering warrants consideration. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) Gold Shield holder.
1877-CC Type 2 Reverse	MS66+	PCGS 42140031	F-110	Gem	HOLD $3975	New June 10! Superb Gem, Frosted Luster, Fully Struck, Golden-Gray Patina, Shattered Reverse. GFRC Pricing Reduction - As a dealer, I see a host of Seated coins with many being subjected to past poor treatments. On occasion, a superb gem with perfectly original surfaces appears. So was the case at Summer FUN 2021 and the purchase of this 1877-CC Type2 F-110 dime. Steely fields and natural reflective luster are initial highlights during bright light inspection. Toning is a combination of silver-gray with peripheral gold plus aquamarine on the obverse. Strike is hammered when considering the die pairing and shattered reverse. What appeals to me the most is the thick natural patina that is semi-transparent to the underlying luster. Trust me on this piece, it is a exceptional example for the grade, else I would not have added to GFRC inventory. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2021) holder with CAC approval.
1877-S	MS65	PCGS 55457544	F-111 R5	Gem	$4950	New April 25! Magnificent Gem, Granular Frosted Luster, Vibrant Cartwheels, Rare Die Pairing. GFRC is thrilled to be offering one of the finest 1877-S dimes extant along with being a rare R5 die pairing per my research as published in the Liberty Seated Dime die variety online reference. This is a magnificent gem with granular frosted luster and vibrant cartwheels. A speckled natural gray patina overlays the obverse while the reverse is a lighter uniform gray with gold and rose shades appearing under angled lighting. The surfaces are meticulously preserved too! Now let's move on to the importance of this die pairing in terms of rarity. The F-111 variety is the last of the three different reverse die pairings (F-109, F-110, F-111) with Obverse 7. Reverse C, which was previously paired with the F-103 obverse, shows die wear and erosion at the denticles. There is considerable weakness in the lower left ribbon end and wreath leaves. The reverse die may have been polished after the F-103 die pairing. This is only the fourth F-111 example handled by GFRC with the next finest being a PCGS MS62 CAC example sold during May 2018. Clearly, the finest known F-111 extant. CAC has approved only 22 examples in all grades with three finer. The estimate CAC market value is currently $4900 which recognizes the 1877-S date rarity in full gem. An important offering that belongs in one of the finest Seated dime collections being assembled. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2025) holder with CAC approval.
1878	PR66	PCGS 05763149	F-101	Gem	$2250	Gem Original, Evergreen State Collection.. Fiery orange-red obverse colors overlay sharply mirrored fields on this 1878 PR66 Seated dime. The reverse is equally attractive with blended aquamarine and yellow-gold hues amplified by brilliant mirrors. Pristine surfaces are noted during a careful 10x inspection. The strike is complete from a Type 2 reverse as no proof are known to be struck with the earlier Type 1 reverse design. The wire rims are thin and razor-sharp. The PCGS population report indicates that 9 have been certified at this lofty grade with none finer. With respect to Cameo designated examples, there are 4 at the PR66 grade level and a single PR66+. A nearly unimprovable example with a fair reserve. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2025) holder.
1878 Type 2 Reverse	PR65	PCGS 33723041	F-101	Gem	$810	New April 28! Reflective Mirrors, Even White, Complete Strike. Consignor Price Reduction. 800 proof strikes were produced in 1878 with all being coined from a single Type 2 reverse die pairing. This accurately graded survivor offerings essentially unblemished surfaces with brilliant reflectance. An even white colored example with boldly struck motifs. All 1878 proof strikes will have die rust pits in the lower right gown and a die line in the lower right wreath. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2023) holder.
1879	PR66CAM	PCGS 05931139	F-102	Gem	$1500	Cameo Designation, Superb Gem Original, Colorful Mirrors, Emerald Collection. 1879 saw a dramatic reduction in silver coinage production across Liberty Seated denominations. On the other hand, proof strikes remained steady with a mintage of 1,100 pieces across four die pairs. This F-102 proof strike garnered a Cameo designation and rightly so. Colorful reflective fields are a joy to view while the primary motifs are lightly frosted. Center gold is nicely framed by a peripheral sky blue ring on both the obverse and reverse. Fields are absolutely pristine as one with expect for the certified grade. Classic ring toned proof eye appeal is readily demonstrated on this Emerald Collection offering at an attractive offer price. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder.
1880	MS67+	NGC 5751313001	F-102a	Gem	$3800	Broken 18(80), Condition Census Example, Steely Frosted Luster, CAC Approved. 1880 Seated dime mintage was limited to 36,000 and fairly consistent with its 1879 and 1881 peers. Many collectors view these three consecutiver mintage years as a continuum. This newly consigned example is an exquisite superb Gem with steely-frosted radiance with brilliant mirrors under a bright light. The mirrors are no surprise as circulation strike were accomplished from reused proof dies. Surfaces are essentially untoned with light gold at the borders. A late date issue and an exceptional condition census specimen. F-102a with broken 8 and 0 digits in the date punch. PCGS has graded two at MS67+ with two finer. The price guide is $5000 as reference. Previously Stacks Bowers November 2022 where it realized $3600. Housed in new large font NGC holder with CAC approval.
1880	MS66+	PCGS 25004984	F-102a	Gem	$2400	Low Mintage Circulation Strike, Partially Mirrored, Gem Original, Sheffield Collection. Three die pairs were employed for the 1880 Philadelphia dime issue, only two of which were used for circulation strikes. The F-102 die pairing can be located as a proof strike followed by the F-102a circulation strike as is the case with this Sheffield Collection offering. Since the dies were reused, it is not uncommon to see partially mirrored fields for well preserved F-102a survivors. This example radiates mirrored reflectance that is not impeded by the orange-rose patination. Accurately graded with unquestionably originality. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.6 (20013-2014) holder with CAC approval.
1881	PR63	PCGS 13107684	F-103	Choice	$690	Rare Proof Die Pairing. Mirrored Fields, Thick Crusty Patina, Lakeland Collection. Consignor Pricing Reduction. It is difficult to believe that the low mintage 1881 year yielded three separate proof sets of dies. Let's quote directly from the Seated Dime web-book to understand the importance of this Lakeland Collection offering. The third 1881 proof obverse was discovered by John Dannreuther during his comprehensive proof coinage research project. The incremental proof obverse was reported to the author in late September 2014 and is initially listed at R6+ rarity. A review of Heritage Auction archives during a population study revealed three observations (PF66, PF65 Cameo and PF63) within the database. John Dannreuther shared quarterly 1881 proof mintage figures secured from the National Archives as follows; January/March - 675, April/June - 50, July/September - 0, October/December - 460. John believes the 1881 Variety 101 proofs were struck during the first quarter as the most prevalent in the market while the newly discovered Variety 103 proofs were struck during the second quarter. The F-103 proof Obverse is easily diagnosed by a date position that is far right of that seen on F-101 and F-102. This example is covered by a thick crusty skin with muted mirror reflectivity. Please note that there is a fine toning line in the lower right obverse field above the foot. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.4 (2005-2011) holder.
1882	MS65+	CACG 993009577	F-101a	Gem	$875	Repunched 2, Superior Presentation, Gem Original, Sheffield Collection. Rich frosted luster and golden aquamarine toning are the highlights of this gem 1882 F-101a dime. This piece was struck from proof dies that were re-employed for circulation strikes. Surfaces exhibit granular mint bloom that is consistent on both sides. A bright light review reveals frosted luster that is partially muted by the dense patina. Cartwheels are active, more so on the reverse. Repunching on the 2 digit is evident under the top ball and below the base. An unquestionable gem that is so close to full MS66. Housed in new CAC Grading holder and graded consistent with CAC approval standards.
1882	MS64	NGC 3887987016	F-108a	Choice	$450	Weak and Shattered Reverse, Frosted Luster, Fully Choice, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. As I continue to work through the remaining holdered coins in the Seated dime reference collection, there is the occasional lot that was purchased and never added to the web-book. Such is the case for this 1882 dime that is a late die state example of the F-108 with weak reverse hubbing. This is a brilliant frosted piece with substantial radiance. Given the high circulated grade, the reverse becomes a die variety collector's delight. One can assess the poorly hubbed center denomination and the shattered die in the left wreath with the potential for a full cud to form. Surfaces are pristine and entirely unabraded. This lot has not been submitted to CAC Stickering. Newly added as the 1882 F-108a plate coin within The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference. Housed in newer NGC holder with edge view insert.
1883	PR67	PCGS 38736559	F-103	Gem	$2600	Gem Original, Evergreen State Collection.. Liberty Seated dime proof mintage increased to 1039 pieces during 1883 with the date being well represented in the CAC census. CAC has approved 8 examples at the lofty PR67 grade with an additional 7 with Cameo designation. This Evergreen State example is a strong testament to this grade level as the surfaces are absolutely pristine resulting in undisturbed bright light viewing. The brilliant mirrors offer watery textures and the peripheral copper-gold provides the appropriate framing that we expect from superb gem proofs. The strike is typical of the issue with limited wire rims. The CAC price guide suggests $2600 as current market value. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder with CAC approval.
1883	MS65	NGC 3887987021	F-118	Gem	$550	Steely Frosted Luster, Swirling Cartwheels, Hints of Gold, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection . The outgoing flow of Seated dime research pieces continues from the Fortin Collection towards ongoing upgrading of the core collection. This lovely 1883 dime exhibits granular frosted luster and swirling cartwheels. Angled lighting exposes steely fields and partial reflectance. A faint gold patina attests to the originality. Obverse strike is complete while the reverse has the usual weakness at the upper left wheat grains. Housed in newer NGC holder with edge view insert. The F-118 plate coin at The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Collectors online reference.
1883	MS64	ANACS OWH 2356524		Choice	$385	New June 16! Partial 3 Digit, Rich Aquamarine Rose-Gray Patina, Near-Gem, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. GFRC Price Reduction - The old ANACS white holders continue to contain some pleasant surprises in the Fortin bank box. The time has come to release an unlisted 1883 dime with a partial lower loop on the 3 digit. The interaction between the steely-frosted surfaces and the aquamarine rose-gray toning leads to noteworthy eye appeal. Strike is nearly complete with just a touch of weakness at the top of the head and within the upper reverse wheat grains that are always problematic. A lovely Seated dime in a long ago ANACS old white holder.
1883	MS64	CACG 993083029	F-109	Choice	$625	Repunched and Broken 3, Pastel Shades, Gem Eye Candy, Frosty Luster, Active Cartwheels, Sheffield Collection. A wicked nice 1883 Liberty Seated dime as we say in Downeast Maine. Worthy of its CACG near-gem certification with pastel coloring on both sides. Orange, gray, aquamarine shades decorate the obverse while the reverse offers a fiery rose center with orange surrounding the outer wreath devices. Frosted luster, while being immediately evident under a bright light, is move prevalent on the reverse. Surfaces are completely unabraded. Struck from the F-109 die pairing with partial lower loop on the 3 digit and repunching at the upper loop. Housed in new CAC Grading holder and graded consistent with CAC approval standards.
1883	MS63	NGC 3887987020	F-113	Choice	$250	Complete 3, Frosty Luster, Vibrant Cartwheels, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. A well preserved 1883 dime that has been in the Fortin collection for decades. Surfaces are essentially unabraded and radiate a consistent frosted luster. Cartwheels are as expected at the certified grade. This lot is the F-113 plate coin at The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference. Attractively priced and a premium type coin. Housed in newer NGC holder with edge view insert.
1884	PR66CAM	PCGS 13354652	F-101	Gem	$1850	Cameo Designation, Intense Radiance, Gem Original, Evergreen State Collection.. Intensely radiant fields are the highlight of this superb gem 1884 proof dime. The untoned surfaces a hugely brilliant and warrants a sunglass warning for sensitive eyes! The motifs are heavily frosted and are showcased by disparate "dished" fields. The high relief strike is uniform with meticulously impressed devices. A faint line emanating from Liberty's nose is a link mark. There is no explanation for why this lot is not CAC approved other than not being submitted for review. A gorgeous proof strike that deserves careful consideration for type or whatever project that could make use of this gem. Mintage is a reasonable 875 pieces with the date well represented in grades ranging from PR65 to PR67. The reserve has been set well below the PCGS price guide value of $2250. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2025) holder.
1885	PR67CAM	PCGS 43567900	F-101	Gem	$3500	Cameo Designation, Exceptional Gem, Reflective Brilliance, Evergreen State Collection.. An exceptional 1885 Liberty Seated dime proof strike with nicely contrasted cameo eye appeal. This gorgeous gem was originally part of a complete 1885 proof set which has been holdered and dispersed. Though the images indicate classic center to edge copper gold toning, any angled light exposes deeply reflective mirrors with substantial undisturbed brilliance. A thin peripheral blue arc on the obverse is icing on the cake. This is an amazing offering that needs in-hand inspection to be appreciated. Or you can trust this description as I'm in love with this premium proof strike. CAC has approved 13 at the certified grade with one finer and a price guide value estimate at $3500. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2025) holder with CAC approval.
1885-S	MS65	PCGS 51066607	F-101	Gem	$36000	New May 18! Second Finest, Gem Original, Fresh CAC Approval, Gerry Fortin Collection.. A remarkable condition rarity 1885 San Francisco strike and one of the highlights of the Fortin Collection. That year's mintage was anemic at 43,690 pieces with nearly all entering circulation. This date is undoubtedly the rarest Mint State date from 1873 through the design's termination in 1891. Even choice original circulation strikes are prized by collectors given the date's scarcity. This gem example exhibits shimmering frosted luster and swirling cartwheels with a stunning visual presentation. A transparent copper-gold patina is uniform on both sides while the strike is deeply impressed and meticulously detailed with partial wire rims. Immaculate surfaces provide undisturbed eye appeal. F-101, a single pair with usage as the plate coin within the Fortin Liberty Seated dime online reference. The CAC census indicate a sole example at MS65 (this lot) and a single finer. December 2021 via private treaty. Fresh cross into a PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2025) holder with CAC approval.
1886	67Star	NGC 6332606008	F-111	Gem	$2450	Magnificent Gem, Granular Frosted Luster, Gorgeous Rose with Peripheral Blue. NGC Star designated early type typically offers superior eye appeal as is the case for this 1886 F-111 Seated dime. Unfortunately, GFRC images are woefully inadequate is showcasing the granular frosted luster and swirling cartwheels that are activated with angled lighting. The images capture the in-hand center rose and peripheral blues accurate, but a bright light is where this piece excels. This one is heading to CAC on principal if not sold by the of end of September as the surfaces, luster, and grading are consistent with the John Albanese acceptance standards. Housed in new large font NGC holder.
1886	MS65	PCGS 3756017	F-115	Gem	$750	Gem Original, Lustrous Pastel Toning, Fully Struck, Former Birmingham Collection.. This is the second time that GFRC has the pleasure to offer this lovely 1886 Seated dime. Initially sold out of the Birmingham Collection and now upgrade and back on the market. Pastel toning is the highlight with intermixed aquamarine, gold and rose coloring on the obverse and mottled gray, ebony and rose on the reverse. Bright light viewing exposes the luster and accentuates the colors. The overall strike is crisp with no signs of weakness. Same for blemishes as none were seen. If this dime has just a bit more flashy luster, then it would be a candidate for MS66 designation. In the current PCGS holder, it is accurately graded. Housed in old blue label PCGS holder with standard ring insert; serial number 3756017.
1887	PR64	PCGS 85100429	F-101	Choice	$685	Choice Original, Watery Proof Fields, Light Gun Metal Gray Patina, Fully Struck, Accurately Graded, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. An absolutely original 1887 proof dime with watery mirrored fields. As in the case with most proof Seated dime, bright light viewing is required to release the natural coloring and reflective mirrors. In the case of this 1887 specimen, a light source exposes subtle sky blue and light gold on the obverse. These same colors are more pronounced on the reverse and quite attractive. A 10x loupe inspection revealed several die polish lines on the reverse that should not be mistaken for hairlines. Accurately graded and off the market for several decades. Freshly graded and housed in 2015 style PCGS holder. From the Gerry Fortin Liberty Seated Dime Reference Collection.
1887	MS65	PCGS 32848495		Gem	$700	Superb Eye Candy, Brilliant Frosted Luster, Unquestionable Gem, Sheffield Collection. Why not spoil yourself with a little eye candy Seated dime to usher in the 2025 New Year? This Sheffield Collection release offers glowing frosted luster and eye catching obverse toning. When viewed with a bright light, the darker in-hand shades quickly fade and reveal a moderate orange-gold center toning surrounded by sky blues and a hint of outer rose at 12:00 to 2:00. The obverse hues are also seen on the reverse but lighter and circumferential. The die pairing is unlisted with a Denticle Ruler measurement of -1R which does not match the only web-book listing (F-103) with that date punch location. Sometimes I worry about using too many superlatives to describe the superior coins that cross my desk. This one is an unquestionable gem and deserves a JUST BUT IT NOW recommendation. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder.
1887-S	MS64	PCGS 5790890	F-114	Gem	HOLD $750	Doubled UNITED, Gem Original, Heavily Frosted, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection.. Flashy luster and swirling cartwheels are difficult to miss when first inspecting this GFRC-Gem rated 1887-S Seated dime. Not only is the eye appeal exceptional, but the F-114 doubling at UNITED add another dimension as a reason for adding to an advanced Seated collection. Purchased during July 2003 as part of the die variety research effort that resulted in the publishing of The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference. A complete strike further enhances the eye appeal. My favorite 1887-S dime other than the piece in the core Liberty Seated dime set. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.0 (1998-2002) holder with CAC approval.
1887-S	AU53	NGC 3832832044	F-107 R6	Original	$650	Shattered Reverse, Crusty Original, Top 100 Varieties, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. A spectacular 1887-S shattered reverse with die cracks that form a concentric inner ring that covers about 60% of the wreath. There are three exit points to the rim with the 6:00 and 9:00 exits being substantial. Interestingly, this reverse is well struck in spite of the massive die cracks. The Medium S mintmark shows repunching in the upper loop and could be yet another S over S variety. This example has been residing my bank box for years and the time has arrived to sell. The obverse is toned a natural gray with the reverse covered with a thick crusty patina. With a 10x, the shattered reverse is confirmed as being in a later die state consistent with the Top 100 Variety web-book plate coin. Housed in newer NGC holder with edge view insert.
1889	MS65	NGC 958035003	F-110	Gem	$985	Repunched 889, Gem Original, Golden-Aquamarine Patina, Brilliant Frosty Luster, Vibrant Cartwheels, Well Struck, Accurately Graded, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. A difficult 1889 Philadelphia die variety with repunching inside the lower loops of 88 and above the tail of the 9 digit. First listed by Fortin. This offering has to be one of the finest examples extant as I've seen few in my collecting career. Gem original surfaces are covered with semi-transparent golden-aquamarine patina. Frosty luster is brilliant with bold cartwheels during bright light viewing. The F-110 plate coin at The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors. Housed in old NGC holder with standard ring insert. Purchased April 2003 and in the Fortin collection since that time. I really hate to let this one go but all die variety dimes must be eventually sold.
1889	MS65	PCGS 45061352		Gem	$675	Glowing Satiny Luster, Superb Bright Light Eye Appeal, Sheffield Collection. A marvelous 1889 unlisted Seated dime that warrants a JUST BUY IT NOW recommendation. When I first laid eyes on this piece, the immediate thought was a CAC submission given the gem surfaces, glowing satiny luster, and oh, the beautiful toning. This dime brings on the eye appeal. The GFRC images suggest obverse finger print toning which is correct. However, my images are again worse case with the coin in hand showcasing more uniform obverse toning. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.1 (2020-2022) holder.
1889	MS64	NGC 3102384011	F-120	Gem	$475	Gem Original, Cartwheel Luster, Aquamarine/Rose Patel Toning, Conservative Grading.. A gem original 1889 Philadelphia struck dime that is so deserving of CAC approval. Glowing cartwheel luster couple with pretty pastel colors dominate the eye appeal. Obverse strike is nicely executed while the reverse die is weak and cracked resulting in some shallow relief to the reverse strike. This piece is essentially blemish free and atttractive with GFRC images unable to capture and illustrate the overall beauty. Housed in newer NGC holder.
1889	AU58	raw	F-115	Choice	HOLD $145	Misplaced 8 Digit Right of Scroll, Brilliant Frosted Luster, Peripheral Copper-Gold, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. The 1889 Seated dime date is prime for misplaced digit varieties including some spectacular examples in the lower shield. The F-115 variety features a misplaced digit seen directly to the right of the scroll end. This die preparation artifact appears to be the top loop of an 8 digit. This variety is typically found weakly struck as is the case here. Thick mint frost covers both sides with strong radiance under a bright light. There is the faintest of rub with this piece being a conservative AU58 that will easily holder if so desired. Purchased March 1999 and employed as the Liberty Seated dime online reference plate coin.
1890	PR65CAM	PCGS 30041395	F-101a	Gem	$1450	Cameo Designation, Gorgeous Bullseye Toning, Tooled Die Crack Below Bow Knot, Gem Original, Evergreen State Collection.. This gorgeous 1890 proof strike validates that the Philadelphia employed reworked business strike dies for "proof strikes". The F-101 die pairing struck both circulation and proof strikes with the proofs coming after circulation strikes. What is amazing with this die pairing is a reverse die crack that developed from the right ribbon end downward to the denticles below the left ribbon end. Interestingly, an attempt was made to tool out the die crack on the reverse die prior to or during the striking of proof coinage. By using a side lighting source during the photography of the die crack for web-book illustration, the tooled area becomes evident. An important offering previously from the Gerry Fortin Reference Collection that is 1890 F-101a web-book plate coin at The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.1 (2002-2004) holder as purchased during early 2004.
1890	MS64	NGC 956006002	F-121	Gem	$595	Sharply Sloping Date, Brilliant Frosted Luster, Gem Eye Appeal. I could not resist adding this 1890 F-121 dime to inventory after being bought back from a well known client. Though a "common date", this dime possesses the hallmarks of a full gem. Luster is brilliant and frosty with vibrant cartwheels. Strike is nearly complete while the surfaces were meticulously preserved and are unabraded. Surfaces are toned various shades of copper-gold and add much charm. The F-121 die variety captures a sharply downward sloping date that is an eyeball variety. This is a well balance gem at a fair offer price for type. Housed in NGC Gen 7 (1997-2000) holder,
1890	AU50	PCGS 13935293	F-106	Original	$300	Misplaced Date, Original, Steven Vitale Collection.. This lot is the rare Four Misplaced Digits In Lower Gown die variety. The top loops of four digits are visible in the lower gown. The left and right outer digits appear to be the top loops of an 8 and 0 digits and are positioned directly above the final date punch. The two inner misplaced digits appear to be the top loops of a 9 and 0 punch. Chris Pilliod first published this spectacular misplaced date in the Gobrecht Journal. I consider the 1890 F-106 MPD to be one of the key varieties within the Seated Dime misplaced date series and also within the Top 100 Varieties set. The Vitale example is noted to have partially mirrored fields. Their reflectance is limited by scattered field abrasions thus the GFRC-Original quality rating. Housed in PCGS Gen 4.6 (2013-2014) holder. The label documents the die variety as MPD FS-302.
1890-S	MS64	PCGS 30035618	F-114	Choice	HOLD $850	Medium S, Brilliant Luster, Swirling Cartwheels, Frosted Devices, Fully Struck, Newtown Collection. Consignor Price Reduction. Liberty Seated dime collectors should pay special attention to the release of this duplicate 1890-S F-114 dime from the Newtown Collection. I'm having a great time viewing this piece under a lights source. A fantastic strike greets me along with mirrored fields on both sides. The main devices have a frosted finish leading to cameo effects. Faint mottled rose toning covers a portion of the obverse while the reverse is mostly untoned. There are a few reverse field ticks mentioned for 100% accuracy. Overall, eye appeal and luster are excellent reasons for adding this Newtown duplicate to your collection. Accurately graded and housed in older PCGS Gen 4.1 (2002-2004) holder.
1891	MS65	PCGS 30170169	F-128	Gem	$585	Broken Foot on 1 Digit, Brilliant Frosted Luster, Attractive Light Copper-Gold. This 1891 dime is certainly worthy of its GFRC-Gem quality rating given the granular frosted luster and light rose-gold patina. An unquestionably original example with vibrant cartwheels too. The F-128 die pairing is easily attributed by a broken right foot on the 1 digit and reverse die cracks at the upper left reverse. I'm still looking for a late die state cud example of this variety where the cud would appear between 11:30 and 12:00. Like the other recently purchased Seated dimes, this lot has not been to CAC during my watch or that of the seller. Overall a pretty type coin that has been attractively priced. Housed in PCGS Gen 5.0 (2015) holder.
1891	MS63	PCGS OGH 1528240		Choice	$285	Heavily Clashed Dies, Brilliant Frosted Luster, Lightly Toned, Choice Overall. Brilliant frosted radiance and vibrant cartwheels are easily noted when viewing this choice 1891 dime under a bright light. Strike is complete with rim cuds on the obverse rim. An unlisted die pairing with heavily clashed dies. Housed in PCGS Gen 3.1 (1993-1998) holder.
1891	AU58	raw	F-115	Market Acceptable	$195	Retained Cud at 11:00, Frosty Luster, Faint Reverse Hairlines, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. A Liberty Seated Dime web-book 1891 F-115 plate coin with a reverse cud at 11:00. Surfaces retain brilliant frosty luster on both sides. The reverse is lightly hairlined when carefully viewed under 10x loupe along with bright light inspection. The reverse cud is fully formed and delineated with shelf metal on all three sides. As usual, GFRC is meticulous with accurate descriptions of its raw coin offerings. Yet another Seated cud dime from the Gerry Fortin reference collection.
1891-O	MS64	NGC 4189859011	F-116	Choice	$525	Repunched 9, Frosted Luster, Vibrant Cartwheels, Near-Gem Original, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. Another attractive late date Liberty Seated dime that has been in the Fortin collection since the mid-1990s. This F-116 repunched 9 example exhibits frosted luster and vibrant reverse cartwheels when checked under angled lighting. GFRC images accurately capture the speckled rose patina along with aquamarines at the rims. The 1891-O F-116 plate coin at The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference. Housed in newer NGC holder with edge view insert.
1891-O	MS63	PCGS 84123260		Choice	HOLD $375	New June 6! Lovely Frosted Luster, Heavily Cracked Dies, Choice Overall, Hawk Farm Collection. A thoroughly pleasing 1891-O dime with multiple die cracks that I've been unable to match with those listed in the Liberty Seated Dime online die variety reference. Housed in PCGS Gen 6.0 (2015-2020) holder. Immediately sold upon being showcased in the Daily Blog.
1891-S	MS66	CACG 147338931		Gem	$2250	Frosted Luster, Rotating Cartwheels, A Superb Gem, City by The Bay Collection.. The City By The Bay consignor is back with a small duplicates release while the individual lots are quite captivating. Leading the group is this unlisted 1891-S Seated dime with a Filled Small S mintmark. A thick granular mint frost covers the surfaces and results in steely-frosted radiance under a bright light. The cartwheels are further engrossing. A complete strike and pristine surfaces round out the positive attributes. CAC Grading standards are tough, really tough, and to secure a lofty MS66 grade, a coin has to be all there. Housed in new CACG holder and graded to strict standards employed for CAC stickering approval.
1891-S	MS62	NGC 4189140011	F-107	Choice	$225	Medium S, Brilliant Frosted Luster, Complete Strike, Attractively Priced, Gerry Fortin Reference Collection. The time has come to release the 1891-S F-107 plate coin at The Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors online reference. This is a lovely final year of design issue from the San Francisco mint. Creamy frosted luster originates from surfaces covered with natural mint bloom. The radiance is sharp and pleasing under a bright light. Strike is complete too. Some faint obverse field chatter is consistent with the certified grade though the eye appeal is that of a higher level. A nice 1891-S Medium S example to consider. Housed in newer NGC holder with edge view insert.

Liberty Seated Dimes

AU and Mint State Business and Proof Strikes

To Order: Contact Gerry by Phone (207-329-9957) or Email using the shopping cart ()